Should I scold my dog for messing in the house if I couldn't get home to let him out?

Should I scold my dog for messing in the house if I couldn't get home to let him out?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

No that would be cruel. The dog had no choice. We have 3 perfectly housebroken dogs. If I lock them in and they have an accident it is my fault. They do not like going in the house and would have gone out if they were able to.
by

Related questions

Why does my dog, Cato, start shivering,almost violently, when he realizes that we're going to leave him in the house, or the camper, when we go to eat?

Description : Why does my dog, Cato, start shivering,almost violently, when he realizes that we're going to leave him in the house, or the camper, when we go to eat?

Last Answer : Sounds like anxiety.

My dog who was already potty trained is suddenly pooping and peeing in the house. How can I re-train him?

Description : My dog who was already potty trained is suddenly pooping and peeing in the house. How can I re-train him?

Last Answer : …What happened to him at you friends house?

How did you train your dog to let you know that (s)he needs to go out?

Description : How did you train your dog to let you know that (s)he needs to go out?

Last Answer : Do you have a fenced in yard? I have a doggie door, so mine just goes out when she needs or wants to. It sounds like to me you have to start all over from the beginning again. Start taking ... question too. I see that @Dr Dredd has asked a similar question and maybe there is some good advice there.

Dog with ear infection won't let me put drops in his ear?

Description : Dog with ear infection won't let me put drops in his ear?

Last Answer : You need to call the vet back. Perhaps a tranquilizer would help. Maybe doggie’s ear hurts, and a pain killer would help as well. Also suggest you put a muzzle on dog before you try doing anything else with the ear.

Will you let your dog/a dog to lick your face?

Description : Will you let your dog/a dog to lick your face?

Last Answer : Sure, my face has been in a lot dirtier places.

When you walk your dog, do you have it on a lead or let it run free?

Description : When you walk your dog, do you have it on a lead or let it run free?

Last Answer : It depends entirely on the situation, the setting, the dog and the owner. My own dog stays immediately at my side even off-lead, so I tend not to use one. However, if I am at a state park that has a ... -lead do not have adequate control over their pets. And, no, using a leash on a dog is not cruel.

Is it ok the let your dog up on the bed?

Description : Is it ok the let your dog up on the bed?

Last Answer : It’s certainly more than OK with me. I had chemo and would have been very unhappy to have been put in a crate at night.

While teaching in the class one of your students pointed out sharply your mistakes. What will you do in such a condition? (a) You leave the class for the day (b) You scold the child and angrily resist him (c) You feel sorry for committing a blunder. (d) You will not show any emotion.

Description : While teaching in the class one of your students pointed out sharply your mistakes. What will you do in such a condition? (a) You leave the class for the day (b) You scold the child and angrily resist him (c) You feel sorry for committing a blunder. (d) You will not show any emotion.

Last Answer : c) You feel sorry for committing a blunder.

When you make a mistake while teaching in the class and your students points it out sharply then what will you do? Options: A) You break all the limits of anger B) You feel sorry for committing a blunder C) You scold the child and angrily resist him D) You leave the class for a week

Description : When you make a mistake while teaching in the class and your students points it out sharply then what will you do? Options: A) You break all the limits of anger B) You feel sorry for committing a blunder C) You scold the child and angrily resist him D) You leave the class for a week

Last Answer : B) You feel sorry for committing a blunder 

The Best Way To React To A Wrong Answer Given By A Student Is: Options: A) To Scold Him For Not Having Learnt The Lesson B) To Explain Why The Answer Is Wrong C) To Ask Another Student To Give The Correct Answer D) To Ignore The Wrong Answer And Pass On The Next Question

Description : The Best Way To React To A Wrong Answer Given By A Student Is: Options: A) To Scold Him For Not Having Learnt The Lesson B) To Explain Why The Answer Is Wrong C) To Ask Another Student To Give The Correct Answer D) To Ignore The Wrong Answer And Pass On The Next Question

Last Answer : B) To Explain Why The Answer Is Wrong 

When a disciplinary action is necessary with a preschool child, the least acceptable technique would generally be Options: A) To isolate him by sending him to his room B) To take away some of his privileges C) To scold him D) To make him feel sorry for having hurt your feelings

Description : When a disciplinary action is necessary with a preschool child, the least acceptable technique would generally be Options: A) To isolate him by sending him to his room B) To take away some of his privileges C) To scold him D) To make him feel sorry for having hurt your feelings

