Is shutting down the online comments section tantamount to censorship or not?

Is shutting down the online comments section tantamount to censorship or not?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:No. I find it odd that a newspaper would do such a thing – it’s just a curious approach to the dissemination of knowledge, but I don’t see it as censorship. The general public doesn’t have a legal right to comment on news articles; it’s a convenience or a privilege granted by the newspaper, which is owned by someone or something else. If the newspaper decides to no longer offer that, it’s certainly their right to do so. And there are plenty of other places a person can express their opinion, ranging from a personal blog to Facebook and a thousand places inbetween.
by

Related questions

The world is still full of censorship, what kinds of censorship do you agree with?

Description : The world is still full of censorship, what kinds of censorship do you agree with?

Last Answer : From the internet, to what the Government tells us. Myself I do think underage children should be limited to what they have access to ,but adults should be able to make their own minds up, or do you think others should tell adults what they can see, read, or write?

Do you ever practice self-censorship out of fear of eliciting an unfavorable response?

Description : Do you ever practice self-censorship out of fear of eliciting an unfavorable response?

Last Answer : I’m pretty much staight down the line when it comes to my personal view on life’s major talking points, nothing out there or controversial at all. As for speaking up if someone airs what i’d consider an extreme stance on a certain subject, then yeah, i’m going to tell you you’re wrong

Do you believe in censorship?

Description : Do you believe in censorship?

Last Answer : I do believe minors should be censored for their own protection, but legal adults should not.

Does anyone else f@ck&ng hate censorship...

Description : Does anyone else f@ck&ng hate censorship...

Last Answer : answer:Depends on who is doing it. If it is the Government, that is bad. In fact it is illegal. If it is an organization with voluntary membership, quit.

Where do you draw the line between free speech and censorship, examples?

Description : Where do you draw the line between free speech and censorship, examples?

Last Answer : I don’t support censorship but I do support discriminating behavior. Just because one is free to say whatever they want doesn’t mean they should. Examples…hmmm, well….I’m minutes away from an appointment so I will have to come back to this later if I have the time.

Can you list some interesting events, current or past, that deal with censorship of any kind?

Description : Can you list some interesting events, current or past, that deal with censorship of any kind?

Last Answer : answer:The Hollywood blacklist. Wikipedia The Hollywood blacklist was the mid-20th-century list of screenwriters, actors, directors, musicians, and other U.S. entertainment professionals who ... in liberal or humanitarian political causes that enforcers of the blacklist associated with communism

If SOPA comes to pass, is this a technological way to get around the censorship?

Description : If SOPA comes to pass, is this a technological way to get around the censorship?

Last Answer : answer:They are working on it (and have been for a while) but the processing overhead for keeping track of nearby nodes and routing packets remains non-trivial. Hell, in Shadowrun, they ... be far easier to implement. Still, the multi-billion dollar internet gaming industry would suffer immensely

Has anyone here noticed this case of extreme censorship?

Description : Has anyone here noticed this case of extreme censorship?

Last Answer : That’s what happens when moderation is automated, and not performed by human beings. It’s pretty ridiculous, huh?

What are some good questions about t.v., movie, and video game censorship?

Description : What are some good questions about t.v., movie, and video game censorship?

Last Answer : Breanna, you might be wondering why, after an hour, no one has answered your question here on Fluther, when, usually, questions have several answers within a few minutes. I think, though I can ... discuss it, perhaps you could rephrase your question so it sounds less like an assignment from class.

When did youtube add the feature that you can remove individual comments from your video?

Description : When did youtube add the feature that you can remove individual comments from your video?

Last Answer : I mean as a channel owner ..

Does Facebook censor comments?

Description : Does Facebook censor comments?

Last Answer : Yeah, I’ve had swears taken off, and some friends have had mentions of Twitter taken off. But when I posted about it, everyone I knew tried posting swears, but nothing got taken down, so I looked like an idiot. And then my comment with the swear was put back up. So I don’t know.

So, what is your take on El Presidente now eyeing to censor search engine results in his favour?

Description : So, what is your take on El Presidente now eyeing to censor search engine results in his favour?

Last Answer : It increases my desire to vote in the midterms!!!

What is your reaction when you find something that truly offends you, even though it's legal?

Description : What is your reaction when you find something that truly offends you, even though it's legal?

Last Answer : I would only try and do something if minors were exposed to it, other than that just simply ignore it, if it was a business certainly not patronize it, but that is all I would do,how about you?

Has anyone found anything interesting that Facebook has been tracking about them?

Description : Has anyone found anything interesting that Facebook has been tracking about them?

Last Answer : I’ll try it later if you remind me how to unzip a file.

Is there no mechanism that disallows a president from barring certain news outlets?

Description : Is there no mechanism that disallows a president from barring certain news outlets?

Last Answer : answer:Welcome to Trump-Land. Where lies are common and “Fake news” is videos of Trump doing things he said he didn’t do.

Do you believe those who caused UC Berkley $100,000 in damages to be conservatives or liberals?

