A detective in training is called to a room on his first day in, once there his instructor greets him and tells him he has a deck of fish cards. Alongside the instructor are two men who hold three cards from the same deck. He was given a paper reexplaining the prompt which had written on top: 'Each man will say what he has, yet one man is lying... This man is the murderer.' The first man began, he stated he held a shark, a shrimp, and a catfish. The second man stated he held two goldfish and a lion. Who is the murderer? -Riddles

1 Answer

Answer :

A common first answer is the second man, whereas a shrimp is not considered a fish in this case either... You can look over this again if you'd like now. The  The instructor There was only one liar, meaning if the deck was really of fish as the instructor said, they would both be lying in contrary to the prompt. Meaning the only way the statement could be true is if the instructor was the murderer.

Related questions

Description : A murderer was condemned to death. He had to choose between three rooms. The first room was full of raging fires,the second room was full of assassins with loaded guns and the third room was full of lions that haven't eaten in three years. Which room was safest for him? -Riddles

Last Answer : The third room. Lions that haven't eaten in three years are dead.

Description : There are five acquaintances. One of them shot and killed one of the other five. Which man is the murderer? 1. Dan ran in the NY City marathon yesterday with one of the innocent men. 2. Mike ... last computers together. 9. The murderer is Jack's brother; they grew up together in Seattle. -Riddles

Last Answer : 1. Jack is not the murderer, because he is the brother of the murderer. 2. Dan can't be the murderer since he ran a marathon, and the murderer recently had his leg amputated, and wouldn't ... must also be alive since Jeff plans to install Ben's computer next week. This means that Jeff killed Mike.

Description : A murderer is condemned to death. He has to choose between three rooms. The first is full of raging fires, the second is full of assassins with loaded guns, and the third is full of lions that haven't eaten in 3 years. Which room is safest for him? -Riddles

Last Answer : The third. Lions that haven't eaten in three years are dead.

Description : A man was found dead in his study. He was slumped over his desk and a gun was in his hand. There was a cassette recorder on his desk. When the police entered the room and pressed the play ... . How did the detective immediately know that the man had been murdered and it wasn't a suicide? -Riddles

Last Answer : The cassette had started at the beginning of the man's utterance. Someone else had to be there to rewind the tape.

Description : A famous chemist was murdered in his own lab. There was no evidence except for a piece of paper with the names of chemical substances on it. On the day he was murdered, the chemist had only ... his friend Johnathan. The police arrested the murderer right away. How did they know who it was? -Riddles

Last Answer : The piece of paper had a clue on it. If you combine the short names of the chemical substances on the paper, you’ll get a name: Ni-C-O-La-S.

Description : Two cyclists began a training run, one starting from Moscow and the other starting from Simferopol.When the riders were 180 miles apart, a fly took an interest. Starting on one cyclists shoulder, the fly flew ... was 30 mph. Each cyclist speed was 15 mph.How many miles did the fly travel? -Riddles

Last Answer : The cyclists took 6 hours to meet. The fly traveled 6*30=180 miles.

Description : A man walked into a room, and there were three doors. The first door had a sign which read 'Lion's Den.' The second door had a sign which read 'Mountain Top.' The third door had no sign, yet the man knew exactly where it went. How is that possible? -Riddles

Last Answer : The third door is the door that the man entered through.

Description : Once upon a time there was a beautiful princess named Anna. Anna's father, the King, wanted to be sure his daughter married an intelligent man. To test his daughter's suitors the King hid Anna's ... each suitor 'Only one of the three messages is correct.' Which box contained Anna's picture? -Riddles

Last Answer : The silver box contained Anna's picture. If her picture had been in the gold box, two statements would have been true. (The messages on both the gold box and the silver box.) If her picture had ... bronze box, two statements would have been true. (The messages on the bronze box and the silver box.)

Description : A man took a walk in the park. While on his walk, he came across a stray dog who began growling at him and nipped at his heels. The man pulled a crooked stick from his knapsack, told the dog to, 'Fetch ... ----- bit the man on the leg. What was going on here that so infuriated the dog to -Riddles

Last Answer : The man had tormented the dog in the park in the past by telling the dog to fetch the crooked stick (wooden boomerang) he carried with him in his knapsack. The dog could never catch the boomerang, ... who only wanted to play. What goes around comes around, as they say, with boomerangs and in life.

Description : Stanley loved fishing and also loved boasting about how an amazing person he is. One day he went into a bar after fishing, and started telling people in the bar about something that just happened. 'So I was ... : 'You're lying, Stan, are you?' How did the man knew that Stanley was lying? -Riddles

Last Answer : How can the man stab Stanley in the stomach if he's creeping up from BEHIND?

Description : A man was found murdered in his own house on a Sunday morning. His wife called the police. The police questioned the wife and got the following alibis: The wife said she was sleeping. The Cook ... the closet. The police instantly arrested the murderer. Who did it and how did they know? -Riddles

Last Answer : The maid. There is no post on Sunday.