Last Answer : D) To make him feel sorry for having hurt your feelings

A high-caste teacher is biased with the scheduled caste's students. What advise do you like to give to that teacher? Options: A) Nothing is wrong in his attitude B) He should not behave against the national spirit and need of the hour C) Scold him for narrow thinking D) Threat him against the constitutional provisions

Description : A high-caste teacher is biased with the scheduled caste's students. What advise do you like to give to that teacher? Options: A) Nothing is wrong in his attitude B) He should not behave ... and need of the hour C) Scold him for narrow thinking D) Threat him against the constitutional provisions

Last Answer : B) He should not behave against the national spirit and need of the hour

If a teacher requests you to do a favour in a girl student's evaluation, what would you like to do in this situation? Options: A) You will teach him a moral lesson against injustice B) You will scold him that he is a wicked fellow as he loose the sanctity of evaluation C) You will remind him the grace and morality of being a teacher D) You will evaluate the answer-book honestly and give marks accordingly

Description : If a teacher requests you to do a favour in a girl student's evaluation, what would you like to do in this situation? Options: A) You will teach him a moral lesson against injustice ... and morality of being a teacher D) You will evaluate the answer-book honestly and give marks accordingly

Last Answer : D) You will evaluate the answer-book honestly and give marks accordingly 

Why does my dog chew the crotches out of my panties and pants...and is there a way to stop him from doing this?

Description : Why does my dog chew the crotches out of my panties and pants...and is there a way to stop him from doing this?

Last Answer : Yes. Put your underwear and pants into the dirty laundry basket right away. I’ve had this issue since becoming pregnant. The dog has ruined many pairs of my underwear, but it’s my own fault for not putting them in the basket. Other than that, nothing will stop a dog from being gross.

Does the fact that my dog, Cato, has a saggital crest suggest he has some pit bull in him?

Description : Does the fact that my dog, Cato, has a saggital crest suggest he has some pit bull in him?

Last Answer : Reading that article, Cato is part orangutang. No wonder he was mad when you started playing with that cute dog down teh street. p.s. I thought the Sagittal Crest was a ridgeline in the Sierra Nevada.

Is there any sort of discussion I should have with my dog, before abandoning him to the evil surgeon?

Description : Is there any sort of discussion I should have with my dog, before abandoning him to the evil surgeon?

Last Answer : You need to sit him down and tell him what is about to happen. He deserves the truth. Sweetie, I'm taking you in to get your manhood removed. You will never have guy urges again. I'm doing this ... will put you under, whack off your balls and after that, you won't have anything to lick down there.

Why does my dog get nervous when I try to move him to the side of my bed that's against the wall?

Description : Why does my dog get nervous when I try to move him to the side of my bed that's against the wall?

Last Answer : Have you had him since he was a small puppy? If not, do you know his early history? My first thought is that maybe he was abused as a puppy. If the abuse involved small spaces or being cornered, ... If you show him he's safe and can associate that situation with good things, he'll be less nervous.

Why does my dog whine when I pet him?

Description : Why does my dog whine when I pet him?

Last Answer : answer:A belated welcome to Fluther! All I can tell you is that several of our dogs did the same thing, especially when Dad came home from a trip. Dad and the dog would end up on the floor and the dog ... being petted, it is a way of communication. If it were in pain, it would back away or run off.

Anything that I could do for my 14 year dog; I think that his hips are starting to bother him?

Description : Anything that I could do for my 14 year dog; I think that his hips are starting to bother him?

Last Answer : Its time for his hips to have arthritis. my 12 year old border collie has the same problem. the vet gave him some anti-inflammatory medicene for him and it seems to really help. dogs are like humans. once ... seat. he will need your helping had, so plan on it. its just the aging process of us all.

My dog accidently ate an Advil, Is this dangerous for him?

Description : My dog accidently ate an Advil, Is this dangerous for him?

Last Answer : Yes take him to the vet. Ibuporfen can be toxic to dogs.

My dog is afraid of balls. How do I get him used to them?

Description : My dog is afraid of balls. How do I get him used to them?

Last Answer : Why would you want to? Is it mandatory that dogs like balls or should have to play with them?

What is my dog thinking when I get him howling?

Description : What is my dog thinking when I get him howling?

Last Answer : Group howling is a method coyotes and wolves use to strengthen the bonds within a pack, especially when the pack is being challenged or issuing a challenge. You are his pack leader, so he is supporting you.

My dog died in March but I just cant stop crying. He was everything to me, everything reminds me of him. What do I do?

Description : My dog died in March but I just cant stop crying. He was everything to me, everything reminds me of him. What do I do?

Last Answer : Time is your answer

If my dog bites someone that is in my yard, and they hurt him , can i call the police on them?

