What would the north and south be like if the south had seceded?

What would the north and south be like if the south had seceded?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:I think this is the problem that Lincoln wrestled with when he decided that the Union had to be preserved. If you allow secession, then where does it end? Can East Tennessee secede from West Tennessee? Can Mobile secede from the rest of Alabama? Can Upstate New York secede from Manhattan and Long Island secede from both? Had secession been ‘allowed’ then it is very likely that the entire Union would have broken up into small fiefdoms along the lines of what was then Germany. MacKinlay Kantor wrote an interesting article (for Life magazine?) in the 1950s, titled “If the South Had Won the Civil War” which was so popular that he made it into a book of the same title. In the book, everything works out great, and we go on to win WW1 and 2… and then reunite (with Texas, who would have also seceded from everyone else). But I doubt very much whether we would have won the Cold War in like manner.
by

Related questions

What happened after South Carolina seceded in 1860?

Description : What happened after South Carolina seceded in 1860?

Last Answer : It was first joined by states in the Deep South.

What do you think life would be like in the western hemisphere (North and South America) if it had never been invaded by the European colonial powers?

Description : What do you think life would be like in the western hemisphere (North and South America) if it had never been invaded by the European colonial powers?

Last Answer : answer:You mean if the Europeans had not come here at all and brought disease and alcohol? It might be a very interesting place. I do have a slight cavil with your premise. The term “native” Americans is not accurate. They were simply an earlier migration over the Asian land bridge.

Why is there a North AND South Carolina?

Description : Why is there a North AND South Carolina?

Last Answer : I don’t know, why is there a North and South Dakota? Or, Virginia and West Virginia? They are just names. But you can find the history behind the names here.

What simple terms described the opposing sides (communist countries and democratic countries) in the Cold War? East/West or North/South?

Description : What simple terms described the opposing sides (communist countries and democratic countries) in the Cold War? East/West or North/South?

Last Answer : East/West

If the Confederate States seceded from the US during the 1860's and became a sovereign nation, would they have become an ally of Nazi Germany during WW2?

Description : If the Confederate States seceded from the US during the 1860's and became a sovereign nation, would they have become an ally of Nazi Germany during WW2?

Last Answer : They would’ve remained neutral, but why wouldn’t they be on their side? They were in the business of preserving our lord and saviors master race and obtaining more lebensraum for them. Lol.

Which state seceded from Virginia in 1863?

Description : Which state seceded from Virginia in 1863?

Last Answer : West Virginia

Why Texas seceded from union?

Description : Why Texas seceded from union?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

What was North Korea like before Kim Jong Sung took power?

Description : What was North Korea like before Kim Jong Sung took power?

Last Answer : answer:I'm not sure which one you mean. The three names are Kim Il-sung (installed in 1948) Kim Jong-il (succeeded in 1994) Kim Jong-un (succeeded in 2012) There are variants on the ... came to power when Korea was divided into North and South in 1948 and he became the leader of North Korea.

Why did we steal North Dakota from the Native Americans?

Description : Why did we steal North Dakota from the Native Americans?

Last Answer : We did a lot more to them than just that…

The 16th-century North African Corsair Kheir-ed-Din was better known as: Barbarossa, Saladin, or Blackbeard?

Description : The 16th-century North African Corsair Kheir-ed-Din was better known as: Barbarossa, Saladin, or Blackbeard?

Last Answer : Barbarossa

If the South won the American Civil War, would slavery over time end up abolished in the US?

Description : If the South won the American Civil War, would slavery over time end up abolished in the US?

Last Answer : Computers are the new slaves. When we get true artificial intelligence then we will have another civil war for computer rights. Yes I think slavery would have eventually be abolished or moved onto another group ie computers.

Who dominated the South regions of Italy? a. Popeb. Bourbon Kings of Spain c. Austrian Habsburgs c. Bourbon Kings of France

Description : Who dominated the South regions of Italy? a. Popeb. Bourbon Kings of Spain c. Austrian Habsburgs c. Bourbon Kings of France

Last Answer : b. Bourbon Kings of Spain

What do you think the world would look like today if the Confederacy had won the US Civil War?

