Can momentum be hidden to human eyes like how kinetic energy can be hidden as heat? -Physics

1 Answer

Answer :

Yes and no. In a regular mechanical system with macroscopic parts, momentum can not be "hidden" to human eyes. But in other systems, momentum can be hidden. For instance, in an electromagnetic system, momentum can be transferred to the electromagnetic field, which is invisible to human eyes at most frequencies. Therefore, momentum can be "hidden" in the electromagnetic field. Let us explore this topic more in depth. Every isolated system obeys the law of conservation of energy which states that if no energy is externally extracted or inserted into the system, its total energy will remain constant in time. For example, consider two hockey pucks sliding towards each other on ice. If you sum the kinetic (motional) energy of both pucks before they collide, you will find that it equals the sum of both energies after they collide. We can in fact use the conservation of energy along with some other information to predict what will happen in a simple collision like this. But now suppose we fire the two pucks directly at each other at the same speed and cover their sides with perfect glue. What happens? Of course, when the pucks make contact, they stick together and both end up with zero speed, and therefore zero kinetic energy. This means that the total kinetic energy of the two-puck system at the beginning was some big number, but the total kinetic energy at the end was zero (at least according to human eyes). Has the glue broken the law of conservation of energy? No. If you did a careful analysis of this event, and measured everything you could think of, you would find that the heat (thermal energy) in the two pucks increases after the collision by the exact same amount as the kinetic energy that seemed to disappear (neglecting the friction of the ice). The macroscopic kinetic energy has therefore been converted into heat. The law of conservation of energy still holds as long as we add heat as one of the things that contributes to the total energy. Such a collision is called an inelastic collision. But what is heat? On the atomic level, we find that hotter substances have their atoms vibrating faster and moving around at higher speeds. Thermal energy is therefore just the kinetic energy of microscopic, randomly-moving particles. When the two pucks with glue stick together, their kinetic energy is not really converted to some mysterious thing called "heat". Their macroscopic, ordered kinetic energy (ordered in the sense that all the atoms in the puck are moving along with the puck as it zips across the ice) is simply converted to microscopic, random kinetic energy. The atoms at the surface of each puck smash together, get displaced, smash into other atoms, and so on, creating vibrations. Macroscopic, ordered kinetic energy is obvious to the human eye (we see the puck moving), but microscopic, random kinetic energy is invisible to the human eye (we cannot directly see the atoms jiggling). In this sense, an inelastic collision causes some of the kinetic energy to be "hidden" from human eyes in the form of heat. If we include only the forms of energy visible to the human eye, glue seems to defeat the law of conservation of energy. But if we include hidden kinetic energy (heat), the law still holds. Now there is another law called the law of conservation of momentum. It states that the total momentum of an isolated system before an event must be equal to the total momentum of the system after the event. What is the difference between this law and the law of conservation of energy. The difference is that energy is just a number, while momentum has a direction. Conservation of momentum therefore tells us things like: two pucks initially traveling to the right that collide (say, because one is going faster and overtakes the other) must still be traveling to the right after the collision. The total momentum of both pucks is to the right in the beginning, so it must be to the right in the end. The law of conservation of energy cannot tell us this because it says nothing about directions. Or similarly, if one puck traveling east approaches another puck traveling north, the total momentum is in the north-east direction. Conservation of momentum tells us that after the collision, the total momentum must still be in the north-east direction. Since momentum obeys a conservation law just like energy, and since kinetic energy can be hidden from human eyes in the form of microscopic motion, it is natural to wonder whether momentum can also be hidden. Does the two-puck-glue system convert momentum to some hidden form upon collision, and therefore some momentum seems to get "lost" to human eyes? No. The reason the answer is no is because momentum is directional. The atoms do indeed jiggle faster after an inelastic collision, but the total momentum of atoms jiggling in place is always zero. Put simply, when the atomic motion is random, for every atom going left there is another atom going right, so that their directionality adds to zero. Since momentum describes the directionality of motion, the momentum for simple thermal motion is zero. In order for momentum to not be zero, the atoms have to all be traveling more or less in the same direction. But when all the atoms are traveling in the same direction, the macroscopic object itself is traveling somewhere, which is quite visible to the human eye. Because momentum is directional, it cannot be hidden from the human eye in the form of random atomic motion. Therefore, even if we cover the sides of the pucks with glue so that they stick, the total visible momentum before will equal the total visible momentum after. This makes sense because if the two pucks are flying at each other at the same speed from opposite directions (and have the same mass), their total momentum before is zero (east plus the same amount of west equals zero), so their total momentum after sticking together is zero (zero plus zero equals zero). This idea extends beyond pucks colliding. Any macroscopic mechanical system cannot hide momentum. But, if the system has parts that are so small that they are invisible to the naked eye, and these parts can undergo ordered motion, momentum can be transferred and hidden in these parts. For instance, if a tennis ball is covered with dust grains that are so small you can't see them, when the tennis ball gets hit, the dust can fly off to one side and carry away some of the momentum. If we don't notice the dust, and don't include it in our calculations, we would find that some of the total momentum becomes hidden after the collision. Let us move beyond mechanical systems. Electromagnetic waves such as light or radio waves carry momentum. Since all electromagnetic waves are invisible to humans except the narrow range of colors from red to violet, momentum can be hidden in the electromagnetic field. In practice, the momentum carried by electromagnetic waves is so small that you have to use very sensitive instruments to measure it, but in principle it is always there. For instance, if you turn on a radar gun, radio waves come out the front of the gun, carrying momentum with them. Because of momentum conservation, the radar gun itself must therefore recoil in the opposite direction when it is turned on. This recoil is typically too small to notice. But for the sake of the argument, suppose we have a giant radar gun that emits a large amount of radio waves. Since radio waves are invisible to the human eye, all that we would see would be the gun jump backwards upon being turned on, clearly violating conservation of momentum (if we only include visible momentum). We would therefore conclude (and rightly so), that there must be momentum hidden somewhere. In this way, momentum can be "hidden" in the electromagnetic field. Although, it is really only hidden to human eyes. We can detect radio waves just fine with an antenna.

