A thought experiment about the nature of self (see details)- what do you think?

A thought experiment about the nature of self (see details)- what do you think?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

People who believe in a soul might have a problem with this type of thing. Since I believe that I’m just a collection of cells in the same condition that would be accurately duplicated, yes, I think it would be me. I believe that any 100% replication of my atomic bits will also be me. Even if the machine was a copier and not a teleporter, two of me would step out of the machine. The other person would also be me. They would start to be their own person as they start to have separate experiences. If you believe in superstition and think there’s some ‘magic’ part of the body (i.e. soul) that cannot be duplicated, then you would probably argue that the teleported version of yourself isn’t you because the machine destroyed some divine part of you that it cannot recreate.
by

Related questions

What are your thoughts to this classic mind-body and personal identity thought experiment?

Description : What are your thoughts to this classic mind-body and personal identity thought experiment?

Last Answer : answer:It's a little late in the evening to think this one all the way through, but I can certainly answer this part: What if 1 atom was missing, would you still be the same person? How many ... start to decompose and fertilize some plot of earth, I imagine I won't feel quite so much like myself.

Is there such a thing as self control? (Details Important)

Description : Is there such a thing as self control? (Details Important)

Last Answer : A lot of our own mind is ununderstood and uncontrolled by other parts of it, that doesn’t mean that we have no self control at all over it.

Was the Stanford Prison Experiment ethical?

Description : Was the Stanford Prison Experiment ethical?

Last Answer : Ethics was entirely beside the point of the experiment. I would say that even though it was aborted early, much can be said about human behaviour with what we have. An interesting aside ... proviso the the the Stanford prison experiment, or at least an additional variable which bears consideration.

Transported to a previously thought fictional world, with foreknowledge and superior powers, do you feel dutybound to help the protagonist fulfill their quest, or do you feel that you must stay out of the protagonist's story?

Description : Transported to a previously thought fictional world, with foreknowledge and superior powers, do you feel dutybound to help the protagonist fulfill their quest, or do you feel that you must stay out of the protagonist's story?

Last Answer : The only moral response is “defeat the demon king on your own immediately, saving a sizeable number of people in the process,. Anything less would be immoral. Morality is more important than somebody’s chance to be a hero. They can go be a hero somewhere else.

Does political correctness have a tendency to become thought policing?

Description : Does political correctness have a tendency to become thought policing?

Last Answer : I find that I am too prudent and I tend to play it safe .

Is the outcome of every possible action predetermined and quantum mechanics as me know them are an unfinished theory? Einstein thought so.

Description : Is the outcome of every possible action predetermined and quantum mechanics as me know them are an unfinished theory? Einstein thought so.

Last Answer : answer:Well, that's called determinism, and I know many people who believe in it. The idea is that if you have all the data in the universe and were able to analyze it, you could predict ... t subscribe to that. I feel that there is pure randomness that is out there that is not predictable.

Philosophical question: do you take one box or two (see details)?

Description : Philosophical question: do you take one box or two (see details)?

Last Answer : I take just box B. If he’s always right as his record implies, then he predicted that I would do this and I am now rich!

Is there anything you've done in your life that you think of certain things you do now as penance or self-punishment for?

Description : Is there anything you've done in your life that you think of certain things you do now as penance or self-punishment for?

Last Answer : Everyone can relate with your comment Snarp! Here is my take on the subject. We all makes mistakes, the secret is not to make the same mistake twice! Seems like your learned from your mistake, give it up and go on! Burdens are not meant to be carried your whole life. Be happy with thy ownself!

Can nature explain reason?

Description : Can nature explain reason?

Last Answer : I think there is so much we are still discovering about the brain and how it works that all the data is not yet in on what is brain and what is mind. By which I mean that there is a scientific explanation for rationality.

Regarding the "meaning of life" and humanity's self worth, what is the difference between being in a universe created by a god, and a universe created as a computer simulation by an alien race?

Description : Regarding the "meaning of life" and humanity's self worth, what is the difference between being in a universe created by a god, and a universe created as a computer simulation by an alien race?

Last Answer : Does it matter? If there is a god creating a universe, who is to say that the god is not, in fact, the product of a computer simulation? There's no way to tell if this god has godlike characteristics ... a software glitch? I wou;dn't, but I'm not sure it matters. How would it change my life?

What are the pros and cons of self-examination?

Description : What are the pros and cons of self-examination?

Last Answer : Understanding one's understanding (that is recognizing how one has acquired their understanding of whatever they think they understand) enables them to filter out the inculcated beliefs that have little or no ... to focus on what they are looking for, which will likely exclude what can be known.

Have you ever tried to distort your perceptions by imposing self-created beliefs onto yourself?

Description : Have you ever tried to distort your perceptions by imposing self-created beliefs onto yourself?

Last Answer : What do you mean by “self-created beliefs”?

In your opinion, are concepts such as "All men are created equal" a philosophy or a self evident truth??

Description : In your opinion, are concepts such as "All men are created equal" a philosophy or a self evident truth??

Last Answer : Try “all men are created equal under the law” and it works better.

