Are most criminals generally good people who turn situationally bad? Or are there people that are just born bad?

1 Answer

Answer :

You’re assuming, I think, that nonviolent criminals always know that what they’re doing is illegal. I would not be entirely surprised to learn that I had committed a nonviolent crime in the past week or two. Commission of some crimes does not necessarily mean that someone is a “bad person”, does it? If you pick up a wild bird’s feather in your yard, does that make you bad? It’s a crime, after all. Have you ever lied? (Really, NEVER? That would make you decidedly odd.) But when Martha Stewart went to prison – for lying to an FBI agent – did that mean that she was a “bad person” for the lie? I can agree that she might be unlikable for any number of reasons, and maybe she was lying about something even worse that she had done… but she went to prison “for lying”. I’ve lied; I hope I never meet another FBI agent with an agenda. (I used to coach soccer with one, and I liked him, but we were on the same side there.) The fact is that we have enough laws on the books – for nonviolent offenses – that ANYONE can be prosecuted for any number of reasons by someone (or a party of someones) with the means and the agenda to do that. Does anyone not yet understand that this is the only reason that Hillary Clinton has NOT yet been prosecuted for her obvious crimes? Because if the Trump administration prosecutes her then there is a 100% certainty that – no matter what else he does in his administration – he would spend the rest of his life in jail, too. (This is why the Civil War was settled without mass executions, by the way – and that was a violent conflict, as I recall.)

Related questions

Description : How would you define an insignificant person? (Don't tell me about hardened criminals, please.)

Last Answer : That in 30 billion years the universe will tear in to nothingness, destroying time, space, and everything else, thus rendering all human endeavour totally pointless.

Description : How can we know exactly when criminals are suitable to fit into regular society?

Last Answer : answer:You have two cards in play with this question. The first you pointed out: All criminals are not the same. The second: Not all crimes are the same. I don't have a solid answer because one thing ... and can put on that Mask of good behavior, get let out, and then they strike again in society.

Description : Should people with mental illnesses be given the same (or situationally comparable) consideration as the physically-handicapped?

Last Answer : answer:I think that society gives sufficient empathy for those impacted with severe mental illness who absolutely cannot garner a better standard of life through treatments available the same way ... become more exaggerated. Of course that is my personal opinion derived from personal experiences.

Description : Is it just me or do people in England all have bad teeth?

Last Answer : It’s just you. And stereotypes.

Description : Do you feel that white people generally have dry reaction/less expressive compared to black people?

Last Answer : In my experience, culture is the determining factor in such comparisons.

Description : Why do people generally answer the question "Who are you?" with their job title?

Last Answer : answer:Because it’s where many people get their feeling of self-worth from. Ugh, what an awkwardly phrased sentence I just created.

Description : Hospitals aside, where were you born?

Last Answer : answer:In a small manger just outside Bethlehem. My parents had been traveling and couldn’t find a hotel, so we ended up in somebody’s barn. But I grew up to be pretty important. So the where is less important than the who.

Description : Do you suppose that you would be the same person if you were born under different circumstances?

Last Answer : Definitely not. I am the sum of my experiences.

Description : "If you were born in international waters, what would your citizenship be?"?

Last Answer : You would be a citizen of what ever country your parents are from, and what ever country you most recently left. When you turn 18, you will have to decide which country to be a citizen from.

Description : Why does getting into the drivers seat, turn the most intelligent people out there into mindless, clueless, road raging idiots?

Last Answer : answer:Aside from being hyperbolic and inflammatory, your premise is, frankly, absurd. Not all drivers ae slavering, drooling idiots all the time. Some may be that bad at all times, but that's not your premise. And ... which one of them is going to be that bad, so I do have to watch all of them.

Description : Have you found this to be true: people who were bullied, tend to turn into bullies?

Last Answer : There is some correlation I think. Some people can rise above it, but some can’t. Discrimination follows the same trend.

Description : Why do some pretty people turn their nose up at everyone ?

Last Answer : That’ll be the cosmetic surgery kicking in…possibly!