Description : A hiker comes to a fork in the road and doesn't know which way to go to reach his destination. There are two men at the fork, one of whom always tells the truth while the other always lies. The ... the men only one question to find his way. Which man does he ask, and what is the question? -Riddles

Last Answer : Either man should be asked the following question: 'If I were to ask you if this is the way I should go, would you say yes?' While asking the question, the hiker should be pointing at either of the directions going from the fork.

Description : A hiker comes to a fork in the road and doesn't know which way to go to reach his destination. There are two men at the fork, one of whom always tells the truth while the other always lies. The ... the men only one question to find his way. Which man does he ask, and what is the question? -Riddles

Last Answer : Either man should be asked the following question: 'If I were to ask you if this is the way I should go, would you say yes?' While asking the question, the hiker should be pointing at either of the directions going from the fork.

Description : A man strolls into a hospital emergency room where there is a long line up to the reception desk. He walks right to the front and clamly asks to see the consultant in charge. No one gets angry and ... The consultant has never met this man, yet she hurries away from the ward to see him.Why? -Riddles

Last Answer : The man is a florist delievering a bouquet of flowers for the consultant.

Description : An old man wanted to leave all of his money to one of his three sons, but he didn't know which one he should give it to. He gave each of them a few coins and told them to buy something ... filled the room, so he obtained his father's fortune. What were the two things that the man bought? -Riddles

Last Answer : The wise son bought a candle and a box of matches. After lighting the candle, the light filled the entire room.

Description : An old man wanted to leave all of his money to one of his three sons, but he didn't know which one he should give it to. He gave each of them a few coins and told them to buy something ... filled the room, so he obtained his father's fortune. What were the two things that the man bought? -Riddles

Last Answer : The wise son bought a candle and a box of matches. After lighting the candle, the light filled the entire room.

Description : An old man wanted to leave all of his money to one of his three sons, but he didn't know which one he should give it to. He gave each of them a few coins and told them to buy something ... filled the room, so he obtained his father's fortune. What were the two things that the man bought? -Riddles

Last Answer : The wise son bought a candle and a box of matches. After lighting the candle, the light filled the entire room.

Description : A woman waved to a man in a taxi. She got into the taxi and told the taxi driver where to take her. He nodded to her and drove. The woman talked a lot and that annoyed the taxi driver. The taxi ... of the ride. Once she got out of the taxi, she realized he was lying. How did she know? -Riddles

Last Answer : There are two ways she figured out: 1. He would have had to hear her to know she was talking as he was focusing on driving. 2. He would not have heard her directions if he was deaf and wouldn't have nodded in response as a way to confirm he got the directions.

Description : What did the doctor say when a man tells him, 'Doc, help me. I'm addicted to Twitter!' ? -Riddles

Last Answer : The doctor replies, “Sorry, I don’t follow you …”

Description : A man was lying dead on the floor. Next to him was a puddle of water. How did he die? -Riddles

Last Answer : The man was stabbed with an icicle.

Description : Two women sit staring and glaring at each other across a small table. Although the two women don't appear to be friendly toward each other, they do eventually hold each other's hands. A man approaches, puts ... is the word the man shouts to the women, and what in the world is going on here? -Riddles

Last Answer : The word the man shouts to the women is, 'Go!' This is the way most women's arm wrestling competitions start, and hopefully the wrist straps, to keep their hands from slipping apart, won't have to be used.

Description : In 1209, on a hot summer day there was a man who was ordered to be executed by king. The king was a nice king though, and he said that if the man could prove himself wise, he would let him ... The king opened a window, and the man immediately knew which was the real flower. How did he know? -Riddles

Last Answer : When the King opened the window, a bee flew in and landed on the only real flower to gather pollen.

Description : A wealthy man lives alone in a small cottage. Being partially handicapped, he had everything delivered to his cottage. The mailman was delivering a letter one Thursday when he noticed that the front door ... mail. The police officer suspects it was foul play. Who does he suspect and why? -Riddles

Last Answer : The police officer suspects the newspaper delivery person. The absence of Tuesday's and Wednesday's newspaper indicates that the delivery person knew there was no one there to read it.

Description : A man was found murdered on Sunday morning. His wife immediately called the police. The police questioned the wife and staff and got these alibis: The Wife said she was sleeping. The Cook was cooking ... closet. The police instantly arrested the murderer. Who did it and how did they know? -Riddles

Last Answer : It was the Maid. She said she was getting the mail. There is no mail on Sunday! (next day air and email doesn't count)

Description : A man was found murdered on Sunday morning. His wife immediately called the police. The police questioned the wife and staff and got these alibis: The Wife said she was sleeping. The Cook was cooking ... closet. The police instantly arrested the murderer. Who did it and how did they know? -Riddles

Last Answer : It was the Maid. She said she was getting the mail. There is no mail on Sunday!

Description : You walk into your house the electricity is out you see three doors that you have never seen before. You go through the one with a lion that hasn't eaten for over six months. There are another three ... the knife or the electric chair that will kill you in an instant. How will you survive? -Riddles

Last Answer : The electric chair because your electricity is out.