Related questions

Description : Two objects A and B are moving with same momentum. Mass of object 'B' is greater then mass of object 'A'. Which of the two object will have higher kinetic energy? -Physics

Last Answer : Let m1​ and m2​ be the masses of the body Let m1​>m2​Given that m1​v1​=m2​v2​v2​v1​​=m1​m2​​∴ Ratio between their kinetic energies , =K2​K1​​=21​m2​v22​21​m1​v12​​⟹K2​K1​​=m2​m1​​×m12​

Description : A body is moving with velocity 4 m/s , possesses 56 Joules of Kinetic Energy. The momentum of body will be equal to -Physics

Last Answer : (d) 28 kgms-1

Description : If two different gases have the same volume, temperature, and pressure and behave like ideal gases, they will also be identical in which one of the following ways? w) average molecular velocity x) total mass y) total molecular kinetic energy z) average momentum per molecule

Last Answer : ANSWER: Y -- TOTAL MOLECULAR KINETIC ENERGY

Description : During the motion of a projectile fired from the earth surface, ______. (1) its kinetic energy remains constant (2) its momentum remains constant (3) vertical component of its velocity remains constant (4) horizontal component of its velocity remains constant

Last Answer : (4) horizontal component of its velocity remains constant Explanation: The motion of a projectile is a two-dimensional motion-Horizontal motion and vertical motion-that take place independent ... continuously affects the vertical component, so the vertical motion is a uniformly accelerated motion.

Description : If two bodies of different masses, initially at rest, are acted upon by the same force for the same time, then the both bodies acquire the same - (1) velocity (2) momentum (3) acceleration (4) kinetic energy

Last Answer : (2) momentum Explanation: If two bodies of different masses, initially at rest, are acted upon by the same force for the same time, then the both bodies acquire the same momentum.

