What could "transcendental rationalism" be?

1 Answer

Answer :

Disclaimer: The words “transcendental” and “rationalism” have been used in a variety of ways both within and without the Western philosophical tradition. I will be limiting myself to the parts of the Western tradition that gave rise to the most common view that goes by the name “transcendental rationalism.” To understand the term, we’re going to need a little bit of history. First, one of the major philosophical debates of the early modern period (basically, the 16th – 19th centuries, with special emphasis on the 17th century) was that of empiricism vs. rationalism. This started out as a debate over the foundations of knowledge: is the primary source of knowledge our senses or our reason? This debate evolved over the years, particularly as the sciences developed and the empiricists were more and more able to explain things purely in terms of sensory experience. By the time we get to Kant, empiricism had become the view that all knowledge comes from experience, whereas rationalism had become the view that not all knowledge comes from experience. Kant started out as a rationalist, but then had a bit of a crisis when he started reading Hume that he thought affected both rationalism and empiricism: regardless of whether experience is primary or secondary, it is always mediated/filtered by our sensory organs and cognitive faculties—which means there will always be a gap between the world as we know it and the world as it is. This wasn’t an entirely new idea, but Kant had a new approach: transcendental reasoning (aka transcendental argumentation). The basic idea here is to start with a fact about our experience and then work out the necessary conditions for that experience (i.e., what must be true in order for that given fact about our experience to be the case). In simpler terms: if you know you have experience X, and if you determine that experience X is only possible under condition Y, then you know that condition Y obtains. The transcendental rationalist runs with this and claims that there is knowledge that we can gain purely through transcendental reasoning, and that at least some of this knowledge is not ultimately grounded in experience. In other words, it’s a form of rationalism that builds itself on the notion of transcendental reasoning.

Related questions

Description : Anyone else out there practice Transcendental Meditation?

Last Answer : I've always wanted to meditate on a regular basis and to specifically get into this type of meditation but never had the discipline really. Are you having classes? Or doing it on your own? Do you ... that get me excited about it and therefore it's never really captured my heart and soul as yet

Description : Is learning transcendental meditation expensive?

Last Answer : Link One Link Two Enjoy.

Description : The reflector and director of an antenna array are considered as A. Parasitic elements B. Transcendental elements C. Feed-points D. Driven elements

Last Answer : A. Parasitic elements

Description : A reasoning where we start with certain particular statements and conclude with a universal statement is called (A) Deductive Reasoning (B) Inductive Reasoning (C) Abnormal Reasoning (D) Transcendental Reasoning

Last Answer : (D) Transcendental Reasoning

Description : What is rationalism ?

Last Answer : Rationalism ( from the Latin ratio , " cause") is based on the assumption of a philosophical motion which is the source of all knowledge of human reasoning. Rationalism is defined in ... except in some exceptional branch like mathematics. Rationalism is the analysis of behavior based on reason.

Description : What's the difference between rationalism and empiricism?

Last Answer : Rationalism is using logical reasoning and deduction to draw a conclusion about something. Empiricism is using information collected from experience, your senses, and observation to draw conclusions about something.

Description : What's the difference between rationalism and empiricism?

Last Answer : Rationalism is using logical reasoning and deduction to draw a conclusion about something. Empiricism is using information collected from experience, your senses, and observation to draw conclusions about something.

Description : ________________ is the idea that knowledge comes from experience. a. Rationalism b. Deductive Reasoning c. Logic d. Empiricism

Last Answer : d. Empiricism

Description : Which form of reasoning is the process of drawing a specific conclusion from a set of premises? a. Rationalism b. Deductive Reasoning c. Inductive Reasoning d. Probabilistic

Last Answer : b. Deductive Reasoning

Description : Henry hears one of his senior salespeople spreading rumours about the drinking problems experienced by a competitor's sales representative. When they get out to the car, Henry asks ... moral philosophies? A)Ethical formalism B)Relativism C)Humanitarianism D)Opportunism E)Conscious rationalism

Last Answer : A)Ethical formalism

Description : The basis of Neo-Marxism was………. (a) Public opinion (b) Rationalism(c)Liberty (d) Capital

Last Answer : (a) Public opinion

Description : How much wood could Chuck Norris chuck, if Chuck Norris wanted to chuck wood?

Last Answer : Is he awake or asleep?

