How do screw compressors differ from reciprocating ones?

1 Answer

Answer :

All air compressors are divided into two types: reciprocating and screw, and many enterprises are faced with the problem of choosing a compressor. This choice affects not only the efficiency of the equipment, but also its final cost.

It is worth noting that recently there has been a great demand for screw models, which are gradually replacing piston ones. It is likely that the reciprocating compressor could even today become a relic of the past, if not for its attractive cost. In fact, piston models have certain disadvantages that screw ones are completely absent.

First of all, we are talking about a rather low level of reliability of such equipment, tangible vibrations, due to the constant reciprocating movements of the pistons, as well as the high cost and complexity of maintenance. All this, taken together, makes such equipment not as cheap and profitable as it seems at first glance. After just a year, maximum two years of intensive operation, a reciprocating compressor usually needs serious repair, while its scheduled maintenance is carried out all the time.

Screw compressors are devoid of all of the above disadvantages, especially if we compare their power indicators, the latter are in no way inferior to reciprocating compressors.

What are screw compressors?

Each one consists of a pair of screws, an air filter with a separator, a suction valve, an oil and cooling radiator, an electric motor and a thermostat. The air entering through the suction valve passes through the filter, and after cleaning it is supplied to the screw pair, where it mixes with oil and is pumped into the pneumatic system. Further, the air-oil mixture enters the separator, where it is separated into oil and purified air, which, in turn, goes out under pressure.

In the case when the buyer is firmly convinced that he intends to operate the compressor intensively and for a long time - more than 2-3 years - he can be recommended to opt for screw compressor equipment.

Based on materials from the site http://compressor.dukon.ru/ .

Related questions

Description : Where are portable screw compressors used?

Last Answer : Where are portable screw compressors used? The use of a portable screw air compressor in road, construction, mining and installation works indicates that its area of practical use is ... with these important, but fairly simple requirements will significantly lengthen the life of your compressor.

Last Answer : The motor used for the compressors is capacitor-start capacitor-run motor.

Description : Compare reciprocating and rotary air compressor

Last Answer : Reciprocating compressor Rotary compressor  1. Compression of air takes place with help of piston and cylinder arrangement with reciprocating motion of piston. 1. Compression of air takes place ... High 12. More Starting torque required 12. Less Starting torque required

Description : How to Remove a Stripped Screw

Last Answer : How to Remove a Stripped Screw For many mechanics, carpenters, and electricians, a stripped screw is an annoyance that makes maintenance and assembly tasks more difficult than they should be. A really old ... remove stripped screws in no time at all, so that you can replace them with new screws.

Description : Should you buy a screw compressor?

Last Answer : The purchase of screw compressors for the enterprise allows solving several problems at once: reducing the cost of electricity, installation and maintenance, as well as saving space in production. The ... below + 5 °. The advantages also include the almost silent operation of the installation.

Description : What Is The Difference Between A Rotary Screw Compressor And A Reciprocating Compressors?

Last Answer : A rotary screw compressor is one that utilizes two intermeshing helical rotors to trap a volume of air, then compress it to a higher pressure. Rotary screw compressors can be run at lower ... piston compressor (aka reciprocating) uses pistons driven by a crankshaft to deliver air at high pressure.

Description : From the point of lower specific energy consumption, which of the following compressors are suitable for part load operation? a) Two stage reciprocating compressors b) Centrifugal compressors c) Two stage screw compressor d) Single stage screw compressor

Last Answer : a) Two stage reciprocating compressors

Description : Which one of the following statements is correct? A. Reciprocating compressors are used to supply large quantities of air at a lower pressure ratio B. Centrifugal compressors are used to supply ... . Centrifugal compressors cannot be run at high speed because of impeller, diffuser and casing.

Last Answer : ANSWER : B

Description : In reciprocating compressors, one should aim at compressing the air A. Adiabatically B. Isentropically C. Isothermally D. Polytropically

Last Answer : ANSWER : C

Description : Centrifugal compressors compared to reciprocating compressors (A) Require less space (B) Have quieter operation (C) Have lower operating costs (D) All (A), (B) and (C)

Last Answer : (D) All (A), (B) and (C)

Description : What is the effect of increase in altitude on the performance of single stage reciprocating compressors? 

Last Answer : With the increase in altitude, there will be reduction in air pressure, which results in increase in compression ratio, leading to higher discharge temperature and reduced efficiency. 

Description : List the advantages of keeping the discharge pressure for reciprocating compressors at minimum. 

Last Answer : Lower power consumption Less load on the piston rods and hence reduced maintenance costs Lower leakage losses

Description : List the means of capacity control for reciprocating compressors. 

