Should the Electoral College be done away with?

Should the Electoral College be done away with?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:The Electoral College was created with the sole purpose of getting the slave states to agree to ratify the new Constitution and join the union. The non-slave states gave them extra votes for residents (slaves) who were ineligible to vote but were still counted when proportioning votes for the House of Representatives and the President through the EC. It is an egregious institution and needs to be abolished.
by

Related questions

Will the Electoral College serve the purpose the Founding Fathers created it for?

Description : Will the Electoral College serve the purpose the Founding Fathers created it for?

Last Answer : answer:Since the electors are party hacks, the chances are slim. Some states prohibit their electors from backing anyone but the person the state selected but the penalties are not very prohibitive. I ... kill any future they may have within the party structure and, hey, party before country right?

President Trump suggested that all people who cross the border illegally (“invade” was the term he used) should be deported summarily, without a court hearing. Not Constitutional Law but is it another step in Trump running the country his way?

Description : President Trump suggested that all people who cross the border illegally (“invade” was the term he used) should be deported summarily, without a court hearing. Not Constitutional Law but is it another step in Trump running the country his way?

Last Answer : I mean, the guy did say that he would like people to treat him like the North Koreans treat Kim. He wants to be a dictator.

Okay what is your take on Jared Kushner (Trump's Son-in-law) being named Senior Advisor to the President and Federal anti-nepotism rules?

Description : Okay what is your take on Jared Kushner (Trump's Son-in-law) being named Senior Advisor to the President and Federal anti-nepotism rules?

Last Answer : All hail our Highness, the kind Donald I of Trump dynasty.

What's your take on the Trump supporters's initiative to repeal the 19th Amendment to the Constitution so women couldn't vote? If women couldn't vote, Trump would win big.

Description : What's your take on the Trump supporters's initiative to repeal the 19th Amendment to the Constitution so women couldn't vote? If women couldn't vote, Trump would win big.

Last Answer : Will Hillary win if only women are allowed to vote?

Should an educated American know what all of the amendments to the Constitution are, by heart?

Description : Should an educated American know what all of the amendments to the Constitution are, by heart?

Last Answer : I certainly couldn’t pull all of them up, but an educated American should at least have been exposed to them to the extent that they are recognized when referenced. eg. Obama’s 3rd term.

Can the president re-name anything just by the stroke of a pen?

Description : Can the president re-name anything just by the stroke of a pen?

Last Answer : answer:Read the whole article that you didn't link to. The quick answer is no he can't, but in this case, the Bureau of Geographic Names had sat on this request for 40 years, and the president has ... action by the agency. So yes, in this case, the president has the power, but not in all cases.

Is the President breaking the law?

Description : Is the President breaking the law?

Last Answer : I don't think he is breaking the law. I think he has a tendency to overlook other important details that greatly influence his decisions and law-making plans, and focus mainly on the main idea. (I think the ... he doesn't seem to see that.) He is, and continues to be, a work-in-progress president.

How would you role play a Dungeons and Dragons chaotic good bard/character with straight 18's for ability scores?

Description : How would you role play a Dungeons and Dragons chaotic good bard/character with straight 18's for ability scores?

Last Answer : Singing so badly that any monster dies from internal haemorrhaging. Then finish them off with my lute. (My only contacts with D&D are the movie, Neverwinter Nights 2 and the current Neverwinter MMO)

Is the U.S. more... or less "safe" from NSA spying on their own citizens?

Description : Is the U.S. more... or less "safe" from NSA spying on their own citizens?

Last Answer : Sure. Unless you are a reporter who would report negatively on the government, or you have an ex who works for the Feds. Only 4 million people have top secret access. What are the odds you have upset someone in that set?

Do you think that any of the 17 amendments of the Constitution, subsequent to the first 10 (which became the Bill of Rights,) should also come under the auspices of "The Bill of Rights?"?

Description : Do you think that any of the 17 amendments of the Constitution, subsequent to the first 10 (which became the Bill of Rights,) should also come under the auspices of "The Bill of Rights?"?