Description : Could there be lifeforms in open space? (Details )

Last Answer : answer:Yes! In a controlled experiment a crew of ISS exposed Tardigrades to the vacuum and temperature of space - and the critters survived! Tardigrades are notable for being the most resilient animal: they can survive ... °F; −272 °C) (close to absolute zero) to about 420 K (300 °F; 150 °C)

Description : If people could see in the dark, would crime be higher, or lower? (At night. )

Last Answer : According to this, the only types of crimes being significantly more prevalent during the night are rape, sexual assault, and car theft. Though I think that is due to less people being around at ... So, no, I do not think that crime rates would be affected to any statistically significant degree.

Description : ask-publicites. If you could change one thing about men, what would you change? (Details )

Last Answer : Hmmm . First of all, I don't think men have inherent personality/characteristics. Each man is individual and different from one another. If I were to stereotype men I would say that it's best for ... is old news and cliche but still ). And not acting like it's their responsibility to protect women.

Description : Could someone explain the Heisenberg uncertainty principle from a layman's point of view?

Last Answer : Caveat: this could be completely wrong, The way it was explained to me is that it’s like trying to state where a bullet that has just been shot is located. You can tell me where it is at any given moment, you can track it, but when you point out where it is, it is gone.

Description : If you could temporarily change your gender, would you?

Last Answer : Not sure. I'd love the here's your dinner aspect of it but not the part where I'd be looking at / approaching women. Unless you mean that I'd automatically be attracted to women if I changed ... and cook. Much better than becoming a man. I live a pretty pampered life now and admit to liking it.

Description : Could you imagine a world without people?

Last Answer : Read this book: The World Without Us for a detailed, interesting, alarming, and in the end strangely reassuring view of what the earth would be like if we were gone.

Description : Could you explain to me Ludwig Wittgenstein main ideas as if I was a 5 year old?

Last Answer : Wittengstein said that words do not exist absent their use. That meaning comes from usage and context.

Description : Could a man be a lesbian?

Last Answer : It really depends on the definitions used by that person. If they don't identify as a man but you maintain that they are, then there you have a man who identifies as a lesbian. There could also ... identified as a woman or transitioned from a woman. Or perhaps you're just being funny, in your head?

Description : How could you practicly use this statement?

Last Answer : um…maybe if you were talking to a blind person that had no concept of a circle… but then they would probably not have a concept of a line either perhaps…hmmmm

Description : Could two dissimilar items both be perfect for one purpose? (Plus more questions of perfection)

Last Answer : No.

Description : Is it possible that Heaven could turn out to be your Hell?

Last Answer : I dunno…as long as He has the margarita machine up & running, I’m good to go, LOL.

Description : If you had to disable one ability that you possess but it could not be one of your senses in its entirety nor something so insignificant that it didn't affect your regular life what would you choose?

Last Answer : I feel like I’ve already lost the ability to understand what the heck you’re talking about.

Description : Do you agree with famous philosopher Christopher Smith, in regards to the "good old days"?

Last Answer : Real men won’t answer this question. - Ah, I read it too fast. Real men do answer this question.

Description : Would you like to answer this question about plugging into the Matrix?

Last Answer : I would opt to stay put in the Sims! I’m happy where I am at.

Description : What is the path to happiness?

Last Answer : This is a pure personal thing. What allows one person to feel a sense of deep happiness can be completely different than another person. I feel it is not about money or possessions. Finding out what ... start on a lifelong journey. Life also injects many things that can move of out of this space.

Description : What is time?

Last Answer : It is the fourth dimension. What text were you discussing for this question?

Description : What is your views after watching this video on why you will marry the wrong person?

Last Answer : Lol. Very entertaining. I didn’t learn the lesson., but then again i am human.

Description : Does the higher per capita intelligence near prestigious schools improve quality of life?

Last Answer : I'll quibble with the wording. But, having lived in and visited many places, some with very good universities, and some not, I'm going to say yes. At least, for my tastes, and the things I ... arts and studies and people doing what they're interested in, learning and all that comes with all of that.

Description : How accurate do you think this quote from a famous Indian Guru is?

Last Answer : I don’t think ‘retarded’ is the right word. I would have used ‘stupid’. Or maybe ‘simple’.

Description : How did this 2 minute clip make it past the censors?

Last Answer : Why would it be censored? It isn’t obscene. And it isn’t designed for 8 year olds. it’s audience is 44 year old men in Cnada.

Description : What happened before the Big Bang?

Last Answer : Nobody among human beings knows about it.

