Do you think the "Jury" is the greatest weakness of the american justice system?

Do you think the "Jury" is the greatest weakness of the american justice system?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

The jury system is not perfect, but it’s the best we’ve got at this time. I’ll tell you what I think is a bigger problem (and I just posted to another question similarly) and I’m not sure everyone is aware of this. Do you know it is possible for someone to find a lawyer that takes no money until the client gets money (either through a settlement or the legal win) and LIE to this lawyer about someone or some company. The defendant (who can be totally innocent) winds up paying the lying plaintiff good money, to avoid the even LARGER legal fees in going to trial. THIS is a travesty. Something should be done about THIS.
by

Related questions

The US "justice" system is a travesty; what should I do when called for jury duty?

Description : The US "justice" system is a travesty; what should I do when called for jury duty?

Last Answer : Think about if you don't go, who will, in your place? And if the thinking, educated people all manage to get out of jury duty and you find yourself on trial, who will be your jury? Yes, ... . I don't know the answers to these questions myself, and I wish you good conscience in whatever decision.

Bill Cosby's sexual assault trial ended in a hung jury. Do you think there should be a retrial?

Description : Bill Cosby's sexual assault trial ended in a hung jury. Do you think there should be a retrial?

Last Answer : Yes. Too many women with complaints about him might indicate there is at least some truth to their accusations.

What do you think about the O J Simpson trial proceeding in Las Vegas, with an all-white jury?

Description : What do you think about the O J Simpson trial proceeding in Las Vegas, with an all-white jury?

Last Answer : I don’t know what to think of this. Part of me thinks it’s unfair to go with an all white jury, but when he had a mixed jury in his other trial, despite mounds of evidence, he got aquitted! Ughh…it makes my non-racist brain hurt!

Why did both sides pick an all female jury in the Zimmerman / Trayvon case?

Description : Why did both sides pick an all female jury in the Zimmerman / Trayvon case?

Last Answer : They were looking for specific things in potential jurors. I suspect it was a fluke.

If you were the Judge and the Jury, and it were totally up to your judgement and opinion, what would be the punishment for the kid whose webcam spying caused his roommate Tyler Clemente to commit suicide?

Description : If you were the Judge and the Jury, and it were totally up to your judgement and opinion, what would be the punishment for the kid whose webcam spying caused his roommate Tyler Clemente to commit suicide?

Last Answer : He's 18? And he caused another person's death because of his thoughtless douchebaggery? Hmmmm. I'd likely sentence him to a long prison sentence. That other boy is dead because of him; that' ... prison sentence. With a gay cellmate nicknamed Shirley who gets really lonely in the middle of the night.

Do you know of anyone who has used Karma to justify becoming judge, jury, and executioner?

Description : Do you know of anyone who has used Karma to justify becoming judge, jury, and executioner?

Last Answer : Karma doesn’t work that way. To use Karma to become judge, jury and execution defeats the very object and foundation of karma.

I got "selected" for Jury Duty....What should I do?

Description : I got "selected" for Jury Duty....What should I do?

Last Answer : Run. Run hard, run fast and run far. Then show up for Jury duty.

How do you feel about our justice system? Is it right? Is it fair?

Description : How do you feel about our justice system? Is it right? Is it fair?

Last Answer : answer:The legal system is definitely not “fair.” It is slanted to protect the accused. That is a lesser evil than having it slanted the other way. It is not perfect, but then neither are human beings.

What does the phrase "No justice!, No peace!" mean?

Description : What does the phrase "No justice!, No peace!" mean?

Last Answer : I think it means that the protesting group’s demands must be met, or they will continue to protest and disrupt a certain area.

Whitey Bulger, 89-year old mobster and multiple murderer, was killed yesterday in prison. Is this frontier justice or is it evil?

Description : Whitey Bulger, 89-year old mobster and multiple murderer, was killed yesterday in prison. Is this frontier justice or is it evil?

