Do you think there is a "mind" or is there just "brain"?

Do you think there is a "mind" or is there just "brain"?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

I may be missing the point entirely, but exactly why is it that even the mention that a brain is damaged means that there is no longer any mind?
by

Related questions

What is the difference between mind and reason?

Description : What is the difference between mind and reason?

Last Answer : The mind is the mechanism; reason is the process.

Does the human understanding of time exist outside of the human mind?

Description : Does the human understanding of time exist outside of the human mind?

Last Answer : answer:Other creatures are aware of time but not in the sophisticated way humans understand it. A dog would have little use for a watch but will know when it is time for walkies or time to be ... particles that make up the universe the beginning and the end of the universe seem like the same moment.

Why is the mind also referred to as "soul"?

Description : Why is the mind also referred to as "soul"?

Last Answer : It is not. They are two different things.

What are your thoughts to this classic mind-body and personal identity thought experiment?

Description : What are your thoughts to this classic mind-body and personal identity thought experiment?

Last Answer : answer:It's a little late in the evening to think this one all the way through, but I can certainly answer this part: What if 1 atom was missing, would you still be the same person? How many ... start to decompose and fertilize some plot of earth, I imagine I won't feel quite so much like myself.

Would there be a mathematics if there were no mind to contemplate it?

Description : Would there be a mathematics if there were no mind to contemplate it?

Last Answer : Great question! I would have to say the math would be there, even if there were no humans there to do the equations. For example E=mc^2, would still apply, even if we did not know about it. The same goes for πr^2. The circle still exists.

If you have a brain chemistry disorder, do you want a cure?

Description : If you have a brain chemistry disorder, do you want a cure?

Last Answer : I will go so far as to say hells yes. And no, it’s too boring to talk about…all i know is i am not going to let it get in the way of having fun on my Florida Keys trip!

What influence does brain chemistry have on the soul?

Description : What influence does brain chemistry have on the soul?

Last Answer : This GQ requires some pondering. I hope to get back to you later on this.

How did consciousness arise from the brain?

Description : How did consciousness arise from the brain?

Last Answer : Define consciousness please.

What separates the soul from the brain, or are they both the same thing?

Description : What separates the soul from the brain, or are they both the same thing?

Last Answer : answer:You're going to need to define soul very carefully for this question to make sense. Same for true self . It seems the jury is still out on what either of those terms means. But all ... brain was like when you were born, but that information will find no expression in your body any more.

What's the metadata for a brain?

Description : What's the metadata for a brain?

Last Answer : I don’t organize my own thinking. I don’t think it’d be possible for me. Come to think of it, I don’t know if that’s really possible for anyone. Then again, I could just be saying that because it’s really that impossible for me.

Does "Right" and "Just" (justified / Justice served) equate?

Description : Does "Right" and "Just" (justified / Justice served) equate?

Last Answer : I suppose it’s all relative. I mean there’s jaywalking or the Wall st mortgage fraud that nearly collapsed the world economy.

How would you respond if someone told you that they just became enlightened?

Description : How would you respond if someone told you that they just became enlightened?

Last Answer : “The moment you think you’re enlightened, you’re not.”

Do you agree that praise and blame are just random?

Description : Do you agree that praise and blame are just random?

Last Answer : Therer are studies on morality and ethics. These aren't random. There are universal ideas that the majority of humans agree upon BUT what occurs in reality are contexts that bring paradox into the ... what things led to a less than desirable outcome and change these things for the next time.

How accurate do you think this quote from a famous Indian Guru is?

Description : How accurate do you think this quote from a famous Indian Guru is?

Last Answer : I don’t think ‘retarded’ is the right word. I would have used ‘stupid’. Or maybe ‘simple’.

What do you think of the hippie movement and hedonism?

Description : What do you think of the hippie movement and hedonism?

Last Answer : A couple of points. The Hippie movement of the 1960s-1970s is NOT the Hippie Movement of 2019. I don't know what sort of event you are describing in your question. The Hippie movement of ... re either paranoid or overly cynical. Not everything needs a rationale. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

What do you think about this video as an argument against determinism?

Description : What do you think about this video as an argument against determinism?

Last Answer : As I understand it, Determinism is the belief that all events are caused, or acted upon, by prior events. Nothing happens without cause. I think that the video posits an argument for Indeterminism; that is ... are not caused by prior events and that may, or may not, have effect on future events.

Do you think it’s unusual for someone to understand complex and abstract philosophical ideas but still have a learning disability in math?