"Lazy-susan": Did a husband invent this for his lazy wife named Susan? Or did a good humored woman named Susan invent and name it for her lazy self?

Description : "Lazy-susan": Did a husband invent this for his lazy wife named Susan? Or did a good humored woman named Susan invent and name it for her lazy self?

Last Answer : I suspect we’ll never know but fun to think about.

How can I find my self-worth? Where does self-worth come from if not my actions and accomplishments?

Description : How can I find my self-worth? Where does self-worth come from if not my actions and accomplishments?

Last Answer : answer:Self-worth is somewhat self-explanatory. It comes from your self.

Abraham Lincoln said, "All human actions are caused by motives, and at the bottom of these motives are self". Do you agree or disagree that all human actions driven by selfishness?

Description : Abraham Lincoln said, "All human actions are caused by motives, and at the bottom of these motives are self". Do you agree or disagree that all human actions driven by selfishness?

Last Answer : Self, most definitely.

What caused you to assume that reality and other humans besides your self are real and actually exist?

Description : What caused you to assume that reality and other humans besides your self are real and actually exist?

Last Answer : Life is but a dream.

Is every action of a human out of pure self interest?

Description : Is every action of a human out of pure self interest?

Last Answer : Not, every. Depends on what life stage you’re in. Depends on your values etc.

What do you think of this analogy? (Details)

Description : What do you think of this analogy? (Details)

Last Answer : Men are like pigs.

What do you think about Texas' new abortion rules? (Details )

Description : What do you think about Texas' new abortion rules? (Details )

Last Answer : “I believe it is imperative to establish higher standards that reflect our respect for the sanctity of life,” he said in the email, from the state that looks for any way it can to increase the rate of state executions.

Are prison systems a catalyst for poor race relations? (Details)

Description : Are prison systems a catalyst for poor race relations? (Details)

Last Answer : I think poor race relations predate any prison/criminal outcomes.

Do roaches have life figured out? (Details)

Description : Do roaches have life figured out? (Details)

Last Answer : Whatever you’ve been drinking, smoking, and/or sniffing, I want some. LOL To answer the question, roaches may have something up in their antennae, who knows?

Do aliens steal? (Details )

Description : Do aliens steal? (Details )

Last Answer : answer:…yes,....no….maybe? I think that, if aliens are advanced as us, they don’t need to steal. We don’t need to steal either, after all. If they do steal, it would probably be out of necessity or kleptomania, just like us. I may be looking at the whole thing from human’s perspective.

Could there be lifeforms in open space? (Details )

Description : Could there be lifeforms in open space? (Details )

Last Answer : answer:Yes! In a controlled experiment a crew of ISS exposed Tardigrades to the vacuum and temperature of space - and the critters survived! Tardigrades are notable for being the most resilient animal: they can survive ... °F; −272 °C) (close to absolute zero) to about 420 K (300 °F; 150 °C)

Why are most anti-abortion people also against government aid? (Details)

Description : Why are most anti-abortion people also against government aid? (Details)

Last Answer : They believe in personal responsibility and believe life begins at conception.

Should paternity tests be mandatory when a child is born? (Details )

Description : Should paternity tests be mandatory when a child is born? (Details )

Last Answer : Why? What trouble would it save later on? And what about maternity tests as well? It is no longer a given that the woman who gives birth to the child is the genetic mother.

Whose fault is it? (Details )

Description : Whose fault is it? (Details )

Last Answer : Your toe. Your walking method. Your house and furniture. Your decision to answer the telephone. Your fault.

Do aliens have abortions? (Details )

Description : Do aliens have abortions? (Details )

Last Answer : The newborn abort their “parent” immediately after a c section…(John Hurt knows)

Women, gay men. Do you deserve the respect? (Details )

Description : Women, gay men. Do you deserve the respect? (Details )

Last Answer : answer:You are truly an example of patriarchy, so graciously bestowing your respect and admiration of women. And now you lump in gay men? What, are yo some sort of antediluvian throwback? People ... believe in treating people with respect because they are human, not because you deign to honor them.

ask-publicites. If you could change one thing about men, what would you change? (Details )

Description : ask-publicites. If you could change one thing about men, what would you change? (Details )

Last Answer : Hmmm . First of all, I don't think men have inherent personality/characteristics. Each man is individual and different from one another. If I were to stereotype men I would say that it's best for ... is old news and cliche but still ). And not acting like it's their responsibility to protect women.

Should these two sentences be linked to change its meaning? (Details inside)

Description : Should these two sentences be linked to change its meaning? (Details inside)

Last Answer : I learned a lot about myself “in the extreme”. And it was uncomfortable for a while. Now, I am very comfortable. So there you go.

If people could see in the dark, would crime be higher, or lower? (At night. )

Description : If people could see in the dark, would crime be higher, or lower? (At night. )

Last Answer : According to this, the only types of crimes being significantly more prevalent during the night are rape, sexual assault, and car theft. Though I think that is due to less people being around at ... So, no, I do not think that crime rates would be affected to any statistically significant degree.

What do you see when you look in the sky?

Description : What do you see when you look in the sky?

