How to achieve thriving plants in a goldfish aquarium?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:First and foremost a goldfish tank will be a goldfish tank before anything else, Goldfish are notorious rooters and grazers. If you don’t mind not having the “perfect” aquascaped planted freshwater aquarium then that is ok. Get plants that do not taste good to Goldfish, your Java fern is an excellent choice not only do they taste bad to goldfish but they also are a very hardy plant and have low light requirements. I believe your swords are looking the weakest because they are root feeders and they require a good and nutrient filled substrate and do not like their roots exposed and also like moderate light levels (about 2.5w per gallon) I’m not sure what your running as a lighting system Here are some plants I have found that make a good choice for beginner aquariusts. * Java Fern (Microsorum pteropus) A very hardy plant, with low light requirement. Goldfish tend not to like the taste of this one. It can be tied to rocks, decorations is therefore not easily uprooted. * Anubias (Several varieties) Again a hardy plant with low light requirements. It has thick leaves and goldfish leave it alone. Best when tied down to decorations. * Java Moss (Vesicularia dubyana) Java Moss is a hardy plant with low light requirements. Goldfish are not likely to eat it. But they may tear it up during spawning. Because of this it can make your tank quite a mess and have moss fragments slow down your filter. On the other hand when my goldfish spawn I like to provide them with Java Moss as spawning material. * Hornwort (Ceratophyllum demersum) A plant that can float or be placed in the gravel if you prefer. It is hardy and usually escapes goldfish jaws. Mine have kept pace with goldfish grazing the last three years. I like this plant. It provides cover and it is a good nitrate consumer. If I plant it in the gravel and if (or when :)) it gets pulled out I do not have to rush to replant it. It likes to float and it gets good light at the top of the tank. * Crypts and Swords (Echinodorus species) Crypt and swords are rootfeeders. They require a good and nutrient filled substrate. They would not like to be uprooted nor have their roots exposed. For that reason they do not always make the best choices but if you have goldfish that are not too pushy try them. They are very beautiful, and will do well with moderate light levels (at least 2.5 per gallon). While my goldfish were smaller I had both plants. * Vallisneria (Vallisneria species) produce runners and it gets part of its nutrients from the water and part from roots so it requires a substrate. It is hardy and with low requirements. While my goldfish uproot this plant often it does well if I keep replanting it. * Hygrophilas (different varieties) and Watersprite (Ceratopteris thalictroides) These are stemplants and relatively hardy. However goldfish do tend to like to snack on their rather soft leaves. I tend to find them ‘cut down’ a bit if I leave the goldfish without food for a couple of days. But if you have luck with ones above you may want to try these next. Both tend to like better lighting than low, though. Watersprite has the advantage that it does well floating if it is uprooted. * Anacharis (Egeria Densa sometimes called Elodea Densa) Is a common pond plant. It can float or be planted in the gravel. It is good nice colour. People have varied success with it. Some goldfish tend to be particularly fond of anacharis. My goldfish leave them pretty much alone. However the plants tend to prefer cooler temperature and is often hard to keep in warmer aquariums. * Duckweed (Lemna minor) A tiny floating plant that really does grow like a weed if given the chance. In a goldfish aquarium it is rarely given the chance. My goldfish treat these as snack. They have the advantage of providing cover (if they are allowed to grow) and they are good nutrient absorbers without many high requirements. However they tend to like low surface movement and if the you have a lot of filter power these tiny things may be drawn into the filter. Remember though most plants are tropical and like warmer waters so running a cold water tank you will be limited in your plant choices. When I was into fresh water and growing plants (I run a coral reef tank now) I used Flourite aquarium plant substrate, it worked well for me and made my rooted plants happy as can be. But using substrate in goldfish tank can be difficult. Goldfish like to look for food in the substrate they often move rocks around or take them in their mouths to try them out. However if you place your rootfeeders in clay pots you may be able to keep some. You can cover the toplayer of the pot with very small gravel and even use a plastic mesh to help keep the plant from being uprooted. Good luck with your new endeavor. ever thought of just getting rid of the Goldfish and cold water minnows and moving to a more tropical fish(es)?

Related questions

Description : Does the filter in aquarium with goldfish need to operate permanently?

Last Answer : Yes. It is best practice to always have the aquariums filter running. In addition to removing impurities it also promotes a fresher ecosystem for the fish as the water is moving and won't grow stagnant

Description : my lantana plants look leggy and pitiful. I'm in Florida so they should be thriving. What's happening?

Last Answer : I think that they do better planted in the ground. The pots might be root bound. Turn one over and carefully tap the bottom and look at the dirt inside........if you are seeing lots of ... new dirt in the hole & replant it. You also could trim several inches off each top when replanting them.

Description : I have thriving jasmine plants I need to trim. My neighbor asked for cuttings. Can jasmine be propagated from cuttings?

Last Answer : yes........................trim them and tell her to cut off the buds or flowers dip it in rootone and keep them inside until strong enough for harsher weather.

Description : Can I put plant vitamins "for seedlings" on adult plants?