Last Answer : On/off control Load and unload control Multi-step control

Description : What are the likely effects of using very cold water in intercoolers for reciprocating compressors? 

Last Answer : Use of very cold water can result in condensation which may result in water entering the cylinder, thereby reducing valve life, accelerating wear and scoring of piston, piston rings and ... and cause rust which will result in abrasion during compressor operation and significantly reduce efficiency. 

Description : Why inter-coolers are required for multi-stage reciprocating compressors?  

Last Answer : The intercoolers reduce the temperature of air/gas discharged between stages. Ideally, the intake temperature at each stage should be the same as that at the first stage (referred to a perfect cooling), so that the volume of air to be compressed does not increase and hence reduced power consumption.

Description : From base load operation and from achieving best specific energy consumption point of view, which of the following compressors are suitable? a) Single stage reciprocating compressors b) Centrifugal compressors c) Two stage reciprocating compressor d) Multi stage reciprocating compressor

Last Answer : b) Centrifugal compressors

Description : Vertical type reciprocating compressors are used in the capacity range of _____ a) 50 – 150 cfm b) 200 – 500 cfm c) Above 10ooo cfm d) 10 – 50 cfm 

Last Answer : a) 50 – 150 cfm

Description : Explain construction and working of two stage reciprocating air compressors.

Last Answer : Figure: Two Stage Reciprocating air compressor Construction and Working : It consists of two cylinders (L.P. and H.P.) with water cooled intercooler and air receiver. First of all fresh air is ... (ie second stage) from 3 to 4 is delivered by the compressor at pressure P3 & Temp T4.

Description : Which of the following type does Screw compressor belongs to? a) Positive displacementcompressor b) Dynamic compressors c) Both a & b d) None of the above 

Last Answer : a) Positive displacementcompressor

Description : Which of the following is used for pumping crude oil from oil well? (A) Single stage centrifugal pump (B) Gear pump (C) Screw pump (D) Duplex/triplex reciprocating pump

Last Answer : (D) Duplex/triplex reciprocating pump

Description : Slurries can be most conveniently pumped by a __________ pump. (A) Screw (B) Reciprocating (C) Gear (D) Centrifuga

Last Answer : (D) Centrifuga

Description : What are a list of things that one can do to screw up ones life?

Last Answer : 1. Getting hooked on drugs and/or alcohol. No one ever intends to become addicted. The best way to avoid it is not to use.

Description : Does one's outlook, knowledge, and theories of the world differ depending upon gender?

Last Answer : Well I am glad that the thinking of woman's place is in the home is a past time..Well some may feel that still but not as many. I have a little girl I will teach her strive to be anything that she ... for her to accomplish or give her a handicap but to not give up. Women have come along way , baby.

Description : The second generation sulfonylurea hypoglycaemics differ from the first generation ones in that they: A. Are more potent B. Are longer acting C. Do not lower blood sugar in nondiabetic subjects D. Are less prone to cause hypoglycaemic reaction

Last Answer : A. Are more potent

Description : What is the best refrigeration compressors?

Last Answer : There are many kinds of refrigeration compressors, depending on the needs of the consumer. Regardless of whether you have a standard fridge or a walk-in freezer, it is important to purchase ... is available here: http://oee.nrcan.gc.ca/industrial/equipment/commercial-refrigeration/index.cfm?attr=24

Description : wattage of air compressors?

Last Answer : The average air compressor uses only about 120v. Which is the average house socket. Thus using about 400 Watts of power.

Description : Rotary compressors are used for delivering A. Small quantities of air at high pressure B. Large quantities of air at high pressure C. Small quantities of air at low pressure D. Large quantities of air at low pressure

Last Answer : ANSWER : D

Description : Which one of the following types of impeller vanes are most commonly used in centrifugal type compressors? A. Forward curved B. Radial C. Backward curved D. Tangential

Last Answer : ANSWER : C

Description : What is the device used in fiber optic communication which consist of a receiver transmitter use to clean up and amplify digital data moving in one direction and another in the opposite direction? A. Optic compressors B. Optic retarders C. Optic isolator D. Optic regenerators

Last Answer : D. Optic regenerators

Description : Which of the following produces maximum pressure difference for transportation of gases? (A) Vacuum pumps (B) Blowers (C) Fans (D) Compressors

Last Answer : (D) Compressors

Description : The maximum delivery pressure of compressors can be upto __________ atmospheres. (A) 10 (B) 100 (C) 250 (D) 1000

Last Answer : (D) 1000

Description : Multistage compressors are used in industry, because they (A) Reduce the cost of compressor (B) Reduce the size requirement (C) Resemble closely to isothermal compression (D) Are easy to control

Last Answer : (C) Resemble closely to isothermal compression

Description : High noise levels produced during operation of fans and compressors can be reduced by using (A) Mufflers (silencers) (B) Acoustic absorbent (C) Lagging of noisy duct (D) None of these

Last Answer : (A) Mufflers (silencers)

Description : How Centrifugal compressors work?