Last Answer : Good examples of Rayleigh and Mie scattering.

I don't see the value in studying philosophy. Can someone enlighten me?

Description : I don't see the value in studying philosophy. Can someone enlighten me?

Last Answer : I suppose studying philosophy encourages a more elastic mindset, the ability to approach a problem from a different angle. But I must admit, I never had any interest in the field.

Do you think the following thought experiment from the anime "Sakurada Reset" is accurate?

Description : Do you think the following thought experiment from the anime "Sakurada Reset" is accurate?

Last Answer : I prefer this exchange from Star Trek Voyager: Harry Kim : Seven, you've been around humans for a while now. What do you think about love? Seven of Nine : We're scanning for microfractures ... emotional cascade, impairing normal functioning. Harry Kim : Forget it. I think it is much more accurate.

How accurate do you think this quote from a famous Indian Guru is?

Description : How accurate do you think this quote from a famous Indian Guru is?

Last Answer : I don’t think ‘retarded’ is the right word. I would have used ‘stupid’. Or maybe ‘simple’.

What do you think of the hippie movement and hedonism?

Description : What do you think of the hippie movement and hedonism?

Last Answer : A couple of points. The Hippie movement of the 1960s-1970s is NOT the Hippie Movement of 2019. I don't know what sort of event you are describing in your question. The Hippie movement of ... re either paranoid or overly cynical. Not everything needs a rationale. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

What do you think about this video as an argument against determinism?

Description : What do you think about this video as an argument against determinism?

Last Answer : As I understand it, Determinism is the belief that all events are caused, or acted upon, by prior events. Nothing happens without cause. I think that the video posits an argument for Indeterminism; that is ... are not caused by prior events and that may, or may not, have effect on future events.

Do you think it’s unusual for someone to understand complex and abstract philosophical ideas but still have a learning disability in math?

Description : Do you think it’s unusual for someone to understand complex and abstract philosophical ideas but still have a learning disability in math?

Last Answer : Math is built on logic and on itself. Most students fail at math when they fall behind and try to do math without the more fundimental math. Then most give up. Also the Matrix was alluding to ... math, because the class was too perfect. No unknowns for fun answers are in the back of the textbook

Do you think normality is subjective?

Description : Do you think normality is subjective?

Last Answer : Yes, principally because it is defined by the observer. If it was objective, normality would have a generally agreed upon definition.

What do you think about this approach to talking about morality?

Description : What do you think about this approach to talking about morality?

Last Answer : answer:I will use religion to illustrate my thoughts on this. Most if not all religions have the same moral obligation tools in their tool boxes. It will be how they employ these tools based on ... a discussion. Neither one is right or wrong our moral obligation tools are just in a different order.

Do you think that we encounter 'bad' people in our lives?

Description : Do you think that we encounter 'bad' people in our lives?

Last Answer : answer:I think people may be bad for us for whatever reason - they're opportunists, they're addicts, they're users, whatever, a variety of reasons. If you can realize that and keep a distance, it will ... bad for you, for whatever reason, realizing that is enough for you to cut the ties and move on.

Do you think that lying should be a moral concern?

Description : Do you think that lying should be a moral concern?

Last Answer : Of course it should be a moral concern,and lying to spare one feelings is one thing,but politicians and lawyers have made careers out of it and that is bad.

Don't you think that we are all one?

Description : Don't you think that we are all one?

Last Answer : Yes, all life forms sprang from the same source of life giving components. Some organisms evolved into humans, others mammals, plant life, sea life, etc. We are all one, meaning that every ... the roulette wheel of evolution and we could just as easily manifested as a watermelon or an earthworm.

Do you think the anthropic principle helps or hurts the argument for God?

Description : Do you think the anthropic principle helps or hurts the argument for God?

Last Answer : Absolutely not. Oh darn, this question goes two ways. Hmmmm. Okay, lemme put it this way. Just because the Earth is just the right distance form the sun to be perfect for life to exist here, ... our little corner of it didn't just happen by accident with no intelligent thought or design at. all.

What do you think of these nerdy jokes?

Description : What do you think of these nerdy jokes?

Last Answer : Made me laugh, thanks! Descartes before the horse and all that…

In your own personal opinion, do you think I am insane?

Description : In your own personal opinion, do you think I am insane?

Last Answer : answer:Reminds me of a saying I’m particularly fond of: The difference between me and you is, I know I’m crazy. (I’m very serious.)

What would Immanuel Kant think of organ sale?

Description : What would Immanuel Kant think of organ sale?

Last Answer : I think the government made it illegal to keep desparate people safe from predators. They offer to buy a kidney, well they also have orders in for a heart, a liver, a lung (maybe two). What is to keep them from fulfilling those orders from the same person who was offered payment for a kidney?

What do you think about?

Description : What do you think about?

Last Answer : I gravitate to thoughts about human nature and the workings of the mind.

What do you think of Wittgenstein's statement, Whereof one cannot speak, thereon one must remain silent?

Description : What do you think of Wittgenstein's statement, Whereof one cannot speak, thereon one must remain silent?

Last Answer : Solid advice, oh too often ignored!!