If Adam and Eve were unable to judge right from wrong before eating from the tree, why were they punished?

If Adam and Eve were unable to judge right from wrong before eating from the tree, why were they punished?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

they were told directly by God (well, Adam was told directly and Eve had knowledge of it), not to eat from the tree. When Eve gave the fruit to Adam, and he ate it, they were directly disobeying what God had told them to do. they didn’t have to sit around and ponder if they should or not, they had a clear answer already, and disregarded it.
by

Related questions

Who or what besides "Mister Rogers" and "Sesame Street" can you think of as an example of didactic (teaching) entertainment for kids?

Description : Who or what besides "Mister Rogers" and "Sesame Street" can you think of as an example of didactic (teaching) entertainment for kids?

Last Answer : Schoolhouse Rock!

What's a modern-day tale of debt collection--where the services or privileges have been enjoyed, and now the all-too-heavy bill comes due?

Description : What's a modern-day tale of debt collection--where the services or privileges have been enjoyed, and now the all-too-heavy bill comes due?

Last Answer : . . . contemporary movies and fiction . . .

If Adam and Eve didn't know right from wrong till after eating the forbidden fruit, how was it morally wrong to eat it?

Description : If Adam and Eve didn't know right from wrong till after eating the forbidden fruit, how was it morally wrong to eat it?

Last Answer : answer:Because God TOLD them not to eat it. He said, Don't eat them apples offen that tree. Them's my winta apples. Bye n bye the debil, he comes up and says, What fo' don't you eat dem apples offen ... over de fence! YOU WORK FOR YO' HASH! And that's how it was. There's more if you want it.

What was the fruit on the tree that eve and Adam ate?

Description : What was the fruit on the tree that eve and Adam ate?

Last Answer : It was an apple.

Could Adam and Eve suffer injury before the Fall?

Description : Could Adam and Eve suffer injury before the Fall?

Last Answer : There is no mention of death r suffering in the Eden myth. MarkTwain noted this in his stories of Adam and Eve. As an example fishtaken from water just flopped around until returned to the water.Based on that thought - probably not.

If Adam and Eve had two boys then how were there more generations of people?

Description : If Adam and Eve had two boys then how were there more generations of people?

Last Answer : Adam and Eve had many children, not just cain, abel and seth

What nationalities were Adam and Eve?

Last Answer : Adam and Eve had all the nations that emerged from the first pair. One of their great-grandfathers, Noah had three sons, namely: Shem, Cham and Japheth. There are blacks of Ham, and Semites, ... Eve gave Adam an apple. It is written only about fruit. Nowhere is the species specifically described.

How did the black race evolve if Adam and Eve were the first on earth?

Description : How did the black race evolve if Adam and Eve were the first on earth?

Last Answer : If Adam and Eve were the first humans on earth, the scriptures did not tell us the color of their skin. Hence we do not know by the books whether they were black or brown or white ... paler due to lesser sunlight in those areas hence lesser melanin. This has since become an evolutionary adaptation.

What is the religious interpretation of Adam and Eve?

Description : What is the religious interpretation of Adam and Eve?

Last Answer : Here are six different interpretations of “Adam and Eve; What’s the Meaning of the Myth?” http://advocatusatheist.blogspot.com/2011/03/adam-and-eve-whats-meaning-of-myth.html

What would life be like, if Adam and Eve (hypothetically speaking whether you are a believer on not) had never sinned?

Description : What would life be like, if Adam and Eve (hypothetically speaking whether you are a believer on not) had never sinned?

Last Answer : No Dutch Apple Pie. I wouldn’t want to live in that world ;-)

What language did Adam & Eve speak?

Description : What language did Adam & Eve speak?

Last Answer : Fictionese would be my guess.

In what language did the serpent speak to Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden?

Description : In what language did the serpent speak to Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden?

Last Answer : Him speak with forked tongue.

What didn't Adam and Eve have that everyone else has? -Riddles

Description : What didn't Adam and Eve have that everyone else has? -Riddles

Last Answer : Parents.

Where did Adam and Eve live ?

Description : Where did Adam and Eve live ?

