How do you discipline your children? Do you think that 'beating' them is right?

How do you discipline your children? Do you think that 'beating' them is right?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

Most child development experts agree that physical punishment is ineffective, and only serves to alleviate the anger of the adult, rather than actually teach a lesson. We have a 2 year old and a newborn, and we will not be using any form of physical punishment. With our two year old, we have started time outs, and are using the 1–2-3 Magic system, which seems to work really well and was recommended to us by our pediatrician.
by

Related questions

Takin a Beating?

Description : Takin a Beating?

Last Answer : answer:You need to talk to a school counselor, your doctor or your pastor. Don’t wait for things to get worse, seek help. http://www.ndvh.org/ http://www.boystown.org/hotline/index.asp http://www.avhotline.org/ http://www.pamf.org/teen/hotlines.html#violence

How to discipline a toddler?

Description : How to discipline a toddler?

Last Answer : Put him in the ‘naughty corner’. Make sure that what you say you really do mean. He has to understand you are not joking when you tell him to do something. Make him apologise for disrespecting you. When he apologises tell him you love him, but he must do as you tell him.

If your children are perfectly well behaved and kind, and the come to stay with you a few weekends a month, is there any way to avoid spoiling them?

Description : If your children are perfectly well behaved and kind, and the come to stay with you a few weekends a month, is there any way to avoid spoiling them?

Last Answer : I think consistency is so important in parenting. And all the better if both parents maintain similar rules, even in divorce.Perhaps even more so in a divorce situation, (to establish security in children). Also to ... visit. Is it for pizza or fun, or is it for real dad time.That kind of thing.

When someone says single parent, specifically unwed moms raising their children, what pops into your head?

Description : When someone says single parent, specifically unwed moms raising their children, what pops into your head?

Last Answer : answer:If you had said child I would have thought of a teenager raising her result of a wild night. But you said children , so I think of either a divorced mother or a woman having ... them properly despite being looked down on by the whole society. They both deserve more than what they have.

Why is having your own flesh and blood children, so important?

Description : Why is having your own flesh and blood children, so important?

Last Answer : Because my genes are so pure and noble, and commoners would never understand.~ Pfft. My gene pool is a cesspool. Why would I want to pass that on?

How does a parent talk to their high-school-aged children about stress?

Description : How does a parent talk to their high-school-aged children about stress?

Last Answer : answer:MY parents never used the word stress. My sibs and I were dream children as far as they were concerned lots of bragging rights so it never came up directly. I think that the best ... any important emotional information about me with them. I used my friends as therapists, and vice versa.

How are the children of teenage parents doing as adults?

Description : How are the children of teenage parents doing as adults?

Last Answer : Married no kids, work a lot, no police record, and a clean driving record. Psychologically maybe scarred up.

Is this par for the course with grown children? Am I being petty?

Description : Is this par for the course with grown children? Am I being petty?

Last Answer : answer:No I don't think you are. Even if they were your grand-kids, and I know this is not the point, you would be allowed' to stipulate when you can or cannot baby sit. I think this is an ... Then when the parent is gone, they realize the mistakes they made. You can't really change that, I feel.

Does spanking children really teach anything to our children in a positive perspective?

Description : Does spanking children really teach anything to our children in a positive perspective?

Last Answer : I don’t think so, but there is also a difference between a swat, spanking, and hitting. I don’t think spanking and hitting are necessary.

Why do so many parents seem to allow their female children to dress like they are on offer?

Description : Why do so many parents seem to allow their female children to dress like they are on offer?

Last Answer : We have reached a point in society where personifying objects, and objectifying people is the norm. It’s broken on both ends.

What's your take on how children are raised based on the ages of their parents? See details.

Description : What's your take on how children are raised based on the ages of their parents? See details.

Last Answer : answer:@JilltheTooth - The details you provided are perfect to start a discussion. It's dangerous turf, so we all need to keep in mind there are plenty of opinions which are not necessarily true or false ... http://how-old-is-too-old.blogspot.com/2009/01/for-now-prospective-parents-might-want.html

Will my children grow up to be thriving adults? Will I go crazy before they get there? Will we still like each other?

Description : Will my children grow up to be thriving adults? Will I go crazy before they get there? Will we still like each other?

Last Answer : answer:They will always love you. Be the best you can be. Don’t sweat the little stuff. And… RELAX!

Am I being fair in not letting my children have a relationship with their deadbeat father?

Description : Am I being fair in not letting my children have a relationship with their deadbeat father?

Last Answer : First off, good luck. Second, it may well be his GF not wanting him to see his kids but that is not an excuse. He should tell her to pound sand. Third, he may grow up one day and really want ... really ready to be that person. A simple break up with his GF probably won't cut it. Again, good luck.

Should parents who allow their children to become morbidly obese be charged with neglect?

