answer:It really depends on what you’re looking for… They both have the same artistic style (which I prefer) and they have contiguous plots, but there are subtle differences. Obviously one is portable and the other is not, but Phantom Hpurglass is only controllable via a stylus- no analog controls. Phantom Hourglass is shorter too, and somewhat easier in scope. Not to take anything away from Phantom Hourglass- it is an incredible game with a very good story! And the way the stylus controls were implemented, you really won’t miss anything from a “normal” game. The ship control is much easier now with a stylus, and with auto navigation you get to focus on battle and collection of treasures while you sail. Plus, in PH you get to modify your ship to your own liking, whereas in Windwaker you had the same old ship. Phantom Hourglass has a limited wi-fi game too, which is fun. Windwaker doesn’t have this. All in all, I would say that I prefer the accessibility of Phantom Hourglass- almost anyone can pick it up and enjoy…and it isn’t a game that takes forever to figure out. If I had my choice I would pick PH because I like to bring things with me. But if you are looking to have a great game with great scenery, music, challenge, strategy, and humor you may like Windwaker. Some of the animated cut scenes in WW are worth it alone. You really can’t go wrong! Enjoy either way- Zelda will hardly ever disappoint.