Last Answer : Answer : Adam and Eve lived in Jannatul Mawa .

Why do we have different races,skin colour,hair texture when we are all from adam anf eve?

Description : Why do we have different races,skin colour,hair texture when we are all from adam anf eve?

Last Answer : Very interesting question. You know when God created this earth, he never told anyone what or how he is going to do anything, because he is a mysterious God. Just like when he created the animals, he ... anything so that we know he is God. Even Adam and Eve were different it all started from there

Is the Adam and Eve story a myth?

Description : Is the Adam and Eve story a myth?

Last Answer : A myth is defined as a religious story with no verified evidence*. Given that, Adam & Eve certainly fits into this definition. However, unlike the Greco-Roman myths, a large number of people ... one that is concerned with deities or demigods and explains some practice, rite, or phenomenon of nature.

A woman proves in court that her husband was murdered by her sister, but the judge decides that the sister cannot be punished. Why? -Riddles

Description : A woman proves in court that her husband was murdered by her sister, but the judge decides that the sister cannot be punished. Why? -Riddles

Last Answer : The sisters are Siamese twins.

If a judge was unable to grant an injunction against sexual abuse and violence due to lack of evidence would there be a possibility to modify a custody agreement?

Description : If a judge was unable to grant an injunction against sexual abuse and violence due to lack of evidence would there be a possibility to modify a custody agreement?

Last Answer : answer:You have to demonstrate a reason for your request. Accusing someone of sexual abuse is a serious charge; you have to show why and how you know it is happening. You may only get a temporary ... go on. Issues like this, when brought up for the first time in a custody situation, are questioned.

What will you be eating for ********* Eve?

Description : What will you be eating for Christmas Eve?

Last Answer : ive nothing particular in mind

Inspired by a movie I watched: If you were falsely convicted of a crime and done the time, should you, upon release, have the right to commit the crime you were falsely convicted for, without being punished?

Description : Inspired by a movie I watched: If you were falsely convicted of a crime and done the time, should you, upon release, have the right to commit the crime you were falsely convicted for, without being punished?

Last Answer : answer:Well, and just how's that gonna work for you? If you are the only one that knows, in their heart, you were truly innocent and the legal system disagreed, well .all you'd gain is a repeat ... , much better to swallow your bitter pill and move on. Unless you've come to enjoy prison life. lol

What food are you unable to stop eating?

Description : What food are you unable to stop eating?

Last Answer : Chocolate chip cookies. Sweet cantaloupe. Pineapple. .... to name a few.

Three servants were punished after they tried to escape. Two were white, and one was black. The white servants had their contracts extended; the black servant was ordered to serve for the rest of his life. Why were the punishments different?

Description : Three servants were punished after they tried to escape. Two were white, and one was black. The white servants had their contracts extended; the black servant was ordered to serve for the rest of his life. Why were the punishments different?

Last Answer : Because of the servants' race

What is the dance that Tim Allen does during the montage before his second ********* Eve in the Santa Clause?

Description : What is the dance that Tim Allen does during the montage before his second Christmas Eve in the Santa Clause?

Last Answer : It was improvised and done in one take. The Director kept it because it was so good.

How many years do scientists beli eve are left before the sun runs out of hydrogen in its core and leaves the main sequence?

Description : How many years do scientists beli eve are left before the sun runs out of hydrogen in its core and leaves the main sequence?

Last Answer : About 5 billion years. However, long before that - somewherearound 500 million to 1 billion years from now - the Sun isexpected to become so hot that no life can survive on Earth -unless we do something about it, of course.

What are you doing right now for ********* Eve?

Description : What are you doing right now for Christmas Eve?

Last Answer : My family and I just watched Jim Carrey’s The Grinch and Batman: The Dark Knight, and now I’m playing some Twilight Princess and waiting for exhaustion to set in.

What were the habits you had in childhood for which you were punished?

Description : What were the habits you had in childhood for which you were punished?

Last Answer : I was a picky eater. My food could not touch and if it did, I wouldn’t eat it. I had to sit at the table until I ate. I never would. So then I went without dinner. But my dad would sneak in a peanut butter sandwich to me after I was sent to bed. I think he was worried that I didn’t eat.

