Which is better: a classical education or a liberal education?

Which is better: a classical education or a liberal education?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

A bit of both would be best, as children respond in different ways to different subjects and teaching styles. The child’s needs should inform the curriculum, not the other way around.
by

Related questions

What are the advantages of choosing a broad liberal arts education over a more technical one in college?

Description : What are the advantages of choosing a broad liberal arts education over a more technical one in college?

Last Answer : happiness? as an employer, ‘liberal arts’ education means low wage earner.

How could Liberal Studies be a B.S.?

Description : How could Liberal Studies be a B.S.?

Last Answer : That doesn’t make much sense to me, but I’d imagine it wouldn’t matter either way. BS or BA, an English degree is an English degree.

What is your interpretation of these Conservative vs Liberal statistics?

Description : What is your interpretation of these Conservative vs Liberal statistics?

Last Answer : answer:Breaking news: populations that hold different values enact policies that result in different outcomes. In other news, 1 + 1 = 2.

What is the point of a Liberal Arts degree?

Description : What is the point of a Liberal Arts degree?

Last Answer : answer:From what I understand, liberal arts degree from an undergraduate school is mostly for those who want to go into teaching, and occasionally research, I can't think what else it could be really good ... seems to be really the only field they could be certain near 100% of getting a job in.

Liberal hegemony/dogma on college campuses? What's been your experience?

Description : Liberal hegemony/dogma on college campuses? What's been your experience?

Last Answer : Hard to say, not finding the dichotomy & labels conservative/liberal too reflective both of my own views, and of others. We're a lot less politically diverse than many developed nations, yet we're still ... views were pushed to the side & not considered. [must go asap, will try to elaborate later]

What would it take to bring a reanimated Classical Master like Leonardo Davinci up to the qualifications of his modern Phd. peers?

Description : What would it take to bring a reanimated Classical Master like Leonardo Davinci up to the qualifications of his modern Phd. peers?

Last Answer : He would have to go through all levels of education again, basic included. I mean, the man lived before Leibniz invented calculus. He does not know basic biology, physics, chemistry, or material science, and he likely still believes things about the world that are just flat out wrong.

Do you consider Gospel as legitimate of a musical style as, for instance, jazz and classical?

Description : Do you consider Gospel as legitimate of a musical style as, for instance, jazz and classical?

Last Answer : Yes. Why would it not be?

Is it true that if a child plays a classical instrument (violin, cello, flute, clarinet) he or she will grow up to be very intelligent?

Description : Is it true that if a child plays a classical instrument (violin, cello, flute, clarinet) he or she will grow up to be very intelligent?

Last Answer : They have shown that learning a second language or learning to read and play music (which is similar in the brain to learning a new language) increases the child’s ability to learn. Very true.

Does having an education always mean you will have a better understanding?

Description : Does having an education always mean you will have a better understanding?

Last Answer : Not always, but it sure helps.

Why does religion have such a strong influence on people that they'll sacrifice things like a better education, etc?

Description : Why does religion have such a strong influence on people that they'll sacrifice things like a better education, etc?

Last Answer : Education and faith do not couple well. The churches know this.

Liberalism in education, when it was claimed by universities of the world since the 19th century, meant Options: A) Freedom to be given to education from the clutches of religion B) favouring liberal education as opposed to special education C) Academic freedom for teachers in instruction D) Administrative freedom to universities to run the institution

Description : Liberalism in education, when it was claimed by universities of the world since the 19th century, meant Options: A) Freedom to be given to education from the clutches of religion B) ... C) Academic freedom for teachers in instruction D) Administrative freedom to universities to run the institution

Last Answer : C) Academic freedom for teachers in instruction 

The aim of vocationalization of education is: (A) preparing students for a vocation along with knowledge (B) converting liberal education into vocational education (C) giving more importance to vocational than general education (D) making liberal education job-oriented

Description : The aim of vocationalization of education is: (A) preparing students for a vocation along with knowledge (B) converting liberal education into vocational education (C) giving more importance to vocational than general education (D) making liberal education job-oriented

Last Answer : Answer: A  Vocational education is concerned with the training on vocation. It is related to pr oductivity. Vocational education prepares individuals for jobs. It has adequate employment ... means training in some vocations at the secondary, Higher Secondary level with general education. 

What are your thoughts on the state of public education in our country?

Description : What are your thoughts on the state of public education in our country?

Last Answer : I live in America. Took my child out of the failing public school into a remote only private academy. One of the best decisions we’ve ever made.

Have you ever mistaken education for debate?

Description : Have you ever mistaken education for debate?

Last Answer : I do find other people think they’re in a debate when I’m actually trying to educate them.

Do you have any suggestions on improving grade school education?

Description : Do you have any suggestions on improving grade school education?

Last Answer : Increase teacher pay and school funding. Ending steaming is a good thing too. There are probably tweaks that need to be made regularly to cirriculum to keep it globally competitive, ... between the cracks for various reasons. Class biases and stereotyping can strongly affect individual outcomes.

How would an education system benefit from a rote memory-centric teaching method?

