If the Jews left Israel what would happen in the middle east?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:Thomas Edward Lawrence (Lawrence of Arabia) was quite antisemitic; however, he was one of a group of Brits who were to decide on a National home for Jewish people. In 1917 Great Britain issued the Balfour Declaration for “the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people“and how much British held land in the Middle East was to go to the Jewish people. At first they assigned a much larger amount but Arabs were opposed to Jews having any property with oil. Oil became extremely important and less land was reserved for the Jews than originally planned. “It was only after the Jews re-inhabited their historic homeland of Judea and Samaria, that the myth of an Arab Palestinian nation was created and marketed worldwide. Jews come from Judea, not Palestinians. There is no language known as Palestinian, or any Palestinian culture distinct from that of all the Arabs in the area. There has never been a land known as Palestine governed by Palestinians. “Palestinians” are Arabs indistinguishable from Arabs throughout the Middle East. The great majority of Arabs in greater Palestine and Israel share the same culture, language and religion.” To get on topic here I can only paraphrase but T.E. Lawrence who is known for romanticizing Arab culture based on history said: Any part of a desert where Jews settle becomes an olive orchard and the land becomes an oasis. Any part of a desert where Arabs dwell becomes a garbage dump. And this was from a guy who loved them. I paraphrase only because I don’t have the original text book on hand any more. I am a historian by education. But that was very much what he believed. If Israeli’s were ever forced to leave Israel, which I doubt will happen, and all the many universities and research, technical and agricultural projects disappeared, it would look like it did before the Jewish people settled it. Pretty much a slum in the desert. The now called Palestinians were nomadic tribes – there was no Palestine – that was a rude name given to the area by the conquering Romans. The nomadic tribes had representation in Jordan and were considered Jordanians. After Israel was recognized, they were kept out of Jordan and it’s neighboring countries. “The rebirth of Israel was accompanied by economic prosperity for the region. Arabs migrated to this area to find employment and enjoy the higher standard of living. In documents not more than hundred years, the area is described as a scarcely populated region. Jews by far were the majority in Jerusalem over the small Arab minority. Until the Oslo agreement the major source of income for Arab residents was employment in the Israeli sector. To this day, many Arabs try to migrate into Israel with various deceptions to become a citizen of Israel.”

Related questions

Description : Come Friday - at the United Nations - the Palestinians will ask for an independant State. Netanyahu will be there and he, along with everyone else will vote YES. There will be peace in the middle east - swords will be made into ploughshares and gasoline will be a nickel a gallon. Right?

Last Answer : answer:I'm not sure what you are really asking here. Your question is facetious, yes, but what are you hoping for? That someone will offer you hope? That someone has a real crystal ball? Are you just ... large families choose hard times to have them in? Right. Mr. 1997 (your lurve as I write this).

Description : Tuesday, at Obama's "request," Netanyahu and Abu Mazen will summit. Peace in the Middle East just around the corner?

Last Answer : put pressure on israel. threaten to cease any financial or military support, threaten with sanctions or embargoes. right now israel is acting like a spoilt child, and needs a slap on the wrist.

Description : Will president Obama be good with the middle east conflict?

Last Answer : That’s an excellent question and one that I’m not qualified to answer but I am really looking forward to seeing what other people here at Fluther think about this question.

Description : Why isn't the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians referred to as Civil War?

Last Answer : For exactly the same reason the expropriation of our own land from its native residents was not a civil war. The proper word (and everybody knows it) is of course THEFT.

Description : What is an appropriate way to criticize the policies and actions of the State of Israel and the influence of the Pro-Israel lobby without being antisemitic?

Last Answer : I would preface such comments with some sort of disclaimer, with no disrespect to the religious beliefs of any involved people…

Description : Has anything changed in Israel since Trump declared that Jerusalem is the Capital?

Last Answer : I would like to hear what Jimmy Carter has to say on the issue. My guess is that the regions progress is set aback twenty years.

Description : Have you heard of this law that SC passed regarding not being able to criticize Israel?

Last Answer : This is just one of several unintended consequences that stem from attempting to normalize censorship of speech and ideas. Hate speech is just that, hatefull but it should not be censored because if you ... is there behind free speech when the tide turns like this? This law should scare everybody.

Description : If the UN guaranteed Israel a piece of land, why all the Presidents before Trump were (maybe i'm mistaken) in favor of Palestine?

Last Answer : America is almost always on the side of Isreal not Palestine. Bush Sr and a few others may not have 100% embraced it, but many did. https://www.nytimes.com/2006/08/02/world/americas/02iht-bush.2363483.html

Description : What are your thoughts on what's currently happening between the Palestinians, and Israel?

Last Answer : As relevant now as it was then.

Description : We all know that Israel and most of the Arab countries nearby are not even remotely friendly. Suppose that an Israeli commercial plane (El Al, for example) had engine trouble and had to make an ... that country - who doesn't acknowledge that Israel exists - do with 300 passengers and the plane?

Last Answer : Most of the Arab states would allow an emergency landing. Iran would be a no. But an Israeli airliner has no business being in their airspace to begin with.