Last Answer : answer:Many of the Founders would object to many of the 17 amendments. Allowing blacks and women to vote? Are you crazy? This is why it is good people die. Civilization needs to weed out that kind of thinking.

There are 27 amendments to the Constitution. Why do only the first 10 come under the umbrella of "The Bill of Rights?"?

Description : There are 27 amendments to the Constitution. Why do only the first 10 come under the umbrella of "The Bill of Rights?"?

Last Answer : answer:Many of the original Founders were concerned (rightly so, apparently!) that a strong centralized government would be automatically too-strong from the get-go and would only get stronger. For ... the Bill of Rights as a precondition for their support of the Constitution as it was written.

Is the U.S. Constitution really clearcut?

Description : Is the U.S. Constitution really clearcut?

Last Answer : The constitution was written about 236 years ago. Maybe when it was written it was clearcut. But times have changed and shit needs to be updated from time to time, just like the second amendment. Guns need ... all of which would have a lesser of chance of happening if guns weren't legal in the US.

What do you think of Romney choosing Robert Bork to select his judicial nominees?

Description : What do you think of Romney choosing Robert Bork to select his judicial nominees?

Last Answer : I hope this gets people who are disappointed in Obama interested in fighting for his re-election.

What is the constitutional basis for the Civil Rights Act?

Description : What is the constitutional basis for the Civil Rights Act?

Last Answer : answer:I think its basis is this section of the Declaration of Independence: We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator ... , Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed,

Is there a defense fund for protesters wrongly arrested while exercising their constitutional rights?

Description : Is there a defense fund for protesters wrongly arrested while exercising their constitutional rights?

Last Answer : I have no idea, but that is the greatest darn idea, ever. We can start with the woman that was pulled by her hair across the street, and the woman that was punched in the face.

Casey Anthony acquittal, to whom does it seem to be the O.J. trial feminine style?

Description : Casey Anthony acquittal, to whom does it seem to be the O.J. trial feminine style?

Last Answer : Spoiler Alert: She was proven non-guilty on all cases in which she was trialed for.

Would it be better if the US president served only one term?

Description : Would it be better if the US president served only one term?

Last Answer : I’d say yes, it would force the president to actually get things done rather than focus on getting reelected and then coasting on with a who gives a damn attitude.

Is there a difference between racism and racial discrimination?

Description : Is there a difference between racism and racial discrimination?

Last Answer : Racial discrimination implies some sort of act. Racism is a belief.

Should the USA Amend the Constitution to allow the President limited powers of war without a Congressional Declaration of War?

Description : Should the USA Amend the Constitution to allow the President limited powers of war without a Congressional Declaration of War?

Last Answer : I think the President is the commander in chief and has the right to onvoke the use of military force without authorization from Congress.

Awlaki and the CIA Hit List -- Should US Presidents have the right to target US Citizens for assassination without any judicial review?

Description : Awlaki and the CIA Hit List -- Should US Presidents have the right to target US Citizens for assassination without any judicial review?

Last Answer : No.

Would you support an Amendment prohibiting the US Gov. from deficit spending even if it would likely lead to a future Great Depression?

Description : Would you support an Amendment prohibiting the US Gov. from deficit spending even if it would likely lead to a future Great Depression?

Last Answer : Oh, if it were only that easy…

Does the right to bear arms include swords?

Description : Does the right to bear arms include swords?

Last Answer : Words mean things. Sometimes, definitions change. Arms at the time when the constitution was written implied those arms which one personally carried (e.g., musket, pistol, swords, dagger). Ordnance ... of today. Its illegal to the constitution to collect federal tax, but they do that anyways.

Is the Supreme Court broken?

Description : Is the Supreme Court broken?

Last Answer : Welcome to America.

We're Not Legally Obligated to Pay State/Federal Income Tax? It is a voluntary tax?

Description : We're Not Legally Obligated to Pay State/Federal Income Tax? It is a voluntary tax?

Last Answer : I can direct you to a law on a dot-gov website that states pretty darn clearly what happens to you if you don’t pay federal income taxes. You go to jail. So if by “voluntary” you mean, your choice is your money or your freedom, the suuuure, it’s voluntary.

