When I bump one end of a long metal bar, the other end instantaneously moves. Can I use this to send messages faster than light? -Space

1 Answer

Answer :

When you bump one end of a long metal bar, the other end does not instantaneously move. The movement would be instantaneous if the bar were perfectly rigid, but perfectly rigid materials are fundamentally impossible in the real world. Although the movement of the bar may seem uniform and instantaneous to our human eyes, it is really not. Our human eyes are simply too slow to notice the quick, but non-instantaneous, sequence of events that happens. Public Domain Image, source: Christopher S. Baird. When you bump one end of a bar, you only locally deform that end and the rest of the bar is unaffected at first. But by inwardly deforming the near end of the bar, you have created a region of high pressure in the bar surrounded by regions of lower pressure. Said another way, you have forced the atoms in the near end of the bar to get closer to each other than the equilibrium positions of their chemical bonds. Said more simply, you have knocked the first few layers of atoms against the next few layers of atoms. What happens next? The near end of the bar which is at a higher pressure pushes on a lower pressure part of the bar a little farther down the bar, causing it to have a high pressure. This process continues and you end up with a pressure wave going down the length of the bar until it finally reaches the far end. We commonly call such a pressure wave by the name "sound". You therefore literally create a sound wave that ripples down the bar when you bump one end. It is not a continuous sound wave like a flute's tone, but it's a sound wave nonetheless. The far end of the bar does not move until the sound wave has had time to reach it and cause it to move. Because the "message" that the bar was bumped is carried to the entire bar by a sound wave, such a setup could only be used to send messages at the speed of sound. The speed of sound is much slower than the speed of light, and is definitely not instantaneous. What exactly is this pressure wave? It is a domino effect of chemical bonds between atoms being compressed, springing back towards equilibrium position, and yanking their neighbors upon springing back. In the simplest picture, the first layer of atoms knocks into the next layer of atoms and gets it moving, which then knocks into the subsequent layer, and so on. Nothing can go faster than light. The speed of light in vacuum is the universal speed limit. When you tap on an object, the sound wave that conveys the tap to the whole object is fundamentally carried by the electromagnetic fields that make up the bonds between the atoms. Light itself is an electromagnetic wave. Therefore it should makes sense that the fastest an electromagnetic field (such as the atomic bonds in a bar) can propagate signals is the speed of light in vacuum. Therefore, in a deep sense, sound waves such as bar deformations can never travel faster than the speed of light in vacuum. The speed of light in vacuum is about 300,000,000 m/s. In contrast, the speed of sound in iron is about 5100 m/s and in copper is about 3600 m/s. If you yanked one end of a copper bar that was 3.6 kilometers long, it would take a full second before the other end of the bar would experience the yank (assuming the bar does not permanently deform). Source: wtamu.edu by Sir Christopher S Baird......

Related questions

Description : The first country to send man to the moon -Space

Last Answer : This includes both crewed and robotic missions. The first human-made object to touch the Moon was the Soviet Union's Luna 2, on 13 September 1959. The United States' Apollo 11 was the first crewed mission to land on the Moon, on 20 July 1969.

Description : Since a star's light takes so long to reach us, how do we know that the star is still there? -Space

Last Answer : We don't know that it is still there. For all we know, the North Star or any other star could have been ingested by a passing black hole years ago. (Although this is highly unlikely, it is ... years ago. It is entirely possible that some of the stars you see tonight do not actually exist anymore.

Description : On the space shuttle I have seen pictures with a covering over the tail end. What is this for?

Last Answer : Aerodynamics when it’s being shipped back to Cape Canaveral. It reduces drag so that when piggy-backed on the 747, it doesn’t cause undo dragand air resistance.

Description : Why do some stars end up as black holes? -Space

Last Answer : Gravity wins out over the internal pressure of the star, because that pressure was produced by a normal, hot gas, and that gas is losing energy as the star radiates energy from the surface. The star may thus end up as a black hole.

Description : Some black holes, including the M87 black hole, shoot narrow “jets” of ionized matter away from the black hole at nearly the speed of light. How far do the jets from the M87 black hole extend? -Space

Last Answer : The M87 black hole's jets blast along its axis of rotation to a distance of roughly 5,000 light years.

Description : Why is light a pure energy? -Space

Last Answer : Light is not pure energy. While it is true that light has no mass, this fact does not imply that light is pure energy. Light is composed of fundamental quantum objects called photons which we list ... For more information visit https://wtamu.edu/~cbaird/sq/2015/01/12/why-is-light-pure-energy/

Description : How does a photon accelerate to light speed so quickly? -Space

Last Answer : A photon of light does not accelerate to light speed. Rather, a photon is already traveling at light speed c when it is created. It's not like a photon jumps from a speed of zero to light speed ... source: US Department of Health and Human Services. Source: wtamu.edu by Sir Christopher S Baird......

