Do you think this woman just "messed up," when she allowed her children to be severely abused?

Do you think this woman just "messed up," when she allowed her children to be severely abused?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:I am not excusing her. Yet the dynamics of an abusive environment can lead people into inexcusable behavior that they would otherwise not take part in. Bear in mind the framing of your question carries much judgment within it: asking if she “just” messed up, The attorney did not say she “just” messed up, that would be minimizing her acceptance of responsibility. And saying she “allowed” her children to be abused implies full ability for her to exercise discretion, yet does not describe what dynamic was going on in the house. She is accepting responsibility for her part in it, and going to jail. She is not getting away with it.
by

Related questions

I think my friend is being abused by his foster parents what do I do?

Description : I think my friend is being abused by his foster parents what do I do?

Last Answer : Document document document. Things might be fresh in your mind right now, but if you can write everything down with clarity and simplicity about what you saw, what you supposed you saw, etc, and keep an ... at school. Talk to them about it too. And bring your written down evidence to all of this.

Why didn't this girl's parents pull her out of school?

Description : Why didn't this girl's parents pull her out of school?

Last Answer : It's so easy to believe nothing bad will really happen. You don't want trouble or dusruption. You could be overreacting. Things will probably turn out all right. If nothing happens, there won't be ... could have. So you talk yourself out of it instead of going into alarm and taking drastic steps.

How do I speak with her about her abusive relationship?

Description : How do I speak with her about her abusive relationship?

Last Answer : answer:What you don't have to do is take verbal abuse from this jerk. Tell him and her the next time he speaks to you like that, you are out of there. As to her hearing you, all you can do is say, ... domestic abuse hotline) 888-743-5754. Then you have to let it go. It's up to her at that point.

Do you think there should be a reconsideration about the foster care system in the Untied States?

Description : Do you think there should be a reconsideration about the foster care system in the Untied States?

Last Answer : answer:During the years following World War II, the U.S. began closing orphanages - large residential institutions - and transitioning to group homes and foster care. Traditional orphanages are no longer a ... care about were to enter the foster system, which seems too much like a game of roulette.

Do you think domestic violence is ever the victim's fault?

Description : Do you think domestic violence is ever the victim's fault?

Last Answer : I’m sure there are enough times when the trigger of violence warrants a closer look (such as the fact that the victim is also violent towards her spouse or abusive of children, etc.) but in the situation you describe, no…besides even if certain situations are explainable, violence isn’t excusable.

Why do you think male rape is taboo?

Description : Why do you think male rape is taboo?

Last Answer : I would assume that homophobia is the culprit. All that I can say is that I hope it is a dynamic that changes, because it certainly isn’t right. I haven’t read the article, yet, so if that was discussed in the article feel free to mod me out.

Which do you think is worse: Elderly abuse or child abuse?

Description : Which do you think is worse: Elderly abuse or child abuse?

Last Answer : answer:Abuse is abuse, in my opinion. Both are horrid. However, if there has to be a worse one, it would depend on the severity of the physical abuse – not so much the age of the victim. It would also depend on the person’s ability to defend themselves and communicate the abuse to someone else.

What do you think about Chris Brown fans?

Description : What do you think about Chris Brown fans?

Last Answer : I don’t see why anyone cares.

My friend, who is a druggie and looks kind of scary at first sight, but is actuallly very nice, sometimes has anger issues and a short temper, will he be fine in the future? Or do you think he will be very violent to be around and abusive?

Description : My friend, who is a druggie and looks kind of scary at first sight, but is actuallly very nice, sometimes has anger issues and a short temper, will he be fine in the future? Or do you think he will be very violent to be around and abusive?

Last Answer : Well.. you can never know for sure… as long as he isn’t physically abusive, because everyone can have anger issues. He could work it out, tell him about how scary he is during when he lashes out, and maybe he could change.

How do I come to terms/deal with all of this?

Description : How do I come to terms/deal with all of this?

Last Answer : Get. The. Heck. Away. From. Him. Physically, emotionally (you might seek help for that), and break all contacts (social media, phone numbers, mail addresses, etc.) He sounds like a manipulative predator.

Have you ever been "gaslighted"?

Description : Have you ever been "gaslighted"?