Description : What do you think the world would look like today if the Confederacy had won the US Civil War?

Last Answer : answer:Counterfactuals, whee! Well, that would have been a victory for the plantation economy over the industrial economy And decentralized government over a federal system. Which means that ... economic system Which means that 20th century world history would likely have been completely different.

8. Suppose you had the power to inscribe your orders, what four commands would you like to issue? -History

Description : 8. Suppose you had the power to inscribe your orders, what four commands would you like to issue? -History

Last Answer : I would like to issue the following four orders: Everyone should respect the elders and elders should love their youngers. Everyone should respect the other's religion. One should try to understand ... religion and respect it. Be kind to your servants and employees. Be loyal to your motherland.

7. If you had a natural pebble-like the ones shown on page 13 in the textbook, what would you use it for? -History

Description : 7. If you had a natural pebble-like the ones shown on page 13 in the textbook, what would you use it for? -History

Last Answer : I would have used some of these stone tools to cut meat and bone, scrape bark (from trees) and hides (animal skins), chop fruit, and roots. Some may have been attached to handles of bone or ... make spears and arrows for hunting. Other stone tools were used to chop wood, which was used as firewood,

Where do you think we'd be if the Civil War had never been fought?

Description : Where do you think we'd be if the Civil War had never been fought?

Last Answer : The Northern States would have been the United States of America, while the Southern states would have been independent states, like individual countries. Slavery would have ended by about 1900 (1920, at the ... point a Black man/woman would have been elected in the north, that much can be said.

Has the USA ever had a monarch on their currency?

Description : Has the USA ever had a monarch on their currency?

Last Answer : No.

If Tadeusz Cosciuszko had not returned to Poland after the war, but rather stayed to establish the states, might he have been the first U.S. President?

Description : If Tadeusz Cosciuszko had not returned to Poland after the war, but rather stayed to establish the states, might he have been the first U.S. President?

Last Answer : There is no disputing his intelligence or bravery, but he was foreign born (Lithuania) and wouldn’t qualify. Same problem Alexander Hamilton had.

What are the effects that imperialism had on their ruling nations and subject populations?

Description : What are the effects that imperialism had on their ruling nations and subject populations?

Last Answer : answer:For ruling nations -Strong sense of Nationalism -Vast increase to natural resources and production -Military nation mentality Subject Nations - Defeated nation mentality -Loss of natural resources, production ... are you referring too? The Nazis or the Prussians, the Soviets or the Czar?

Is it possible to see who had your social security number in the past?

Description : Is it possible to see who had your social security number in the past?

Last Answer : Social Security numbers are not recycled. Therefore, you can’t see who had it before. http://www.ssa.gov/history/hfaq.html

Was there any slavery in Europe around the same time we had in America?

Description : Was there any slavery in Europe around the same time we had in America?

Last Answer : Yes there was. Basically all the major European powers of the early colonial era practiced slavery. But it was outlawed and ended there far earlier (late 1700’s early 1800’s).

What might have been different had Adam eaten the forbidden fruit first?

Description : What might have been different had Adam eaten the forbidden fruit first?

Last Answer : Boys would be making $.74 for every one of my dollars. And I'd hit them back for it by tucking them into their g-strings because their mommies didn't hug them enough. I'd get to wear the ... probably never think about it. Until I got to college and took some bullshit men's studies course.~ ;)

Which of these historical events/periods would you eliminate from humanity's existence (if you had the power to modify the outcome)?

Description : Which of these historical events/periods would you eliminate from humanity's existence (if you had the power to modify the outcome)?

Last Answer : where’s “the founding of christianity” ? that’s what i would erase, well actually, any religion for that matter

If you had one opportunity to time travel, would you rather experience the future or the past?

Description : If you had one opportunity to time travel, would you rather experience the future or the past?

Last Answer : The future.

Have you ever had a dream or feeling that you were someone or something else in a previous life?

Description : Have you ever had a dream or feeling that you were someone or something else in a previous life?