Description : Do you believe those who caused UC Berkley $100,000 in damages to be conservatives or liberals?

Last Answer : It was liberals. It’s always the liberals that riot. They didn’t like the idea of a conservative giving a speech in their liberal safe zone.

How to differ valid, true and correct information from lies and propaganda in an era where we are flooded with information?

Description : How to differ valid, true and correct information from lies and propaganda in an era where we are flooded with information?

Last Answer : answer:First of all, one needs to learn to discern between statements of “fact” and statements that are really opinion or viewpoint. And then, one must discern what one considers to be responsible or accurate nessources. Even then one must be willing to confirm that fact from multiple sources.

Should newspapers publish the hacked Sony e-mails and files?

Description : Should newspapers publish the hacked Sony e-mails and files?

Last Answer : I think it's a pretty poor idea to release the private information of any person/corporation/group if they are not suspected of actually harming the public. The whole idea of if they have nothing to ... of thing across the board seem to me to be pretty naive about just how damaging that could be.

Should profanity (whatever that is) be allowed on gravestones?

Description : Should profanity (whatever that is) be allowed on gravestones?

Last Answer : answer:I wouldn’t want near my loved one’s grave. I wouldn’t want to see it. That’s just me, though. If I don’t have to see it, I don’t care what you put on there. Honest opinion.

If kids Twitter about their teachers, can they be policed by school boards?

Description : If kids Twitter about their teachers, can they be policed by school boards?

Last Answer : Do Canadians have as much ‘free speech’ as Americans theoretically do? I’m not really up on Canadian law.

Are anonymous denunciations of other people's posts on social networking websites a good thing?

Description : Are anonymous denunciations of other people's posts on social networking websites a good thing?

Last Answer : In the country I live in I am supposed to be able to face my accuser and demand they show cause for the charges. I know the originators of Facebook are Americans, but I think they may ... , I don't think they should taken seriously on Facebook and the Mods should weigh censorship very carefully.

Should Mein Kampf remain banned in Germany?

Description : Should Mein Kampf remain banned in Germany?

Last Answer : answer:I say let it expire. Yes, it’s terrible, but a part of history and important insight nonetheless. I wouldn’t want that censored any more than I want slavery taken out of educational textbooks. Plus, I’m half Jewish, so I feel like a have at least a little stake in this. ;)

Should the government be policing people who hold up their middle fingers?

Description : Should the government be policing people who hold up their middle fingers?

Last Answer : Don’t see how the government would become involved. There is no article in your link, BTW.

What are your thoughts on Cee Lo Green changing the words of "Imagine"?

Description : What are your thoughts on Cee Lo Green changing the words of "Imagine"?

Last Answer : Kind of defeats one of the main purposes of the song, no? I don’t really care, exactly, but it seems like something Lennon would have cared about. I actually watched it, and didn’t even notice that at the time, though.

How to respond to someone who has a problem with what you post on Facebook?

Description : How to respond to someone who has a problem with what you post on Facebook?

Last Answer : Something worse.

When do stand up comedians cross the line?

Description : When do stand up comedians cross the line?

Last Answer : answer:This comedian Steve Hughes talks about the idea of something being ‘offensive’. I thought the difference was that hate speech is trying to convince and persuade others rather than just express views, but I may be wrong on that!

How much money does it cost for the Chinese Govt. to censor the internet?

Description : How much money does it cost for the Chinese Govt. to censor the internet?

Last Answer : I get the feeling that that information would be censored, so finding accurate numbers is likely impossible. If anyone does find those numbers, they are likely based on official Chinese sources, so take them with a grain of salt.

Should possibly inflammatory Tweets be protected as free speech?

Description : Should possibly inflammatory Tweets be protected as free speech?

Last Answer : answer:In my mind, people should only be prosecuted if there is credible evidence that they will actually do something, as opposed to just saying it. Like i'm gonna blow up tha airport lol! should ... up tha airport and I have bomb making supplies in my basement should be. Your mileage may vary.

In Mythbuster why did the censor out the barcode on the lighter?

Description : In Mythbuster why did the censor out the barcode on the lighter?

Last Answer : Probably because if they got bad results, the people at Mythbusters couldn't get in trouble with the good people at BIC lighters for saying they blow up in your car or in the dyer etc. They never said ... a BIC. Other than the fact that it's a BIC lighter and anyone could probably point that out.

Does anyone besides the confidential recipient have access to PM's?

Description : Does anyone besides the confidential recipient have access to PM's?

Last Answer : Only certain individuals (owners and manager) can read pm’s, and do so only to investigate complaints.

Is Fluther catering too much to the oversensitive and the paranoid?

Description : Is Fluther catering too much to the oversensitive and the paranoid?

Last Answer : I think it’s mostly a business decision. The site needs more new users, and they, apparently, are turned off by jokes, sarcasm or “jerk” responses. It’s the way things are, I’m afraid. My advice: just go with the flow.

What did Kyle say at the end of the recent South-Park episode #201?

Description : What did Kyle say at the end of the recent South-Park episode #201?