Is the Electoral College about proportional representation, and if not why not?

Description : Is the Electoral College about proportional representation, and if not why not?

Last Answer : It is about representing the wishes / votes of the nation. If we went merely by the popular vote, then the densely populated areas such as New York and Southern California would determine the outcome. Places like Kansas and Alabama and Wyoming would not matter, because their populations are so low.

What is your opinion on Colorado's (largely symbolic) effort to get rid of the Electoral college?

Description : What is your opinion on Colorado's (largely symbolic) effort to get rid of the Electoral college?

Last Answer : The author of that op-ed has no idea what the fuck he's talking about. The individual states may apportion its electoral votes in whatever manner it chooses. If a state wishes to assign all its ... votes to the national popular vote winner then it is well within its Constitutional right to do do.

Why is Electoral College a fair way of doing democracy?

Description : Why is Electoral College a fair way of doing democracy?

Last Answer : Because without the electoral college, only large, urban areas and densely populated regions would be represented, due to the sheer number of people. Furthermore, politicians would only campaign ... favor Republicans because most people in large cities and urban sprawl between cities vote Democrat,

Should Electoral College be allowed to vote their conscience?

Description : Should Electoral College be allowed to vote their conscience?

Last Answer : They are allowed. The worst that can happen to them if they exercise that right is a small fine. I think it's absurd that a handful of people can enforce their will over the will of the ... the EC will ever fulfill its purpose as envisioned by the founders, and should simply be done away with.

Should the "Winner Take All" rules in the Electoral College be modified?

Description : Should the "Winner Take All" rules in the Electoral College be modified?

Last Answer : Modifying the all or nothing rules such that the electoral votes went to each candidate in proportion to the way the voters voted within the state (like NE and ME already do it) would better serve the will of the ... to a popular vote, but I think we may as well go to a popular vote at that point.

If 100% of all voters had voted for Hillary, would Trump have won anyway due to the Electoral College?

Description : If 100% of all voters had voted for Hillary, would Trump have won anyway due to the Electoral College?

Last Answer : No.

Has a third party ever won electoral college votes?

Description : Has a third party ever won electoral college votes?

Last Answer : I think George Wallace did. In 1968 he won 45 electoral votes, mostly from the south, mostly. He also got one vote from a “faithless elector”, who ignored the States vote. Source

Is it time for the USA to graduate from the Electoral College?

Description : Is it time for the USA to graduate from the Electoral College?

Last Answer : I think it’s high time that the Electoral College was put to rest. The only thing it ever guaranteed was that the will of the voters was ignored.

Is the electoral college system really fair?

Description : Is the electoral college system really fair?

Last Answer : The Electoral College is a great big steaming pile of dog shit. If the majority of the country wanted Al Gore to be president, then Al Gore should’ve been president. Since when is the purpose of a vote to allow the minority to choose? Is it friggin Opposite Day somewhere in the world?

What is an Electoral College? -SST 10th

Description : What is an Electoral College? -SST 10th

Last Answer : An Electoral College consists of the Legislative elected members of both the Houses of Parliament and elected members of the Legislative Assemblies of the States including Union Territories possessing assemblies.

Who constitutes the Electoral College for the election -SST 10th

Description : Who constitutes the Electoral College for the election -SST 10th

Last Answer : The Electoral College consists of the elected members of the State Legislative Assemblies and the elected members of the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha.

How many members consist of the Electoral college?

Description : How many members consist of the Electoral college?

Last Answer : 538

What is Electoral College ?

Description : What is Electoral College ?

Last Answer : The Electoral College (USA) is the indirect presidential election process in the United States , through which the President of the United States and the Vice President of the United States ... States Constitution gives the electorate one vote for the President and another for the Vice President.

What is Electoral College ?

Description : What is Electoral College ?

Last Answer : Electoral College is the electorate.

Who makes up the electoral College?

Description : Who makes up the electoral College?