Description : Should parents who allow their children to become morbidly obese be charged with neglect?

Last Answer : Yes

Do children owe their parents anything?

Description : Do children owe their parents anything?

Last Answer : More of that same unconditional love and acceptance of what their parents decide to do with their lives after the children are off on their own. In a perfect world the roles would gradually ... and crumble, their children will make sure they have adequate housing, food, clothing and medical care.

Do parents owe their children anything?

Description : Do parents owe their children anything?

Last Answer : You don’t have any children do you?

Is it harmful to tell children "you are special, just the way you are"?

Description : Is it harmful to tell children "you are special, just the way you are"?

Last Answer : I don't think so. Telling a child they are special just the way they are, does not equal entitlement. I think telling a child that is more so they accept who they are, flaws and all. That first article ... and let a child grow and learn to be an adult. There are life lessons that need to be taught.

What is the best approach to exposing your children to alcohol?

Description : What is the best approach to exposing your children to alcohol?

Last Answer : Not even 3? Surely that’s too young. Alcohol needs to be taboo for children.

Any advice on how to talk to young children about adoption?

Description : Any advice on how to talk to young children about adoption?

Last Answer : We explained it to our children thusly: Every mom and dad has two important jobs. One is to make babies and the other is to help them grow up. Most moms and dads can do both of these ... included everything we had about and from their birth parents and our trips to meet them for the first time.

Why don't parents like their children to have personal lives?

Description : Why don't parents like their children to have personal lives?

Last Answer : answer:I’m on my iPhone, so I can’t look for a link, but I answered a similar question a couple months ago… Perhaps another Ask-public will recall and kindly post a link. I think it was asked by Squirbel or maybe Bulbatron :-/

Is the"generation gap" between Baby Boomers and their children is as great as the one between Boomers and their parents?

Description : Is the"generation gap" between Baby Boomers and their children is as great as the one between Boomers and their parents?

Last Answer : Greater.

Man catches a 14 year old trying to steal his wallet and disciplines him with a whoopin. Right or wrong?

Description : Man catches a 14 year old trying to steal his wallet and disciplines him with a whoopin. Right or wrong?

Last Answer : All kinds of wrong

If your parents ever beat you, do you feel that they were in the right?

Description : If your parents ever beat you, do you feel that they were in the right?

Last Answer : There are always alternatives to spanking or beating. It's just easiest to resort to physical punishment, and not sitting down with the child and make sure there is an understanding why they acted wrong. I ... need other help, that parents alone can't give them. They all need help in that matter.

If you can't rely on them telling you, how do you know what people want?

Description : If you can't rely on them telling you, how do you know what people want?

Last Answer : answer:I wouldn't say anything. I understand your concern, but most likely she very much enjoys time with you. When the right opportunity comes up you can reassure her that she ... in adult relationships, assumptions of this kind and miscommunication are the source of discord and discontent.

How do parents feel if they've had one or more of their adult offspring living with them for awhile?

Description : How do parents feel if they've had one or more of their adult offspring living with them for awhile?

Last Answer : answer:I lived with my parents until last year. My mom said I spoiled her, because I did most of the cooking. She's reminded me of that fact in the past week several times, since I've ... my parents were annoyed sometimes because there were periods where it seemed he wasn't doing anything at all.

What's your opinion on naming twins rhyming names and dressing them alike?

Description : What's your opinion on naming twins rhyming names and dressing them alike?

Last Answer : I think it’s a horrible idea. I went to school with two fraternal twins named Paul and Paula, and they both hated it. Give them their own names and let them be their own people instead of two halves of one whole.

What do you think about this punishment (details inside)?

Description : What do you think about this punishment (details inside)?

Last Answer : Good for dad!

Do you think always being a negative speaker will actually make the things worse or is it not so?

Description : Do you think always being a negative speaker will actually make the things worse or is it not so?

Last Answer : answer:I think neither always nagging nor always praising is good. Constant nagging destroys one’s confidence and detemination, and constant praising makes one judge themselves too high. You need a combination of both. You have to point out their mistakes while appreciating their effort.

Do you think a parent should be able to shut off their kids' cell phones remotely? (see details)

Description : Do you think a parent should be able to shut off their kids' cell phones remotely? (see details)

Last Answer : answer:If your child is allowing you to pay for their phone, and you have the option of shutting the phone down if they don’t respond to your inquiries, then you should feel free to do so. A child using a phone that you are paying for is a dependent, and subject to your rules.

What do you think of this case, where a 200 pound 3rd grader was placed in foster care because (the state said) the mother wasn't doing enough to control his weight?

Description : What do you think of this case, where a 200 pound 3rd grader was placed in foster care because (the state said) the mother wasn't doing enough to control his weight?

Last Answer : The state has a point. The question is whether the kid can be predicted to fare better when thrown to the whims of he state. When does the need for clinical intervention overtake the nurturing of a loving parent?

