How do we deal with everything being immoral?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:You can’t separate morality from intentionality. Morality isn’t concerned so much with the actual consequences of an action as with the intentions of the actor. This is why we hold someone who plots an act of terror to be immoral even if the attack is thwarted; and why we judge people who unintentionally cause an accident not to be morally culpable. So the measure of immorality isn’t harm, but the intention to cause harm. Harm is difficult to define in absolute terms. On the grand scale of the universe, there is just the constant churn of change, none of it problematic. Things are just as they are. Zoom in on a local level, though, and you find that change is disruptive. insofar as the well-being of some beings is invested in things being a certain way, then messing with that state of affairs will cause suffering; you now have harm. From an absolute perspective, you could say that we all just need to accept that everything changes, that there’s no state of affairs that one can pin one’s well-being to without having that pulled out from under you at some point, so everyone just needs to go with the flow. Maybe it’s true that if all beings could do this, we’d find that there’s no more suffering, and so no more harm. Just the churn of change. But we live our lives on a local level, where the relative matters as much as the absolute. It’s at this relative level that morality comes into play. Our lives are shaped by our human mind, which has the peculiarity of being attuned to what others feel. It resonates with other minds. On some level, it suffers when others suffer, and is happy when others are happy. Metaphorically, we’re all swimming in the same pool of feeling. If we required of each other that nobody do anything that might potentially cause a disruptive change that will negatively impact some being down the road, we would indeed be paralyzed. But that’s not what we ask. Instead, we seek a balance between the absolute and the relative. We accept that change is inevitable, and that no one can always have things as they like. But we also demand that each person, to the best of their ability, make a good-faith effort to be a good citizen of this common pool of feeling. You can justify anything if you see your actions as “Shiva, the Destroyer and Creator”, but that errs in the direction of the absolute. Or you can get so bogged down in the knowledge that you can’t do anything without impacting another being that you cannot act at all; but that is to err in the direction of the relative. Instead we have to thread a path that allows us to function as healthy beings, while giving as much consideration as possible to the well-being of others. It’s not always easy to know how to do that.

Related questions

Description : When it comes to “questioning everything” are all topics fair game?

Last Answer : All topics are fair game.

Description : Is everything subjective?

Last Answer : Who says that? There are still objective things out there like the law of nature.

Description : Is it better to know everything or stay ignorant about some things?

Last Answer : answer:You would know what you need to know, when you need to know. Trying to know only the sake of knowing is a vain pursuit anyway. When you are faced with something and you need an answer, it will be right there.

Description : Do you believe that everything happens for a reason?

Last Answer : I would disagree, most things happen for a reason because someone or something is behind it purposefully trying to get some sort of result out of it. But many things occur that were outside the awareness of all the individuals involved, which would be coincidence.

Description : Regarding the "meaning of life" and humanity's self worth, what is the difference between being in a universe created by a god, and a universe created as a computer simulation by an alien race?

Last Answer : Does it matter? If there is a god creating a universe, who is to say that the god is not, in fact, the product of a computer simulation? There's no way to tell if this god has godlike characteristics ... a software glitch? I wou;dn't, but I'm not sure it matters. How would it change my life?

Description : On a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being "complete BS" and 10 being "divine wisdom", how would you rate the following statement?

Last Answer : 42

Description : Would you live your life being born original but dying a copy?

Last Answer : In giving up your individuality you actually gain it and you will be established forever.

Description : If actions are far from being actually done, will words be enough to "speak" for you?

Last Answer : I can think of many people who cannot move, and yet they still manage to communicate. You can still tell if a tiny infant is content or not, simply by their attitude. Communication is still possible. However, in the case of a person in a coma, you’re probably right.

Description : How far does being "open-minded" go?

Last Answer : I don't think there's a need to commit to their way of thinking in order to be open minded. I'm more than happy to use the assuming that's true tactic if I can't agree with what someone's ... refuse to accept any propositions on your part well I just get tired, and that's how far it goes with me.

Description : Do we need more sins? Is seven enough?

Last Answer : Your president has six of the seven deadly sins with the possible exception of envy. This tally doesn't do justice to the huge injury he is doing to his country and its reputation or to the psychic damage he is ... of him and his family in the White House. I'm stuck. I cannot put a name to it.

Description : Do you think that we encounter 'bad' people in our lives?

Last Answer : answer:I think people may be bad for us for whatever reason - they're opportunists, they're addicts, they're users, whatever, a variety of reasons. If you can realize that and keep a distance, it will ... bad for you, for whatever reason, realizing that is enough for you to cut the ties and move on.

