Who were the first humans to identify language forms and develop rules in grammar?

Who were the first humans to identify language forms and develop rules in grammar?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

Language and language structures pre-date history. (One cannot have a hsitory to share without a way to communicate it). And there are disaprate structures and rules that arose independently across the globe. Different cultures and groups and regions developed in isolation. Similarities only arose through trade and interaction with neighbors.
by

Related questions

Grammar question: where is the line between the passive voice and (to be) as a linking verb?

Description : Grammar question: where is the line between the passive voice and (to be) as a linking verb?

Last Answer : Here is how I see it. For a word to be an adjective, it must be describing some object. If you say, The pot was watched , watched is not a property of the pot. There is an irony in ... would ordinarily be on the current state of the pot rather than acts of tarnishing that had been made on it.

Grammar question: does a one word or phrase answer in "social" have to be capitalized?

Description : Grammar question: does a one word or phrase answer in "social" have to be capitalized?

Last Answer : I’ve been dinged for it now & then. The gods must be forgiven for confusing omnipotence with perfection. We must not be allowed to forget who’s boss.

Can we blame The Doors (musical group) for bad grammar?

Description : Can we blame The Doors (musical group) for bad grammar?

Last Answer : No, because no one ever knew “The Doors”.

Does the grammar rule a and a(n) with vowels apply to speaking?

Description : Does the grammar rule a and a(n) with vowels apply to speaking?

Last Answer : of course. speaking or writing, the rules are the same.

Is my grammar okay? (Apology letter for a lover)

Description : Is my grammar okay? (Apology letter for a lover)

Last Answer : please help me

Grammar Police: If something is made by an artisan, is it called "artisan" or "artisanal?"?

Description : Grammar Police: If something is made by an artisan, is it called "artisan" or "artisanal?"?

Last Answer : The adjective is artisanal, Artisan is the person who made it.

English grammar question: is this right even though it sounds wrong?

Description : English grammar question: is this right even though it sounds wrong?

Last Answer : Were turning to the left. .. is what I would say.

Is , "you should be eating healthy" correct grammar?

Description : Is , "you should be eating healthy" correct grammar?

Last Answer : answer:No. I have heard ‘healthily” so it is not unknown. But more often I have heard it expressed differently – “you should it eat a healthier diet.” Healthy is an adjective, so it ought to be used as an adjective, not as an adverb.

What is your opinion on this article about the resurgence of grammar?

Description : What is your opinion on this article about the resurgence of grammar?

Last Answer : answer:I agree grammar should be creative and interesting for it to be fun enough for kids or even some adults to want to try. I do think that a lot of the much older' ... educated people and could knock their socks off with our various expertise, without the scornful attitude, hopefully.

Grammar question: Past participles used as adjectives?

Description : Grammar question: Past participles used as adjectives?

Last Answer : answer:In 1 and 2, shown and expected are past participles in reduced clauses. 1' The image (that is) shown on the home page is wrong. 2' When I don't get the thing (that is ... .com/110933/active-or-passive-or-past-participle-adjective/ http://www.fluther.com/90503/what-does-this-sentence-mean/

Ever wanted to point out someone's spelling errors/poor grammar online?

Description : Ever wanted to point out someone's spelling errors/poor grammar online?

Last Answer : Very, very often.

My fellow nit-picking grammar jellies: How should this be written?

Description : My fellow nit-picking grammar jellies: How should this be written?

Last Answer : Well, you definitely don’t want the apostrophe there but otherwise it is o.k. It might be preferable to write out “mid-seventeen hundreds” though.

Is this incorrect grammar?

Description : Is this incorrect grammar?

Last Answer : I sometimes use “they” in the place of “he or she,” but if the gender of the person is known, it makes more sense (and is more correct) to be specific. “He or she” is more correct than “they” as well, but I feel weird saying “he or she” on a casual conversation.

How well do you score on a grammar quiz?

Description : How well do you score on a grammar quiz?

Last Answer : I got 14, although I found myself brooding about #1 and changed my mind twice.

Why is it that people with poor grammar skills consistently confuse when to use 'I' and when to use 'me'?

Description : Why is it that people with poor grammar skills consistently confuse when to use 'I' and when to use 'me'?

Last Answer : answer:Technically, “This is I,” is correct. “He sent a telegram to my grandson and I” is not. The really easy way to prevent this is to separate the double subject or object into two parts. “Me went shopping.” “He sent a telegram to I.”

Grammar question : Difference between these sentences.

Description : Grammar question : Difference between these sentences.

Last Answer : answer:First of all, they should all begin ”To select the new file,...” “For selecting the new file” makes little sense.