Description : Do you think it’s unusual for someone to understand complex and abstract philosophical ideas but still have a learning disability in math?

Last Answer : Math is built on logic and on itself. Most students fail at math when they fall behind and try to do math without the more fundimental math. Then most give up. Also the Matrix was alluding to ... math, because the class was too perfect. No unknowns for fun answers are in the back of the textbook

What do you think of this analogy? (Details)

Description : What do you think of this analogy? (Details)

Last Answer : Men are like pigs.

What do you think about Texas' new abortion rules? (Details )

Description : What do you think about Texas' new abortion rules? (Details )

Last Answer : “I believe it is imperative to establish higher standards that reflect our respect for the sanctity of life,” he said in the email, from the state that looks for any way it can to increase the rate of state executions.

Do you think normality is subjective?

Description : Do you think normality is subjective?

Last Answer : Yes, principally because it is defined by the observer. If it was objective, normality would have a generally agreed upon definition.

What do you think about this approach to talking about morality?

Description : What do you think about this approach to talking about morality?

Last Answer : answer:I will use religion to illustrate my thoughts on this. Most if not all religions have the same moral obligation tools in their tool boxes. It will be how they employ these tools based on ... a discussion. Neither one is right or wrong our moral obligation tools are just in a different order.

Do you think that we encounter 'bad' people in our lives?

Description : Do you think that we encounter 'bad' people in our lives?

Last Answer : answer:I think people may be bad for us for whatever reason - they're opportunists, they're addicts, they're users, whatever, a variety of reasons. If you can realize that and keep a distance, it will ... bad for you, for whatever reason, realizing that is enough for you to cut the ties and move on.

Do you think that lying should be a moral concern?

Description : Do you think that lying should be a moral concern?

Last Answer : Of course it should be a moral concern,and lying to spare one feelings is one thing,but politicians and lawyers have made careers out of it and that is bad.

Don't you think that we are all one?

Description : Don't you think that we are all one?

Last Answer : Yes, all life forms sprang from the same source of life giving components. Some organisms evolved into humans, others mammals, plant life, sea life, etc. We are all one, meaning that every ... the roulette wheel of evolution and we could just as easily manifested as a watermelon or an earthworm.

Do you think the anthropic principle helps or hurts the argument for God?

Description : Do you think the anthropic principle helps or hurts the argument for God?

Last Answer : Absolutely not. Oh darn, this question goes two ways. Hmmmm. Okay, lemme put it this way. Just because the Earth is just the right distance form the sun to be perfect for life to exist here, ... our little corner of it didn't just happen by accident with no intelligent thought or design at. all.

What do you think of these nerdy jokes?

Description : What do you think of these nerdy jokes?

Last Answer : Made me laugh, thanks! Descartes before the horse and all that…

In your own personal opinion, do you think I am insane?

Description : In your own personal opinion, do you think I am insane?

Last Answer : answer:Reminds me of a saying I’m particularly fond of: The difference between me and you is, I know I’m crazy. (I’m very serious.)

What would Immanuel Kant think of organ sale?

Description : What would Immanuel Kant think of organ sale?

Last Answer : I think the government made it illegal to keep desparate people safe from predators. They offer to buy a kidney, well they also have orders in for a heart, a liver, a lung (maybe two). What is to keep them from fulfilling those orders from the same person who was offered payment for a kidney?

What do you think about?

Description : What do you think about?

Last Answer : I gravitate to thoughts about human nature and the workings of the mind.

What do you think of Wittgenstein's statement, Whereof one cannot speak, thereon one must remain silent?

Description : What do you think of Wittgenstein's statement, Whereof one cannot speak, thereon one must remain silent?

Last Answer : Solid advice, oh too often ignored!!

What is the difference between teaching a person how to think and teaching someone what to think?

Description : What is the difference between teaching a person how to think and teaching someone what to think?

Last Answer : Well you maintain a kind of detachment with the former kind of like when you read any article, try to figure out who the audience is, what the evidence provided is and whether it's consistent ... you tell them what their opinion should be after reading the article is telling them what to think.

What do you think philosophers and other famous figures would be like online?

Description : What do you think philosophers and other famous figures would be like online?

Last Answer : answer:What…, Simone is a philosopher? They would love Fluther and @wundayatta’s answer would be short compared to theirs. ~ We would see threads with contribution numbers in the threehundreds.

Do you think we are all seperate beings operating in a vacuum, or are we all one, or is it something in between?