Last Answer : I'm not sure he would've gotten out of prison eventually since he was 89 years old when he died. I find it kinda odd they would transfer him to a prison in WV. I read a couple of ... lived the life of luxury near a beach in California for 15 years after murdering several people for no reason.

How is this in any way justice?

Description : How is this in any way justice?

Last Answer : Car insurance was never meant to replace your car, just to pay off damages. Although I have seen commercials that say they will replace your car now. I’m sure it is very expensive and the lady that has been involved in many accidents probably couldn’t afford it. No, I don’t think this is fair.

Shock and Consternation! Clinton gets a pass from the FBI. Is there no justice?

Description : Shock and Consternation! Clinton gets a pass from the FBI. Is there no justice?

Last Answer : answer:I'd say that there is justice, and we just saw it properly administered. The FBI - the premier investigative agency in the US - did their work and essentially cleared Hillary Clinton. ... -hatred so strong that anything that doesn't fit your narrative of the world is immediately suspect?

Was justice served by Dennis Hastert getting a sentence of 15 months for molesting children?

Description : Was justice served by Dennis Hastert getting a sentence of 15 months for molesting children?

Last Answer : answer:Well technically, he pleaded guilty to and was convicted for one count of illegally structuring $950,000 in bank withdrawals to avoid reporting requirements. He admitted in a plea agreement ... will be a measure of justice for those who believe that punishment is ever appropriate justice.

What's more important compassion or justice (details inside ) ?

Description : What's more important compassion or justice (details inside ) ?

Last Answer : Justice. Compassion only means that they’ll do it again.

Is there any hope for reducing the gross inequities defining our criminal justice systems?

Description : Is there any hope for reducing the gross inequities defining our criminal justice systems?

Last Answer : Who told you I was on Jury Duty (true!). It might be helpful if you mentioned some of those gross inequities. I think Body Cameras are a big step forward, as were the existence of all these cell phone ... him lunging at the cops with a knife. The claims and evidence didn't get a lot of media play.

Is justice a luxury?

Description : Is justice a luxury?

Last Answer : answer:Nothing is cheaper than mob justice. Legal justice that mimics moral justice as precisely as possible is indeed a luxury. Westerners often enough do not appreciate the relative security that their ... occasionally find flaws in it, does not diminish it's value as a civilization advancement.

If it was your call, what Supreme Court Justice/s would you replace?

Description : If it was your call, what Supreme Court Justice/s would you replace?

Last Answer : Roberts Scalia Alito Kennedy and Thomas

Is there evidence that the notion of "social justice" is actually an excuse for ineptitude, incompetence, and vice?

Description : Is there evidence that the notion of "social justice" is actually an excuse for ineptitude, incompetence, and vice?

Last Answer : No.

What part of the world can I move to where there is the most amount of JUSTICE?

Description : What part of the world can I move to where there is the most amount of JUSTICE?

Last Answer : I would think most of the Scandinavian countries are the most just and fair societies to live in if that’s what you are asking.

All of us 6.8 billion people on Earth are almost identical genetically - If more people were aware of this, would this replace racism with justice?

Description : All of us 6.8 billion people on Earth are almost identical genetically - If more people were aware of this, would this replace racism with justice?

Last Answer : You’d think so but politics has a way of reinforcing xenophobia.

How does the victim get better justice if the criminal is tried as a juvenile?

Description : How does the victim get better justice if the criminal is tried as a juvenile?

Last Answer : Justice isn’t just about the victim. It is about all involved, including the perpetrator. It is not justice when the perpetrator is burdened with a sentence that is unbefitting his mental state, e.g. , when he can not be fully held responsible for the offence.

What is the nature of justice?

Description : What is the nature of justice?

Last Answer : No one is entitled to any rights. Rights are conferred by agreement of a group of people. If we all agree that we all should have free speech, and we'll all protect each other's attempts to speak freely, ... you better attribute them, or I will hunt you down, tie you up, and feed you to the ACLU!

Criminal Justice Topic?

Description : Criminal Justice Topic?