Description : If two bodies of different masses, initially at rest, are acted upon by the same force for the same time, then the both bodies acquire the same - (1) velocity (2) momentum (3) acceleration (4) kinetic energy

Last Answer : (2) momentum Explanation: If two bodies of different masses, initially at rest, are acted upon by the same force for the same time, then the both bodies acquire the same momentum.

Description : The following particles move with same kinetic energy. Which of them has maximum momentum? (1) Electron (2) Proton (3) Deutron (4) Alpha Particle

Last Answer : (4) Alpha Particle Explanation: The formula for kinetic energy in terms of momentum for fundamental particles is basically just a quantized version of the classical formula, KE=(P^2)/2m, where KE is kinetic energy, p is momentum and m is the particle’s mass.

Description : If the total kinetic energy and momentum of a system becomes zero after collision, then the collision is A. elastic B. inelastic C. conserved D. not conserved

Last Answer :  inelastic

Description : In elastic collisions, A. only the total momentum of the colliding objects is conserved. B. only the total kinetic energy is conserved. C. both of the momentum and total kinetic energy ... D. neither momentum of the colliding bodies nor the total kinetic energy are recoverable.

Last Answer : both of the momentum and total kinetic energy are conserved.

Description : Which of the following statements is TRUE about an ELASTIC collision between two particles? Is it true that: w) neither particle loses any of its kinetic energy x) neither particle loses any of ... that lost by the other z) the total kinetic energy before and after the collision remains constant

Last Answer : ANSWER: Z -- THE TOTAL KINETIC ENERGY BEFORE AND AFTER THE COLLISION RE

Description : In a collision, which of the following four quantities is always conserved? w) momentum x) kinetic energy y) torque z) moment of inertia

Last Answer : ANSWER: W -- MOMENTUM

Description : In any collision, which of the following is conserved: w) kinetic energy x) velocity y) momentum z) potential energy

Last Answer : ANSWER: Y -- MOMENTUM

Description : When the velocity of an object is tripled, another quantity which is tripled at the same time is the object's: w) momentum x) potential energy y) kinetic energy z) mass

Last Answer : ANSWER: W -- MOMENTUM

Description : An ice skater is rotating with her arms extended. When she pulls in her arms her rate of rotation increases. Which of the following statements dealing with the process is TRUE? w) Her moment of ... conserved. y) The skater does work when pulling in her arms. z) Angular momentum is increased.

Last Answer : ANSWER: Y -- THE SKATER DOES WORK WHEN PULLING IN HER ARMS 

Description : According to the kinetic theory, the Kelvin temperature of an ideal gas is proportional to which one of the following. Is the temperature proportional to the gas's average molecular: w) velocity x) momentum y) kinetic energy z) potential energy

Last Answer : ANSWER: Y -- KINETIC ENERGY

Description : During the motion of a projectile fired from the earth surface, _______ (1) its kinetic energy remains constant (2) its momentum remains constant (3) vertical component of its velocity remains constant (4) horizontal component of its velocity remains constant

Last Answer : horizontal component of its velocity remains constant

Description : The following particles move with same kinetic energy. Which of them has maximum momentum ? (1) Electron (2) Proton (3) Deutron (4) Alpha Particle

Last Answer : Alpha Particle

Description : If speed of a car becomes 4 times, its kinetic energy becomes -Physics

Last Answer : (c) 16 times

Description : If the momentum of a body is tripled, its KE will -Physics

Last Answer : It becomes nine times its original value.

Description : What is momentum ? -Physics

Last Answer : Momentum is the product of it's Mass (m) and Vilocity (v). Momentum is denoted by p. p = m x v

Description : In physics, a radian per second squared is a unit of: w) angular displacement x) angular velocity y) angular acceleration z) angular momentum.

Last Answer : ANSWER: Y -- ANGULAR ACCELERATION

Description : In physics, a radian per second is a unit of: w) angular displacement x) angular velocity y) angular acceleration z) angular momentum.