Last Answer : creepy…

If you had to pick a different time period, what would you choose and why?

Description : If you had to pick a different time period, what would you choose and why?

Last Answer : Roaring Twenties The Beatnik Era The late 80s

What were the different reasons people had for not sending girls to school? -History

Description : What were the different reasons people had for not sending girls to school? -History

Last Answer : Vidyasagar in Calcutta (now Kolkata) and many other reformers in Bombay. (now Mumbai) set up schools for girls. When the first schools were opened in the mid-nineteenth century, many people ... reach school. This would have a corrupting influence on them. GMs should stay away from public spaces.

Why did Mahatma Gandhi think that English education had enslaved Indians? -History

Description : Why did Mahatma Gandhi think that English education had enslaved Indians? -History

Last Answer : According to Mahatma Gandhi, colonial education created a sense of inferiority in the minds of Indians. He said it made them see Western civilisation as superior which destroyed the pride they had in ... to work with their hands and learn a craft. They should know how different things operated.

During the 1830s, had sought to put together a coherent programme for a unitary Italian Republic. a. Giuseppe Garibaldi b. Giuseppe Mazzini c. Victor Emanuel II d. Cavour

Description : During the 1830s, had sought to put together a coherent programme for a unitary Italian Republic. a. Giuseppe Garibaldi b. Giuseppe Mazzini c. Victor Emanuel II d. Cavour

Last Answer : b. Giuseppe Mazzini

The nationalist in Greece got the support of the West European nations because: a) They were fighting against the Muslim Ottoman Empire b) They had sympathies for ancient Greek culture c) Greece was considered the cradle of European civilisation d) All the above

Description : The nationalist in Greece got the support of the West European nations because: a) They were fighting against the Muslim Ottoman Empire b) They had sympathies for ancient Greek culture c) Greece was considered the cradle of European civilisation d) All the above

Last Answer : b) They had sympathies for ancient Greek culture

Most castles had a small private chapel beside the ****’s chambers. True or False?

Description : Most castles had a small private chapel beside the lord’s chambers. True or False?

Last Answer : True

Which king of England had to fight a civil war against his cousin Matilda?

Description : Which king of England had to fight a civil war against his cousin Matilda?

Last Answer : Stephen

Which Battle of Britain fighter had the same name as a type of storm?

Description : Which Battle of Britain fighter had the same name as a type of storm?

Last Answer : Hurricane

Dynamite is a tool that can be used to cut down trees. To cut a tree 18 inches in diameter requires five sticks of dynamite: one on the north, south, east and west sides of the tree, and the fifth stick on the side to which the tree should fall. During construction of a dam, a tree 18 inches in diameter was completely covered by water. Since the treetop was fouling the boat's propellers, it had to be cut down. A diver went down and put a stick of dynamite on the four sides of the tree. Since the current is flowing south at 2 knots per hour, on which side of the tree would you instruct the diver to put the fifth stick of dynamite if you wanted the tree to fall north? -Riddles

Description : Dynamite is a tool that can be used to cut down trees. To cut a tree 18 inches in diameter requires five sticks of dynamite: one on the north, south, east and west sides of the tree, and the ... you instruct the diver to put the fifth stick of dynamite if you wanted the tree to fall north? -Riddles

Last Answer : It doesn't matter where the fifth stick is placed, since the tree won't fall in any direction. Being wood, it will float and rise to the surface.

When did north America and south America that had gained independence by 1823?

Description : When did north America and south America that had gained independence by 1823?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

In the events leading up to Hitler and Nazi Germany, were there groups like the KKK and neoNazis already stirring?

Description : In the events leading up to Hitler and Nazi Germany, were there groups like the KKK and neoNazis already stirring?

Last Answer : There was a large anti semitic movement, a eugenics movement in the sciences, intolerance to gays, zenophobia plus other factors. What I read pretty much painted a picture where Hitler was heavily ... are all players now when in that time many were legitimately ignorant of the unfolding situation.

Why are many mailboxes shaped like arches?