Description : Why are you pro-Israel?

Last Answer : answer:I am pro-Israel because as a people, the Jewish people are worthy of a homeland in their ancient land. They have been persecuted for millennia, and almost exterminated by the Nazi's. ... the Palestinian residents. Yet an attempt at a peaceful existence would have led to prosperity for all.

Description : Why does the US support Israel?

Last Answer : answer:A lot of reasons. Here are a few off the top of my head. Feel free to agree, disagree, nitpick, whatever. I am throwing out ideas to get the conversation going. I am not trying to make a ... has only become a big factor in the past 30 years. PS Here is a funny topical article from The Onion

Description : How do you pronounce "Czernowin" (last name of a person from Israel)?

Last Answer : answer:Looks Russian. I would guess Zir-now-en (maybe in not en) but I am guessing as an American. Best to ask the person how they prefer their name be pronounced. I’ll send it to an Israeli jelly. Not sure if he has been around lately.

Description : What do you think about the comments Romney made about Israel and culture?

Last Answer : His comments would only be true if the Palestinians didn’t have so many restrictions placed on them by Israel on trade.

Description : Should Israel attack Iran's nuclear program?

Last Answer : Damned if they do; damned if they don’t.

Description : What did you think about the 60 Minutes episode last night about Christians in Israel?

Last Answer : Now I have to find it on the intranet.

Description : US Support for Israel? Too much already?

Last Answer : I’m not that educated on the subject, but from what I’ve read about it, the US is close to Israel for whatever reason. I guess the suggestion is that they’re too close, but if it wasn’t Israel, it would be somewhere else? This is just International Relations: friends and enemies for self interest.

Description : Would impending mutual doom force Israel and Palestine to create peace?

Last Answer : I dunno – would it work for the US in all the wars it’s involved in right now?

Description : Could toddlers solve major disputes, like Israel/Palestine and the like?

Last Answer : I would not call it a childish view; I would call it naive, maybe. Toddlers reasons for a dispute in the sandbox would be far less complex than the Israel/Palestine dispute. You not only have the ... in religion, tolerance, hatred, power plays, and a myriad of other complex (if not logical) issues.

Description : To what extent does Judaism play a role in the state of Israel?

Last Answer : answer:There is a long standing tension in Israel between Orthodox interpretation of laws and secular interpretation. This carries to such things as travel on the Sabbath, non-kosher food stuffs ... Orthodox right has worked to tighten the privilege. You should find discussion in recent periodicals.

Description : Will you please answer two questions I have about the two state solution for Israel and the Palestinians?

Last Answer : Without getting too bogged down in the details that will surely follow, my gut is: 1) Nope. I imagine most may even stay in Israel if they're welcome since Israel's economy is in far better ... recognize their sovereignty, even if Israel will somehow cede their claim on the land (also won't happen).

Description : Is it reasonable for Palestine to expect all descendants of refugees to be allowed to migrate to Israel?

Last Answer : answer:I wish both sides nothing but success in this process and hope that a settlement can be reached for the worlds sake, for Isreal's sake, and for the palastinians sake. When I heard Netenyahu on ... that have the right to exsist but that would be Christlike and we wouldn't want that would we.

Description : What is the approximate value of a Taglit trip (Birthright Israel) for one person?

Last Answer : According to this article, about $2500 per person in 2007.

Description : If 78% of Palestine is Jordan and 22% of Palestine is Israel why do the Palestinians say Israel stole Palestine?

Last Answer : Good point. Actually blame the bloody Brits. Why don’t Palestinians?

Description : Why were so many people upset about what Helen Thomas said about Israel? Does that land not really belong to them? I always thought it didn't...

Last Answer : Where are you from? Does the United States still belong to the Native Americans? Does Canada belong to the UK? Do we ignore every U.N. vote based on some other “people” complaining about it?

Description : Israel intentionally humiliates the turkish ambassador on camera. What do you think about this?

Last Answer : I read it twice and I just can’t get the image of a group of little kids, feeling so self-important and acting like it, until someone comes along and takes away their toys.

Description : What is your opinion on the latest news from Israel?

Last Answer : That’s completely bogus. Why would they need/want that? Do I really want to know?

Description : What do you think about the fact that Israel will not accept a Palaestinian state with full sovereignty while demanding that Palaestina recognise Israel's full sovereignty?

Last Answer : Well, what can I say – I think it’s baloney but you don’t want me to get started with my anti-Israeli politics sentiments

Description : Does Israel have the right to invade Gaza?

Last Answer : Did America have the right to invade Iraq? No one really has the “right” to invade another country, but if you have the resources and sufficient reasoning, than you have the “privilege” of doing so. Edit: I don’t have a definition for “sufficient reasoning.”

Description : How does the "Security Fence," Israel is building differ from me building a fence that wraps around my neighbors swimming pool and rose garden?

Last Answer : Does your neighbor routinely strap bombs to his chest and blow himself up in your kitchen?

Description : Why does Israel, who America gives billions of dollars a year to, not have a mutual extradition law with us and allow criminals from the U.S. to flee to Israel to escape prosecution here?

