How was johns Marshall interpretation of the constitution different from Thomas Jefferson?

1 Answer

Answer :

John Marshall had a loose interpretation of the Constitutionwhile Thomas Jefferson supposedly had a strict interpretation ofit. John Marshall strongly believed in the elastic clause (thenecessary and proper clause) which meant: "The Congress shall havePower - To make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper forcarrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powersvested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States,or in any Department or Officer thereof". So he thought that if alaw was needed, then it could be added and adjusted into theConstitution and one didn't have to stick to the exact words of theConstitution. Thomas Jefferson supposedly had a strict constructionof the Constitution, but his actions such as the Louisiana Purchaseand the Embargo Act showed loose interpretations because neitherone of those were written in the Constitution. He very rarelyshowed a strict interpretation where he stuck directly to theConstitution, so they really weren't that different in views eventhough in titles they were.

Related questions

Description : What position did Thomas Jefferson take in the debate over the Constitution?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : The Nobel Prize, 2005 for Literature has been awarded to (1) Robert J. Aumann and Thomas C. Schelling (2) Robert H. Grubbs and Richard R. Schrock (3) Harold Pinter (4) Barry J. Marshall and J Robin Warren

Last Answer : Harold Pinter

Description : There was a common traits of George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and Sam Adams?

Last Answer : They brewed beer

Description : On which date Thomas Jefferson wrote the last letter?

Last Answer : 26th June 1826

Description : A fine example of colonial architecture is Monticello, the home of Thomas Jefferson?

Last Answer : Monique, we are improving our product to make doing your homework faster and much easier. Would you mind taking a moment with us to share your opinions and suggestions? If so please schedule a time that works for you: https://calendly.com/answers-design/15min

Description : What did Thomas Jefferson based his unalienable rights on the work of what?

Last Answer : The statements made in the beginning of the Declaration ofIndependence are from the philosophy of john Locke. His philosophywas revolutionary because people had no rights for anything. Onlykings had rights.

Description : Why did Thomas Jefferson oppose re chartering the bank of the us in 1811?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : How did Thomas Jefferson behave after being elected?

Last Answer : Thomas Jefferson acted more like a gentleman farmer than a privileged politician after elected.

Description : What would thomas Jefferson do to prove a point?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : Why was Thomas Jefferson alarmed to learn that the French control the Louisiana territory?

Last Answer : U.S. President Thomas Jefferson was worried bout what would happen to U.S. trade on the Mississippi.

Description : When did Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton run for presidant?

Last Answer : Jefferson ran in 1796, but lost to John Adams. He ran again andwon against Adams in 1800. Hamilton never ran for president.Hamilton was not born in the US, and was not eligible to bePresident.

Description : What decimal system of America's did Thomas Jefferson disign?

Last Answer : Jefferson designed a decimal system for weights and measureswhich was proposed to Congress before the metric system (The SIsystem) which is now used throughout the world. He also devised adecimal ... of countries still stuck withthe Imperial system though it did adopt the decimal currency in1792.

Description : What two assertions of Thomas Jefferson helped James Madison change his mind about the need for a Bill of Rights and nbsp?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : Why was Thomas Jefferson alarm to learn that the french-controlled the Louisiana Territory?

Last Answer : U.S. President Thomas Jefferson was worried bout what would happen to U.S. trade on the Mississippi.

Description : When Thomas Jefferson wrote all men are equal to whom was he likely referring to?

Last Answer : He meant “mankind “ was created equal. His reference doesn’tmean what we think today because of the difference in time and theworld. In his world no one was equal and everyone was below theking.

Description : What did thomas Jefferson find his polygraph machine so very handy?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : How did Thomas Jefferson try to unite the nation after he was elected?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : Why did president thomas Jefferson want to buy new Orleans and west Florida from France?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : What did thomas Jefferson do to the Missouri compromise?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : What did thomas Jefferson meant by the phrase and ldquoshall restrain men from injuring one another and?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : Did Thomas Jefferson been referring to citizens who sought to poison others?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : What Thomas Jefferson urged architects to model bulding designs after the style used in?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : What accomplishment of Thomas Jefferson is reflected by the unorganized territory of the US?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : How did the opinions of Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton differ on the issue of the whiskey rebellion?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : Was Thomas Jefferson a trustworthy person?

