What qualifies as "cultural appropriation"?

1 Answer

Answer :

Well, it used to be called “assimilation.” But if I had to guess when it started being called “cultural appropriation” I’d say it started in the age of Jazz, when white people started copying cool black phrases and terms, such as “man,” and “cat,” and “cool,” back in the 20s and we never stopped because we wanna be as cool as black people! But we are jive turkey honkys and we can never be as cool as black people and most of us look silly when we try.

Related questions

Description : What is cultural appropriation and why do people hate it (extremely long details inside)

Last Answer : “Appropriation” means to take. But in this case it’s not like they lose it. I don’t know why anyone would get insulted by someone who wants to mimick parts of a culture. We’ve borrowed a LOT of cool stuff from the black culture.

Description : What are your cultural expectations of 24-year-old female?

Last Answer : USA, 60ish female – 24 year old might be sharing an apartment in a city with friends or a boyfriend and working at her first post-college career job.

Description : Is our aversion to dead animals instinctive or cultural?

Last Answer : It is cultural. If it was instinctive there would be no market for dog fighting.

Description : What are some cultural differences between the US and Russia?

Last Answer : USA speaks mainly English and Spanish while Russia speaks Russian.

Description : Does cultural fetishizing or normaliization of breasts have a notifiable impact on the quality of life in a given culture?

Last Answer : Might make hot weather uncomfortable to have to cover them up. Otherwise, I don’t know. Might be able to argue that those who don’t view breasts as sexual are missing out on some great fun. ;)

Description : Why does "ethnic" or "cultural" always refer to something non-white?

Last Answer : Because white is implied to be normative.

Description : Is there a cultural reason why there are so many traditionally attractive athletes in women's curling?

Last Answer : Maybe it has something to do with the spandex. I haven’t seen a bad looking athlete in the Olympics yet, I don’t think.

Description : What are some of the ways you resist cultural expectations?

Last Answer : Well you’ve already resisted cultural expectations by your phrasing of ‘identity as a woman’ =) And yes, I do resist cultural expectations in my own small way. Like not being a teen who is in touch with all the latest music (although I am slowly changing on that front).

Description : At what point does culinary cultural appropriation go to far?

Last Answer : When it doesn’t taste any good. Otherwise, all’s fair in love and cooking.

Description : Thoughts on Cultural Appropriation?

Last Answer : For one thing germanic tribes, vikings and probably the celts were known to wear dreads.

Description : Is cultural appropriation forgivable in the name of fashion?

Last Answer : ~When in Rome…

Description : What’s your opinion of cultural appropriation in fashion?

Last Answer : I'm not sure what you mean. The current fashion includes every culture you can imagine. The traditional Native American fashion of the Choctaw Nation of Oklahoma reflects the influence of the European ... with the fashion of the day since ready made clothing became available in the early 1900's.

Description : What's the dumbest example of incorrect cultural appropriation?

Last Answer : All of them. You don't see the Scots getting pissed off any time a non Scots guy wears a kilt do you? No, just the twitter dumb fucks who can't live without drama. Share your culture. Embrace ... of others. And ducking learn something other than tribal this is mine and you can't have it bullshit.

Description : what if white actor made up to look like an Asian in a film about karate is considered an example of cultural appropriation because it's constitutes the?

Last Answer : unga

Description : Is it rude to ask the KFC clerk to give you fresh chicken?

Last Answer : Not rude as long as you don’t ask while they are busy or just before closing.

Description : Are right and wrong convertible terms dependant on popular opinion?

Last Answer : Dicey question. Right or wrong can sometimes be a huge gray area. Or a matter of personal opinion. Let's take the abortion issue as an example. I support women's rights, and their right to ... yet are willing to deny that same choice to a woman needing an abortion. Does that make sense?

Description : Is anyone else old enough to remember the Nairobi Trio?

Last Answer : Yes I'm old enough to remember them. As a matter of fact, I had already started going to school when they first appeared on the Ernie Kovac Show.I found more than one. Admittedly, a few are similar vids ... the time. My dad loved them & my Mom hated them. I found them to be mildly amusing at best.