Last Answer : answer:What is the legal insanity defense, and does it make sense? How is it or should it be determined? Is the death penalty ever the correct course of action, considering mistakes in conviction can never ... ON, what offends your personal sense of justice and righteousness in the world????????????

What are the Careers in Criminal Justice

Description : What are the Careers in Criminal Justice

Last Answer : What are the Careers in Criminal Justice For many people, fighting crime is a calling too hard to resist. There is something noble, inspirational, and heroic about ridding the community of ... re sure to find your place and task in safeguarding everyone from crime and other lawless elements.

So, what is your opinion on Bolton threatening the International Criminal court with sanctions and legal actions, should they dare to prosecute american war criminals?

Description : So, what is your opinion on Bolton threatening the International Criminal court with sanctions and legal actions, should they dare to prosecute american war criminals?

Last Answer : It’s an open invitation for everyone else to ignore the rules and go after Americans. Same as the use of torture the last time Bolton was allowed near the levers of power.

If Elizabeth Bathory was caught today, would she be declared criminally insane by an American court of law?

Description : If Elizabeth Bathory was caught today, would she be declared criminally insane by an American court of law?

Last Answer : Probably not, judging by the work of Dietz.

When is it ok to take vengeance on your own instead of trusting the system, if ever?

Description : When is it ok to take vengeance on your own instead of trusting the system, if ever?

Last Answer : One of my personal laws is never to answer any question by someone named “penis”

What should be the nature of our penal system?

Description : What should be the nature of our penal system?

Last Answer : Rehabilitation. The Vulcan Science Directorate has determined that as a general rule, humans can be reeducated and reprogrammed to become valuable members of society. Besides, we do not even know what he did ... typo, the bigger question is why he was sentenced to a life sentence in the first place.

Do you think blackmailing is the most harmful suffering to do to a person, and the most undesirable, psychologically?

Description : Do you think blackmailing is the most harmful suffering to do to a person, and the most undesirable, psychologically?

Last Answer : No. Scaring the person (if he hates spiders, put him in a room of spiders) is at least as effective. Or threatening to kill loved ones. Are you planning anything we should know about?

For those who think abortion should be illegal, why should a woman not be punished for requesting one?

Description : For those who think abortion should be illegal, why should a woman not be punished for requesting one?

Last Answer : Or maybe the argument is that the doctor should know better since he is professionally trained. That does not make sense to me. What if the abortion is performed by someone who is not a doctor? Who is liable in that case?

Who do you think lied, Judge Thomas or Anita Hill?

Description : Who do you think lied, Judge Thomas or Anita Hill?

Last Answer : Anita Hill was telling the truth. Clarence Thomas was protected by the old boys network that considers women’s claims as hysteria.

Do you think killing in order to show that killing is wrong is okay?

Description : Do you think killing in order to show that killing is wrong is okay?

Last Answer : No, I don’t believe that’s fine.

What do you think about helping a person who put him/herself in a bad situation?

Description : What do you think about helping a person who put him/herself in a bad situation?

Last Answer : It would depend on how many strikes this person has against them in regards to repetitive behavior of the sort that got them in the situation they are asking me to help them get through.

Does the legality of Osama bin Laden's death concern you? Do you think it was an illegal act?

Description : Does the legality of Osama bin Laden's death concern you? Do you think it was an illegal act?

Last Answer : answer:In the end, the question is irrelevant, because the actor was the US Government, and they are above international law. For that matter, it’s important to note that Osama bin Laden didn’t exactly respect international law either.

Do you think capital punishment is moral?

Description : Do you think capital punishment is moral?

Last Answer : In my opinion, it is wrong to take a human life. Period.

Do you think Jail/Prison is for punishment or rehabilitation?

Description : Do you think Jail/Prison is for punishment or rehabilitation?

Last Answer : I think it’s school for criminals, neither punishment nor rehabilitation.

Do you think Obama should pardon the teenage pirate captured off the coast of Somalia?

Description : Do you think Obama should pardon the teenage pirate captured off the coast of Somalia?

