Should WikiLeaks be closed down and the people involved be prosecuted?

Should WikiLeaks be closed down and the people involved be prosecuted?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:The patriot in me says “HELL YES” , but the web geek in me says “let’em fight a little longer”. But this is such precarious footing in terms of the security of freedoms that I honestly would need to know in-depth consequences of their disclosures to really decide.
by

Related questions

Is Wikileaks release of war documents responsible or irresponsible journalism?

Description : Is Wikileaks release of war documents responsible or irresponsible journalism?

Last Answer : answer:I think it becomes irresponsible when it actually endangers human life by (for example) revealing the identities of undercover agents or anonymous sources. As far as I understand, Wikileaks has ... in that we've reached a point of technological development where such a leak is possible.

Shouldn’t the news media be allowed to shape public opinion?

Description : Shouldn’t the news media be allowed to shape public opinion?

Last Answer : The press, in the US and elsewhere, has always been used to shape public opinion.

Should Americans empathize with Khashoggi?

Description : Should Americans empathize with Khashoggi?

Last Answer : Yes. And I can't help wondering if this is further even than Trump meant to go with his poisonous enemies of the people talk. (Nobody seems to love the media more than he does, going way ... worse crime, if you ask me, than blatant tariffs and other schemes, which can be reversed. Death cannot.

A few questions about the Donald Trump/John Miller tape.

Description : A few questions about the Donald Trump/John Miller tape.

Last Answer : answer:I didn't listen to the whole conversation. 1. The voice may or may not be Trump's. I'm no expert. 2. These are not statements made by a professional PR person. 3. Trump is ... office, the rep said that they did meet, and it was to discuss recommendations about a residential location. Story

Who can introduce me journals on marine transport and naval architecture?

Description : Who can introduce me journals on marine transport and naval architecture?

Last Answer : Your university librarian is a good person to start with

Why is it that Fox News cannot have real experts?

Description : Why is it that Fox News cannot have real experts?

Last Answer : They are all guilty of stupid.

Supposing you were a reporter, which issues would you like to investigate and cover?

Description : Supposing you were a reporter, which issues would you like to investigate and cover?

Last Answer : Science.

Which online newspaper allows you to see/read it as it is on paper, i.e page by page?

Description : Which online newspaper allows you to see/read it as it is on paper, i.e page by page?

Last Answer : The New York Times is set up like that, just like the front page. The San Francisco Chronicle has an e-edition that way too, but you have to be a regular subscriber to have access to it that way; same with the Washington Post.

How do I find a specific journalist?

Description : How do I find a specific journalist?

Last Answer : Do you have the title of the article?

Where can I find archives of Daily Herald articles?

Description : Where can I find archives of Daily Herald articles?

Last Answer : You could try your local public or university library. They usually have subscription to newspaper databases such as America’s Newspapers which can go back several decades.

Where can I read the Oliver Stone interview with the Times of London?

Description : Where can I read the Oliver Stone interview with the Times of London?

Last Answer : Their online content is by subscription only but there’s a possible, low-tech, old-fashioned solution. Call your local library and see if they have a subscription and then go there and read it.

What does this say about NBC/MSNBC?

Description : What does this say about NBC/MSNBC?

Last Answer : Ranget (note correct spelling) has already issued a formal apology to Russert.

What is the ask-public opinion on Facebook?

Description : What is the ask-public opinion on Facebook?

Last Answer : I used it for a bit and deleted my account when my sister asked to be my friend. I only had one friend on it and he lives 10 minutes away.

Does Bill O'Reilly bear any responsibility for those who commit crimes based on his hateful rhetoric?

Description : Does Bill O'Reilly bear any responsibility for those who commit crimes based on his hateful rhetoric?

Last Answer : No.

What would you like to see at E3 2009?

Description : What would you like to see at E3 2009?

Last Answer : Oooo videogames, I am a gamer and I would like demos

Do you believe everything you see on the internet?

Description : Do you believe everything you see on the internet?

Last Answer : Common sense and my beliefs.

Do you feel that journalism ethics are not adhered to by bloggers?

Description : Do you feel that journalism ethics are not adhered to by bloggers?

Last Answer : answer:i dont think so. blogs are a wonderful way to express personal thoughts and tell stories whereas journalism is supposed to be a medium serving the purpose of objective' ... higher institutional basis, whereas blog could be compared with personal megaphones just my personal appraisal.

What are the ramifications for a journalist who does not heed the "off the record" statement?