Description : Why do people freak out when they turn 30 ?

Last Answer : I didn’t. Loved it, actually. 40 wasn’t great, 50 won’t be either.

Description : Is there someone around you who, if they ever turn out to be a serial killer, you'll say "I knew it!"?

Last Answer : I recently found out that a guy I went to high school with (he wasn't really a friend, but we had some mutual friends) has been committed because he's seriously out of touch with reality. I ... but he's convinced that he can communicate with aliens and is severely paranoid. It didn't surprise me.

Description : Why do you think bad things happen to innocent people?

Last Answer : answer:Bad things happen to everyone. There is no immunity regardless of how you are perceived or have lived your life. except for me. i have bad things happen in my life because god hates me.

Description : Do you think people are basically good or basically bad?

Last Answer : The Bad Seed.

Description : Is it bad that I mispronounce the names of these famous people even though I'm aware of how they're actually pronounced?

Last Answer : answer:I’ve suffered for years wanting to pronounce “Porsche” correctly, but the masses here in the U.S. insist that it’s one syllable. And I bow to the masses. No, it’s not “bad”—but aren’t we all silly not wanting to get things corrected once and for all ;-)

Description : Do good people do bad things; do bad people do good things?

Last Answer : Yes, as in yin and yang. Yin has a bit of yang in it and yang has a bit of yin in it, but who’s to say whats bad and whats good?

Description : When was the last time you felt really bad/sad/sorry for a stranger?

Last Answer : I always feel sad for street people with signs. My best friend is actually doing something about it… this.

Description : What's something bad you did (or said) that you didn't regret, or even enjoyed?

Last Answer : If I don’t regret it, do I really think it was bad?

Description : Is anyone of you having a bad day recently?

Last Answer : You must have missed my last week.

Description : Is it a bad idea if you keep logging in a website?

Last Answer : I rarely log off any site, but many seem to be set up to automatically log off users, since they often ask me to log in.

Description : Do you feel that good things are more short lived than bad things?

Last Answer : I agree. But then again, I am not the most optimistic person in the world.

Description : What are the best memories you have had? Why did you like them? (No bad or inappropriate memories...)

Last Answer : What do you mean by….inappropriate?

Description : Did you ever get a bad reputation you didn't deserve?

Last Answer : That sounds awful. Just plain jealousy on your daughters behalf. To be fair to her, I can see that and she probably didn’t try out of revenge on you. Is your daughter still at school?

Description : If someone comes to the door and you dont feel like seeing anyone - eg bad hair day or in your pjs or house a mess what do you find yourself doing?...

Last Answer : i don’t open it if i don’t feel like it. no need to hide!

Description : So you've made a bad first impression. How do you recover?

Last Answer : Who were you making the impression on? That might make the answer change for me.

Description : What do you think of the statement "A suicidal man is a bad investment"?

Last Answer : It sounds kind of mean and insensitive. It treats humans as if they are money-earning objects, not human beings.

Description : Why is a punishment for prison inmates, to pick up trash on highways? Isn't this something we all need to do, not just criminals?

Last Answer : Actually for civilians picking up trash as court ordered community service it is punishment but it is my understanding that for convicts/inmates,it is actually a treat as they get out instead of being locked up.

Description : What to do about people who just want to praise themselves constantly?

Last Answer : You worship them as your one true God.

Description : At what point do you, personally, quit trying to explain things to people who just don't understand?

Last Answer : there’s always a way to convince someone of anything. you just have to figure out the right pattern of language. that said I have a low tolerance to stupid personally, so it really depends of how passionate about something I am.

Description : Have you ever had someone make assumptions about you just because you are _______________?

Last Answer : answer:Often. I'm a gamer, but I dislike D&D. I'm a computer geek who doesn't code. (I'm more of a hardware guy.) I'm a Liberal who supports gun rights and small business owners. I'm a ... or mechanic tries fast-talking my mother; she used to be a VW mechanic back when Volkswagen meant Beetle .

Description : Ever meet someone who was just mean for the sake of being mean?

