Description : If Adam and Eve were unable to judge right from wrong before eating from the tree, why were they punished?
Last Answer : they were told directly by God (well, Adam was told directly and Eve had knowledge of it), not to eat from the tree. When Eve gave the fruit to Adam, and he ate it, they were directly disobeying ... to sit around and ponder if they should or not, they had a clear answer already, and disregarded it.