Description : How should we go with judging someone?

Last Answer : I think we all judge in some ways. You did it. You said they had to be a non-believer and lover of art. It’s just something I try to be aware of so I don’t do it too much.

Description : Don't you think that we are all one?

Last Answer : Yes, all life forms sprang from the same source of life giving components. Some organisms evolved into humans, others mammals, plant life, sea life, etc. We are all one, meaning that every ... the roulette wheel of evolution and we could just as easily manifested as a watermelon or an earthworm.

Description : How slow can we make a beam or photon of light go?

Last Answer : Over 10 years ago a research team at Harvard slowed a beam of light down to 38 mph, (61 km/h). Physicists Slow Speed of Light I’m sure they’ve gone even slower since that time.

Description : Why does time "speed up" as we age?

Last Answer : answer:There are several reasons. When we are older we are more aware of what is planned in the future. We have a doctor's appointment next month, or a vacation planned in two months from now, or our ... a blur, but during those years I felt almost every minute of the day as the minutes went by.

Description : What might we define as the Tao of Physics?

Last Answer : answer:I was actually discussing this with someone recently (maybe @thorninmud).? My brain is fuzzy from a headache right now but I think I was relating it to T.S. Eliot as well and the idea of something ... the crowned knot of fire And the fire and the rose are one. T.S. Elito, Little Gidding

Description : Do you think we are all seperate beings operating in a vacuum, or are we all one, or is it something in between?

Last Answer : Well we weem to be individual specks of awareness with the potential to connect & exchange info, so the connections have to be made, they don’t seem to just be there. It is hard to say what we are in this respect…

Description : When should we disregard explanations that are intuitively appealing?

Last Answer : When they get in the way of explanations that are even more intuitively appealing.

Description : If our physical appearance never changed past a certain age, yet we continued to age normally, how would this visual perception effect the world? or you?

Last Answer : People would be surprised when you dropped dead of old age or behaved in a senile fashion. Besides, with enough plastic surgery your fantasy is real today.

Description : Why do we need more people here on planet earth?

Last Answer : I’d prefer that women (couples) limit themselves to 2 or fewer children to allow for ZPG (zero population growth. Particularly in the developed countries with low child mortality.

Description : What if we are really alone in the Universe?

Last Answer : Since that is the premise that I have been living under lo these many years, nothing would change.

Description : How can we fundementally understand how the world truly works and can we handle it?

Last Answer : Read Heidegger’s Being and Time. Most people can handle it.

Description : A "to what extent do we control our own destiny" type question.

Last Answer : We are responsible insofar as we do not examine history, and insofar as we acquiesce. These methods you speak of are far from secret. Dwight Eisenhower's last gift to America was to warn about the Military ... now. (Blue Dogs are called dogs because they roll over for Big Pharma and Big Medical.)

Description : Are we, who we think, that our friends think, that we think, that we are?

Last Answer : We are ourselves. How someone else sees you is true to them. It is their perception of you and all they will know. How you see yourself is who you are. How your friend sees you is who ... knows your experiences, or your motivations better than you. Nobody has the right to judge your life but you

Description : Are we living in an age of irony?

Last Answer : It's hard to judge an age from the present. Did the renaissance artists in the 14th Century call themselves renaissance artists? No, that came later. Our present age, if it is indeed the ... 300 years earlier thanks, Dark Ages, for nothing things would be very interesting indeed. Good Question.

Description : If time itself was an element of existance (and not independant of it), and the manipulation of time was possible, wouldn't it also mean that we have always been the slaves to destiny?

Last Answer : Either im too stupid to anwser the question or it requires more explanation. But ill give it a shot anyway as it sounds like an interesting question to me. If there was a big bang and then a big ... for all eternity. In that case we have always been enslaved to our destiny and we will always be.

Description : Aristotle once said that in order to succeed we must ask the right questions - Is this one reason why ask-public became so popular?

Last Answer : That would be great. That would mean people on the internet are getting more interested in becoming better critical thinkers. I wouldn't look for the reason in a deliberate, foresightful decision to become ... A need for a place to discuss random things one wonders about, in this case, I surmise.

Description : Shall we glean noble knowledge through the divination of bloody entrails where the carcass of Truth Molested has been sacrificed?

Last Answer : Truth is always more important to me, personally. No matter how ugly or evil it might be.

Description : When did we become a society of people for whom job and role were the only basis for "common ground interactions" or friendships?

Last Answer : Since we adopted the 50 hour work week…

Description : What defines who we are? What is our identity?