Description : What problems from the far past to now has philosophy solved?

Last Answer : The study of philosophy is to help us to use critical thinking to solve our own problems and reach our own goals in life. Critical thinking helps us to recognize the difference between things ... true. My personal opinion is that very few people even have the ability to understand these concepts.

Description : Regarding the "meaning of life" and humanity's self worth, what is the difference between being in a universe created by a god, and a universe created as a computer simulation by an alien race?

Last Answer : Does it matter? If there is a god creating a universe, who is to say that the god is not, in fact, the product of a computer simulation? There's no way to tell if this god has godlike characteristics ... a software glitch? I wou;dn't, but I'm not sure it matters. How would it change my life?

Description : How would you describe the difference between intelligence and wisdom?

Last Answer : Intelligence is processing information and being able to extrapolate hypothesis and conclusions from various pieces of knowledge. It's more than just memorizing information, although memory is part of it, ... really does help in many situations in a way that just knowing information can't.

Description : Moral dilemma: save the dog or the braindead child?

Last Answer : I would choose my child, always. My son/daughter might be braindead, but I’m still here to love him/her. I would give him/her every chance to survive and have a happy life. ~Besides I don’t like dogs, if it was a cat then perhaps…

Description : Do we need more sins? Is seven enough?

Last Answer : Your president has six of the seven deadly sins with the possible exception of envy. This tally doesn't do justice to the huge injury he is doing to his country and its reputation or to the psychic damage he is ... of him and his family in the White House. I'm stuck. I cannot put a name to it.

Description : Please help me understand what this guy is talking about?

Last Answer : It’s interesting to think about, which is probably why it interests some people. Have you ever watched Big Bang Theory? Sheldon talks about parallel universe’s all the time. You could watch the NEW Star Trek on Netflix, it’s about the same thing.

Description : What is the difference between mind and reason?

Last Answer : The mind is the mechanism; reason is the process.

Description : A priori or a posteriori, which one is more reliable?

Last Answer : Neither. It depends on other qualities of the situation. But if you’re taking a logic test, go with a priori. If you’re in a real situation where you have incomplete information, you may want to give a posteriori more weight.

Description : What does prime matter mean in philosophy?

Last Answer : Hylomorphism - Wikipedia In some cases, a substance's matter will itself be a substance. ... According to Aristotelians, such a substance has only prime matter as its matter. Prime matter is ... into various kinds of substances without remaining any kind of substance all the time. Hope this helps.

Description : What do you think of the hippie movement and hedonism?

Last Answer : A couple of points. The Hippie movement of the 1960s-1970s is NOT the Hippie Movement of 2019. I don't know what sort of event you are describing in your question. The Hippie movement of ... re either paranoid or overly cynical. Not everything needs a rationale. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

Description : Am I doing something wrong by refusing to serve in a military where service is obligated?

Last Answer : Supposedly Donald Trump had heal spurs and dodged the Vietnam draft ,and he became president of the USA. He gets ribbed on a little bit but he is doing fine.

Description : On a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being "complete BS" and 10 being "divine wisdom", how would you rate the following statement?

Last Answer : 42

Description : Is there even such a thing as "the outside"?

Last Answer : I think there is, as long as you are inside. Or, outside is the new inside.

Description : What view do you have in regard to the following statement?

Last Answer : I believe it to be true. I have built many emotional barriers over the years to keep me from being hurt but the do tend to keep me separated from others, even family members. I come off ... sadness or uncomfortable emotions . So yes, walls work both ways keeping things out;and keeping things in.

Description : What are some instances or situations that support the idea of moral relativism?

Last Answer : The modern abhorrence of slavery as fundamentally immoral, versus the biblical and divine endorsement of slavery. Any time someone brings up the “it was a different time” excuse, when past cultures’ moral failings are judged.

Description : In your opinion is Thomas Aquinas the greatest theologian of all time with his classic work Summa Theologica ?

Last Answer : That's what I've been told. But interposed between Aquinas and the trophy looms the formidable Augustine. I have soaked up just enough of the musings of both to understand that I will never be ... folks who know about such things that when it comes to theological gunslinging, Maimonedes is one BMF.

Description : What do you think about this video as an argument against determinism?

Last Answer : As I understand it, Determinism is the belief that all events are caused, or acted upon, by prior events. Nothing happens without cause. I think that the video posits an argument for Indeterminism; that is ... are not caused by prior events and that may, or may not, have effect on future events.