Do you know any website I can use to improve grammar and writing?

Description : Do you know any website I can use to improve grammar and writing?

Last Answer : This Grammar of Doom game from the list looks like fun.

Quick grammar question: not superlative but on its way?

Description : Quick grammar question: not superlative but on its way?

Last Answer : They’re called “comparative adjectives”.

Is this sentence grammatically correct? (calling all grammar geeks!)

Description : Is this sentence grammatically correct? (calling all grammar geeks!)

Last Answer : I hope this helps: http://grammar.quickanddirtytips.com/where-versus-in-whichadverbs.aspx

How do you say "She was pretty" in French? (grammar)

Description : How do you say "She was pretty" in French? (grammar)

Last Answer : The way you originally wrote it is the passé composé, but one would rarely use the passé composé in this situation. That would translate to “She has been pretty”. You would more likely say “Elle etait jolie”, which is the imperfect tense.

What's the reason for the enclosed English grammar usage?

Description : What's the reason for the enclosed English grammar usage?

Last Answer : “Were” is the subjunctive mood of “to be.”

In grammar, what is a matrix clause?

Description : In grammar, what is a matrix clause?

Last Answer : answer:A matrix clause is a clause that surrounds an embedded clause. It is typically-but not always-the main clause of a sentence. Example: Jim's old car, which was never any good in the first place, ... is a matrix clause. which was never any good in the first place is an embedded clause.

Does English grammar really matter?

Description : Does English grammar really matter?

Last Answer : answer:Yes, it matters for clarity and precision in meaning. But if English is not your native language and you’re still working on it then we’ll certainly make allowances and try to clarify things we need to understand when responding. I’ve been working on it for over half a century now.

Is there an app that tests you on punctuation and grammar?

Description : Is there an app that tests you on punctuation and grammar?

Last Answer : Grammar App by Tap to Learn. You’ll find it in the Apple App Store on iTunes.

Is the word "I'd've" considered proper grammar?

Description : Is the word "I'd've" considered proper grammar?

Last Answer : I’ve’rd it u’db’f’re, so why n’t?

Is it ok to correct her grammar?

Description : Is it ok to correct her grammar?

Last Answer : As a seasoned veteran of the Grammar Gestapo, I think it depends on how well you know her. If you think she’ll be offended at the slightest criticism (however friendly), then don’t bother.

What's a good grammar app for the iPad?

Description : What's a good grammar app for the iPad?

Last Answer : I really, really like Grammar App HD ($1.99); check it out at http://appsto.re/gahd ; also worthy of noting—it was named one of eight ’’[b]rilliant Writing’’ apps by copyblogger in 2010 http://j.mp/cpyblggr

Why is using proper grammar such a problem for some people?

Description : Why is using proper grammar such a problem for some people?

Last Answer : answer:Because my brain is better at Quantum Physics than it ever was with grammar and punctuation. that's why but mostly I'm just too lazy to care. I actually had learning dissabilities that when ... can also screw up grammar and punctuation in a few languages so Not everyone can say that either.

English grammar question involving conditional tense.

Description : English grammar question involving conditional tense.

Last Answer : Am…..you’re speaking in the present tense.

What's it called in grammar when you don't say what "it" is? (details)

Description : What's it called in grammar when you don't say what "it" is? (details)

Last Answer : From your description, I’d say it’s a case of a pronoun that’s lacking an antecedent. Faulty pronoun reference is the error.

Does bad grammar in songs bother you?

Description : Does bad grammar in songs bother you?

Last Answer : It doesn’t bother me at all. If I like the song, I don’t care about the grammar. For example, there’s a very good song, that says “the most loneliest day of my life”. I don’t care. The song is awesome.

Can someone help me with a quick grammar question?

Description : Can someone help me with a quick grammar question?

Last Answer : It could be “a twenty-dollar hourly charge” or “an hourly charge of twenty dollars”.

Nitpicky English grammar question.

Description : Nitpicky English grammar question.

Last Answer : “People should think more,” is a good compromise. But the first sentence is utterly correct, and would only confuse someone who is not a human.

English Grammar- What is the correct pronoun to refer to 'family'?

Description : English Grammar- What is the correct pronoun to refer to 'family'?

Last Answer : answer:Read the best answer for this yahoo post: http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20061101113028AANVwIx Is it really correct? It sounds very awkward using ‘it’ to refer to a family.

Can you help me with this Spanish grammar rule?

Description : Can you help me with this Spanish grammar rule?