Last Answer : D to the N to the A, plus the person you are in the deepest part of your mind as a result of your childhood nurturing.

Description : Do we need bad to define good?

Last Answer : answer:We humans like contrast. Light and dark, white and black, good and evil (or good and bad, although I do not consider them exactly the same thing), fast and slow, up and down. I ... some portion of things on the good side of the curve would migrate to not-good-enough and eventually bad.

Description : Which of the following is not one of the grounds for proceedings against a CPA? a. Insanity. b. Immoral or dishonorable conduct. c. Gross negligence or incompetence in the practice of his profession. d. Engaging in public practice while being employed in a private enterprise

Last Answer : Engaging in public practice while being employed in a private enterprise

Description : Do you agree with famous philosopher Christopher Smith, in regards to the "good old days"?

Last Answer : Real men won’t answer this question. - Ah, I read it too fast. Real men do answer this question.

Description : Would you like to answer this question about plugging into the Matrix?

Last Answer : I would opt to stay put in the Sims! I’m happy where I am at.

Description : What is the path to happiness?

Last Answer : This is a pure personal thing. What allows one person to feel a sense of deep happiness can be completely different than another person. I feel it is not about money or possessions. Finding out what ... start on a lifelong journey. Life also injects many things that can move of out of this space.

Description : What is time?

Last Answer : It is the fourth dimension. What text were you discussing for this question?

Description : What is your views after watching this video on why you will marry the wrong person?

Last Answer : Lol. Very entertaining. I didn’t learn the lesson., but then again i am human.

Description : Does the higher per capita intelligence near prestigious schools improve quality of life?

Last Answer : I'll quibble with the wording. But, having lived in and visited many places, some with very good universities, and some not, I'm going to say yes. At least, for my tastes, and the things I ... arts and studies and people doing what they're interested in, learning and all that comes with all of that.

Description : How accurate do you think this quote from a famous Indian Guru is?

Last Answer : I don’t think ‘retarded’ is the right word. I would have used ‘stupid’. Or maybe ‘simple’.

Description : How did this 2 minute clip make it past the censors?

Last Answer : Why would it be censored? It isn’t obscene. And it isn’t designed for 8 year olds. it’s audience is 44 year old men in Cnada.

Description : What happened before the Big Bang?

Last Answer : Nobody among human beings knows about it.

Description : What problems from the far past to now has philosophy solved?

Last Answer : The study of philosophy is to help us to use critical thinking to solve our own problems and reach our own goals in life. Critical thinking helps us to recognize the difference between things ... true. My personal opinion is that very few people even have the ability to understand these concepts.

Description : How would you describe the difference between intelligence and wisdom?

Last Answer : Intelligence is processing information and being able to extrapolate hypothesis and conclusions from various pieces of knowledge. It's more than just memorizing information, although memory is part of it, ... really does help in many situations in a way that just knowing information can't.

Description : Moral dilemma: save the dog or the braindead child?

Last Answer : I would choose my child, always. My son/daughter might be braindead, but I’m still here to love him/her. I would give him/her every chance to survive and have a happy life. ~Besides I don’t like dogs, if it was a cat then perhaps…

Description : Please help me understand what this guy is talking about?

Last Answer : It’s interesting to think about, which is probably why it interests some people. Have you ever watched Big Bang Theory? Sheldon talks about parallel universe’s all the time. You could watch the NEW Star Trek on Netflix, it’s about the same thing.

Description : What is the difference between mind and reason?

Last Answer : The mind is the mechanism; reason is the process.

Description : A priori or a posteriori, which one is more reliable?

Last Answer : Neither. It depends on other qualities of the situation. But if you’re taking a logic test, go with a priori. If you’re in a real situation where you have incomplete information, you may want to give a posteriori more weight.

Description : What does prime matter mean in philosophy?

Last Answer : Hylomorphism - Wikipedia In some cases, a substance's matter will itself be a substance. ... According to Aristotelians, such a substance has only prime matter as its matter. Prime matter is ... into various kinds of substances without remaining any kind of substance all the time. Hope this helps.

Description : What do you think of the hippie movement and hedonism?

Last Answer : A couple of points. The Hippie movement of the 1960s-1970s is NOT the Hippie Movement of 2019. I don't know what sort of event you are describing in your question. The Hippie movement of ... re either paranoid or overly cynical. Not everything needs a rationale. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

Description : Am I doing something wrong by refusing to serve in a military where service is obligated?

Last Answer : Supposedly Donald Trump had heal spurs and dodged the Vietnam draft ,and he became president of the USA. He gets ribbed on a little bit but he is doing fine.