Last Answer : They won’t do any harm, but it is not “just like regular plant food” because food/fertilizer for seedlings is less robust to keep from burning the seedlings.

Description : How does the biological process work in plants that helps them point towards the sun?

Last Answer : Check the last section of this link. In short, plants have a chemical called auxin, which moves away from blue light rays to areas having less light. The auxins stimulate growth on the side that does not get light, causing the plant to bend toward the light. Link with picture

Description : If plants don't feel pain because they are not inteligent than what about smart people? Do they suffer more?

Last Answer : I'm not sure you are making a bad assumption here. Plants have been shown to have the ability to sense their surroundings and react to it which might indicate intelligence. http://www.bbc.com/earth/ ... neither to many of the people we consider smart. Well, at least they don't have common sense.

Description : Can plants, insects, animals and fish suffer mental disorders?

Last Answer : Let’s ask them

Description : Are there any plants in folklore or legend similar to mandrake?

Last Answer : There are dryads, talking trees (which inspired Tolkien’s Ents), and man-eating trees. All of these are fictional, of course.

Description : Do you think something like this would deter the cats from crappin' in the potted plants?

Last Answer : Bird spikes might work. So will cayenne pepper mixed into or shaken onto the plant’s dirt.

Description : Where should I grow my tomato plants?

Last Answer : Do you know what variety?

Description : Do plants feel pain?

Last Answer : Yeah. They express their pain by making that weird, sad, kinda creepy wailing noise when the wind is blowing.

Description : Do seed vaults include banned plants?

Last Answer : answer:I don't know if they actually do, but they should. More than once, something that was thought to be a weed has turned out to be a farmable, profit-making plant that has commercial ... that the political correctness lobbyists would not stand in the way of storing seeds for unpopular' plants.

Description : Can I move my outdoor potted plants from CA to Oregon?

Last Answer : I moved some of mine several states on the floor in the back of my car. They were fine.

Description : I've found on the web a site which describes the majority of animal species. What is a site that describes most plants?

Last Answer : I use this site for plant research

Description : Mom always told me that spraying my plants with water before a hard freeze would save them - how would that work, exactly?

Last Answer : The idea is that the ice on the plants would insulate them from much lower temperatures. But I live in California, I have no idea if it works.

Description : What kind(s) of plants are these?

Last Answer : They all seem to be varieties of Coleus.

Description : Do caterpillars excrete something special that can heal plants after munching on them?

Last Answer : answer:While I don't think it's something the caterpillar was excreting helping your plant grow I can offer you another reason. I study plant and insect interactions at university. What I think ... actual organism either due to chemicals the bugs excrete or the sound of their leaves getting eaten.

Description : If certain plants mutated, which mutations would cause more impact for society?

Last Answer : answer:When I first read the main question I had all sorts of positive scenarios in mind like Honey Crisp apples being able to grow in Florida and Vidalias having a longer growing season. With ... to control crops more, maybe have more hydroponic farms where bad crops can't contaminate good ones.

Description : What plants and flowers do not attract deer?

Last Answer : answer:Some reliable perennials are bee balm, black-eyed Susan, obedience plant (physostegia), phlox, lobelia siphilitica, the various flowering sages, rugosa roses, clematis, mallow, perennial poppies, globe ... ; hot pepper, moth balls, smelly soap on strings, and both male and female urine.

Description : How much time would it take to grow enough plants on Mars so that it would create enough oxygen for animals, organisms and humans breath without the aid of an enclosed ecosystem?

Last Answer : The bigger problem is the lack of water on Mars. Hard to grow plants with no water. Yes, there’s some water on Mars, but not anywhere near enough to grow and sustain sufficient plant life.

Description : Are there any plants that flower in the winter?

Last Answer : Christmas cactus is one that comes to mind immediately. What you have to know is if it’s a long day flowering plant or a long night flowering plant and give it the right photoclimate.

Description : Can plants be cute?

Last Answer : Of course they can, I LOVE my plants and talk to them. Hubs won’t let me touch them with my black thumb but some are super cute!!

Description : Can you use the water from a humidifier to water your plants?

Last Answer : You can certainly use it on your houseplants.

Description : Do plants like caffeine?

Last Answer : It might keep them up a bit.

Description : Has anyone tried to bring plants from Canada into the U.S. (not Mary Jane)

Last Answer : Here, what plants are you bringing in? https://help.cbp.gov/app/answers/detail/a_id/600/kw/Michigan%20Plants

Description : Tomato plants: safe or not?

Last Answer : I would say they should be safe. It’s been three months since the break. But I have had some close calls and I wouldn’t take a chance on them. The downside is a lot bigger than the upside.

Description : Can you recommend some easy going house plants?

Last Answer : answer:By easy-going, I assume you mean low-maintenance? You need some light for part of the day for most plants. Popularity has nothing to do with it. The toughest houseplants are ... the plants I listed below are on this list. Chinese evergreen Arrowhead vine Zeezee plant Pothos Philodendrom

Description : Are there any plants that can turn plastic into something sustainable for the earth?

Last Answer : Possibly for certain types of plastic, such as cellulose nitrate which is used for making celluloid film. I suspect it’s probably cheaper and easier to engineer the plastic than the plant.

