Do you decide a question is Great based on solely on the question, or on question + details?

Do you decide a question is Great based on solely on the question, or on question + details?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

Do unto others..so, yes.
by

Related questions

Is human knowledge (science, math, etc) dependent solely on human perception or can we claim certainty in certain areas?

Description : Is human knowledge (science, math, etc) dependent solely on human perception or can we claim certainty in certain areas?

Last Answer : We can’t know anything for certain. But that does not give us reason to believe things outside of our current understanding.

Why do you answer a question without reading the details and responses from the OP?

Description : Why do you answer a question without reading the details and responses from the OP?

Last Answer : answer:Why do you answer a question without reading the details and responses from the OP? Sometimes I don't, because I think the questions are too obvious to read further details. It's painfully ... Are you really curious? Or have someone here pissed you off because they didn't read your details?

Stupid question: Can anyone explain these contradictions (details inside)

Description : Stupid question: Can anyone explain these contradictions (details inside)

Last Answer : answer:It's not a contradiction, it's an alternative reality. Books are often a way to escape or to explore other ways of living or other choices. No one (that I know of) is really a ... reading Harry Potter. It's because we can let our imaginations fly into a different world with different rules.

Stupid relationship question: what should I do now (extremely long details inside)

Description : Stupid relationship question: what should I do now (extremely long details inside)

Last Answer : A seems to be a “user” and she’ll take advantage of you as long as you let her. Who controls your life, her or you?

I have a question from my brother. [Details inside]?

Description : I have a question from my brother. [Details inside]?

Last Answer : I can't speak for women not being one.. but I've always been a fan of the classics. There's no need to write something in the sky or propose at midcourt of an nba game if it's the right ... to a romantic spot that they can remember forever, get on one knee, and tell her what she means to him.

If I asked “Alaska?” as a fluther question, and offered no supporting details, what would you answer?

Description : If I asked “Alaska?” as a fluther question, and offered no supporting details, what would you answer?

Last Answer : Baked or fried?

Why do some people feel the need to piss all over a question when they aren't actually answering the question (examples in details)?

Description : Why do some people feel the need to piss all over a question when they aren't actually answering the question (examples in details)?

Last Answer : I never got that, either. That’s why most of my Qs are in General, and why I can’t ask some light-hearted ones that I would like to because they’d be moved to Social. I guess some people never master the art of simply not clicking…

How carefully do you read the details of a question?

Description : How carefully do you read the details of a question?

Last Answer : I do read the detalis as well as fill in the details pretty well when asking questions.

Is this a Great Question?

Description : Is this a Great Question?

Last Answer : I always looked upon it as more of a grand question. Grand in its grandiosity.

Why is it that, a reasonable question will get zero, or maybe one, great question award, but the answers will get multiple great answer awards?

Description : Why is it that, a reasonable question will get zero, or maybe one, great question award, but the answers will get multiple great answer awards?

Last Answer : Fluddies. Fluther buddies hi-fiving each other.

Great Question versus Flag; other possible options and variations?

Description : Great Question versus Flag; other possible options and variations?

Last Answer : I suggested this on the Suggestions thread, but here it goes again: On Ravelry, instead of just Great Answer (or Question ), there are other ways to show lurve : Educational , Interesting , ... akin to this would be an excellent path for Fluther to take-and a great way to achieve new awards.

What makes a test question great?

Description : What makes a test question great?

Last Answer : Keep it simple. Test questions are generally very to the point and direct. It should be relatively easy for people that have been doing the coursework. Essay questions are great because it ... If someone is trying to BS their way through an essay question, it becomes apparently very quickly.

Do you think Fluther should have a "Not Great Answer" and/or a "Not Great Question" button?

Description : Do you think Fluther should have a "Not Great Answer" and/or a "Not Great Question" button?

Last Answer : no

Based solely on looks, how would you rank the various iterations of the Enterprise?

Description : Based solely on looks, how would you rank the various iterations of the Enterprise?