How young do you think a child could go without their mom for two weeks?

Description : How young do you think a child could go without their mom for two weeks?

Last Answer : I think three is a fine age. It will be a good experience for her. She will miss you, but she will be learning that mommies have a life too.

What do you think of this guy's actions?

Description : What do you think of this guy's actions?

Last Answer : I applaud this man.

What do you think of this situation?

Description : What do you think of this situation?

Last Answer : It could be worse. Kids get hurt. It happens.

What do you think about this potential custody issue?

Description : What do you think about this potential custody issue?

Last Answer : I think it depends on whether the guy is even going to fight for custody. Does she suspect he really will, or is she just using this as an excuse to procrastinate on the divorce?

If you were dating a woman like this, what would you think?

Description : If you were dating a woman like this, what would you think?

Last Answer : I would probably not like someone who would behave that way toward her sick child.

Where are you in your family's birth order and how do you think that effected you growing up?

Description : Where are you in your family's birth order and how do you think that effected you growing up?

Last Answer : Being an only child definitely made me more spoiled lol. My mom couldn’t afford another kid anyway.

What do you think of a genderless upbringing?

Description : What do you think of a genderless upbringing?

Last Answer : answer:The name is Storm? Stripper name. It’s a girl.

What do you think should be the punishment for the "Hot Sauce Mom" who poured hot sauce in her 7 year old son's mouth and put him in a cold shower?

Description : What do you think should be the punishment for the "Hot Sauce Mom" who poured hot sauce in her 7 year old son's mouth and put him in a cold shower?

Last Answer : Someone larger, stronger, and in a position of authority over her should pour hot sauce into her mouth and scream in her face while she’s in a cold shower. Poetic justice.

What do you think about parents that smoke weed?

Description : What do you think about parents that smoke weed?

Last Answer : I don’t think anyone should smoke anything around children. Kids don’t have the choice that adults do to remove themselves from an area where second-hand smoke is present, so it could be considered a form of abuse.

Do you think it's a good idea for a mother of a teenage son to advise the son not to date girls, and just concentrate on school?

Description : Do you think it's a good idea for a mother of a teenage son to advise the son not to date girls, and just concentrate on school?

Last Answer : answer:This kind of parenting is begging for a teen pregnancy. I mean, I’m all about encouraging the kid to focus on school but ordering them not to date is asking for rebellion.

Do you think he was looking at me the wrong way or am I overreacting?

Description : Do you think he was looking at me the wrong way or am I overreacting?

Last Answer : excuse me for being naive, but what does under my wife beater mean?

Do you think a single mother with a boy should date?

Description : Do you think a single mother with a boy should date?

Last Answer : I don’t see what would be wrong with some very very casual dates to get started—maybe some widows or divorced dads with kids about your age.

Do you think preschoolers benefit from childcare?

Description : Do you think preschoolers benefit from childcare?

Last Answer : Childcare will not hurt your child. However, you need to pick a wonderful place for your child, a place where they will pay attention to her and not just plunk her in front of a tv for the time ... attention to her and her needs-take it slow if that is what she wants. She may surprise you though.

What do you think of this style of parenting?

Description : What do you think of this style of parenting?

Last Answer : i approve

Do you think having a secret facebook account is safe?

Description : Do you think having a secret facebook account is safe?

Last Answer : Nothing is safe on the internet. You don’t say how old this niece of yours is; may I inquire upon that? If she’s above the age of 13 you have no business betraying her trust like that. Do her parents know about Facebook and it’s privacy policies? It’s sounding like you don’t even know yourself.

What do you think of "those" parents?

Description : What do you think of "those" parents?

Last Answer : I think parents who do not immunize are not being logical and could experience great heartache. I am totally opposed to antibacterial soaps and cleaners. Currently, there have been MRSA cases in seven local ... think there is a balance in keeping your child safe and let your child be in the world.

I am doing a paper on arguing value, and i cannot think of a topic for the life of me, what are your honest opinions about parent accountability laws?

Description : I am doing a paper on arguing value, and i cannot think of a topic for the life of me, what are your honest opinions about parent accountability laws?

Last Answer : As long as the kids are minors, then the parents have to be held accountable for what they do. It doesn't matter how mature the kids seem, they have no say in what they do and cannot ... it would not only teach the child, but it would force the parents to develop some sense of accountability.

What do you think about allowing 17 year old's to buy a morning-after pill without a prescription?

Description : What do you think about allowing 17 year old's to buy a morning-after pill without a prescription?

Last Answer : Better than unwanted teen pregnancies.

Do you think that Homer Simpson is a good father?

Description : Do you think that Homer Simpson is a good father?

Last Answer : D’oh! I mean no!

Do you think the rule makes sence?

Description : Do you think the rule makes sence?

Last Answer : Harsh…. That’s all I can say.