Last Answer : Answer: High-speed impellers increase the kinetic energy of the gas, converting this energy into higher pressures in a divergent outlet passage called a diffuser. Large volume of gas at moderate pressure.

Description : What are the types of compressors?

Last Answer : Answer: Positive Displacement, Centrifugal and Axial, rotary screw, rotary vane, rotary lobe, dynamic, liquid ring compressors.

Description : Does It Matter Where I Install My Compressors On My Vehicle?

Last Answer : This depends on several factors such as available space, whether or not the compressor is of a sealed or vented type, as well as personal preference and aesthetics. Make sure to utilize the rubber insulators to keep vibration and noise to a minimum.

Description : If Carrier develops a new air conditioning compressor that lasts twice as long as existing compressors but only uses half the electricity, it will probably establish its pricing based on: A)cash flow. B)product quality. C)survival. D)return on investment. E)market share.

Last Answer : B)product quality.

Description : What are the methods of capacity control in centrifugal air compressors?  

Last Answer : Centrifugal compressors operate best at the design point. They are prone to surging at flow rates less than 50% of the rated capacity. The following types of controls are employed in ... variable speed drives to match compressor output to meet varying load requirements is by speed control 

Description : What is a surge point and how do you prevent surging, in centrifugal compressors?

Last Answer : Surge point is the point on the performance curve where a further decrease inflow (typically in the region of 50-70 % of rated capacity) causes instability, resulting in a pulsating flow, ... to thrust reversals, or excessive vibration. Bypass valves advents are commonly used to prevent surging. 

Description : Give major classifications of compressors and the basic principle of its working.  

Last Answer : The major classifications of compressors are positive displacement and dynamic type. Positive displacement can be further divided in to (a) Reciprocating (b) Rotary. Dynamic compressors divided into Radial and ... increase the air or gas velocity, which is then converted to increase the pressure. 

Description : Identify the correct statement for air compressors. a. For every 5.5oC drop in the inlet air temperature, the increase in energy consumption is by 2%. b. For every 4 oC rise in ... increase in energy consumption is by 1% d. The energy consumption remains same irrespective of inlet air temperature 

Last Answer : c. For every 4 oC rise in the inter air temperature, the increase in energy consumption is by 1% 

Description : Which of the statement is True for centrifugal compressors? a) The compressor should not be operated at full load b) The compressor should be operated at shut off pressure c) The ... operated with inlet-guide vane control d) The compressor should not be operated close to the surge point 

Last Answer : d) The compressor should not be operated close to the surge point

Description : The compression ratios for axial flow compressors are ____. a) Lesser b) Higher c) moderate d) None 

Last Answer : b) Higher

Description : Jigsaw or Reciprocating Saw?

Last Answer : answer:It depends what kind of work you want to do. A reciprocating saw can become a jigsaw, but they are not quite as precise and fine. A reciprocating saw is more for trimming trees, or rougher ... right blade, would be useful for cutting someone out of a car crash, a jigsaw would not really.

Description : The domestic refrigerator uses following type of compressor (a) centrifugal (b) axial (c) miniature sealed unit (d) piston type reciprocating

Last Answer : Ans: d

Description : In a naturally aspirated diesel engine, the air is supplied by a A. supercharger B. centrifugal pump C. movement of engine piston D. reciprocating pump

Last Answer : ANSWER : C

Description : A reciprocating compressor is not suitable for use as a supercharger because: A. it runs at lower rpm B. the pressure ratio is high C. volumetric efficiency is high D. it is bulky and can handle small quantity of air

Last Answer : ANSWER : D

Description : Which one of the following types of compressor is mostly used for supercharging of IC engines? (a) Radial flow compressor (b) Axial flow compressor (c) Root blower (d) Reciprocating compressor

Last Answer : Ans : c

Description : Compressor mostly used for supercharging of IC engine is A. Radial flow compressor B. Axial flow compressor C. Root blower compressor D. Reciprocating compressor

Last Answer : ANSWER : A

Description : A large clearance volume in a reciprocating compressor results in A. Reduced volume flow rate B. Increased volume flow rate C. Lower suction pressure D. Lower delivery pressure

Last Answer : ANSWER : A