Description : Do you think we are all seperate beings operating in a vacuum, or are we all one, or is it something in between?

Last Answer : Well we weem to be individual specks of awareness with the potential to connect & exchange info, so the connections have to be made, they don’t seem to just be there. It is hard to say what we are in this respect…

Steppenwolf the Novel. What do you think about it?

Description : Steppenwolf the Novel. What do you think about it?

Last Answer : I remember liking it. I don’t remember anything about the story though.

What do you think of the phrase "openness to the unbidden"?

Description : What do you think of the phrase "openness to the unbidden"?

Last Answer : Ah, my wish for pundits (I hate them) everywhere.

Do you think that the Law of One is legitimate?

Description : Do you think that the Law of One is legitimate?

Last Answer : answer:I don't think it makes a difference whether they are authentic or not. You must judge for yourself whether they are valuable to you, or not. To say that some idea comes from some authority no one ... them. If they do speak to you, then keep on reading. That is the only legitimacy you need.

What do you think those in late middle age should do with their lives?

Description : What do you think those in late middle age should do with their lives?

Last Answer : I don’t think the issue is related to age and I’ll leave it at that.

What would the child you once were think of the adult you are today?

Description : What would the child you once were think of the adult you are today?

Last Answer : He’d be pretty disappointed. But he wouldn’t understand, either.

Do you think you'd be friends with yourself?

Description : Do you think you'd be friends with yourself?

Last Answer : We would be lovers.

What do you think of ''deconstruction'' approach?

Description : What do you think of ''deconstruction'' approach?

Last Answer : This sounds like you thought about it. :) I like to think that the universe comes in pairs or is balanced. I try to apply this in my life. Helps me make sense of things.

Why do you think people disagree with you at all?

Description : Why do you think people disagree with you at all?

Last Answer : The things they find important in life are probably different than the things I find important in life.

Will the children that are born into the age of the internet think in a more insightful and enlightened way by the time they turn 18?

Description : Will the children that are born into the age of the internet think in a more insightful and enlightened way by the time they turn 18?

Last Answer : I don’t think it has anything to do with evolution. Evolution requires many, many generations. Changes wrought by the internet are not heritable, they don’t happen at the DNA level.

What do you think of the saying "A little knowledge is a dangerous thing?

Description : What do you think of the saying "A little knowledge is a dangerous thing?

Last Answer : answer:A lot of knowledge can be a dangerous thing as well. It just depends on what you know. Ever heard of the saying, what you don't know won't hurt you? If you're ambitious and/or ... might blow up in your face. Taking risks is important, but knowing what you're doing is important as well.

What do you think is the basis of all human motivation?

Description : What do you think is the basis of all human motivation?

Last Answer : Most folks are driven by fear and greed.

Is there anything you've done in your life that you think of certain things you do now as penance or self-punishment for?

Description : Is there anything you've done in your life that you think of certain things you do now as penance or self-punishment for?

Last Answer : Everyone can relate with your comment Snarp! Here is my take on the subject. We all makes mistakes, the secret is not to make the same mistake twice! Seems like your learned from your mistake, give it up and go on! Burdens are not meant to be carried your whole life. Be happy with thy ownself!

Do you think "I think, therefore I am" is true?

Description : Do you think "I think, therefore I am" is true?

Last Answer : @Russter I’ll have to think about that.

Are we, who we think, that our friends think, that we think, that we are?

Description : Are we, who we think, that our friends think, that we think, that we are?

Last Answer : We are ourselves. How someone else sees you is true to them. It is their perception of you and all they will know. How you see yourself is who you are. How your friend sees you is who ... knows your experiences, or your motivations better than you. Nobody has the right to judge your life but you

A thought experiment about the nature of self (see details)- what do you think?

Description : A thought experiment about the nature of self (see details)- what do you think?

Last Answer : People who believe in a soul might have a problem with this type of thing. Since I believe that I'm just a collection of cells in the same condition that would be accurately duplicated, yes, ... of yourself isn't you because the machine destroyed some divine part of you that it cannot recreate.

Anyone else think the concept of karma is inherently flawed?

Description : Anyone else think the concept of karma is inherently flawed?

Last Answer : I asked the same question three days ago. The general agreement was that there is no such thing as karma

Science is organized knowledge. Wisdom is organized life. What do you think about this quote from Immanuel Kant?

Description : Science is organized knowledge. Wisdom is organized life. What do you think about this quote from Immanuel Kant?

Last Answer : It’s cute.