I almost got one from there, but it was much smaller than the ring I ended up getting…which was not from Tiffany’s. To me, it’s just a brand. Is she going to walk around telling everyone where she got the ring from? Because only she and you will know, is it really that important to you two? I personally am in love with Jared’s! We got our wedding bands there, and I wish we would have gotten my engagement ring there. My parents now get all their jewelry from there, and are always satisfied. They have affordable, and not so affordable things (for us) but I just love the selection. Also, it’s really the quality that counts. Yes, Tiffany’s has some great quality jewelry, but so do other places. To me, you’d just be buying the name (and I don’t think that’s the same as an Apple vs non-Apple product)