Last Answer : i dont see how he cant be a trustworthy person

Description : What did thomas Jefferson feel?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : What did Thomas Jefferson john Adams Benjamin Franklin believed that the new republic must?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : Why was Thomas Jefferson alarm to learn that the french-controlled the Louisiana Territory?

Last Answer : U.S. President Thomas Jefferson was worried bout what would happen to U.S. trade on the Mississippi.

Description : When Thomas Jefferson wrote all men are equal to whom was he likely referring to?

Last Answer : He meant “mankind “ was created equal. His reference doesn’tmean what we think today because of the difference in time and theworld. In his world no one was equal and everyone was below theking.

Description : How much is a Thomas Jefferson 1985, 185th anniversary coin worth It looks to me as if it is gold, but im not sure. How bout a John Fitzgerald Kennedy 1985 25th anniversary coin, which also looks gold. How much would that one be ?

Last Answer : I would switch over to Dish Network. They are much cheaper than cable. You should also get Vonage for your phone or get the Magic Jack.

Description : What role did Thomas Jefferson play in the development of democracy in the US?

Last Answer : he wrote the Declaration of Independence

Description : Does Thomas Jefferson have children?

Last Answer : Yes, Thomas Jefferson has 6 kids.

Description : Can I sale a Thomas Jefferson 1802-1809 stamp ?

Last Answer : Can I sale my Thomas Jefferson 1802-1809 stamp ? And to who ?

Description : The Republican Party as Thomas Jefferson knew it later became the _______ Party.?

Last Answer : democratic (A+)

Description : Which of these foreign policy decisions was made by President Thomas Jefferson?

Last Answer : To buy the Louisiana Territory from France (apex)

Description : When Thomas Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence he said that all men had three basic rights - what were those three rights?

Last Answer : "Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness."

Description : When Thomas Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence he said that all men had three basic rights - what were those three rights?

Last Answer : "Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness."

Description : Who drafted the ?Declaration of American Independence? a. George Washington b. Thomas Jefferson c. Karl Marx d. None of these

Last Answer : b. Thomas Jefferson

Description : One of the first two political factions in United States, the Democratic Republicans, was led by: (a) Jefferson Davis (b) Alexander Hamilton (c) Thomas Jefferson (d) George Washington

Last Answer : (c) Thomas Jefferson

Description : Thomas Jefferson was the ________ president of America. (a) First (b) Second (c) Third (d) Fifth

Last Answer : (c) Third

Description : Declaration of independence was written by: (a) George Washington (b) Thomas Jefferson (c) John adams

Last Answer : (b) Thomas Jefferson

Description : The Declaration of Independence was written by: (a) George Washington (b) Thomas Jefferson (c) John Adams

Last Answer : (b) Thomas Jefferson

Description : _________ is the most prominent author of the Declaration of Independence. (A) George Washington (B) John Adams (C) Thomas Jefferson (D) Abraham Lincoln

Last Answer : (C) Thomas Jefferson 

Description : Which president was the first in the White House? (A) George Washington (B) John Adams (C) Abraham Lincoln (D) Thomas Jefferson

Last Answer : (B) John Adams 

Description : Who wrote the Declaration of Independence? Choose one: a. Abraham Lincoln. b. James Madison. c. George Washington. d. Thomas Jefferson.

Last Answer : Correct Answer: d. Thomas Jefferson.

Description : Thomas Jefferson Famous Motivational And Inspirational Quotes

Last Answer : 1. I believe that every human mind feels pleasure in doing good to another.  2. The energy, the faith, the devotion which we bring to this endeavor will light our country and all who serve it, ... of a newspaper.  22. Walking is the best possible exercise. Habituate yourself to walk very far.  

Description : What was Jefferson main objection to the constitution?

Last Answer : There was no Bill of Rights

Description : What does Jefferson say about whether the US Constitution allows for an agreement such as the Louisiana Purchase How can you tell?

Last Answer : Jefferson had concerns that a U.S. president did not have the constitutional authority to make such a deal. He alsoo thought that to do so would erode state rights by increasing federal executive power.

Description : Which one of the following enjoys the title of “Father of American Constitution”: (a) Jefferson (b) Washington (c) Madison

Last Answer : (c) Madison