Last Answer : The USS Enterprise?

What video entertainment do you find yourself watching solely based on a crush for one of the actors/actresses on the show?

Description : What video entertainment do you find yourself watching solely based on a crush for one of the actors/actresses on the show?

Last Answer : I used to watch every move Kevin Costner was in because I crushed on him. But I got bored with his movies and I guess with him, so I stopped watching his movies.

Have you ever made a decision based solely on your emotions, and if so, how did it turn out?

Description : Have you ever made a decision based solely on your emotions, and if so, how did it turn out?

Last Answer : answer:That’s how I make most of my romantic decisions… without any rationality or reason, only pure emotion. It gets me in trouble nearly always, but it gives me plenty to write about.

If you had to book a Superbowm halftime show based solely on your music taste, what would it be?

Description : If you had to book a Superbowm halftime show based solely on your music taste, what would it be?

Last Answer : A lot of ska or Tyler the creator

When describing Organizational Culture, some Mgt Thinkers use expressions such as ------- “ the way things are around here”. In relation to this statement, which of the following is the most urgent task of Strategists ? A. To build a future based solely on the existing culture B. To investigate the taken-for-granted aspects of the culture C. To make changes in Control Systems so that the culture changes D. To make structural changes so that the culture changes

Description : When describing Organizational Culture, some Mgt Thinkers use expressions such as ------- the way things are around here . In relation to this statement, which of the following is the ... in Control Systems so that the culture changes D. To make structural changes so that the culture changes

Last Answer : To investigate the taken-for-granted aspects of the culture

Ageism refers to a) Bias against older people based solely on chronological age Individuals demonstrating ageism base their beliefs and attitudes about older people based upon chronological age without consideration of functional capacity. b) fear of old age. Fear of aging and the inability of many to confront their own aging process may trigger ageist beliefs. c) loss of memory. Age-related loss of memory occurs more with short-term and recent memory. d) benign senescent forgetfulness. Benign senescent forgetfulness refers to the age-related loss of memory in the absence of a pathologic process.

Description : Ageism refers to a) Bias against older people based solely on chronological age Individuals demonstrating ageism base their beliefs and attitudes about older people based upon chronological age without consideration ... refers to the age-related loss of memory in the absence of a pathologic process.

Last Answer : a) Bias against older people based solely on chronological age Individuals demonstrating ageism base their beliefs and attitudes about older people based upon chronological age without consideration of functional capacity.

BEE star rating is solely based on appliance's power .................. A) Consumption. C) Delivery. B) Recovery. D) Rejection.

Description : BEE star rating is solely based on appliance's power .................. A) Consumption. C) Delivery. B) Recovery. D) Rejection.

Last Answer : Consumption.

Which of the following is a strength of the divisional structure? (a) It focuses on results ; (b) It gains advantages due to work specialization (c) Employees have more than one boss ; (d) It is based solely on teams

Description : Which of the following is a strength of the divisional structure? (a) It focuses on results ; (b) It gains advantages due to work specialization (c) Employees have more than one boss ; (d) It is based solely on teams

Last Answer : (a) It focuses on results ; 

Which of the following is a feature of progressive education? Options: A) Instruction based solely on prescribed textbooks B) Emphasis on scoring good marks in examinations C) Frequent tests and examinations D) Flexible timetable and seating arrangement

Description : Which of the following is a feature of progressive education? Options: A) Instruction based solely on prescribed textbooks B) Emphasis on scoring good marks in examinations C) Frequent tests and examinations D) Flexible timetable and seating arrangement

Last Answer : C) Frequent tests and examinations 

Was he really joking, or was his intention beyond that (long details inside, sorry)

Description : Was he really joking, or was his intention beyond that (long details inside, sorry)

Last Answer : They were standing together exchanging love talk like usual. Suddenly the boyfriend asked me if I felt left out (that is just a literal translation, he actually used a specific word that could either ... wheel? Which is very possible when they are lovey-dovey and you are on the side observing.