Description : What is your personal opinion on abortion?

Last Answer : The choice belongs to the woman and her doctor, not to governments.

Description : What could be the reason why some people develop martial arts and some don’t?

Last Answer : I took Tae Kwondo because I was athletic and the idea appealed to me. Of course that has nothing to do with why the martial arts originated in the far east. I guess they are on a whole other spiritual plane.

Description : Why do so many of us Jellies have an interest in Iceland?

Last Answer : I can’t speak for anyone else, but there are three reasons I would like to go to Iceland: 1) the homogeneous population and culture 2) the lay of the land: rocky, rough, almost visceral, with the backdrop of the North Atlantic. 3) a country with in active volcano – how cool is that….

Description : Are all/most Brazilians dark skinned?

Last Answer : What’s dark? Brazilians come in many different skin shades, just like all of the Americas.

Description : What traditions would be good to get rid of?

Last Answer : Gender based clothing, gender based social roles, and weasel stomping day.

Description : How much money should I give to an acquaintance getting married?

Last Answer : That seems fine to me. I should think an add on would not be at all obligated, so any token ought to be fine.

Description : How come nearly every culture ever established patriarchy?

Last Answer : answer:I can think of 2 potential reasons. 1) Women have to carry a fetus and go through some pretty difficult times to give birth. Men can continue working in the field while the woman is feeding and ... . In the Asian tribe you mentioned, are the women smaller, equal to, or larger than the men?

Description : What is more prestigious to be an astronaut, or to win a world record setting gold medal in the Olympics?

Last Answer : answer:Hard to say, you're mostly comparing two versions of meh . I recognize the names of astronauts from 40 and 50 years ago, but none in the last ten years except for what's his name the ... . There was what's her name, the woman shot putter. Neither pursue their goal for honor or recognition.

Description : Do you still have your childhood gun?

Last Answer : answer:No, and your question makes me wonder now where it went after I moved out of the house. We lived in the burbs, so there was no real place for me to shoot (and I couldn't drive myself until I ... basement of the house. I shot targets placed on a 2 12 plank at about 20 yards or so. Fun times.

Description : From someone who comes from a non-Halloween celebrating place: How do you actually celebrate Halloween?

Last Answer : You snatch the brats that are making a ruckus in front of your door, and turn them into skeletons.

Description : Younger women: Do you live in a society where brides are still expected to have a dowry?

Last Answer : What can I get for $31 and 3 cup of soups?

Description : What is collectivistic consciousness?

Last Answer : The correct term is collective consciousness. When I googled it, I got lots of entries. Wikipedia has a nice description. Let us know if you need further help.

Description : How do I know if I make enough to buy a home?

Last Answer : answer:What is your income and your credit score? That is number one. Rule of thumb, the principal payment on a house will be roughly 10% of the cost of the house. So payment on the principal on a ... are rules of thumbs that I've always used as my standard, and they seem pretty accurate to me.

Description : Should FIFA have a responsibility to speak out against hate speech from fans?

Last Answer : answer:There are lots of things FIFA should take action about. Corruption, cheating, racism, hate speech. I am not holding my breath. But the incidents of which you speak is not a FIFA event, it is the ... and to remove any fan that makes a place unsafe. oh wait, IOC is just as corrupt as FIFA.

Description : What is modern life like in Ireland?

Last Answer : answer:Well speaking as a born Irish citizen myself things are pretty good in Ireland for the most part. We are starting to really come out of recession in a big way, jobs are becoming more available. However ... do my best to answer. I could be wrong, but I may be the only Irish Jelly here hehe.

Description : Would you write a letter to your rapist if you had the chance?

Last Answer : answer:I wouldn't. I think doing so would just dredge up a lot of sad, angry and vulnerable feelings that I just don't want to experience. I'm not who I was then. I don't think I would gain ... sending it, perhaps do so. We're all different. What do you think you would gain from taking this action?

