What is your take on the "first cause" argument?

What is your take on the "first cause" argument?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

My take is it’s a steaming load of BS. We do not know that 1 is true. We do not know that 2 is true. We do not know that 3 is true. And we don’t even know if the Universe always existed, or came suddenly into existence. The “first cause” argument is based on nothing but conjecture and an unsubstantiated assumption that what we currently perceive to be true has been as it is now throughout all time. It’s all based on human perceptions and observations made locally, and does not have any established validity when applied to all timespace.
by

Related questions

If our entire universe was moved 8 metres to the left would anyone notice?

Description : If our entire universe was moved 8 metres to the left would anyone notice?

Last Answer : No one would know because there is no stable non-moving point of reference. And the universe is constantly expanding so we’ve moved farther than that between that moment. And this one.

Is there a relationship between the Noösphere, The Singularity and cyberspace?

Description : Is there a relationship between the Noösphere, The Singularity and cyberspace?

Last Answer : answer:I think there is a connection, but they are not exactly one and the same. It seems that the Noosphere is the next step from the Biosphere. ( In the theory of Vernadsky, the noosphere ... they are progressions of the preceding theory, i.e. they evolve from the previous condition of mankind.

Our universe is a bit older - How many people are already aware of this?

Description : Our universe is a bit older - How many people are already aware of this?

Last Answer : I don’t get any of this. Who cares? What difference does this sort of thing mean to us? How on earth do they know? Will it all change again just when we get used to it?

Is Jupiter really bigger than Saturn?

Description : Is Jupiter really bigger than Saturn?

Last Answer : answer:Jupiter is much bigger than Saturn in mass. Saturn would actually float on water, theoretically of course.

Does the Universe have a centre?

Description : Does the Universe have a centre?

Last Answer : Yep! You’re looking at her ;)

What's the matter with matter? (Strange Universe Series -- 2011).

Description : What's the matter with matter? (Strange Universe Series -- 2011).

Last Answer : answer:I think 1 or more hidden properties of the universe exist, and Dark Matter is a convenient way to hand wave a lot of things. If we do eventually find dark matter, I ... a new fundamental force that controls its behavior, weakly interacts with normal matter, and varies over distance.

What happens when the expansion of the Universe reaches the speed of light?

Description : What happens when the expansion of the Universe reaches the speed of light?

Last Answer : answer:The short answer is: It can’t. The observation of speed is relative, not absolute.

As a scientific theory, how good is the God Model?

Description : As a scientific theory, how good is the God Model?

Last Answer : Not too good. There are far too many small pieces which makes it difficult to glue together.

If we live in a multiverse, how many are there?

Description : If we live in a multiverse, how many are there?

Last Answer : Removed by me. Brain freeze.

Can you provide an argument against CO2 being the main cause of Global Warming?

Description : Can you provide an argument against CO2 being the main cause of Global Warming?

Last Answer : I think this question could get real ugly. You're asking people to provide legitimate scientific information to argue against the scientific consensus. In other words, a bunch of programmers, ... chance of understanding what we know about climate change is to understand the scientific consensus.

The following statement is an example of what kind of logical fallacy? "The university should increase funding of intramural sports because it has a responsibility to back its sports programs financially." a) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship b) Circular Reasoning c) Ad Populum (Bandwagon) Argument d) False Analogy e) None of the above

Description : The following statement is an example of what kind of logical fallacy? "The university should increase funding of intramural sports because it has a responsibility to back its sports programs financially." a) ... Reasoning c) Ad Populum (Bandwagon) Argument d) False Analogy e) None of the above

Last Answer : b) Circular Reasoning

What kind of argument is the following: "Raising the speed limit is like giving **** to an alcoholic." a) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship b) False Analogy c) Ad Populum (Join the bandwagon) Argument d) Circular Reasoning e) None of the above

Description : What kind of argument is the following: "Raising the speed limit is like giving beer to an alcoholic." a) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship b) False Analogy c) Ad Populum (Join the bandwagon) Argument d) Circular Reasoning e) None of the above

Last Answer : b) False Analogy

What kind of fallacy is the following: "I wore this exact same baseball cap when I got an "A" last week and the week before. If I wear my lucky baseball cap, I will get "A"s on all my tests." a) Circular Reasoning b) False Analogy c) Ad Hominem Argument d) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship e) None of the above

Description : What kind of fallacy is the following: "I wore this exact same baseball cap when I got an "A" last week and the week before. If I wear my lucky baseball cap, I will get "A"s on all my ... Reasoning b) False Analogy c) Ad Hominem Argument d) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship e) None of the above

Last Answer : d) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship

The following statement is an example of what kind of logical fallacy? "The university should increase funding of intramural sports because it has a responsibility to back its sports programs financially." a) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship b) Circular Reasoning c) Ad Populum (Bandwagon) Argument d) False Analogy e) None of the above

Description : The following statement is an example of what kind of logical fallacy? "The university should increase funding of intramural sports because it has a responsibility to back its sports programs financially." a) ... Reasoning c) Ad Populum (Bandwagon) Argument d) False Analogy e) None of the above

Last Answer : b) Circular Reasoning

What kind of argument is the following: "Raising the speed limit is like giving **** to an alcoholic." a) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship b) False Analogy c) Ad Populum (Join the bandwagon) Argument d) Circular Reasoning e) None of the above

Description : What kind of argument is the following: "Raising the speed limit is like giving beer to an alcoholic." a) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship b) False Analogy c) Ad Populum (Join the bandwagon) Argument d) Circular Reasoning e) None of the above

Last Answer : b) False Analogy

"I wore this exact same baseball cap when I got an "A" last week and the week before. If I wear my lucky baseball cap, I will get "A"s on all my tests." a) Circular Reasoning b) False Analogy c) Ad Hominem Argument d) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship e) None of the above

Description : "I wore this exact same baseball cap when I got an "A" last week and the week before. If I wear my lucky baseball cap, I will get "A"s on all my tests." a) Circular Reasoning b) False Analogy c) Ad Hominem Argument d) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship e) None of the above

Last Answer : d) Faulty Cause-Effect Relationship

The relationship between premises and conclusion in a deductive argument is--. A) Cause-Effect B) Analytic-Synthetic C) A priori-A posterior D) Implication-Entailment.

Description : The relationship between premises and conclusion in a deductive argument is--. A) Cause-Effect B) Analytic-Synthetic C) A priori-A posterior D) Implication-Entailment. 

Last Answer : D) Implication-Entailment. 

How do you handle it when someone throws you under the bus, trying to get you to take sides in an argument or issue?

Description : How do you handle it when someone throws you under the bus, trying to get you to take sides in an argument or issue?

Last Answer : The day I sport the robe and swing the gavel, is the day I will judge for you. Not before.