How can I do a purchase safely on Ebay (details inside)?

Description : How can I do a purchase safely on Ebay (details inside)?

Last Answer : answer:Not sure, @Mimishu1995. I usually use PayPal and semi-trust them but you seem to indicate this is not an option. You might try contacting PP or EBay direct and find out why they do not offer such services in your country.

Given Murphy's Law, "Anything that can go wrong, will." Can you come up with your own law of the universe? [Details]?

Description : Given Murphy's Law, "Anything that can go wrong, will." Can you come up with your own law of the universe? [Details]?

Last Answer : answer:That isn't trying on to me. That's putting on. I try on more when I'm overweight. JL's law: Your weight directly impacts your need to try on multiple outfits before going out for the ... don't get washed by themselves. Actually, I think someone said that before me. I hate washing dishes.

Is it okay to ask potential employers if they have any questions for you? (Please see details)

Description : Is it okay to ask potential employers if they have any questions for you? (Please see details)

Last Answer : Overconfident? Not at all.. It’s a great idea.

{Details inside} So... Where do I go from here?

Description : {Details inside} So... Where do I go from here?

Last Answer : answer:My daughter's former long-term boy friend has MS. That might be a possibility because there are many variations of symptoms manifested in different people. But this is just a wild guess. Under ... sorry you are going through both the physical mysery and the ongoing anxiety. It ain't fun.

[Details inside] Can you give me some advice for this sticky situation?

Description : [Details inside] Can you give me some advice for this sticky situation?

Last Answer : answer:No. You're not over-reacting if people are being told to not have girls interact with him. Tell your parents what is happening, and they might be able to contact the administrators for the ... there are official warnings being given, then there is a reason for them. Better safe than sorry.

How to solve this trigonometric mathematic function? (Details inside)

Description : How to solve this trigonometric mathematic function? (Details inside)

Last Answer : answer:According to this wiki article, subtracting two arcsines can be rewritten as the arcsine of the first number times the square root of 1 minus the second number squared, minus the second number times the square root ... sqrt(1-b^2) - b*sqrt(1-a^2)) Does that point you in the right direction?

Would you rather eat a shot of live wasps or eat the shot glass? [Read details.]?

Description : Would you rather eat a shot of live wasps or eat the shot glass? [Read details.]?

Last Answer : Well….....if the choices suck, we can’t help if we don’t like either.

Should I be angry and freaked out? Or should I shut up? (please see details)

Description : Should I be angry and freaked out? Or should I shut up? (please see details)

Last Answer : Sounds very intrusive. Ask him about it when your sister is present

I've been having dreams of two dogs what do they mean? (details inside on them).

Description : I've been having dreams of two dogs what do they mean? (details inside on them).

Last Answer : I THINK that your just really touched by the death of one of them and your brains unconciously thinking about it.maybe even about how the other one died.

Are my Questions confusing, thought-provoking or just downright nonsense (See details)

Description : Are my Questions confusing, thought-provoking or just downright nonsense (See details)

Last Answer : I usually find it helpful to have the question in the “question” part and then add details in the “details” part. If the two don’t match then I stop reading.

How do you read questions and details here on ask-public?

Description : How do you read questions and details here on ask-public?

Last Answer : answer:I try to be very thorough, both in the reading and writing of questions and their details. While reading, I pay more attention to the details than the title, as they often don't necessarily agree with each ... also trying not to write a book. I did move your question to Meta, by the way. :)

How long should questions, details, (Oxford comma) and answers be?

Description : How long should questions, details, (Oxford comma) and answers be?

Last Answer : I don’t mind if a question or answer is long as long as it’s readable. Breaks and paragraphs are nice and readable. When someone just writes on and on in one big block then I give up.

Are you annoyed when answers given in a topic seems like no one read the details?

Description : Are you annoyed when answers given in a topic seems like no one read the details?