Description : What is it that identifies you as a person?

Last Answer : The fact that I’m an oddball who loves every unpopular things from almost all aspects of life.

Description : What is the actual difference between equality and sameness?

Last Answer : People are the same when they are not different. People are equal when their differences are irrelevant.

Description : What are your thoughts on this response by The Pagan Federation of Ireland to a homophobic and racist couple?

Last Answer : Haha! Nice response.

Description : Do you think the differences between cultures and ethnicities will change over time?

Last Answer : answer:There is a big difference between ethnicities and cultures. In many ways, we are becoming more multi ethnic all the time, people have much more diverse genetic backgrounds than people one hundred ... , there seem to be too many divisive factors at play, religions, language, climate, politics.

Description : What is your opinion of gender norms?

Last Answer : Gender norms are fluid. A century ago women were assaulted and beaten for wanting to vote in this country. About 50 years ago my sister was wait-listed at MIT, today they would have courted her and offered ... old professional woman. The examples go on and on, I won't begin to list them all here.

Description : Is arguing about what constitutes the beginning of ones humanity helpful within a discussion about abortion?

Last Answer : Regarding pro-choice discussing when life begins can be relevant. I don't think arguing whether life begins at conception is relevant, but to me viability of the fetus is. There is a bit of hypocrisy in it. ... , but once the baby is no longer parasitic on the mother, I'm not ok with killing it.

Description : Do you think public opinion on organised religion with the general public has changed in the last decade?

Last Answer : answer:http://www.gallup.com/poll/155690/confidence-organized-religion-low-point.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/1690/religion.aspx http://www.pewforum.org/2015/11/03/u-s-public-becoming-less-religious/

Description : Do you think it is sexist for a barber to refuse to cut a woman's hair?

Last Answer : They weren't allowed to cut women's hair? That's kind of stupid. I don't see any difference between men's hair and women's hair. I wouldn't exactly call it sexist, I'm not sure that that ... gender discrimating. That's kind of messed up, honestly. How can you not be qualified to cut women's hair?

Description : A question about South East Asian customs. Details inside.

Last Answer : answer:Sounds like the stereotyped husband domination to me. The mentality isn't so uncommon in many Asian countries, especially in China, India and the like. The husband gets the ultimate role in every ... the wife only has to follow them, no question asked. Does the couple you see look Chinese?

Description : Do you think police brutality is a huge problem or do you think they are isolated incidents?

Last Answer : Isolated but not trivial

Description : Is Pennsylvania the only state in the US that allows self-uniting marriages?

Last Answer : I had to look that one up! Seems like Pennsylvania is about it, and even then you need to be Quaker or Bah’ai to be okayed.

Description : Do you think there should be limits to freedom of expression?

Last Answer : Anyone who doesn’t support free expression needs to shut the fuck up.

Description : What do you think about those who purposely avoid introverted people?

Last Answer : perhaps they are introverted themselves?

Description : Are there any cultures in your own country that you have a very hard time identifying with, or understanding?

Last Answer : I am all for gun ownership, but I do not understand gun culture.

Description : Does the conflict in this scene from an episode of Star Trek DS9 look familiar to you?

Last Answer : A lot of tv shows, and movies for that matter, tend to draw on conflicts and occurrences that are happening around us. It's no surprise that DS9 is doing the same thing. They basically take what ... lines too. To be honest, it doesn't surprise me that this scene is reminiscent of real life history

Description : What do you think about this individual's “solution” to dealing with atheism and homosexuality in America?

Last Answer : True Christians are supposed to love thy neighbor and not be hate mongers. I have no opinion, nor do I even think about someone that spreads such vicious hate.

Description : What are your views on abortion?

Last Answer : I’m pro-choice. However, I have serious qualms about the late-term abortion of healthy fetuses. That is abortions that take place after 20 weeks. I realise there may be reasons why an abortion at a late stage might be justifiable, the idea of aborting a fetus at such a late stage disturbs me.