Can you help me fact-check my history textbooks?

1 Answer

Answer :

They seem mostly true, albeit simplistic, with a little Nationalistic propaganda to help it go down better. America was a collection of colonies, and colonial history was necessarily exploitative. Those who claimed ownership over colonies held the idea of a vassal state to be as natural as human slavery. The books you mention feel more like they frame the evil British as having a specific agenda of suppressing the power of the colonies out of fear of the very nationalism that would come to create America. Like Americanism is some immutable property of the people here, and the British were just fundamentally against it. The books also don’t mention that it was Britain’s very inability to control the colonies which had been the history of American prosperity for 100 years. Our founding fathers were smugglers and tax evaders, and it when Britain tried to yoke them, it became clear that the colonies were already too powerful to be controlled, and wealth was too entrenched to cede power across the ocean.

Related questions

Description : Do you have a favorite or interesting history fact to share?

Last Answer : Canadian Prime Minster Justin Trudeau's father was Pierre Elliott Trudeau also a Canadian prime minster in the 70's.. Pierre Elliott Trudeau, was a Canadian politician who served as the 15th Prime Minister of Canada from ... 20, 1968, to June 4, 1979, and again from March 3, 1980, to June 30, 1984.

Description : Find out the history of the town you live in or of any town nearby. Check when and how it grew, and how it has changed over the years. You could look at the history of the bazaars, the buildings, cultural institutions, and settlements. -History

Last Answer : Monu Nagar (An Imaginary Town): Monu Nagar was a small village along G.T. Road. People in the village lived a simple life, mostly of the agriculturist. Slowly modern life style came. People ... years. Some air-conditioned restaurants were opened during last five years. It has become a big town.

Description : What do you make of Bush's statement, "Whatever the verdict on my presidency, I'm comfortable with the fact that I won't be around to hear it."?

Last Answer : answer:Oh… it says “he believes it will be decades before a judgement on his presidency can be rendered.” Too quick on the trigger, it seems. My apologies.

Description : What historical fact surprised you when you learned of it?

Last Answer : I didn’t know that the vietnam war was the first war that was televised in america. I can’t imagine not watching video clips and media news of a war, no wonder people started caring more about it once they saw what was going on.

Description : How will history textbooks reflect the Trump years? How will school curricula in Germany and France differ from school curricula in the US?

Last Answer : ”...people around the world” already learn two completely different interpretations. Actualy more than two interpretations. And there isn;t even agreement on US histroy wohin the United States. And we aren’t talking just US history, but world history.

Description : Can you help me find information about the Master's and Servant's Acts in Australia's History?

Last Answer : Wikipedia has an excellent article with several references listed at the bottom. You can find what you need there.

Description : Will someone help me with my history homework?

Last Answer : Honestly I’m not sure if he is in power at this time. The teacher doesn’t explain anything about it until we have our discussion group which is the same day its due.

Description : Who wants to help me with my history essays?

Last Answer : Whoa. These aren’t essays, but major papers. My daughter did a version of #1 in high school (Semester 1 was from Amercian Rev to Civil War, Semester 2 was Civil War to Vietnam War) and each paper was 30 pages long. Isolationism to Imperialism.

Description : Can you help me help my brother with this US history homework question?

Last Answer : The question is asking what brand-new, mindboggling changes the New Deal was hoping to implement. Read about what the New Deal was, and you should find your answer.

Description : What to do with old photos? Check what this man did using animation.

Last Answer : Check out his website Alexey Zakharov looks like he makes a living doing CGI videos and animations. I’m impressed.

Description : Is it coming from "check your gun at the bar" to "check your phone at the door"?

Last Answer : Don’t fall down a slippery slope dude. Phones are generally not a risk, but in hospitals, particularly ICU’s, they can disrupt some of the equipment, same reason why you have to turn your phone off on an airplane. I don’t think they’ll be banned outside ICU’s anytime soon.

Description : What to do about false hits on criminal background check?

Last Answer : Wait for the HR rep to investigate further. False hits are not that uncommon and it won’t damage your buddy at all if the school has a reliable service doing the background checks.

Description : How did the discovery of fire help early man? -History

Last Answer : The discovery of fire helped early man in the following ways: It helped him cook his food. It helped him protect from the danger of wild animals.

Description : How did the widow’s home at Poona help the widows? -History

Last Answer : It trained them so that they could manage financial support for themselves.