Description : Can you light diamond on fire? -Space

Last Answer : Yes. Diamonds are made from pure carbon, and carbon will burn in an oxygen atmosphere to produce carbon dioxide. However, you needn't worry about leaving a diamond in the sun. It would take a ... the carbon atoms in a diamond are in a tight three-dimensional array that's very hard to disrupt.

Description : Where is the light seen around the hole that it is consuming coming from? -Space

Last Answer : If a passing photon is a bit too close, it will get trapped in orbit around the black hole. This creates what is called a "photon ring" or "photon sphere", a perfect ring of light predicted to surround the black hole, inside the inner rim of the accretion disc, but outside the event horizon.

Description : The black hole is approximately 55 million light years away, how was its existence known and how was it pictured with just telescopes? -Space

Last Answer : The existence of this black hole was first guessed at because the Messier87 galaxy when imaged at radio frequencies shows the signature twin-jets of plasma that are squirted out at near-relativistic ... matter, if one has telescopes with sharp enough vision, which the Event Horizon Telescope had.

Description : Name the extremely remote celestial object, emitting exceptionally large amounts of light energy, and typically having a star like image in a telescope. -Space

Last Answer : answer:

Description : How Does A Black Hole Distort Light? -Space

Last Answer : Light rays that pass close to the black hole get caught and cannot escape. Therefore, the region around the black hole is a dark disk. Light rays that pass a little further away don't get caught ... bent by the black hole's gravity. This makes the starfield appear distorted, as in a funhouse mirror.

Description : The Closest Black Hole from Earth is how many Light Years away? -Space

Last Answer : At just 1,000 light-years away, the black hole is closer to our solar system than any other that astronomers have found to date. A thousand light-years might sound distant to us, but in cosmic proportions, it's very close.

Description : A black hole 'belches' light and radiation whenever something falls into its event horizon. What does that mean and why does that happen? -Space

Last Answer : A black hole is an astronomical object with a gravitational pull so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape it. A black hole's “surface,” called its event horizon, defines the boundary where the velocity needed to escape exceeds the speed of light, which is the speed limit of the cosmos

Description : If nothing travels at the speed of light, except light, how can a black hole also pull light into itself? -Space

Last Answer : This bending of the light rays increases as the strength of the gravitational field increases. A black hole is simply a region where the effect on light is so great that light cannot escape the region.

Description : What powerful force allows black holes to absorb light? -Space

Last Answer : Actually, the torrent of ultraviolet radiation is being emitted by gas that is heated as it is pulled into the black hole's powerful gravity. Black holes, by definition, are regions from which light cannot escape. Thus, any radiation observed from outside must come from outside black holes.

Description : If photons (light) have no mass, how can they be trapped by the gravitational field of a black hole? -Space

Last Answer : Although photons have no mass, they do have energy, and the gravity of a black hole (or any other gravitating body) will attract them. According to Einstein's theory of gravity, it is energy, not mass, that feels the gravitational force. That's the short answer

Description : How can we learn about black holes if they trap light, and can't actually be seen? -Space

Last Answer : The immense gravity of black holes also distorts space itself, so it is possible to see the influence of an invisible gravitational pull on stars and other objects

Description : Should we send people to Mars if it is a one-way trip?

Last Answer : Glen Beck?

Description : How long would an astronaut last in space if they were separated from the station and drifted off?

Last Answer : Around 7 hours before his oxygen system will give out.

Description : About how long will it take for our Sun to turn into a black hole? -Space

Last Answer : In about 5 billion years, the Sun will start to run out of hydrogen in its core to fuse, and it will begin to collapse.

Description : Over time, a black hole will evaporate via a process called Hawking radiation. How long will it take for the M87 black hole to fully evaporate? -Space

Last Answer : A supermassive black hole with a mass of 1011 (100 billion) M ☉ will evaporate in around 2 10100 years. Some monster black holes in the universe are predicted to continue to grow up to ... the collapse of superclusters of galaxies. Even these would evaporate over a timescale of up to 10106 years.

Description : How long does it take to make a black hole? -Space

Last Answer : Using NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory, astronomers have seen that the famous giant black hole in Messier 87 is propelling particles at speeds greater than 99% of the speed of light

Description : How many times more massive than our Sun is the M87 black hole? -Space

Last Answer : 6.5 billion times Black hole at the centre of the massive galaxy M87, about 55 million light-years from Earth, as imaged by the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT). The black hole is 6.5 billion times more massive than the Sun.

Description : What is the temperature on the ISS (International Space Station)?

Last Answer : It's apparently about 24 degrees C. The heating system is probably both very simple and hilariously complicated depending on how you look at life. Think about it - it's a sealed box surrounded by ... it's minus 247. The trick is to keep hold of the heat you produce without cooking everything.

Description : Forget about the price. Would you want to be launched into space for 10-15 minutes and be weightless? What a rush!

Last Answer : Nope. I hear a lot of people throw up. No thanks.

Description : Did we get a message today recently from outer space?