Description : If my dog bites someone that is in my yard, and they hurt him , can i call the police on them?

Last Answer : You can call the police, but, you still might face civil liability. this is called a tort. if your dog is prone to biting humans, you should have a warning signs posted on all four side of ... and a similiar situation occurs, if you are sued, posting the signs in advance will be in your defense

I'm curious why my dog often sees his own reflection in a large glass door and barks at himself as if there is another dog outside, but when I have him sit in front of a full-length mirror he never reacts to his own reflection?

Description : I'm curious why my dog often sees his own reflection in a large glass door and barks at himself as if there is another dog outside, but when I have him sit in front of a full-length mirror he never reacts to his own reflection?

Last Answer : I think the difference is that the dog in the glass is outside the boundary of the den—your house—and thus is not recognized as himself. Therefore, barking.

Anyone who has a dog on a senior diet, what brand of dog food do you feed him/her?

Description : Anyone who has a dog on a senior diet, what brand of dog food do you feed him/her?

Last Answer : If your dog is used to dry food, I really like EVO since it has no grain at all. I think the link may have a list of ingredients. I don’t buy all the hyperbole, but I have gone over the formulation with some very knowledgeable assistance, and it ranks very very high for dry food.

Do you think it's it okay to hit a dog in order to train him in this case?

Description : Do you think it's it okay to hit a dog in order to train him in this case?

Last Answer : I don’t treat my pets that way… But everyone is different. Perhaps he doesn’t understand there are other effective ways to train a lab.

Does anyone know what might cause my dog to panic every time we take him to the groomer?

Description : Does anyone know what might cause my dog to panic every time we take him to the groomer?

Last Answer : He could of had a bad experience like getting scared by a bigger dog, or the groomer could of accidentally hurt him. I would hope anyone who works with animals wouldn’t be abusive, but you never know these days. Maybe you could try another groomer and see if he has the same reaction.

If you catch your puppy in the act of peeing in the house, is it OK to scold them?

Description : If you catch your puppy in the act of peeing in the house, is it OK to scold them?

Last Answer : Sending this on to @syz.

What should I have in the house before I pick up my dog?

Description : What should I have in the house before I pick up my dog?

Last Answer : A dog bed that you want him to use.

Why would my dog suddenly start pooping and peeing in the house, on the carpet, after over a year of pretty much flawless behavior?

Description : Why would my dog suddenly start pooping and peeing in the house, on the carpet, after over a year of pretty much flawless behavior?

Last Answer : If this is a very recent change, you may want to visit the veterinarian to rule out any bladder or G.I. tract troubles.

How do I stop an old dog from peeing in the house?

Description : How do I stop an old dog from peeing in the house?

Last Answer : Just take her out as often as possible to use the restroom. I think teaching a 13 year old dog something new will be difficult.

Dog lovers: do you discover something new about your dog everyday - like you would with a new baby? Does it seem the same, almost, like having another person in the house?

Description : Dog lovers: do you discover something new about your dog everyday - like you would with a new baby? Does it seem the same, almost, like having another person in the house?

Last Answer : Yes! She does something new and cute every day. The snow has been really fun for her and she acts like a little kid playing in it.

Why is my dog suddenly hiding when i leave the house?

Description : Why is my dog suddenly hiding when i leave the house?

Last Answer : Was there a significant thunder storm recently in your area? Or maybe an alarm that was going off while you were gone that might have scared her?

Ideas for getting a dog to not fear getting dried off before coming into the house?

Description : Ideas for getting a dog to not fear getting dried off before coming into the house?

Last Answer : answer:Seems like there are two associations you need to tackle: coming back from creek = towelling and towelling = bad. Try changing up the routine... take her to the creek, then go for a long walk so ... tolerate) the towelling. How does she she react if you just try to towel her when she's dry?

What would you do if you saw someone beating their dog as if it was brought home by the red-headed step child?

Description : What would you do if you saw someone beating their dog as if it was brought home by the red-headed step child?

Last Answer : answer:I am very bold and not easily intimidated. I would confront them on the spot, call the police and find a way to detain them until the law arrived. I do not carry firearms but yep, I ... to witness something horrible all bets are off, I'll take my chances on being arrested for my intervention.

Did your rescue dog fall asleep in the car driving to his new home and why?

Description : Did your rescue dog fall asleep in the car driving to his new home and why?

Last Answer : No, but my one eyed rescue goose “Sonora” rode all the way home on a 2 hour drive standing in a wicker laundry basket with his head peeking out strapped into the front seat of my car. haha He was very happy to go swimming in his new pool and have a refreshing salad when he got to his new home.