What is wrong with the people on Judge Judy?

Description : What is wrong with the people on Judge Judy?

Last Answer : Everything is wrong with them.

Should children get punished if they tell ties? Why?

Description : Should children get punished if they tell ties? Why?

Last Answer : Yes. If kids did mistakes, we should punish them. It's not harsh way. It's just to discipline them. Try different punishments like Neel down, running, Eating bitter gourd juice, etc. It makes them healthy and at that time punishment.

How can Society and Politicians be punished, when they commit crimes together by being each others support/partners in crime, against someone/anyone?

Description : How can Society and Politicians be punished, when they commit crimes together by being each others support/partners in crime, against someone/anyone?

Last Answer : That's a tough question, but a very relevant one for my country right now. In the past few years, Brasil has witnessed the reveal of massive, country-wide (and even international) scandals and corruption ... Democracy tries to put power in the hands of the people, but they need to actually use it.

My tomato fruits have small yellow specks on the surface. When the fruit is peeled, those yellow specks form a tough spot that must be cut off before eating the tomatoes. What is wrong?

Description : My tomato fruits have small yellow specks on the surface. When the fruit is peeled, those yellow specks form a tough spot that must be cut off before eating the tomatoes. What is wrong?

Last Answer : A. The yellow speckling is caused by injury from sucking insects such as stinkbugs or leaf-footed bugs. Early control of sucking insects that feed on the fruit is necessary to reduce the problem.

How does a pilot react to heavy freezing rain at 2,000ft/AGL, when he is unable to deice nor land? a. He ascends to the cold air layer above b. He continues to fly at the same altitude c. He turns back before the aircraft loses maneuverability d. He descends to the warm air layer below

Description : How does a pilot react to heavy freezing rain at 2,000ft/AGL, when he is unable to deice nor  land?  a. He ascends to the cold air layer above  b. He continues to fly at the same altitude  c. He turns back before the aircraft loses maneuverability  d. He descends to the warm air layer below

Last Answer : c. He turns back before the aircraft loses maneuverability 

Before the nurse can develop a relevant care plan, the nurse understands that in post-laryngectomy, the trachea and the esophagus are permanently separated. Therefore, which of the following will the nurse expect? A. No risk of aspiration during swallowing; speech is lost B. Normal speaking, breathing and swallowing are restored C. Unable to communicate with difficulty of swallowing and breathing D. Permanent tracheostomy created; normal speech is lost

Description : Before the nurse can develop a relevant care plan, the nurse understands that in post-laryngectomy, the trachea and the esophagus are permanently separated. Therefore, which of the ... with difficulty of swallowing and breathing D. Permanent tracheostomy created; normal speech is lost

Last Answer : D. Permanent tracheostomy created; normal speech is lost

How does a pilot react to heavy freezing rain at 2,000ft/AGL, when he is unable to deice nor land? a. He ascends to the cold air layer above b. He continues to fly at the same altitude c. He turns back before the aircraft loses maneuverability d. He descends to the warm air layer below

Description : How does a pilot react to heavy freezing rain at 2,000ft/AGL, when he is unable to deice nor land? a. He ascends to the cold air layer above b. He continues to fly at the same altitude c. He turns back before the aircraft loses maneuverability d. He descends to the warm air layer below

Last Answer : c. He turns back before the aircraft loses maneuverability

A person was unable to close his right eye. There is dribbling of saliva from right angle of his mouth and he in unable to make a pout. The probable diagnosis is Options: 1) Bell’s Palsy 2) Trigeminal Neuralgia 3) Optic Nerve Injury 4) Oculomotor Nerve Injury

Description : A person was unable to close his right eye. There is dribbling of saliva from right angle of his mouth and he in unable to make a pout. The probable diagnosis is Options: 1) Bell’s Palsy 2) Trigeminal Neuralgia 3) Optic Nerve Injury 4) Oculomotor Nerve Injury

Last Answer : Correct Answer: 1) Bell’s Palsy

What did Adam say the day before *********? -Riddles

Description : What did Adam say the day before Christmas? -Riddles

Last Answer : It's Christmas, Eve!

