What are your thoughts to this classic mind-body and personal identity thought experiment?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:It’s a little late in the evening to think this one all the way through, but I can certainly answer this part: What if 1 atom was missing, would you still be the same person? How many atoms would need to be missing before you wouldn’t consider this the same person (would this be different if it recycled your atoms from when they killed you to when they re-built you)? I shed atoms all the time. I file my nails and have my hair cut. I’ve lost teeth and had major surgery. I am at the point in life where I think I must be losing brain cells faster than I can make them. Yet I entertain the illusion that I am the same person now that I was when I started typing this post. As illusions go, it is a reasonably convincing one. When I start to decompose and fertilize some plot of earth, I imagine I won’t feel quite so much like myself.

Related questions

Description : A thought experiment about the nature of self (see details)- what do you think?

Last Answer : People who believe in a soul might have a problem with this type of thing. Since I believe that I'm just a collection of cells in the same condition that would be accurately duplicated, yes, ... of yourself isn't you because the machine destroyed some divine part of you that it cannot recreate.

Description : In your opinion is Thomas Aquinas the greatest theologian of all time with his classic work Summa Theologica ?

Last Answer : That's what I've been told. But interposed between Aquinas and the trophy looms the formidable Augustine. I have soaked up just enough of the musings of both to understand that I will never be ... folks who know about such things that when it comes to theological gunslinging, Maimonedes is one BMF.

Description : How much of your identity is tied up with your gender?

Last Answer : Genes.

Description : What defines who we are? What is our identity?

Last Answer : D to the N to the A, plus the person you are in the deepest part of your mind as a result of your childhood nurturing.

Description : Was the Stanford Prison Experiment ethical?

Last Answer : Ethics was entirely beside the point of the experiment. I would say that even though it was aborted early, much can be said about human behaviour with what we have. An interesting aside ... proviso the the the Stanford prison experiment, or at least an additional variable which bears consideration.

Description : Transported to a previously thought fictional world, with foreknowledge and superior powers, do you feel dutybound to help the protagonist fulfill their quest, or do you feel that you must stay out of the protagonist's story?

Last Answer : The only moral response is “defeat the demon king on your own immediately, saving a sizeable number of people in the process,. Anything less would be immoral. Morality is more important than somebody’s chance to be a hero. They can go be a hero somewhere else.

Description : Does political correctness have a tendency to become thought policing?

Last Answer : I find that I am too prudent and I tend to play it safe .

Description : Is the outcome of every possible action predetermined and quantum mechanics as me know them are an unfinished theory? Einstein thought so.

Last Answer : answer:Well, that's called determinism, and I know many people who believe in it. The idea is that if you have all the data in the universe and were able to analyze it, you could predict ... t subscribe to that. I feel that there is pure randomness that is out there that is not predictable.

Description : What is the difference between mind and reason?

Last Answer : The mind is the mechanism; reason is the process.

Description : Does the human understanding of time exist outside of the human mind?

Last Answer : answer:Other creatures are aware of time but not in the sophisticated way humans understand it. A dog would have little use for a watch but will know when it is time for walkies or time to be ... particles that make up the universe the beginning and the end of the universe seem like the same moment.

Description : Why is the mind also referred to as "soul"?

Last Answer : It is not. They are two different things.

Description : Do you think there is a "mind" or is there just "brain"?

Last Answer : I may be missing the point entirely, but exactly why is it that even the mention that a brain is damaged means that there is no longer any mind?

Description : Would there be a mathematics if there were no mind to contemplate it?

Last Answer : Great question! I would have to say the math would be there, even if there were no humans there to do the equations. For example E=mc^2, would still apply, even if we did not know about it. The same goes for πr^2. The circle still exists.

Description : Thoughts before you were born and thoughts after you die?

Last Answer : I’m thinking 1313 is a weird date to put for the future!

Description : How many thoughts can you do at once?

Last Answer : Probably only one. There are times when it feels like two are more are going on at the same time, but I think it comes down to another thought quickly creeping in and taking over the lead role. For ... to the destination; one thought just takes a front seat for a moment. (Is this what you mean?)