Last Answer : Yes, by my hubby when he was abusive. That was decades ago. He doesn’t do that anymore, and now he calls out men who abuse. (He’s a rare gem!)

What should I do?

Description : What should I do?

Last Answer : 1. Next time your father is in a violent rage, call 9-1-1. Call them overtime he starts to go off on one of you. 2. Start preparing to move out as soon as possible. When your dad ... not let him back into your life until he has demonstrated he has been to long term counseling and anger management.

Is this considered child neglect? And would you have spoken to to parent in this situation?

Description : Is this considered child neglect? And would you have spoken to to parent in this situation?

Last Answer : No, I don't see it as child abuse or neglect. I see it as two brothers playing. From your description, it's hard to even call it bullying. It's more like horseplay, with the older kid probably not ... . If you had butted in, the father would have been well within his rights to tell you to piss off.

Would you have called the police in this situation?

Description : Would you have called the police in this situation?

Last Answer : Yes of course! Why even question that?

How should I treat an "ex" who was verbally and physically abusive when he's at a party I'm attending?

Description : How should I treat an "ex" who was verbally and physically abusive when he's at a party I'm attending?

Last Answer : Wow. The answer is very individual and probably so complicated that you should work it out with your therapist. You don't have control over your emotional reaction. You feel how you feel and that's neither good ... though, that's why if I were in your shoes I'd spend a few session with a therapist.

Would you say something about workplace abuse under these conditions?

Description : Would you say something about workplace abuse under these conditions?

Last Answer : Yes, I would speak up. You might be helping to mitigate a grave injustice, and you really have nothing to lose. You re safe now, so you can speak, be a voice for the voiceless.

How do you handle dealing with people who don't take abuse you have suffered seriously?

Description : How do you handle dealing with people who don't take abuse you have suffered seriously?

Last Answer : answer:I don't associate with people who do things that hurt me. I encourage my children to do the same. If you are dealing with issues from your past that are painful, it's often safe to work ... - if you find that you feel worse due to interactions there, it's likely that you should stop.

Did stress affected my ovulation and period this month?

Description : Did stress affected my ovulation and period this month?

Last Answer : answer:Stress affects your body, so your period must be affected. According to your description you are suffering from severe stress, so it's no wonder why your period changes. Not to mention the ... your boyfriend for a while. Stress will not only affect your health but also your exam results.

Worst abusive mother ever. What should I do now?

Description : Worst abusive mother ever. What should I do now?

Last Answer : answer:Well, for starters, you should probably see if you can get this question moved to General, because it's obviously a question that you want to have answered seriously - since it's such a serious topic ... the future; it comes down to how you deal with it and map out your actions from now on.

What are the chances of a teenage boy like this turning into an abuser?

Description : What are the chances of a teenage boy like this turning into an abuser?

Last Answer : Well; I can safely say that the last one is not abusing anyone.

Why do caregivers abuse the elderly?

Description : Why do caregivers abuse the elderly?

Last Answer : There is really never an excuse for abuse. I think the elderly are susceptible because #1, they are often unable to defend themselves and sometimes unable to communicate well enough to either ... to losing their tempers or resorting to abusive behavior will snap under the right circumstances.

Has anyone here (and not necessarily on this particular website) ever been "trolled" before?

Description : Has anyone here (and not necessarily on this particular website) ever been "trolled" before?

Last Answer : answer:I cannot speak for other sites but on Fluther you would contact the community manager Augustlan. She is well-equipped to help and is an expert at this sort of thing. And just to let you know. Fluther is not a troll-friendly site. We do not tolerate harassment.

How does someone disappear, permanently, because of DV and threats?

Description : How does someone disappear, permanently, because of DV and threats?

Last Answer : answer:First thing to do is report the threats to the police. They might not act on them but if you have every threat documented with them it will come in handy later. After that there are ... people in your situation and are able to provide shelter. This website provides details that may be useful.

How do you question the actions of a supposed hero?

Description : How do you question the actions of a supposed hero?

Last Answer : answer:Is this possible hypothermia hypothetical? Either way too many may(s) and possible(s) for my taste. Unless the eye witness (you?) is 100% sure, I would not risk destroying someone ... damaging accusations such as these. And the fact that she is a hero is irrelevant to the equation.