Description : Jason is lying dead. He has an iron bar across his back and some food lying in front of him. How did Jason meet his sorry end? -Riddles

Last Answer : He is a mouse caught in a mousetrap.

Description : What happens when Henry approaches his regiment who is the guard that greets him?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : I give you a group of three. One is sitting down, and will never get up. The second eats as much as is given to him, yet is always hungry. The third goes away and never returns. -Riddles

Last Answer : Stove, fire, and smoke.

Description : A man enters an expensive restraunt and orders a meal. When the waiter brings him his meal the man takes out a slip of paper and writes down 102004180, then leaves. The cashier hands the slip of paper to the cashier who understood it immediately.What did the slip of paper say? -Riddles

Last Answer : I =1, 0=Ought, 2=To, 0=Owe, 0=Nothing, 4=For, 1=I, 8=Ate, 0=Nothing. I Ought To Owe Nothing For I Ate Nothing. 102004180

Description : Near a castle without a moat, a well-known queen was captured and held hostage by a dark and powerful enemy force. Several of her loyal servants tried to break through enemy lines to free her ... this well-known queen and the lowly servant who performed the greatest sacrifice to save her? -Riddles

Last Answer : The queen was the white queen, and the servant who was sacrificed was a white pawn who had reached the back row of the black chess pieces—and was subsequently promoted/exchanged for the captured white queen.

Description : I am as light as a feather, yet the strongest of men cannot hold me for more than a minute. I am with you from the day you are born to the day you die. I can be as putrid as onions and garlic, yet as pleasant as freshly picked roses. What am I? -Riddles

Last Answer : Breath.

Description : There was once a girl who was always jealous of her sister. One day a genie appeared and told her that he was 'half magic' which meant that he could grant her wishes, but her sister would always ... woman in the world, but her sister gets twice as much beauty.What was her third wish? -Riddles

Last Answer : She askes the genie to grab a nearby stick and beat her half to death.

Description : A man is discovered dead sitting at his desk, alone in the locked office. He did not commit suicide and there was no weapons in the room. The only clue is a sealed envelope on the desk in front of him.How did he die? -Riddles

Last Answer : The envelope glue was poisoned and when the man licked the envelope to seal it, he died.

Description : 3 men go into a motel. The man behind the desk said the room is $30, so each man paid $10 and went to the room. A while later the man behind thedesk realized the room wasonly $25, so he sent the ... whichis a total of $27, add the $2 that the bellboy kept = $29. where is the other dollar? -Riddles

Last Answer : The three men HAVE paid $27. But the bellboy's $2 are part of it. The hotel has $25 of the men's dollars. The bellboy has the other two. That's $27, and the three the men have make $30. The ... elsewhere on riddles.com, but the answer given was 'I don't know'! So I figured it out and posted it.

Description : A highschool has a strange principal. on the first day of school he does something weird. There are 1000 lockers and 1000 students. He tells the first student to open every first locker. The second student ... this until all the students have done it. How many lockers are open at the end? -Riddles

Last Answer : 31 lockers.

Description : There is a door, on the side of the door that you are on, there is a skeletal army ready to trample you underneath their feet, on the other side is a city with a wall that will keep you safe. ... get one chance to guess. The doorkeeper says 'twenty one'. What do you say to get to safety? -Riddles

Last Answer : You would say 'nine' as, 21 is nine letters long. It's quite simple actually. Eight is five letters long hence 'five' and nine is four letters long hence the word 'four'.

Description : Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson were going on a hike through the woods. After a long day of hiking, they stopped for the night. They ate a cold meal, pitched a tent, and went to sleep. Both ... know!' Doctor Watson retorted, annoyed. 'What does it tell you?' What did the detective notice? -Riddles

Last Answer : Elementary, my dear Watson. Someone has stolen our tent.

Description : There was a circular building with three floors. On the first floor lived elderly Mr. Davis and Mrs. Davis. On the second lived a newly-married couple, Sam and Jenny. On the third floor lived ... was studying for her upcoming exams on Face Time with her friend. Who murdered Mrs. Davis? -Riddles

Last Answer : Sam was the murderer. He said he was drinking coffee in a corner of the room, but the building was a circular building.

Description : On a fine sunny day a ship was in the harbor. All of a sudden the ship began to sink. There was no storm and nothing wrong with the ship yet it sank right in front of the spectators eyes. What caused the ship to sink? -Riddles

Last Answer : The 'Submarine' Captain ordered the crew to dive.

Description : On a fine sunny day a ship was in the harbor. All of a sudden the ship began to sink. There was no storm and nothing wrong with the ship yet it sank right in front of the spectators eyes. What caused the ship to sink? -Riddles

Last Answer : It was a Submarine.

Description : A magician was boasting one day at how long he could hold his breath under water. His record was 6 minutes. A kid that was listening said, 'that's nothing, I can stay under water for 10 minutes using no ... he'd give him $10,000. The kid did it and won the money.Can you figure out how? -Riddles

Last Answer : The kid filled a glass of water and held it over his head for 10 minutes.