Description : Why were Jyotirao Phule and Ramaswami Naicker critical of the national movement? Did their criticism help the national struggle in any way? -History

Last Answer : Both Jyoti Rao Phule and Naicker were critical of national movement in their own times. Jyoti Rao Phule was critical of nationalism preached by upper castes. He wrote that they give advice ... speeches and writings did lead to rethink and self-criticism among the upper caste nationalist leaders.

Description : How did the knowledge of ancient texts help the reformers promote new laws? -History

Last Answer : The reformers tried to convince people that widow burning, caste distinctions, child marriage, etc had no sanction in ancient texts. Their knowledge of ancient texts gave them immense confidence and ... laws. They did not get feared when people raised voice against the reforms they had brought.

Description : How a major in history can take me far?

Last Answer : It will take you as far as you want. If you're extremely passionate about history, then I see no reason why you should consider another major. There are some people in law school who were ... a useless major that gets constantly bashed). Just do internships, make connections, and get good grades.

Description : Can you tell me some really good and comprehensive general history sites?

Last Answer : answer:My sister was a missionary in Ghana. I will message you her contact information. Maybe she can help you. From what I understand it was initially the control of malaria carrying mosquitoes that started the trend. That and better health care availability.

Description : I have a History and Philosophy of math course which covers everything from the beginning of math history, could anybody give me some IDEAS as to what topic I should write about?

Last Answer : Why don’t you do some research on historical mathematicians, like Archimedes. Just make sure you don’t use Wiki as a research reference.

Description : Any recommendations for good books on the history of Scotland?

Last Answer : Magnus Magnusson’s “Scotland:the Story of a Nation” is worth a look and it is quite readable. It was published in 2000 so isn’t right up to date.

Description : How are you celebrating Black History Month?

Last Answer : Is that a holiday there or just a celebration day? I could suggest searching for George Washington Carver to learn and appreciate the man. Basically he was a Black scientist who was born as a slave. And also I’m really curious about that CRT post :P

Description : Did America, at any point in history, do something to Cambodia (details inside)

Last Answer : Yes, we did. I can look up the specifics (or maybe @kritiper knows them; he's crafting a response right now), but my recollection is that the Americans pulled out and left them to their fate when ... on the subject of what happened in Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge, and this is how I remember it.

Description : When you think about your family history does it make you sad or happy?

Last Answer : I feel deep Pride. There are many great people and accomplishments in my family tree.

Description : When in history did the United States become the biggest economic and millitary power?

Last Answer : After World War Two. The transition period started under Teddy Roosevelt, and the Great White Fleet of steel battleships that toured the world to demonstrate naval superiority. But that wasn't fully ... as the only major economy that wasn't destroyed to some extent solidified the economic might.

Description : Which people have made an impact in history in England?

Last Answer : there are far too many to list. I’m sure this is something you can easily research on your own by searching for a short history of England or famous people in English history. This is an easy assignment which I am sure you are meant to do on your own.

Description : Are there events in history that you thought you knew about but then you learn details much later that totally surprised you?

Last Answer : I was surprised by how much was omitted from standard texts and teaching. When I was in grade/middle school, in the early-mid 60s, no mention at all was made of Japanese-American internment camps. A ... 10th grade, and we were able to discuss it in school. It was heavily spun to justify it.

Description : What is the biggest hoax in history that people still believe today?

Last Answer : .

Description : Do any of you know any quotes or quips from people in history?

Last Answer : I’ll start..Daniel Boone was once queried by some admirers as to whether he had ever been lost in the wilderness. He responded that, “I can’t rightly say as I was ever lost, but I did get a mite bewildered once for a couple of weeks”. . .

Description : Is history a science?

Last Answer : Do you mean history as it happened or as reported?

Description : Do you have a favorite history topic?

Last Answer : answer:If I had to be specific, I like to study Irish culture from the late Iron Age to the beginning of the Viking age. Trying to parse out the neo-pagan celtic nonsense from the actual ... are supposed to have taken place. There are other areas I enjoy studying, but that is my main focus.

Description : Have you seen this history documentary?

Last Answer : I’m on my phone right now, so I can’t check the accuracy of my memory, but I believe Cuba was under the protection, and therefore under the flag of the U.S. for a number of years after that war. I’ll look it up some time in the next 12 hours and verify or correct.