Last Answer : ANSWER: X -- ANGULAR VELOCITY 

Description : In the impact problems the following conditions must always be satisfied a.The total kinetic energy remains unchanged b.The total linear momentum remains unchanged c.The magnitude of the total linear ... is reduced by a factor proportional to the coefficient of restitution e.None of the above

Last Answer : b. The total linear momentum remains unchanged

Description : During SHM which of the following is conserved? a.Kinetic energy b.Potential energy c.Total energy d.Momentum e.All of the above

Last Answer : d. Momentum

Description : Which of the following pair will have identical dimensions? a.Pressure and surface tension b.Work and kinetic energy c.Momentum and force d.Moment of inertia and angular momentum e.None of the above

Last Answer : c. Momentum and force

Description : Which of the following statement is incorrect? a.A body can have energy without having momentum b.A body cannot have kinetic energy without having momentum c.A body in motion will always have kinetic energy more than the potential energy d.None of the above e.107 dynes

Last Answer : c. A body in motion will always have kinetic energy more than the potential energy

Description : A block slides down a smooth inclined plane when released from the top while another falls freely from the same point. The value of which parameter in the two cases will be identical? a.Time ... ground c.Momentum at the ground d.Velocity while touching the ground e.Kinetic energy after one second

Last Answer : d. Velocity while touching the ground

Description : The statement that the sum of the kinetic and potential energies of a particle in the earth's gravitational field is constant is known as a.Principle of conservation of mechanical energy b.Law of gravitation c.Newton's law d.Principle of conservation of momentum e.Law of nature

Last Answer : a. Principle of conservation of mechanical energy

Description : If the Kinetic Energy of a body is increased by 300%, how much will its momentum increase? -Do You Know?

Last Answer : answer:

Description : When the velocity of a body is doubled, its 1. acceleration is doubled 2. momentum is doubled 3. kinetic energy becomes four times 4. potential energy is doubled Which of the above is/are correct? (a) 2 only (b) 2 and 3 (c) 3 only (d) 2 and 4

Last Answer : Ans:(b)

Description : In an inelastic collision, state which of the following statements is true: (a) Momentum is conserved and kinetic energy is conserved. (b) Momentum is not conserved and kinetic energy is conserved ... conserved and kinetic energy is not conserved. (d) Momentum is kinetic energy are not conserved.

Last Answer : Ans:(c)

Description : A moving bullet hits a solid target resting on a frictionless surface and gets embedded in it. What is conserved in this process? (a) Both momentum and kinetic energy (b) Kinetic energy alone (c) Momentum alone (d) Neither momentum nor kinetic energy

Last Answer : Ans:(c)

Description : The rate of change of linear momentum of a body falling freely under gravity is equal to it's (1) Kinetic Energy (2) Weight (3) Potential Energy (4) Impulse

Last Answer : (2) Weight Explanation: Rate of change of impulse equals the force. In case of freely falling body the only force is the weight.

Description : If the Kinetic Energy of a body is increased by 300%, how much will its momentum increase?

Last Answer : 100%

Description : If the mass of the body is doubled and velocity is made halved, the kinetic energy will become? -Physics 9th

Last Answer : New kinetic energy becomes, So, the new kinetic energy of the object gets doubled.

Description : An object of mass m and velocity v has kinetic energy= 200J. Find the new kinetic energy if the mass of the object becomes double and velocity still remains the same? -Physics 9th

Last Answer : let the k.e. in first case be x x = 1/2*m*v^2=200j in second case let the kinetic energy be x' v'=v m'=2m x'= 1/2*2m*v^2 x'= 2(1/2*m*v^2) x'=2(x) x'=2*200j x'=400j

Description : State and explain one example where kinetic energy is present in a body and is used -Physics 9th

Last Answer : (i) Kinetic energy is the energy present in a body by virtue of its motion. When water is stored in a dam at particular height, we say it has maximum potential energy as the water ... potential energy is stored in the water which transforms into kinetic energy when it released from that height.