Description : How would an education system benefit from a rote memory-centric teaching method?

Last Answer : Just for entry level jobs. Eventually they would lead to creating new knowledge and expertise; as they master the skill. Fast food restaurants who would like to standardize menu items would like your style of learning.

What did President Biden's State of the Union address speech change to education?

Description : What did President Biden's State of the Union address speech change to education?

Last Answer : He did not add four more years of free high school. High School is already federally funded for four years, and then one graduates. He proposed free community college (2 years) and two years of pre- ... 5). Also, this was not a State of the Union address He will give a SOTU next February..

How important was education to your family of origin?

Description : How important was education to your family of origin?

Last Answer : Big ol’ 10, but without the understanding of why it was so important, it was just a given. I grew up privileged in the North East. As an adult, I realized the value of the education I got. I passed that on to my family.

If you're critical of the education system, how do/did you get your children through it?

Description : If you're critical of the education system, how do/did you get your children through it?

Last Answer : At first I homeschooled. Then after that they ended up going to private schools. In some places there are grassroots organizations that work together to hold the school board accountable. PM me for details if you’re interested.

Would online schools help education in the US?

Description : Would online schools help education in the US?

Last Answer : Yes, very much. The Charter school that my grandsons are in has introduced online line learning that is a great help. I am at a disadvantage because I have to learn even more than ... Education, through the college level. Many specialized college level courses can also supplement the higher levels.

Did you hear Jerry Falwell will lead the higher education task force?

Description : Did you hear Jerry Falwell will lead the higher education task force?

Last Answer : answer:That is what NBC, CBS, USA Today, and just about everybody else is saying. And that’s Jerry Falwell, Jr., Leslie. I’m sure you know that, but you damn near gave me a heart attack. I was unaware that insect had left his spawn behind. Now I’m just having a junior heart attack.

With the haul of gold medals by the US in the last Olympics stood up aside where the US ranks in education does it seem the US is more focused on sports and competition than education?

Description : With the haul of gold medals by the US in the last Olympics stood up aside where the US ranks in education does it seem the US is more focused on sports and competition than education?

Last Answer : answer:Sure, but there are many other much more relevant-seeming signs than that that the US education system is wacked. Also, education measures are about average performance, not about peak ... being about something different, but by being a very different type of numeric comparison, anyway.

What is your opinion of Catholics still getting special treatment for primary education in Ireland?

Description : What is your opinion of Catholics still getting special treatment for primary education in Ireland?

Last Answer : What is the school system like in Ireland? Is it “public” (paid for by taxpayer funds) like in the U.S.? Do you have a link that would explain it? I honestly have no idea. And, has anything changed in the last 6 months since that article?

Do you think that this approach on education is good/can work?

Description : Do you think that this approach on education is good/can work?

Last Answer : answer:I don't know where you live, but I'm in America and I don't use any of those terms related to education. I don't work in education though, so maybe the people who do think in ... learn. Learning to help be successful, learning for curiosity's sake, learning to be able to function in society.

The present education system for K-12 is weak but you hate vouchers, what is your fix of the education system, if you had a say?

Description : The present education system for K-12 is weak but you hate vouchers, what is your fix of the education system, if you had a say?

Last Answer : My fix? Reduce the ridiculous amount that we spend on the military complex and put it into education.

Is education a marketable business?

Description : Is education a marketable business?

Last Answer : answer:Although it seems like it would be lucrative (the tuition costs are outrageous!) private schools are not big money makers. The cost of running such a place is so incredibly high as to be ... emotionally prepared, that alone would be a good argument against. Sorry to be so abrupt about this.

What careers (besides teaching) can a person pursue with a BA in Elementary Education?

Description : What careers (besides teaching) can a person pursue with a BA in Elementary Education?

Last Answer : answer:Translating? Creative writing? Historican? Human resources managing? As far as I know any job that involve social science offers BA.

Is education a bulwark against homelesseness?

Description : Is education a bulwark against homelesseness?

Last Answer : answer:No, it is not a defense. Yes, I have known homeless men, locally, who held a Ph.d or master degree. There is also that newsworthy example a few years back. Maurice Johnson Is Homeless With ... % of homeless always exists. What changes are the people who slip in and out of that homeless %.

What do you think of higher education in America?

Description : What do you think of higher education in America?

Last Answer : Everyone should attain a college education and get some sort of degree. (And only college educated people should be allowed to vote!) The student should pay his/her own way which makes it more valuable.

Common Core. Is It Improving Education?

Description : Common Core. Is It Improving Education?

Last Answer : answer:It’s just another step in the dumbing down of american students. And it is quite obvious why they are doing it. Why would you want intelligent, educated slaves?

Why is education compared among countries?

Description : Why is education compared among countries?

Last Answer : Because the colonies self-proclaim themselves to be the best at everything. This distorted self-image is pervasive among its “culture”, so anything that threatens to shatter this image is great news material.

What do you think about the wording every child is entitled to an adequate education?

Description : What do you think about the wording every child is entitled to an adequate education?