Description : What are the ramifications for a journalist who does not heed the "off the record" statement?

Last Answer : I’ve often wondered about that myself. I don’t think it’s illegal, but it’s more like a professional courtesy. And if you break that trust, you won’t likely be hearing from that person on anything you can quote.

Should Rosie O'Donnell be prosecuted?

Description : Should Rosie O'Donnell be prosecuted?

Last Answer : She could have charges brought against her. That would be fine with me. I am no fan of hers, even if we do have similar political views. This article argues that it would be a difficult case. Comedians are ... a trial would be of benefit to her. As they say, there is no such thing as bad publicity.

Cosby can't be prosecuted. So why not admit the rapes and let the whole issue go away?

Description : Cosby can't be prosecuted. So why not admit the rapes and let the whole issue go away?

Last Answer : You can not possibly believe that admitting to being a rapist would make the “issue go away”.

When will Tony Stewart be prosecuted for murder?

Description : When will Tony Stewart be prosecuted for murder?

Last Answer : I don't see how. I feel badly for him. The other driver got out of his car and walked on the track! My husband races and they are instructed not to leave their cars unless told it is safe and ... killed was a hot head too. He lost his common sense being pissed off, and put himself in grave danger.

Penn State: Why are the officials who knew and did nothing not prosecuted?

Description : Penn State: Why are the officials who knew and did nothing not prosecuted?

Last Answer : I just missed my edit time. I meant not prosecuted. I hope everyone got it from the context.

Will Anthony Bologna be prosecuted for this ?

Description : Will Anthony Bologna be prosecuted for this ?

Last Answer : answer:Your link just brings me back to this question. I don’t have enough details to issue an informed opinion at this time.

Should Harold Camping be arrested and prosecuted for his false doomsday prophesy?

Description : Should Harold Camping be arrested and prosecuted for his false doomsday prophesy?

Last Answer : answer:Freedom of religion gives him the right to say anything he chooses. It also gives people the right to choose to associate with him or not. He did not do anything illegal. (Sadly)

Should white collar crimes be prosecuted more similarly to violent crimes?

Description : Should white collar crimes be prosecuted more similarly to violent crimes?

Last Answer : I totally agree. Hello comrade. And now the right will call us anti-business.

Can a 5-year-old still be prosecuted for identity theft?

Description : Can a 5-year-old still be prosecuted for identity theft?

Last Answer : Sampson I’ll just hope that there’s one on here. Thanks. (Or any non-lawyer who knows about this law and penalties will suffice.)

Can you think of any culture in history, at any point in time, where rape was less prevalent or more aggressively prosecuted than it is in Western societies today?

Description : Can you think of any culture in history, at any point in time, where rape was less prevalent or more aggressively prosecuted than it is in Western societies today?

Last Answer : Yes. A quick search might have helped you. Death as a punishment is pretty common. As far as I’m concerned, I’m cool with that.

Why can't cyber bullies be prosecuted for slander or libel?

Description : Why can't cyber bullies be prosecuted for slander or libel?

Last Answer : answer:The cases are very different things-yelling fire in a crowded theater (when there isn't one) would serve to cause panic, and is generally illegal under something like inciting a riot or ... 's my un-informed opinion). Read up on defamation, here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defamation

If a person knows they have AIDS/HIV and they knowingly gave it to others, what do you think the punishement should be. Should they be prosecuted or not?

Description : If a person knows they have AIDS/HIV and they knowingly gave it to others, what do you think the punishement should be. Should they be prosecuted or not?

Last Answer : I’ve read about this happening quite a few times.Not sure what the punishment was though. Possibly attempted murder or something along those lines.

Why was Dr Cheever being prosecuted in the movie contagion?

Description : Why was Dr Cheever being prosecuted in the movie contagion?

Last Answer : Need answer

As per the Dowry Prohibition Act 1961, when any person is prosecuted for taking or abetting the taking of dowry then the burden of proving that he/she has not committed the offence lies with a) everyone associated with the person who is being prosecuted b) the person who is being prosecuted c) the local councillor d) the marriage registrar

Description : As per the Dowry Prohibition Act 1961, when any person is prosecuted for taking or abetting the taking of dowry then the burden of proving that he/she has not committed the offence lies with ... prosecuted b) the person who is being prosecuted c) the local councillor d) the marriage registrar 

Last Answer : b) the person who is being prosecuted  

What is your take on the latest Wikileaks dump on the CIA?