Description : How can I learn about the history of everyday life?

Last Answer : The internet is a boon for finding out such information. I have had a blast for the past few years collaborating with my cousin in Australia, 9000 miles away from me, to help rebuild our combined ... there to help and thousands of folks willing to expend the time to help you expand your horizons.

Description : When you learned about slavery and segregation in America, was it taught as American history, or more specifically Southern history?

Last Answer : answer:US History. Not being from the South, we didn’t have a Southern History course. Public schools in the northwest tend to have a northwest history section, and teach about the indigenous people and how we were scumbags to them as we took their land, cheated them and killed them off.

Description : Where's the best place to start if someone wants to learn about world history in extreme depth?

Last Answer : I’ve heard the history book by Bill Bryson is good. It’s called “A Short History of Nearly Everything”. I haven’t read it, but many of his other books are informative, funny, and easy to read.

Description : Violations of Civil Rights that weren't fought for? What events in American history would be considered violations of TODAY's civil rights?

Last Answer : A prime example would be the interenment of Japanese Americans during the Second World War. Then there were the infamous McCarthy hearings wherein citizens were persecuted and found their lives and careers destroyed ... I could spend the rest of the day on this question but others deserve a chance.

Description : Students of history and anthropology: does it ever get to you?

Last Answer : Certainly, as a scholar of history I have come across many horror stories and much despair. However, this is countered by many, many examples of determination, courage and sacrifice. Often the ... and documents I examine, some amazing and inspiring people. They give me hope for the future.

Description : Is it possible to honor Confederate history in the US without glorifying racism? [Details]?

Last Answer : No, it is not. Just as it is not possible to honour the 3rd Reich without glorifying the Holocaust. You can not just ignore the 11 million people that were murdered in the ... the primary reason for the secession in the declaration of causes' by various southern states, including Missouri

Description : Have you heard of the "Bonus Army" in American history? [link] [details]?

Last Answer : answer:I knew the generalities, but your link provided more information than I had known before. It seems to me that Hoover was wrong in not firing MacArthur for crossing the bridge to Bonus City in the face ... if he had had the same type of lust for absolute power, and similar demons to Hitler's )

Description : How far can you reach back into history with 2 degrees of separation?

Last Answer : answer:Some time at the last half of the 18th century. As far as I know, the oldest person in my family tree lived during that period.

Description : I want to study religion, and the social history of religion. Where should I start?

Last Answer : The Egyptian Book of the Dead

Description : Is anyone here really interested in history?

Last Answer : Absolutely not. I don’t have any interest whatsoever.

Description : What is your favorite period in history, and what about it specifically do you find interesting?

Last Answer : The possible future as depicted in Star Trek. Because it is better than the present and all past periods of history combined.

Description : What's a good book to learn about 20th century political history?

Last Answer : You want a book on political history that doesn’t discuss politics? Huh?

Description : How can a person determine if he is on the right side of history?

Last Answer : How would you define “the right side of history”? That seems too big a goal to aspire to. Ask yourself instead if your opinions and actions are in line with your moral beliefs.

Description : Hidden history: Did you know about this event? (Trigger warning for homophobic violence).

Last Answer : answer:I actually have heard about this, only because Ghost Hunters filmed an episode there last season. I don’t understand how some people can be so hateful. It makes me sick to my stomach.

Description : Imagine you could say 12 words to anyone in history who would you speak to and why?

Last Answer : I’d tell Hitler as a child…“I’m going to kill you, The Boys From Brazil has inspired me.” As for why, for the lulz, pure & simple.

Description : What will the "History" Channel talk about when the World doesn't end on Dec. 21, 2012?

Last Answer : answer:They will hunt for the next end-of-the-world date. Anyone done any research as to when this date is and why?

Description : It's time for a George-off! Who is the best George in history, and why?

Last Answer : Lonesome George!

Description : Can you think of ten moments that changed history?

Last Answer : None of those were on my list. I was thinking of a lot different events. The Battle of the 300 Midway WW I and the Middle East, primarily Arabia. Henry Ford and mass production, etc i.e. the Industrial Revolution. for starters.

Description : How do you feel about the still-to-be-built Smithsonian Black History Museum?

Last Answer : There are musuems for pretty much every ethnic culture. I agree we need to forget about race altogether, but that’s not how things are now, so I see no problem with it.