Last Answer : Reading the article, it points out that it could be quite a number of things. I wouldn't put my money on it being a signal from an extraterrestrial species. We have received signals in the past that we ... it being aliens only for it to turn out to be a pulsar (a rotating neutron star) or something.

Description : If we were to redo the Voyager space probes with modern technology then what would be the difference?

Last Answer : Everything would be better except for the power supply. The original probes were basically nuclear powered. Can’t really get away with launching radioactive materials these days.

Description : Are survivalists like Doomsday Preppers building shelters in outer space yet?

Last Answer : If they’re smart enough to build a vast financial empire, they’re probably smart enough to realize that there’s not much that can be done to fight the end of the world. A bunker is probably a lot safer and more practical, perhaps a lair in a volcano would be even safer than that.

Description : Can space junk be mined for metals and minerals?

Last Answer : Right now the cost to do it would outweigh what they could get for it. And it can also be pretty dangerous I would guess, too. It would be a good idea to get it down. What kinds of materials are ... I could imagine how some of our frenemies would feel if we snaked some of their old stuff to look at.

Description : How can space expand between individual hydrogen atoms? [Strange Universe Series, 2011]

Last Answer : Gravitational force becomes weaker over distance (inverse square). Also, gravity is the a very weak force. You can not even measure it in small scale (a.k.a sub-atomic scale). It does not help either that ... of add up, is enough to still be bigger than the ZPE's pressure of the space between them.

Description : If Space is emptiness, what does gravity grab to bend it? (Strange Universe series)

Last Answer : answer:Well, if we accept some of the string theory perceptions of the universe, considering that there are 10 or 26 dimensions aside from the three we clearly and fourth we kind of see what we perceive ... the math at this point to see what's really there. Then again, it could just be leprachauns.

Description : Is anyone else sad that Nasa's space shuttle program is shutting down?

Last Answer : Yes.

Description : Are they going to renew the space shuttles when the ones now are put into retirement?

Last Answer : answer:Last I heard, NASA's looking at zero space vehicles, thanks to a certain elected official's massive funding cuts. Needless to say, the guys at NASA are peeved. There is ... The space elevator, a longtime favorite, still faces some technological hurdles before serious development can begin.

Description : What is your image of Space going on forever?

Last Answer : The only way I can translate the image in my head to text is this: ∞.

Description : Is compressing files worth it if only a few KB's of space are saved?

Last Answer : No, not that useful. I mean, I suppose in the long-long run, it’ll add up, but I don’t think the effect would be that great or useful to you. I would say you are better off just getting more storage.

Description : Is there really an up/down, left/right, north/south in space?

Last Answer : directions are three dimensional in space, (perhaps more) and the up/down, left/right, north/south directions refer more to two dimensional maps. Pluto misses you as well, and sends its’ love.

Description : Do you think that with all the space crafts going up into space is damaging the ozone?

Last Answer : I don’t think it works like that. The ozone layer is gas. It’s not like a balloon where the rockets are punching wholes in it. It’s more like a submarine in the ocean. As it goes down, the water just takes it’s place. Same concept applies here. The gasses don’t stay torn apart.

Description : Inner Earth or Outer Space- which would you prefer to explore?

Last Answer : Inner space. It feels almost as infinite, and a bit more reasonable to reach.

Description : Is this one reason men need space?

Last Answer : Men can be very single minded when it comes to women in a new relationship especially. We want you around but know we can not concentrate on anything else if you are there. Give us our space as necessary, accept us as morons and love us anyway.

Description : How many heat tiles on the space shuttle?

Last Answer : www.google.com

Description : How far does space go?

Last Answer : No straight line. Follow the energizer bunny.

Description : Think of this: space?

Last Answer : there is most def other life out there “if not that’s an awful lot of wasted space”

Description : How far up is space, in miles.

Last Answer : I’m not sure what you mean. Space is infinite.

Description : Does anyone else find themselves a little creeped out by space?

Last Answer : One that really got me when I was younger was, trying to figure the shape of space! Everything that we know of has some sort of shape, but what about space?

Description : he first space rocket brought back to earth after orbiting the moon -Space

Last Answer : Zond-5 is the right answer

Description : The first unmanned moon buggy to explore surface of the moon -Space

Last Answer : Lunakhod-1 (U.S.S.R.) is

Description : The first space-vehicle to orbit the moon -Space

Last Answer : Luna-10 (U.S.S.R.) is answer

Description : The first spaceship which carried three American astronauts to land two of them on the moon -Space

Last Answer : The Apollo 11 Command Module Columbia carried astronauts Neil Armstrong, Edwin "Buzz" Aldrin, and Michael Collins on their historic voyage to the Moon and back on July 16-24, 1969. During the mission, astronauts Armstrong and Aldrin became the first human explorers of another world.

Description : The first manned space vehicle to land on the moon -Space

Last Answer : Apollo 11 was the first manned mission to land on the Moon. The first steps by humans on another planetary body were taken by Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin on July 20, 1969. The astronauts also returned to Earth the first samples from another planetary body.