Last Answer : I actually perfer the “adequate” wording over “equal.” This is because “equal” does not say anything about the quality of the education. I feel that inadequate generally implies unequal, but equal does not imply adequate.

Does the Qur'an actually prohibit women from being educated; or does it only allow them religious education?

Description : Does the Qur'an actually prohibit women from being educated; or does it only allow them religious education?

Last Answer : It depends on which sect you are talking about.

Ultimately, what is the purpose of a university education?

Description : Ultimately, what is the purpose of a university education?

Last Answer : answer:When I was that age I wish people would have quit telling me it was about the education I got in my classes. It really wasn't and it became really obvious once I got there. Freshman classes had ... experiences, those friends, and there's no time like where she's at in her life to get them.

If a teacher double majors in Education and the Humanities what can s/he teach?

Description : If a teacher double majors in Education and the Humanities what can s/he teach?

Last Answer : answer:I feel like the other major would have to be History in order to teach History. Are there really schools that offer a Humanities major? How broad. It's like colleges that offer degrees in Liberal ... clue what I want to do with my life. I say choose a concentration that's more specific.

Do the students who are currently attending or have graduated from the education programs at these schools have any legal recourse?

Description : Do the students who are currently attending or have graduated from the education programs at these schools have any legal recourse?

Last Answer : It’s possible. I would contact a lawyer and explore the possibilities.

Why do we provide public education?

Description : Why do we provide public education?

Last Answer : Well, I want even the most menial laborer to be able to read the voting ballot.

Is the education of children a parental right?

Description : Is the education of children a parental right?

Last Answer : answer:No, it is not a fundamental right. Just like sole control of health care of children is a fundamental right. The welfare of the child trumps any claim to rights by the parents. Parents may not ... it is better for the welfare of the child that someone step in and say the parents are wrong.

Do you use online education services?

Description : Do you use online education services?

Last Answer : I have not so far, but I’m interested in which ones are out there.

Do you value library education for your child?

Description : Do you value library education for your child?

Last Answer : When I was a kid, we had a librarian that taught us how to use the library and to me she was the most wonderful person in the world. I would get so excited just to see her. I think teachers have enough on their plate and that this should fall to the librarian.

What do you think about education?

Description : What do you think about education?

Last Answer : We’re still doing it wrong imo.

Your thoughts on religion and it's place in education?

Description : Your thoughts on religion and it's place in education?

Last Answer : Is it right that children having grown up on one faith should be essentially forced by the curriculum to learn of many faiths? I don't see anything wrong with that unless the teacher is shoving down ... religion come off as some sort of empirical fact (e.g. the nefarious teachings of creationism).

Which books are near-universally read for (non-religious) education purposes? Have you read them?

Description : Which books are near-universally read for (non-religious) education purposes? Have you read them?

Last Answer : answer:I either read or was supposed to read all of those. Mockingbird and Catcher bored me to tears so I gave up. Not really into American literature, I guess. Gatsby was OK. Other required reading included The Odyssey, The Canterbury Tales (but not The Decameron, which angered me), and 1984.

What do you think the future of U.S. education is?

Description : What do you think the future of U.S. education is?

Last Answer : Great question and one I wish I had a reliable crystal ball to answer. If my crystal ball warned me that the US would stay the course to educational failure, I'd start planning where else on ... years. Right now it's a political football neither Party seems willing to advance in any meaningful way.

I would like to know if there is a good town in New Mexico to move with jobs and a good education?

Description : I would like to know if there is a good town in New Mexico to move with jobs and a good education?

Last Answer : answer:Angelfire is near Taos and close to the Colorado border. It boasts beautiful forests and olympic class skiing in winter, but, no culture. Lots of wilderness, incredibly beautiful area. Santa Fe would ... for the Bureau of Indian affairs, but I need more greenery and live in California. :-)

Would/Does a national education/health-care system lower the quality of life?

Description : Would/Does a national education/health-care system lower the quality of life?

Last Answer : The best hospital in the world can only trat a limited number of people, but giving everyone access to education and health care raises the standards for everyone.

How were you raised to think about education?

Description : How were you raised to think about education?

Last Answer : My parents were very helpful. They taught us that it was the most important thing in the world. The house was always filled with books and my mother read to us nightly when we were young. My ... ) attend college and twelve years of private schools and tutoring made that much easier for all of us.

What can you tell me about education in Functionalism?

Description : What can you tell me about education in Functionalism?

Last Answer : Functionalists believe that the education system should be based around concensus (the theory that everything and everyone must come to an agreement Education is good in the eyes of a functionalist, because it ... it drove me mad that there was no fact about how society works (and never will)

Do you think students should get as much education as they can afford?

Description : Do you think students should get as much education as they can afford?

Last Answer : No, as much as they feel they need.

For GDP purposes, do economists classify education spending as consumption, investment, or gov't spending?

Description : For GDP purposes, do economists classify education spending as consumption, investment, or gov't spending?

Last Answer : I don't think you can make that kind of generalization, lumping public and private education together. I've only taken AP Macroeconomics so I'm certainly no expert, but I would think that publicly ... though, that's a large generalization, the types of spending would have to be further broken down.