Are blackouts and crying fits common with post traumatic stress disorder?

Description : Are blackouts and crying fits common with post traumatic stress disorder?

Last Answer : Someone hit you while you were at the gym? I’m confused.

Why is it so much more acceptable to berate someone verbally than it is to do so physically?

Description : Why is it so much more acceptable to berate someone verbally than it is to do so physically?

Last Answer : Verbal abuse causes mental and emotional scars. Physical abuse causes physical, mental, and emotional scars.

Have you ever hit yourself?

Description : Have you ever hit yourself?

Last Answer : I have run into things, but never intentionaly “hit” or “punched” myself. I have, however, gotten very mad and kicked a wall and that hurt like hell.

Is multi-tasking abusive?

Description : Is multi-tasking abusive?

Last Answer : I have deliberately kept my life relatively simple as I function musch better when not over-stressed. I am fortunate to be able to afford to work only part time and do not carry a cellphone on purpose ... all that comes at one in America today and partly because of Fluther! (Seriously.) But I try .

I'm dealing with a co-worker who's partner is emotionally abusive? Why are people emotionally abusive?

Description : I'm dealing with a co-worker who's partner is emotionally abusive? Why are people emotionally abusive?

Last Answer : A better question might be, what is your coworker doing about it?

Why don't we take childhood obesity much more seriously as a society?

Description : Why don't we take childhood obesity much more seriously as a society?

Last Answer : Do you want to make it illegal to have a fat kid??? Kids used to walk to school or ride a bike, now most are bussed. After school was spent at the playground playing pick up basketball, baseball ... is all organized and don't forget to properly hydrate! Add to that a lot of parents are overweight.

Do you care about what happens to rapists in prisons?

Description : Do you care about what happens to rapists in prisons?

Last Answer : From what I hear, they get what they had coming to them… usually. But no, it’s not very high on my list of things to care about.

my daughter lives in champaign ,il she has two children,she was living in shelter for abused moms and children the shelter is closing due to funds. she has no place to go . please anyone is there any homeless shelters in rantoul ,il. ?

Description : my daughter lives in champaign ,il she has two children,she was living in shelter for abused moms and children the shelter is closing due to funds. she has no place to go . please anyone is there any homeless shelters in rantoul ,il. ?

Last Answer : No she would need to go to the big city Catholic Worker House-St Jude 317 South Randolph Street, Champaign, IL- (217) 355-9774

She gave me a cold shoulder when I went to see her. (1) abused me (2) insulted me (3) ignored me

Description : She gave me a cold shoulder when I went to see her. (1) abused me (2) insulted me (3) ignored me

Last Answer : (3) ignored me

A wealthy wise old woman feared that her daughter was lazy and as a result rather stupid. When the old woman died, her will stipulated that her assets were to be liquidated and a check was to be written for the full amount. The check was to be placed in one of three envelopes. The other two envelopes would contain a blank piece of paper. If the daughter could determine from the writing on the envelope which envelope contained the check, she would inherit her mother's fortune. Otherwise, the fortune would go to the old woman's favorite charity for animals. The daughter was not allowed to touch the envelopes. Her decision had to be made based on the writing on the envelopes. The daughter was told that only one envelope had a true statement and that the other two statements were false. The en

Description : A wealthy wise old woman feared that her daughter was lazy and as a result rather stupid. When the old woman died, her will stipulated that her assets were to be liquidated and a check was to be ... only one envelope had a true statement and that the other two statements were false. The en -Riddles

Last Answer : The daughter should pick envelope 1. Unfortunately she picked envelope 3. Statements 1 and 2 were false, and the only true statement was statement 3. If the check was in envelope 1, that would make statement 1 ... both be true. If the check was in envelope 3, statements 1 and 3 would both be true.

If a woman developed skin cancer as result of a mutated gene in the skin cells of her arms could she pass skin cancer gene to her children justify your answer?

Description : If a woman developed skin cancer as result of a mutated gene in the skin cells of her arms could she pass skin cancer gene to her children justify your answer?

Last Answer : Need answer

If you have a severely matted dog and he or she is fearful of the clippers, is sedation an option?