Description : Why are many mailboxes shaped like arches?

Last Answer : I think it makes sense. Ease of construction. A sloping roof to let water roll down. A flat bottom to lay letters.

Older Fluther folks, can you let me know what a good economy was like?

Description : Older Fluther folks, can you let me know what a good economy was like?

Last Answer : McDonalds Burgers 29 cents, Macs popsicle 29 cents, Domo Gas 29.9, gold $290/ounce, 10% interest on bank accounts, college $3000 per year. Easy mortgage’s. All in the 80’s in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. Also $8 a barrel west Texas Crude Oil.

We all know we are in a mild depression. Do you anticipate that America will revive again like after the great depression?

Description : We all know we are in a mild depression. Do you anticipate that America will revive again like after the great depression?

Last Answer : answer:I sure hope that things will turn around. After all, my well being still largely hinges on the economy recovering. That said, I do not see much reason for optimism. I see the situation facing the ... US hegemony if it fails. We will see if the world will need to suffer another Dark Age first.

Do you like to go over past questions and answers?

Description : Do you like to go over past questions and answers?

Last Answer : Sometimes I'll see that someone has lurved an old answer that I don't even remember giving, so I'll go back and read it out of curiosity. That's about the extent of it. The only benefit I ... I say here sticks around for a long time. Sure makes me more careful about clicking that Answer button.

I've always wondered about this: How do Germans today feel about their past? Is it awkward and not talked about like some things in America?

Description : I've always wondered about this: How do Germans today feel about their past? Is it awkward and not talked about like some things in America?

Last Answer : My S/O is a German native, came here when she was 2 with her family. Her mother would talk a little about the experiences they had during the war, but little else. One of my clients from my ... tank battles but nothing else. If you asked questions they'd change the subject and I didn't push it.

Would you like to share the history of your house with us?

Description : Would you like to share the history of your house with us?

Last Answer : The house I live in is newer, so it doesn’t have a huge history behind it. It was built after I was born.

Americans, if we decided to build something again, like we used to, what Big Thing would we do?

Description : Americans, if we decided to build something again, like we used to, what Big Thing would we do?

Last Answer : Rebuild Detroit around more than one product!

Where would you like your remains to remain?

Description : Where would you like your remains to remain?

Last Answer : I’d like to be cremated and scattered in the lava flow from Kilauea Volcano and in the sea.

What was the Congo like before colonization?

Description : What was the Congo like before colonization?

Last Answer : Other than an undeveloped jungle, it was part of the Arab slave trade network for about 700 years. The infrastructure of blacks selling blacks was so well developed in the Congo, that the Europeans simply took it over and continued it after the Arabs left.

Do you think anything like Woodstock or the 1963 march on Washington will ever happen again?

Description : Do you think anything like Woodstock or the 1963 march on Washington will ever happen again?

Last Answer : Don’t miss the next big event in history while looking for old ones.

Is there an historical precedent for groups like al Qaeda?

Description : Is there an historical precedent for groups like al Qaeda?

Last Answer : Well terrorist groups span centuries. The earliest group who were well known as being terrorists would have to be the Jacobians who were at the heart of the French Revolution, they would use terror ... extreme they sound, the more coverage they get and the more people are effected by their message.

If you were in your late teens or early twenties during the Carter recession, what was it like for you?

Description : If you were in your late teens or early twenties during the Carter recession, what was it like for you?

Last Answer : I remember people standing in line for a job at McDonald’s. Then I moved to California (looking for work) and there were job applications on the place-mats in McDonald’s. I guess California recovered a lot faster than Oregon.

Do you ever feel like some, if they have the luxury of it, use barbaric history as an excuse not to do what they can to minimize present-day injustice?

Description : Do you ever feel like some, if they have the luxury of it, use barbaric history as an excuse not to do what they can to minimize present-day injustice?

Last Answer : Ahh but oppression still exists today. And even though they may not face the exact injustice they still face the effects of it. And by denying that you are contributing to said oppression. ... more discussion. However I believe the answer above will cover most examples of this type of behavior.