Description : What is the best place to buy tree-like house plants in San Francisco?

Last Answer : answer:I can't help you with a specific store but might suggest a medium-sized banana tree. They grow really rapidly and yet, if purchased fairly small, can be hauled up several flights of stairs ... carriers' discs. Do any of the uni's have arboretums? Often you can find unsprayed specimen there.

Description : Anyone else find that having plants around you to be soothing?

Last Answer : As do I. Maybe it’s the fresh oxygen.

Description : You love flowers and plants. You could see yourself working in a garden all day. What would be a great career?

Last Answer : answer:There is a brother-sister team here who do weekly garden housekeeping for my sister and an occasional day for me. 25$ per person an hour. They prune, weed, whack, fertilize, relay flagstones ... a lot of land and gardens, fields, woods, streams, wildlife, butterflies and birds we protect.

Description : Help identify these plants?

Last Answer : answer:http://cactiguide.com/most_common/ Is it one on this list? Looks like “Echinopsis species”

Description : Bringing plants into Oregon on the plane?

Last Answer : Most of the West coast has pretty strict codes about not bringing anything like plants in. I’m guessing you get yourself into a major jam over it.. Welcome to fluther.

Description : In a narrow shaded area where drainage may be a problem, do plants help or hinder?

Last Answer : If it’s a shaded area, the plants may not have enough sun. You may need to choose plant varieties that can tolerate both shade and boggy conditions. It depends on the area, but I suspect if it’s already shaded, plants might not shade it appreciably more than it already is.

Description : Do trees and plants need oxygen to survive?

Last Answer : I believe they need it for respiration? Somebody please correct me because I remember something about that when I was studying biology. Trees and plants release way more oxygen than they need though.

Description : Traveling with plants?

Last Answer : Probably by seed or in-vitro tissue culture. Just read you are moving cacti. Are they rare or something? Is there a reason you can’t just get new plants after the move?

Description : How do I make the soil I have available suit specific plants?

Last Answer : answer:You start, as with all gardening, by doing your research. That means buying a book and reading or going on line and checking it out. If you want to plant delphiniums, for example, you need a ... buy some good gardening books; there is nothing nicer to read on a cold night. Where do you live?

Description : What plants can I sever and plant?

Last Answer : Depending on the plant a little, you can do it with all of them. If they’re tough to propogate you can always try air layering.

Description : What should I do about my soapy plants!

Last Answer : You need to repot, with new dirt, now, or you are going to have dead plants. And, I think you need to call a plumber. Having soapy water coming out of faucets simply becase the washer is spinning is not normal!

Description : Are there any flowers or plants I can plant in August, Zone 5?

Last Answer : answer:For edibles, basil grows fast. You might get a crop if the weather holds up. Also, I have noticed that any store selling young plants & seedlings has a really short prime selling season. So often they have stragglers at dirt cheap prices.

Description : Are these plants Chamomile?

Last Answer : answer:Chamomile daisies appear to have fewer petals; this looks like a fleabane (erigeron) to me. The petals are more needle-like. It is a really common tall weed and is growing all over here now. Daisy fleabane

Description : Cat Owners: How Can I Keep My Plants Safe?

Last Answer : I don’t know if it will harm the plant or not, but bitter spray works good for electronic cords and such.

Description : What's your tip for keeping your house plants happy?

Last Answer : Give the the lighting, water and fertilizer that they need. Every plant needs different things, I have many many different plants from a simple christmas catus to a banana tree and pomegrante. I go ... mini cherry trees none of the new plants have produced yet but they are still small and growing.

Description : How long does runoff toxicity/contamination in plants last?

Last Answer : Lead from gasoline/petrol last for a long – long time.

Description : Gardening in the face of pests - what's the effect of covering plants?

Last Answer : My mother had an evening ritual every evening to get rid of slugs in her garden which seemed to work because she doesn't have the issue anymore. She took a coffee can and put about an ... gasoline in it and then proceeded to collect slugs every morning and evening. The gasoline kills them instantly.

Description : In all seriousness, why do we plant grass instead of mint or other useful plants (details)?

Last Answer : answer:Grass is very tough. You can run and play on it and even park cars on it. However, when I was a suburban dweller, I often thought a cash crop like tobacco or soybeans would be a much better use for all my time, sweat and money.

Description : What kinds of plants are really hard to kill?

Last Answer : Kudzu!!!!

Description : How are the plants in these pictures properly spaced (details)?

Last Answer : answer:Plants in pots are usually annuals, meaning that they will give you glorious blooms for the summer (or their blooming season, depending on what your growing zone is.) That is very different from ... need, water and enjoy. After the first frost, you dump the whole thing into your compost.

Description : Are all ground cover plants also invasive plants?

Last Answer : No, invasive simply means that it isn’t native to an area, and it readily displaces natives. They can grow at various “levels”, including ground. Ground cover plants can be natives, like clover.

Description : Are we designed more intelligently than plants?

Last Answer : I think they are, and the day they find their voices and legs, we are in big trouble!