Description : Is what one values dependent on personal gain?

Last Answer : ~I heard another similar catch phrase. That a man is only as loyal as his options.

Description : In your own personal opinion, do you think I am insane?

Last Answer : answer:Reminds me of a saying I’m particularly fond of: The difference between me and you is, I know I’m crazy. (I’m very serious.)

Description : Is our personal perception of life subjective? If so, what is reality?

Last Answer : There is a reality, but we cannot perceive it from without our paradigm.

Description : Is Body Integrity Identity Disorder as genuine in your mind Gender Identity Disorder?

Last Answer : I'm the same as you though I'm not really sure why. I'm quick with sympathizing for people with GID but for some reason I just can't wrap my mind around BIID. I just watched a movie that ... called Armless. As the title implies he wanted both his arms amputated in order to feel whole .weird movie .

Description : Do you somehow anthropomorphize the thought of your cellphone number into a part of your identity?

Last Answer : answer:No, but I like my number because it starts and ends with the same three numbers. for example: 543–234-1543

Description : Do you think the following thought experiment from the anime "Sakurada Reset" is accurate?

Last Answer : I prefer this exchange from Star Trek Voyager: Harry Kim : Seven, you've been around humans for a while now. What do you think about love? Seven of Nine : We're scanning for microfractures ... emotional cascade, impairing normal functioning. Harry Kim : Forget it. I think it is much more accurate.

Description : What do we mean when we say "me"? A thought experiment.

Last Answer : What does this have to do with the word ‘me’?

Description : Have you read the short story / thought experiment called God's Debris? If so this could be a chance to discuss what you thought of it, if not this is your chance to read it.

Last Answer : I have been reading it on and off since yesterday. I’ll get back to you.

Description : Thinking about weird stuff - What is your favorite thought experiment?

Last Answer : It may not qualify for an experiment, but rather a weird thought. I dunno of what to call it…I sometimes imagined that this universe is inside of someone’s stomach, and that’s why there’s so darkness around. Another one: how would it feel if you grow out the universe.

Description : Why Galileo's thought experiment about the ball rolling forever on a level surface could only be a thought experiment.?

Last Answer : Schrödinger's exp involved a cat placed inside a box w/ a vialof poisonous gas, released when an radioactive atom decays. Awnserby Jake Henderson

Description : Do you agree with famous philosopher Christopher Smith, in regards to the "good old days"?

Last Answer : Real men won’t answer this question. - Ah, I read it too fast. Real men do answer this question.

Description : Would you like to answer this question about plugging into the Matrix?

Last Answer : I would opt to stay put in the Sims! I’m happy where I am at.

Description : What is the path to happiness?

Last Answer : This is a pure personal thing. What allows one person to feel a sense of deep happiness can be completely different than another person. I feel it is not about money or possessions. Finding out what ... start on a lifelong journey. Life also injects many things that can move of out of this space.

Description : What is time?

Last Answer : It is the fourth dimension. What text were you discussing for this question?

Description : What is your views after watching this video on why you will marry the wrong person?

Last Answer : Lol. Very entertaining. I didn’t learn the lesson., but then again i am human.

Description : Does the higher per capita intelligence near prestigious schools improve quality of life?

Last Answer : I'll quibble with the wording. But, having lived in and visited many places, some with very good universities, and some not, I'm going to say yes. At least, for my tastes, and the things I ... arts and studies and people doing what they're interested in, learning and all that comes with all of that.

Description : How accurate do you think this quote from a famous Indian Guru is?

Last Answer : I don’t think ‘retarded’ is the right word. I would have used ‘stupid’. Or maybe ‘simple’.

Description : How did this 2 minute clip make it past the censors?

Last Answer : Why would it be censored? It isn’t obscene. And it isn’t designed for 8 year olds. it’s audience is 44 year old men in Cnada.

Description : What happened before the Big Bang?

Last Answer : Nobody among human beings knows about it.