Description : If you have a severely matted dog and he or she is fearful of the clippers, is sedation an option?

Last Answer : If the dog is severely freaked, I personally would start at the vet, for light sedation and to have the worst of the mats removed. I had to do this with my Westie when I first adopted him. He had ... stuff, and had a skin problem to boot. The first grooming was done with light sedation at the vet.

Doctors, those who work with battered women, children and abused animals; how do you detach yourself from your work?

Description : Doctors, those who work with battered women, children and abused animals; how do you detach yourself from your work?

Last Answer : answer:You could also ask this qusetion in relations to a police officer. We see as much, if not more, than medical doctors.

The children living next door are being horribly abused by their parents. The only way to stop the abuse is to adopt the children and care for them in your home. Would you?

Description : The children living next door are being horribly abused by their parents. The only way to stop the abuse is to adopt the children and care for them in your home. Would you?

Last Answer : answer:Absolutely. edited for poor spelling Oh, and also - I'm a survivor myself, and I can't stand seeing other kids suffering. I know I can't save everyone, but in this hypothetical situation, there's ... adopt a few children at some point in the future. My husband and I both want a large family.

Avatars can help abused children?

Description : Avatars can help abused children?

Last Answer : feel safe and more confident.

What would you say to your 31-year-old daughter who sticks with a man who has abused her?

Description : What would you say to your 31-year-old daughter who sticks with a man who has abused her?

Last Answer : answer:Your daughter ls living with a stick of dynamite, but you know this. I realize that love can sometimes be blind, but domestic violence situations can turn ugly, really fast. Even to the point of death. ... an extreme move on your part as her parent, but how far would you go to save her life?

My cat got into a fight with a stray and her ear is all messed up - how can I clean it?

Description : My cat got into a fight with a stray and her ear is all messed up - how can I clean it?

Last Answer : I would take her to the vet for an antibiotic shot, and professional check. She might have punctures other places under her fur, as well, that could abcess if not treated. That happened to my cat once ... 't seen, and had quite a time clearing up her infection from that one tiny puncture. Good Luck!

What do women do when they see a grave ? I know that women are not allowed to visit graves. But if a woman ever walks past a grave on the side of a road , will she be able to salute the gravedigger ? What should women do if they see a grave ?

Description : What do women do when they see a grave ? I know that women are not allowed to visit graves. But if a woman ever walks past a grave on the side of a road , will she be able to salute the gravedigger ? What should women do if they see a grave ?

Last Answer : The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) forbade women to visit graves ; On the contrary, he said about visiting the graves of women , " Allah's curse is on those who visit graves." ... forbidden act has been termed as a cursed act by the Hadith of the Prophet (peace be upon him).

A couple, both severely retarded/down's syndrome/etcetera: should society literally prevent them from having children?

Description : A couple, both severely retarded/down's syndrome/etcetera: should society literally prevent them from having children?

Last Answer : Your other question was easier. Neither of them are able to take care of the child?

Olive Oyl: A ditzy naïve woman who just wants to find love and doesn’t realize all the trouble she’s causing? Or is she a trouble making skank, who gets off on watching men fight each other for her affection?

Description : Olive Oyl: A ditzy naïve woman who just wants to find love and doesn’t realize all the trouble she’s causing? Or is she a trouble making skank, who gets off on watching men fight each other for her affection?

Last Answer : answer:Can’t she be both? Neither Popeye nor Bluto are real catches. I wonder about her insecurity and self-image if those are the only two guys she can feel comfortable with. She can do better. I suppose in the end, her choice will be based on whether or not she likes the taste of spinach.

What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Description : What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Last Answer : Uhhhhhh OP you good?

What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Description : What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Last Answer : Uhhhhhh OP you good?

What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Description : What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Last Answer : Uhhhhhh OP you good?

What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Description : What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Last Answer : Uhhhhhh OP you good?

What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Description : What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Last Answer : Uhhhhhh OP you good?

What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Description : What's your thoughts on a Childfree 26 year old woman that Never wants to move out of her parents house but works full time as a CNA/med tech and is very productive. She just simply would Rather have a Relationship without having kids nor living with her significant other?

Last Answer : Uhhhhhh OP you good?