Last Answer : I'm under the impression (and it could be wrong but this is just what I've heard) that we give them millions, not billions. Granted it's hundreds of millions, but yah. Back up the numbers you ... law as it might force us to extradite some people that we don't think should be, think Palestinians).

Description : Do you believe the US should continue to support Israel to the near unconditional magnitdue which currently does?

Last Answer : based on what you have said, no they should not.

Description : Are you for or against the "two-state solution" of Palestine/Israel why or why not?

Last Answer : Whatever stops the violence now and whatever ceases future violence, opression and persecution.

Description : Do you think Israel is a de facto fascist state?

Last Answer : Hmmm .. Yes and no .. They vote, their people enjoy lots of freedoms despite some controls, and the people are largely nationalistic of their own will. I've met a few Jews from Israel, and they tend ... they do have some fascist qualities about them. But nearly a century of war will do that too ya.

Description : Do the saudis hate israel?

Last Answer : Look, Iraqis and Iranians don't hate Israel mostly. Most of these people think about work, friends, talking about sports or spending time with the family. And in many cases, just trying to make it through ... wish there would be peace in the region. Only hate and blood seems to make the news shows.

Description : How long do you think it will be before Israel bombs Iran?

Last Answer : I think – Monday-ish? Is that a good day for you?

Description : What countries consider Israel a country and why do many countries not like Israel?

Last Answer : People tend to not like Israel for the same reasons that people do not like the USA. They prick wave their way into everything.

Description : If Iran attacks Israel,what do you think the USA and the world will do?

Last Answer : Bomb the living shit out of them and run an oil pipeline directly to 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.

Description : In the Israel/Palestine conflict, who do you consider to be the aggressor?

Last Answer : Britain was the aggressor.

Description : Do the Falasha (Ethiopian) Jews identify with the Mizrahi or the Sephardi?

Last Answer : The word “Falasha” is considered a derogatory term.

Description : Does how you feel about the Israeli Palestinian conflict have anything to do with how you feel about Jews, Israelis, Palestinians or Muslims in your country?

Last Answer : If you're asking if the Israeli/Palestinian issue influences my views on Jewish or Palestinian residents of the United States, the answer is: Yes. Of course I make assumptions, the ... Palestinians pro Palestine. Interacting with Jews or Palestinians here, the topic rarely comes up. Interesting

Description : How is it that so many Jews ended up in the forests of central Europe?

Last Answer : answer:I am not sure how the Jews wound up in Europe, I think probably we travelled to where the work was or where we were not being killed or enslaved, but that is a guess, my history ... 1900's, Many considered themselves Zionists. I don't find your question antisemitic or offensive by the way.

Description : Do the Jews get any preference when it comes to issues of racism?

Last Answer : answer:Anti-Israeli govt. =/= Antisemetism (i.e. Anti-Jew ) All the Jews/Israelis I've ever met disagreed with a lot of the internationally contentious behaviours of the Israeli Govt. And, ... says, he's a natural power-monger. Sounds like he's buddies with the expansionist Israeli politicians.

Description : Why were the Jews given Palestine?

Last Answer : For the record, the British Mandate and subsequent UN partition did not give Palestine to the Jews. It was split into two states initially, that were subsequently unified during the war of 1948 (when ... Kingdom (it could easily have been incorporated as part of the plan back then, but wasn't).

Description : Why some Jews are for West Bank & Gaza (Settlements) and others are not?

Last Answer : Why are some people for any issue and some not. There are differences of opinions. I don’t know of any population of humans that thinks in lock step on any issue. We are not a hive mind, after all.

Description : Have you been following Ahed Tamimi's case?

Last Answer : I'd completely forgotten about her. I see she got 8 months. The situation with Israel has to be one of the truly great ironies in history's many tragedies. Of all the peoples on the earth, ... with their foot on the throat of an oppressed people. It's almost unbelievable and is tragic BEYOND belief.

Description : Do you support BDS?

Last Answer : I have not been paying attention to it but I support the concept. Israel should be leading the region out of the Dark Ages, but the right wingers and fundamentalists have a stake in maintaining strife. They can do it because US taxpayers are subsidizing them.

Description : UN Ambassador Nikki Haley announced that the US will be "taking names" of countries that vote against the US in the Jerusalem embassy move controversy. Is this a smart foreign policy move by the US?

Last Answer : Well, it’s pretty easy for her. Just take a list of U.N. Security Council member states, cross the US off the list, and there are all the names. The US has renounced diplomacy and openly said there is no foreign policy other than the US economy.

Description : Does Cuomo have public support for his new anti-BDS executive order?

Last Answer : Sure he does. Most Americans know only what they see on TV. And TV tells them that to be “pro-Israel” means supporting far-right Israeli parties and politicians. And TV tells them that Arab means “ISIS and al Qaeda”.

Description : What do you think of this video of an Israeli soldier and a young boy?

Last Answer : answer:My thoughts are that it was completely unnecessary for a soldier with what appears to be some kind of semi-automatic weapon (I don't know guns) try to arrest a young boy with a ... to protect the child was kicking into high gear. I have strong opinions about Israel/Palestine in general.