Is it okay to leave a dog home alone for 12 hours, Monday - Friday?

Description : Is it okay to leave a dog home alone for 12 hours, Monday - Friday?

Last Answer : I wouldn’t do it, especially if you get a puppy. A puppy can’t go that long without needing to potty and dogs in general need to get some exercise. If you aren’t crating the dog, it will get bored and perhaps start chewing up the furniture, carpet and even walls. It would get lonely too.

Do you have a dog that has to stay home alone for a number of hours while you are at work?

Description : Do you have a dog that has to stay home alone for a number of hours while you are at work?

Last Answer : it appears he sleeps most of the time, never causes trouble which is good considering I also have six cats.

The neighbor's dog has been barking for 1/2 an hour straight. Don't think that anyone is home. What should I do?

Description : The neighbor's dog has been barking for 1/2 an hour straight. Don't think that anyone is home. What should I do?

Last Answer : Well…if you don’t have any contact numbers for them, not much you can do. Is the dog outside? If so you can toss him some food or something to divert him, but otherwise….uh, guess you just have to deal with it.

Will my dog find her way home?

Description : Will my dog find her way home?

Last Answer : Ask around and get everyone to keep an eye out for your dog. I hope she comes back soon. I'd be sick if my dog ran off. Fortunately, she is very well trained not to leave the yard, but all it takes ... We had a cat get out in a snowstorm and come back after three days, so there's hope for your dog.

What are some ideas to get my two dogs from running up the hill in the back yard and barking at the other dogs when the neighbors let theirs out?

Description : What are some ideas to get my two dogs from running up the hill in the back yard and barking at the other dogs when the neighbors let theirs out?

Last Answer : I recommend watching a couple of episodes of “The Dog Whisperer”.

Why do some people let their dogs walk off leash?

Description : Why do some people let their dogs walk off leash?

Last Answer : some are just really well trained.

If you couldn't store more memories in your head from that day on, because every new experience would knock out an old one, would you let your old memories be forgotten, or would you never do anything memorable again but protect your past?

Description : If you couldn’t keep more memories in your head from that day on, because every new experience would knock out an old one, would you let your old memories be forgotten, or would you never do anything memorable again but protect your past?

Last Answer : I do, many times I want to erase the past, so smoothly.

Have you ever been angry because of someone/something that you know you probably shouldn't be, but you couldn't let go of it anyway?

Description : Have you ever been angry because of someone/something that you know you probably shouldn't be, but you couldn't let go of it anyway?

Last Answer : Vent in writing to no one and get it out of your system. Start out letting the emotions fly, then examine the situation from all angles. This is most often what I use my journal for, regardless of whether my emotions are justified or not.

I need transportation to a hospital for surgery and have no friends or family. Also I am unemployed and have no $. Is there an agency who can help with my day surgery The hospital will not let me drive or take a cab (which I couldn't afford anyway)?

Description : I need transportation to a hospital for surgery and have no friends or family. Also I am unemployed and have no $. Is there an agency who can help with my day surgery The hospital will not let me drive or take a cab (which I couldn't afford anyway)?

Last Answer : You could try to get a credit care card and use it for a medical transport.

I'll be getting a puppy (bully) 2-3 weeks from now, can you help me name him?

Description : I'll be getting a puppy (bully) 2-3 weeks from now, can you help me name him?

Last Answer : Is he a pit bull? “Steeler”, as in Pittsburgh Steeler. “Finch” as in Bullfinch At least he already has a theme song

Why won't my puppy come when I call him, and he acts scared of me?

Description : Why won't my puppy come when I call him, and he acts scared of me?

Last Answer : answer:Here’s a good lecture about dog training. http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/ian_dunbar_on_dog_friendly_dog_training.html

How can i do a parkour roll with out messing up my shoulder?

Description : How can i do a parkour roll with out messing up my shoulder?

Last Answer : practice summersaults first from a standing position before you do anything that could hurt you. roll from right shoulder to left hip so the ground takes the longest route on your back.

Two cops walked into a room with no windows and found a dead man who obviously hung himself from the ceiling, though they couldn't figure out how. There was no chair beneath him that he might have jumped off of, or a table. Just a puddle of water. How'd he do it? -Riddles

Description : Two cops walked into a room with no windows and found a dead man who obviously hung himself from the ceiling, though they couldn't figure out how. There was no chair beneath him that he might have jumped off of, or a table. Just a puddle of water. How'd he do it? -Riddles

Last Answer : He stood on a block of ice until it melted.