Description : A car is accelerated on a levelled road and attains a velocity 4 times of its initial velocity. In this process the kinetic energy of the car -Physics 9th

Last Answer : The kinetic energy becomes 16 time that of initial kinetic energy Final speed = 4 times of initial speed The kinetic energy of car Where, m = mass of car v = initial velocity of car ... of initial velocity, then kinetic energy Hence, The kinetic energy becomes 16 time that of initial kinetic energy

Description : In which form is the supplied heat energy stored during change in temperature of substance? (1) Heat energy (2) Kinetic energy (3) Potential energy (4) Both kinetic and potential energy

Last Answer : (2) Kinetic energy Explanation: Temperature is used as a measure for heat in an object by measuring the amount of kinetic energy in the molecules that make up the object. It is a measure of the average ... from the heat source to the molecules, and it can also change its form from heat to movement.

Description : The energy stored in a watch spring is (1) Kinetic energy (2) Potential energy (3) Heat energy (4) Chemical energy

Last Answer : (2) Potential energy

Description : The temperature of a gas measures the: w) number of calories of heat present x) average kinetic energy of the particles in the gas y) exact number of particles in the gas z) potential energy of the gas

Last Answer : ANSWER: X -- AVERAGE KINETIC ENERGY OF THE PARTICLES IN THE GAS 

Description : Energy stored in a body as thermal or internal energy consists of one of the following. Does it consist of: w) heat in the form of radiant energy x) molecular kinetic energy only y) molecular potential energy only z) both kinetic and potential energy

Last Answer : ANSWER: Z -- BOTH KINETIC AND POTENTIAL ENERGY

Description : A block of wood initially at rest slides down an inclined plane. Neglecting friction, the kinetic energy of the block at the bottom of the plane is: w) all converted into heat x) equal to its ... kinetic energy at the top of the plane z) dependant on the materials of which the block is made 

Last Answer : ANSWER: X -- EQUAL TO ITS POTENTIAL ENERGY (WITH RESPECT TO THE BOTTOM OF PLANE) WHEN IT WAS AT THE TOP OF THE PLANE.

Description : In which form is the supplied heat energy stored during change in temperature of substance? (1) Heat energy (2) Kinetic energy (3) Potential energy (4) Both kinetic and potential energy

Last Answer : Kinetic energy

Description : The energy stored in a watch spring is (1) kinetic energy (2) potential energy (3) heat energy (4) chemical energy

Last Answer : potential energy 

Description : If two bodies one light and one heavy have equal kinetic energies, which one has a greater momentum? a.Momentum depends on velocities b.Heavy body c.Both have equal momentum d.Nothing can be concluded on the basis of information provided e.Light body

Last Answer : b. Heavy body

Description : A rocket is moving up with a velocity v. If the velocity of this rocket is suddenly tripled, what will be the ratio of two kinetic energies? -Physics 9th

Last Answer : hope its clear

Description : Which among the following is a vector quantity? (1) Heat (2) Angular momentum (3) Work (4) Time

Last Answer : (2) Angular momentum Explanation: Angular momentum is a vector quantity that represents the product of a body's rotational inertia and rotational velocity about a particular axis.

Description : How does a microwave oven heat up food even though it emits no thermal radiation? -Physics

Last Answer : A microwave oven does emit thermal radiation to heat up food. Microwave radiation is thermal radiation. For some reason, most sources have a mistaken notion that thermal radiation = infrared radiation ... a broad spectrum of frequencies with a certain shape that depends on the emitter's temperature.

Description : When I sit by a campfire, how does its hot air heat me? -Physics

Last Answer : When you sit by a campfire, most of the heat you are receiving from the fire does not come from hot air. It comes from thermal radiation. Generally, there are three ways that heat can travel ... of your body facing away from the fire is literally in shadow and cannot receive the thermal radiation.