What did Adam say the day before *********?

Description : What did Adam say the day before Christmas?

Last Answer : its Christmas Eve

Did Adam die before the flood?

Description : Did Adam die before the flood?

Last Answer : Need answer

Can a player in any sport be sued by a fan, or punished, for scoring on their own net, or throwing the game ?

Description : Can a player in any sport be sued by a fan, or punished, for scoring on their own net, or throwing the game ?

Last Answer : No. Never. We are living in the age of cancel culture and it’s already terrifying enough. And it’s not the player’s fault that someone loses money. You put the bet, you know the risk. No one forces you to. Anything else is just needless violence.

In light of Trumps ex-lawyer Cohen’s secretly recording Trump’s conversation(s) do you feel lawyers should be punished by losing their law license forever?

Description : In light of Trumps ex-lawyer Cohen’s secretly recording Trump’s conversation(s) do you feel lawyers should be punished by losing their law license forever?

Last Answer : Please restate for clarity. Do you mean should lawyers who do that be punished? or just Cohen? or all lawyers?

For those who think abortion should be illegal, why should a woman not be punished for requesting one?

Description : For those who think abortion should be illegal, why should a woman not be punished for requesting one?

Last Answer : Or maybe the argument is that the doctor should know better since he is professionally trained. That does not make sense to me. What if the abortion is performed by someone who is not a doctor? Who is liable in that case?

Should this kid be punished or rewarded?

Description : Should this kid be punished or rewarded?

Last Answer : Sounds like something that he was planning to sell. I vote for punishment.

Should this 8 year old be punished?

Description : Should this 8 year old be punished?

Last Answer : answer:If it were the other way around, the four year old stabbing the eight year old, I would say the four year old didn't know any better. Eight years old is old enough to understand the ... in a quiet place with a lot of doctors. I think the parents have some serious explaining to do.

Who was responsible of 911 and who should be punished?

Description : Who was responsible of 911 and who should be punished?

Last Answer : answer:It has been not only ascribed to Al Qaida, but they also loudly proclaimed having done it. So take both sides assignment of responsibility. And there are not schools of thought ... to be confide about. No real authoritative source has come up with a plausible alternative explanation.

Should unsuccessful crime be punished less severely than successful crime?

Description : Should unsuccessful crime be punished less severely than successful crime?

Last Answer : Attempted murder is not the same as murder, even though it was the intention. Sometime ineptitude is rewarded.

Can you attest the validity of this phrase "No Good deed goes un-punished"?

Description : Can you attest the validity of this phrase "No Good deed goes un-punished"?

Last Answer : I don’t think that it is true at all.

Hypothetical: Eleven year old boy damages things when punished. What to do?

Description : Hypothetical: Eleven year old boy damages things when punished. What to do?

Last Answer : Get him into counseling ASAP. That goes way beyond appropriate acting out of anger. Proof isn’t the issue. Anger management and/or diagnosis is.

Should a person who committed an illegal sexual act as a kid still be punished and not play in the NFL?

Description : Should a person who committed an illegal sexual act as a kid still be punished and not play in the NFL?

Last Answer : answer:All Time Felon Team. He should be allowed to play.

Do pets have the cognitive ability to 'punish' their owners? Has your dog (or other pet) ever punished you?

Description : Do pets have the cognitive ability to 'punish' their owners? Has your dog (or other pet) ever punished you?

Last Answer : Gormless Prince would chew his bed to bits if we left him alone in the evening. I eventually stopped buying beds for him and would give him an old pillow to sleep on. I do think it was probably anxiety rather than punishment but I could be wrong.

Should a law be passed that parents should also be punished when their children commit crimes?

Description : Should a law be passed that parents should also be punished when their children commit crimes?

Last Answer : I wouldn’t support a law like that at all. It’s not always the parent’s fault that their kids do the things they do. I’d hate to see my mum or dad punished for something I did. That wouldn’t be fair at all. In fact I couldn’t think of anything worse.