Last Answer : answer:Are you talking about during his speech? If so: Matt and Trey made a statement on the South Park website: In the 14 years we've been doing South Park we have never done a show that ... back next week with a whole new show about something completely different and we'll see what happens to it.

If you owned a web site or magazine - and the KKK wanted to purchase a banner or advertisement - would you allow them to?

Description : If you owned a web site or magazine - and the KKK wanted to purchase a banner or advertisement - would you allow them to?

Last Answer : No. I turn away ad offers that don’t directly appeal to my audience – there’s no faster way to make people zone out. Never mind an ad placement for the KKK.

Why do people flag questions? If you don't like them don't read them .

Description : Why do people flag questions? If you don't like them don't read them .

Last Answer : I flag to let the moderators know I, personally, disagree with the content or validity of something. If the moderators see the flags they will investigate for themselves. It’s much like a democracy. I am the congress and they are the governor.

Isn't bragging about being the most conservative candidate tantamount to boasting of being the biggest ideologue?

Description : Isn't bragging about being the most conservative candidate tantamount to boasting of being the biggest ideologue?

Last Answer : I agree. But the same is true of Liberal, Libertarian, etc.

What does Tantamount mean ?

Last Answer : The word means the same or equal

In the auditing environment, failure to meet the PSAs is often a. An accepted practice. b. A suggestion of negligence. c. Conclusive evidence of negligence. d. Tantamount to criminal behavio

Description : In the auditing environment, failure to meet the PSAs is often a. An accepted practice. b. A suggestion of negligence. c. Conclusive evidence of negligence. d. Tantamount to criminal behavio

Last Answer : Conclusive evidence of negligence

What is your opinion on Vine shutting down?

Description : What is your opinion on Vine shutting down?

Last Answer : never cared. not caring now, either.

Computer Shutting Down Automatically?

Description : Computer Shutting Down Automatically?

Last Answer : Have a look at the fan and heat sink on your CPU. How much dust is on there?

How can shutting down the government be a great idea?

Description : How can shutting down the government be a great idea?

Last Answer : More to the point, do member of Congress get paid?

Will shutting down my PC extend the life of my power supply?

Description : Will shutting down my PC extend the life of my power supply?

Last Answer : Not really, as far as I am aware. It will save power (if you haven’t set your computer’s power settings up properly, like most people, though, it might not), but the biggest source of stress on electronic components that I know of is turning them on and off again thousands of times.

Is there a way to keep my Macbook Pro from shutting down automatically?

Description : Is there a way to keep my Macbook Pro from shutting down automatically?

Last Answer : Click on the blue apple and go into system preferences. From there go into energy saver and set it to where you want it. But remember it is a good idea to keep it set to go to sleep after a reasonable period of time when you are not downloading, in order to preserve energy consumption.

Why is my computer shutting down randomly?

Description : Why is my computer shutting down randomly?

Last Answer : A ram chip is not seated, the fan that cools your processor is clogged with dust, or your hard drive is in the process of failing. Back up everything while you have a chance!

How come every time I start up iChat after shutting it down, even after a computer restart an old chat room shows up?

Description : How come every time I start up iChat after shutting it down, even after a computer restart an old chat room shows up?

Last Answer : answer:Save your sanity. System Preferences -> General -> Un-check restore Windows when opening and closing http://i.imgur.com/2WaxE.png

Macbook Pro shutting down after 10 min of use, then has to rest for hour before I can restart it?

Description : Macbook Pro shutting down after 10 min of use, then has to rest for hour before I can restart it?

Last Answer : There must be a problem with the fan I guess? I do not know if it’s worth fixing but I think you should take it to the nearest apple store and have them check it out? From the way I see it, I think you should get the new macbook pro. Good luck :)

Why is my Madden 08' for the PC shutting down?

Description : Why is my Madden 08' for the PC shutting down?

Last Answer : if it’s working with other games it’s probably the game. You should check the scratches…If you can’t get the game working, you can probably find it on amazon for $10 or less…

Is anyone else sad that Nasa's space shuttle program is shutting down?

Description : Is anyone else sad that Nasa's space shuttle program is shutting down?

Last Answer : Yes.

Any one out there with a dell labtop and having problems with shutting down? Or with just vista and having problems with shutting their system down.

Description : Any one out there with a dell labtop and having problems with shutting down? Or with just vista and having problems with shutting their system down.

Last Answer : I have a Dell Latitude D620 and had Vista taken off and XP Pro installed instead because of startup / shutdown issues. I've never looked back. apart from anything else it runs so much quicker! Not a huge fan ... it much of a chance either. Might be worth trying as it's likely to be a vista issue. BB

Is there a significant difference in energy usage between shutting down a computer overnight and putting it on sleep/standby?

Description : Is there a significant difference in energy usage between shutting down a computer overnight and putting it on sleep/standby?

Last Answer : i have always wondered the same. GQ Trustinglife!

Is my cell phone shutting down my laptop?

Description : Is my cell phone shutting down my laptop?

Last Answer : Do they have bluetooth?