Last Answer : I don’t think Obama should. At least he will get a trial and know what he is charged with.

Did you hear the sentences for Ahmaud Arbery's killers?

Description : Did you hear the sentences for Ahmaud Arbery's killers?

Last Answer : Excellent, about time .

What sentence will Jussie Smollett get?

Description : What sentence will Jussie Smollett get?

Last Answer : He’ll likely get off with probation. If he gets some prison time then the “big guy” will commute the sentence down to probation. (Let’s go Brandon).

What are your thoughts about using databases of DNA to solve serious crimes?

Description : What are your thoughts about using databases of DNA to solve serious crimes?

Last Answer : I think it's great for solving crimes. Having said that - it is intrusive as all get-out and it bugs the heck out of me that there are no controls over public DNA databases. Which is why I will ... your background through DNA things. My dad did, but I have no interest in doing it for my generation..

What percentage of the success you’ve achieved in life would you attribute to the circumstances of your birth?

Description : What percentage of the success you’ve achieved in life would you attribute to the circumstances of your birth?

Last Answer : I attribute about a third to birth, a third to innate aptitude, and a third to diligent work.

Speaking of racial conflict, can horses and zebras interbreed?

Description : Speaking of racial conflict, can horses and zebras interbreed?

Last Answer : Yes, they can. They (zebra’s) can mate with any kind of equine. Zebroids is what you get. A horbra, or a zorse.

Can you explain how this fictional case would proceed to me, someone who have never attended a real court case before?

Description : Can you explain how this fictional case would proceed to me, someone who have never attended a real court case before?

Last Answer : The most important evidence in a case like this is the testimony of those who were actually present. Jack would certainly be called as a witness, and assuming he told the truth his evidence would ... to all the evidence the jury would discuss the case among themselves and come to a decision.

What will happen to the crime rate when the homeless realize they are guaranteed a better standard of living in jail than out on the streets?

Description : What will happen to the crime rate when the homeless realize they are guaranteed a better standard of living in jail than out on the streets?

Last Answer : Getting three meals a day in jail is not a new thing. Jail has a lot of downsides.

Is it just that FEMA reimburse the relatives of covid death victims for funeral expenses?

Description : Is it just that FEMA reimburse the relatives of covid death victims for funeral expenses?

Last Answer : Since probably a large majority of those deaths are the result of deliberate negligence by the former orange regime, I would absolutely say that it is just.

Speaking of atrocities, how was Taco Bell allowed to brutally terminate the career of that chihuahua?

Description : Speaking of atrocities, how was Taco Bell allowed to brutally terminate the career of that chihuahua?

Last Answer : “Yo quiero Taco Bell”

In a criminal trial, if the parties exchange the witness' lists during discovery, isn't there a risk the witnesses are coerced, murdered, etc?

Description : In a criminal trial, if the parties exchange the witness' lists during discovery, isn't there a risk the witnesses are coerced, murdered, etc?

Last Answer : Sure. The Mafia in the US was known for witness intimidation. My guess is that gangs do the same thing. But the law is that witnesses are to be announced and shared by the parties, and (usually) deposed, so that their testimony can be properly questioned and verified.

Is it essential that poverty be degrading?

Description : Is it essential that poverty be degrading?

Last Answer : 6 years ago I was in line at Safeway and my credit card delined and had to cancel $300 worth of groceries. I thought that I paid it off, but instead it would take three days to clear my payment. I was embarrassed.

Which is worse? Behaving badly sexually, or behaving badly racially?

Description : Which is worse? Behaving badly sexually, or behaving badly racially?

Last Answer : There are degrees of everything. In the examples you gave, sexual assault is worse than someone wearing black face, assuming they don’t also assault someone.

Is it really necessary to stigmatize brazen people?

Description : Is it really necessary to stigmatize brazen people?

Last Answer : I think it’s a judgement call and I can hardly blame if a person, especially a female feels more wary than elated about being brazenly complimented in public. My thinking is that they just don’t want to encourage the behaviour.