Last Answer : I’m confused. Where do you want to put the u? O means or, is that what you are talking about? My spanish is good, but not perfect. I’ll also send this to a some Spanish speakers for you.

Grammar question regarding quotation marks.

Description : Grammar question regarding quotation marks.

Last Answer : 1

Those who aren't grammar Nazis - what gramatical errors go too far, even for you?

Description : Those who aren't grammar Nazis - what gramatical errors go too far, even for you?

Last Answer : I don’t really care about gramatical errors. This is fluther not school. The only time I mention someones gramatical errors is when they are arrogantly insulting others.

ASL facial expressions/grammar - do I have to have different faces for y/n vs whq?

Description : ASL facial expressions/grammar - do I have to have different faces for y/n vs whq?

Last Answer : Ooh I used to know this. From what I remember, they are different. With a wh- question, the eyebrows tend to get an inquisitive-furrow sort of thing (they go more down than anything), and with a y/n question the eyebrows get a raised inquisitivity (they go up). —Does that make any sense?—

Grammar: the difference between "be + about + Ving" and "be + about + to V"?

Description : Grammar: the difference between "be + about + Ving" and "be + about + to V"?

Last Answer : “The mother was about fainting” is more of a colloquialism, not the correct form for use in writing.

Can someone help me check these two sentences for grammar?

Description : Can someone help me check these two sentences for grammar?

Last Answer : answer:Neither version is really optimal, in my opinion. Agglomeration isn't the right word for a group of people. What are you trying to say with the word? Are you speaking of number, interest ... a clear, uncomplicated statement of your thought first, and then let's see how best to express it.

How can I improve my English spelling and grammar?

Description : How can I improve my English spelling and grammar?

Last Answer : answer:It's just a start, but you could head over to http://www.babbel.com/ (http://es.babbel.com/ for Spanish translation) It's free, and has many courses (including English ones). It's how I ... The only way to get perfect at English is to immerse yourself in it and strictly speak it for a while.

Do you consider yourself a Grammar Nazi?

Description : Do you consider yourself a Grammar Nazi?

Last Answer : Not at all…though I do find the term ‘grammar nazi’ unnecessary.

Can someone help me with some grammar questions?

Description : Can someone help me with some grammar questions?

Last Answer : answer:I'm by no means a grammar expert, but I'll take a crack at answering a few of these. 1. I would use a comma in this instance. 2. I think it is actually spelled bubblegum (one word) and ... m not sure how I would rewrite it. Sorry if I wasn't especially helpful. Have fun with your story! :)

What are some good websites for Arabic grammar?

Description : What are some good websites for Arabic grammar?

Last Answer : answer:I really like livemocha.com it's like a community for learning new languages. You can take lessons and then submit your speech and writing samples for review by people who natively speak the language ... to learn. Presently I am learning Farsi and the site has been a great benefit to me.

Grammar: is it "David and I" or "me and David"?

Description : Grammar: is it "David and I" or "me and David"?

Last Answer : answer:Would you like to go to Canada with David and me? Take “David” out: Would you like to go to Canada with me? See? And I was always taught hat the other person being referred to comes before you talk about yourself in such cases. Why, I don’t know.

Why is there such a flagrant disregard of proper spelling and grammar on many internet forums?

Description : Why is there such a flagrant disregard of proper spelling and grammar on many internet forums?

Last Answer : Essentially it is because it is easier and more efficient to use poor grammar. Sad but true that the English language is butchered to make it easier to type.

What is proper grammar; I caught a cold, I have a cold, I got a cold..?

Description : What is proper grammar; I caught a cold, I have a cold, I got a cold..?

Last Answer : answer:Pretty much got is to be avoided in all instances if possible. I caught a cold, or I came down with a cold is commonly used.

How do you feel about spelling and grammar on this site?

Description : How do you feel about spelling and grammar on this site?

Last Answer : I think the standard here is already higher than a lot of other paces but I also think it would be a mistake to tighten up on it. Sure, discourage “txtspeak”, but please also remember that some people do not have English as their first language and some are dyslexic.

Grammar question re: "are" versus "is"?

Description : Grammar question re: "are" versus "is"?

Last Answer : answer:Initially I would say: Are – lights and horses are two things. But I think that the sentence just needs to be restructured as Cyanotic Wasp points out below.

Should teachers be held to a higher level of accountability when it comes to grammar, spelling, etc.?

Description : Should teachers be held to a higher level of accountability when it comes to grammar, spelling, etc.?

Last Answer : I don’t hold teachers (of subjects other than English) to a higher standard than non-teachers. I’m appalled at the state of grammar everywhere- including my own at times.