Last Answer : Clearly the man was NOT in his right mind. Some people want to feel rush of power by bullying others. Had a man been with you at the time, be sure he would not have done that! Just the way people like that get a thrill out of their day.

Description : Hypothetical question, What would be your reaction be if the human birth rate just stopped for 3 years?

Last Answer : Oh shit, Children of Men is real

Description : What is the acceptable waiting time for someone you just met to call?

Last Answer : Two-three days.

Description : Do you ever just want to know what's going on in other people's lives?

Last Answer : answer:I have many good friends on Fluther. You know how inquisitive cops are, so if I have a question, I just go to their pm and ask, like, how has your day been? I never get personal, ... that person asks a personal question first. Yes, I would like to know, but that is what keeps us wondering.

Description : Do you know someone who argues just for the sake of arguing?

Last Answer : answer:Not anymore. These would be called toxic' people. I keep a hefty dose of garlic and silver bullets around for these types. lol It's all ego and narcissism, and, trying to have a meaningful ... doesn't change it's spots. Best to just be able to identify the leopard before it strikes. haha

Description : Just out of curiousity, has anyone ever used a dollar store pregnancy test and if so, what were you thinking?

Last Answer : answer:A little too conveniently placed next to the dollar box of condoms, I’d say. I know that conditioning makes us think that brands are better and that sometimes non-popular brands are as good if not better…. but…. [bleep] that.

Description : How can I find out if my friend is dead or just doesn't want to talk to me anymore, or both?

Last Answer : The third option, “both,” is a no-starter. And are you serious?

Description : Do you think this is just "pack mentality"?

Last Answer : That makes me crazed! I simply don’t get it…at all. Maybe those people have a pack mentality; or perhaps we’re antisocial?

Description : Why do we just assume things about Flutherites?

Last Answer : It could be an involuntary response to the fact that your name begins with “man”. That is what they read and in their heads that was what they pictured.

Description : Does everyone have a personality quirk, or are we just weird? And why?

Last Answer : Pirates kick ass.

Description : How important does somebody have to be before their death is considered an assassination instead of just murder?

Last Answer : Hmm. Offhand, I’d say it’s not the importance of the victim that makes it an assassination, it’s the motive of the killer. I think a killing for political ends is an assassination, whereas a killing with theft, jealousy, rage, etc. as the motive would be considered a murder.

Description : How do criminals and people get so caught up in crime they can not get out of it ?

Last Answer : answer:They have psychological issues where the part of their brain that controls their rational thinking is just a bit off I think they are in survival mode when they rob banks. Probably don't hold a ... rips people off anyways and their stock won't be affected -Buddy Newsom (I made him up)

Description : Criminals of Reddit, what is your favorite type of cheese?

Last Answer : answer:Swiss is the best. Actually. Now that I'm saying that out loud. I can see why they arrested me.

Description : How many of us are afraid of the upcoming caravan invasion of diseased criminals?

Last Answer : The only thing that worries me is that a bunch of people will arrive and instead of giving them the opportunity to work and pay taxes, and contribute to the community, they will be set up in tent cities ... moment you tell them they have to work on Saturdays, it is a few weeks before they move on.

Description : Are there magazines for criminals?

Last Answer : I think how-to lore is conveyed mostly by word of mouth, especially in certain concentrated populations. Also this is not likely to be a group that goes in for paid subscriptions.

Description : So, what is your opinion on Bolton threatening the International Criminal court with sanctions and legal actions, should they dare to prosecute american war criminals?

Last Answer : It’s an open invitation for everyone else to ignore the rules and go after Americans. Same as the use of torture the last time Bolton was allowed near the levers of power.

Description : Who are the richest criminals in the world?

Last Answer : Criminals and dictators tend not to publish reliable information on their assets. Neither do many of the world's richest people. Also, criminals and dictators have other assets in terms of loyal ... , accused cannibal) $500 million Zine al Abidine Ben Ali (ousted President of Tunisia) $50 million

Description : Has anyone ever tried sentencing criminals to a life of humor?

Last Answer : Shiv me now.~