Last Answer : AY Laddie! And no.

If a person belongs to a small family branch of a famous person, can they rightfully claim to be the great-grandchild of that famous person?

Description : If a person belongs to a small family branch of a famous person, can they rightfully claim to be the great-grandchild of that famous person?

Last Answer : Sure, although it may not matter much, ya know, “10 degrees of separation”, or however it goes… I am the great great great great grand nephew of the commanding confederate general who was killed at Shiloh. But I don’t brag about it…

Will our grandkids, great grandkids, etc. stalk our social media someday?

Description : Will our grandkids, great grandkids, etc. stalk our social media someday?

Last Answer : Absolutely. I inherited both my grandmothers' book collections and find it fascinating to read their margin notes. Old letters are another gold mine, but I don't have many of those, unfortunately. ... some) descendants and will be far more numerous thanks to the easier saveability of digital info.

Do you check out the status table on the right and peek at other ask-publiconians Great Questions?

Description : Do you check out the status table on the right and peek at other ask-publiconians Great Questions?

Last Answer : answer:It's basically how I ask-public. I initially objected to the whole lurve, awards, feed thing - it was distracting for me - both physically (vision-wise) and mentally; now I just go with the flow ... check out the GQ's and usually find about 7 of 10 would have been of interest to me anyway.

What would be some great questions to ask an elderly?

Description : What would be some great questions to ask an elderly?

Last Answer : An elderly what? Cat? Dog? Person?

Is the 3-questions limit based on an absolute 24 hours, or a day determined by 12 AM-11:59 PM?

Description : Is the 3-questions limit based on an absolute 24 hours, or a day determined by 12 AM-11:59 PM?

Last Answer : Logically speaking I’d say yes you can ask again a minute later. As it says you can ask three a day, not three every 24 hours.

Could you compose an orphan question on Fluther?

Description : Could you compose an orphan question on Fluther?

Last Answer : Provided that you won’t come and answer :D

If a question turns into a human being, what kind of a person he or she would be?

Description : If a question turns into a human being, what kind of a person he or she would be?

Last Answer : He would be a faceless, paranoid, conspiracy theorist.

Ever spend hours crafting a response only to have the question pulled?

Description : Ever spend hours crafting a response only to have the question pulled?

Last Answer : Yup. I’ve even written out long answers only to realize that I needed to pull the question. If you’d like, I can send you the text of your answer and you can post it here. I’m sure many people would be grateful for your… “advice.”

Can I ask a question in a foreign language?

Description : Can I ask a question in a foreign language?

Last Answer : No. You may put the information in the other language in the details.

What is the best way to get extra clarification on a question, when you feel like you can't give a thoughtful answer without more information from an OP?

Description : What is the best way to get extra clarification on a question, when you feel like you can't give a thoughtful answer without more information from an OP?

Last Answer : You can only lead a horse to water…

Assuming they answer honestly, what is the single most telling question you can ask a person?

Description : Assuming they answer honestly, what is the single most telling question you can ask a person?

Last Answer : If they are from the US: How much do you tip?

What happened to the question about yesterday's terrorist attack in Britain?

Description : What happened to the question about yesterday's terrorist attack in Britain?

Last Answer : I see two questions related to it in Social, was there another one? Hard to believe one would be taken down for subject.

Do you think there should be dislike button for a question?

Description : Do you think there should be dislike button for a question?

Last Answer : The problem is, the dislike button will be abused quickly. It's much easier to dislike than like. People will dislike a question out of personal feeling toward the OP, and things get ugly quickly. ... a small amount of likes than let them know there are several dislike next to their little likes.

Are your question asking fields hard to edit?

Description : Are your question asking fields hard to edit?

Last Answer : answer:I have a different problem with the title question field. When I'm creating a question, it is blank until I actually hit the final place where it posts the question. I've never brought it up, ... enough problem. I've honestly never typed more than it would hold. You've given me a challenge.