Description : What is your take on the latest Wikileaks dump on the CIA?

Last Answer : I’m glad it is being more publicized, and horrified that not only is our government doing this, but that companies are enabling them, and people aren’t complaining enough. It should be treated as the serious crime that it is.

Should Wikileaks be limited?

Description : Should Wikileaks be limited?

Last Answer : answer:No. It should not. The fewer secrets the world has the better for all and not just those elite few in power. The press MUST maintain an adversarial approach to power and we, the people, must help them do so

According to WikiLeaks Japanese authorities serially ignored warnings on security lapses in nuclear plants - Gross negligence?

Description : According to WikiLeaks Japanese authorities serially ignored warnings on security lapses in nuclear plants - Gross negligence?

Last Answer : answer:I doubt this situation is unique to these plants or to Japan. There are plants in the US that are also built near fault lines. I'm not sure outrage is the right response. There has ... these risks outweigh the benefits from using this energy source (which will run out in 100 years anyway)?

Did WikiLeaks bring us into a new era of Info Wars?

Description : Did WikiLeaks bring us into a new era of Info Wars?

Last Answer : The people behind the retaliation against the oppressors call themselves Anonymous They may say they do this for the cause, but really, they only do this for the Lulz (and to fight what they perceive ... say just this: Anonymous is Legion. They do not forgive, they do not forget. Expect them.

What are the documents released by WikiLeaks about?

Description : What are the documents released by WikiLeaks about?

Last Answer : answer:If you read the papers (I suppose this goes for most papers), there are quite some articles analysing released facts. For example, today I read something about a list being made public ... released) would be undoable, really, but it's not hard to find articles highlighting crucial documents.

Does the cutting off of service to Wikileaks by its NH service provider, EveryDNS, not go against the state's motto "Live Free Or Die" and the very core of American political philosophy?

Description : Does the cutting off of service to Wikileaks by its NH service provider, EveryDNS, not go against the state's motto "Live Free Or Die" and the very core of American political philosophy?

Last Answer : It’s unfortunate, but if you want freedom of speech for your site, you need to go elsewhere than the USA to host your site…

Is this backlash against WikiLeaks a case of killing the messenger and ignoring the message?

Description : Is this backlash against WikiLeaks a case of killing the messenger and ignoring the message?

Last Answer : answer:Yes. I predict an even larger uproar to come in the following days, when incriminating documents outlining the falsity of this recent war come out. Julian Assange will be tried as a criminal, with ... of our rights as citizens for the sake of national security. Amen. has a nice effect, no?

Do the charges against Julian Assange change your feelings about Wikileaks?

Description : Do the charges against Julian Assange change your feelings about Wikileaks?

Last Answer : answer:Considering the apparent absence of concern for the safety of any unredacted parties associated with the releases, I was already suspicious of his ethics. However, my concerns about him ... the information that it does Wikileaks prevents government impunity. Well, works against it at least.

Which of the recent Wikileaks documents are (a) most embarassing and (b) potentially very dangerous?

Description : Which of the recent Wikileaks documents are (a) most embarassing and (b) potentially very dangerous?

Last Answer : Well, regarding the Prince Andrew “revelations” it comes as no suprise. I mean the man’s a complete twat, famous for putting his royal foot in it.

In what year did WikiLeaks start its journey ?

Description : In what year did WikiLeaks start its journey ?

Last Answer : WikiLeaks started in 2006 .

What is WikiLeaks ?

Description : What is WikiLeaks ?

Last Answer : WikiLeaks is an international non-profit media organization known for publishing confidential documents. WikiLeaks CEO Julian Assange. He has sought political asylum at the Ecuadorian embassy in the United Kingdom since June 19 , 2012, for fear of arrest.

The founder of Wikileaks scam belongs to: (a) America (b) Australia (c) Austria (d) England

Description : The founder of Wikileaks scam belongs to: (a) America (b) Australia (c) Austria (d) England

Last Answer : (b) Australia

WIKILEAKS, a whistleblowers website is an international organisation based in (1) U.S.A. (2) U.K. (3) Sweden (4) Norway

Description : WIKILEAKS, a whistleblowers website is an international organisation based in (1) U.S.A. (2) U.K. (3) Sweden (4) Norway

Last Answer : U.S.A.

All a/c’s are closed down at the end of the accounting year.

Description : All a/c’s are closed down at the end of the accounting year.

Last Answer : State whether the following statement are ‘True or False’ with reason : All a/c’s are closed down at the end of the accounting year.