Last Answer : 538 delegates makes up an electoral college who cast the votes that formally elect the President. The candidates who receives the majority of electoral votes wins the Presidency.

What is the electoral College?

Description : What is the electoral College?

Last Answer : Electoral College is made up 538 delegates who cast the votes that formally elects the President. The process actually differs from state to state.

How many electoral college votes does the state of Illinois receive each election?

Description : How many electoral college votes does the state of Illinois receive each election?

Last Answer : Need answer

What is the key difference between the popular vote and the electoral college vote?

Description : What is the key difference between the popular vote and the electoral college vote?

Last Answer : Need answer

When Jefferson win electoral college?

Description : When Jefferson win electoral college?

Last Answer : Thomas Jeffersonwon the 1804 presidential election defeating Charles Pinckney. Inthe 1804 presidential election Thomas Jefferson received 162electoral votes and Charles Pinckney received 14 electoralvotes.

How do the popular and electoral college votes decide the presidency?

Description : How do the popular and electoral college votes decide the presidency?

Last Answer : Electoral votes in the Electoral College determine the Presidentof the United States. Every state and DC are awarded a certainnumber of electoral votes with which to elect the President. Eachstate has ... in each state and each candidate for elector swears in advancewhom he will vote for.

How does the electoral college function?

Description : How does the electoral college function?

Last Answer : Electoral votesin the U.S. Electoral College determine the President and VicePresident of the United States. Every state and the District ofColumbia are awarded a certain number of electoral ... tabulated at the jointsession of Congress and the winner of the election is officiallydeclared.

What is the electoral college system?

Description : What is the electoral college system?

Last Answer : Electoral votesin the U.S. Electoral College determine the President and VicePresident of the United States. Every state and the District ofColumbia are awarded a certain number of electoral ... tabulated at the jointsession of Congress and the winner of the election is officiallydeclared.

If no presidential and vice-presidential candidates wins a majority of Electoral college votes?

Description : If no presidential and vice-presidential candidates wins a majority of Electoral college votes?

Last Answer : If no candidate receives a majority of electoral votes, the Twelfth Amendment of the United States Constitution provides that the U.S. House of Representatives will select the president, with each of the fifty state delegations casting one vote, and the U.S. Senate will select the vice-president.

The Electoral College that elects the President of India consists of – (1) Elected members of all the State Legislatures (2) Members of the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies (3) Elected members of the Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha and State Assemblies (4) Elected members of the Rajya Sabha and State Legislatures

Description : The Electoral College that elects the President of India consists of - (1) Elected members of all the State Legislatures (2) Members of the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies (3) Elected members of ... Sabha, Rajya Sabha and State Assemblies (4) Elected members of the Rajya Sabha and State Legislatures

Last Answer : (3) Elected members of the Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha and State Assemblies Explanation: The President is chosen by an electoral college consisting of the elected members of both houses of ... and the elected members of the legislative assemblies of the Union Territories of Delhi and Puducherry.

Which one of the following is part of the Electoral College for the election of the president of India but does not form part of the forum for his impeachment? (1) Lok Sabha (2) Rajya Sabha (3) State Legislative Councils (4) State legislative Assemblies

Description : Which one of the following is part of the Electoral College for the election of the president of India but does not form part of the forum for his impeachment? (1) Lok Sabha (2) Rajya Sabha (3) State Legislative Councils (4) State legislative Assemblies

Last Answer : (4) State legislative Assemblies Explanation: State legislature assemblies, both houses of the parliament form part of the electoral college for the election of the president. An electoral college is ... represented by a particular number of electors or with votes weighted in a particular way.

Vice-President of India is elected by an electoral college consisting of - (1) members of both Houses of Parliament (2) members of Rajya Sabha only (3) elected members of both Houses of Parliament (4) elected members of Lok Sabha only

Description : Vice-President of India is elected by an electoral college consisting of - (1) members of both Houses of Parliament (2) members of Rajya Sabha only (3) elected members of both Houses of Parliament (4) elected members of Lok Sabha only

Last Answer : (1) members of both Houses of Parliament Explanation: members of both houses of parliament.