Description : What problems from the far past to now has philosophy solved?

Last Answer : The study of philosophy is to help us to use critical thinking to solve our own problems and reach our own goals in life. Critical thinking helps us to recognize the difference between things ... true. My personal opinion is that very few people even have the ability to understand these concepts.

Description : Regarding the "meaning of life" and humanity's self worth, what is the difference between being in a universe created by a god, and a universe created as a computer simulation by an alien race?

Last Answer : Does it matter? If there is a god creating a universe, who is to say that the god is not, in fact, the product of a computer simulation? There's no way to tell if this god has godlike characteristics ... a software glitch? I wou;dn't, but I'm not sure it matters. How would it change my life?

Description : How would you describe the difference between intelligence and wisdom?

Last Answer : Intelligence is processing information and being able to extrapolate hypothesis and conclusions from various pieces of knowledge. It's more than just memorizing information, although memory is part of it, ... really does help in many situations in a way that just knowing information can't.

Description : Moral dilemma: save the dog or the braindead child?

Last Answer : I would choose my child, always. My son/daughter might be braindead, but I’m still here to love him/her. I would give him/her every chance to survive and have a happy life. ~Besides I don’t like dogs, if it was a cat then perhaps…

Description : Do we need more sins? Is seven enough?

Last Answer : Your president has six of the seven deadly sins with the possible exception of envy. This tally doesn't do justice to the huge injury he is doing to his country and its reputation or to the psychic damage he is ... of him and his family in the White House. I'm stuck. I cannot put a name to it.

Description : Please help me understand what this guy is talking about?

Last Answer : It’s interesting to think about, which is probably why it interests some people. Have you ever watched Big Bang Theory? Sheldon talks about parallel universe’s all the time. You could watch the NEW Star Trek on Netflix, it’s about the same thing.

Description : A priori or a posteriori, which one is more reliable?

Last Answer : Neither. It depends on other qualities of the situation. But if you’re taking a logic test, go with a priori. If you’re in a real situation where you have incomplete information, you may want to give a posteriori more weight.

Description : What does prime matter mean in philosophy?

Last Answer : Hylomorphism - Wikipedia In some cases, a substance's matter will itself be a substance. ... According to Aristotelians, such a substance has only prime matter as its matter. Prime matter is ... into various kinds of substances without remaining any kind of substance all the time. Hope this helps.

Description : What do you think of the hippie movement and hedonism?

Last Answer : A couple of points. The Hippie movement of the 1960s-1970s is NOT the Hippie Movement of 2019. I don't know what sort of event you are describing in your question. The Hippie movement of ... re either paranoid or overly cynical. Not everything needs a rationale. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

Description : Am I doing something wrong by refusing to serve in a military where service is obligated?

Last Answer : Supposedly Donald Trump had heal spurs and dodged the Vietnam draft ,and he became president of the USA. He gets ribbed on a little bit but he is doing fine.

Description : On a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being "complete BS" and 10 being "divine wisdom", how would you rate the following statement?

Last Answer : 42

Description : Is there even such a thing as "the outside"?

Last Answer : I think there is, as long as you are inside. Or, outside is the new inside.

Description : What view do you have in regard to the following statement?

Last Answer : I believe it to be true. I have built many emotional barriers over the years to keep me from being hurt but the do tend to keep me separated from others, even family members. I come off ... sadness or uncomfortable emotions . So yes, walls work both ways keeping things out;and keeping things in.

Description : What are some instances or situations that support the idea of moral relativism?

Last Answer : The modern abhorrence of slavery as fundamentally immoral, versus the biblical and divine endorsement of slavery. Any time someone brings up the “it was a different time” excuse, when past cultures’ moral failings are judged.

Description : What do you think about this video as an argument against determinism?

Last Answer : As I understand it, Determinism is the belief that all events are caused, or acted upon, by prior events. Nothing happens without cause. I think that the video posits an argument for Indeterminism; that is ... are not caused by prior events and that may, or may not, have effect on future events.