Anyone want to complain about the Harry Potter movies' inaccuracies?

Anyone want to complain about the Harry Potter movies' inaccuracies?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:This isn’t a specific fact that was changed, but there is a definite lack of depth in the movies that the books had. People who hadn’t read the book and saw Order of the Phoenix didn’t really get that Snape was getting harassed by Harry’s dad as a kid. It was just glossed over. I think Harry had to struggle with realizing that his father might not have been this perfect heroic guy everyone told him, Harry finds out he has more in common with Snape than he thought. There were many other inward struggles Harry went through in the book that just didn’t translate well into movie form.
by

Related questions

Have you read the last Harry Potter book?

Description : Have you read the last Harry Potter book?

Last Answer : answer:Please be specific about which book you are asking about. I have read Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, and found it a fitting end to the 7 book series. We just got Harpy Potter and the Cursed Child, ... Harry has his own kids, and I am waiting for my son to finish it so I can read it.

SPOILER ZONE for Harry Potter and the Cursed Child?

Description : SPOILER ZONE for Harry Potter and the Cursed Child?

Last Answer : answer:Because it was necessary to the plot. Basically. What? You want more than that? This isn’t JK you know.:)

Harry Potter or Twilight, which one are you?

Description : Harry Potter or Twilight, which one are you?

Last Answer : answer:I’m like Switzerland. I’m neutral. (altho the HP books have a much better and imaginative vocabulary range.)

Harry Potter fans, are you trying to gain early access to Pottermore?

Description : Harry Potter fans, are you trying to gain early access to Pottermore?

Last Answer : Not yet, but I will when I have a moment.

Why does the first Harry Potter Book have a different name in the US?

Description : Why does the first Harry Potter Book have a different name in the US?

Last Answer : I believe it’s because it was assumed (probably correctly) by the publisher that Americans in general would be ignorant of the meaning and lore of the Philosopher’s Stone.

Can any Harry Potter fans please help me with decorating ideas?

Description : Can any Harry Potter fans please help me with decorating ideas?

Last Answer : answer:Create some makeshift tapestries. Hang area rugs on the wall. ~ Keep the lighting to a minimum. Using only candlelight would probably be your best bet.

What genre are the Harry Potter books?

Description : What genre are the Harry Potter books?

Last Answer : Fantasy?

Twilight vs Harry Potter?

Description : Twilight vs Harry Potter?

Last Answer : Harry Potter!!! More action, more creativity, less soppiness (except for that one ghost in the girl’s lavatory, Moaning Myrtle), and still some romance.

Why are books likes Harry Potter so inspiring.

Description : Why are books likes Harry Potter so inspiring.

Last Answer : I knew they were entertaining, but not inspiring. I guess it’s supposed to show kids to believe in themselves, no matter what.

Why are there 7 Harry potter books but there are 8 movies?

Description : Why are there 7 Harry potter books but there are 8 movies?

Last Answer : Because the last book "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows" was split into two movies

how many harry potter movies is there?

Description : how many harry potter movies is there?

Last Answer : 8

Has anyone been to the new Harry Potter land at Universal, Florida?

Description : Has anyone been to the new Harry Potter land at Universal, Florida?

Last Answer : answer:I have been there, and I definitely don't regret going! The candy/trick shop is crowded but there wasn't really a line. But Ollivander's, on the other hand, is a different story. ... replicas of the flying car and the Hogwarts Express. I really enjoyed it and would definitely recommend it!

Have your reading habits or those of anyone you know been changed--or created--as a result of the Harry Potter books?

Description : Have your reading habits or those of anyone you know been changed--or created--as a result of the Harry Potter books?

Last Answer : Nope. My sisters both read the books, they enjoyed them. I never touched them. I don’t like fiction. I don’t know anyone that started reading just to read the series, and I don’t know anyone that read them that wouldn’t normally care to read that sort of thing. I think that’s what you’re asking.

If sharing movies and music is illegal, is it illegal to borrow a friends book?

Description : If sharing movies and music is illegal, is it illegal to borrow a friends book?

Last Answer : Sharing movies and music is not illegal in the sense you are describing. However, many people use the word “share” to refer to making copies. In that sense, yes, it is illegal to photocopy your friend’s book for your own use.

We did movies, what are your favorite holiday books?

Description : We did movies, what are your favorite holiday books?

Last Answer : As kids my family took turns reading pages of The Night Before Christmas aloud, then one parent would tuck me in and read The Polar Express. Other favorites are Hurry Home Grandma, Max ... 's Christmas Max and Angelina of Max's Dragon Shirt and Angelina Ballerina fame, respectively.

Do you like to read Stephen King, or see his movies?

Description : Do you like to read Stephen King, or see his movies?

Last Answer : I do like to read Stephen King books, and see his movies. Although I haven't read all of his books or seen all of his movies by a long shot!!! I do, however, have all of the books written by Raymond ... Lisa Gardner, Lisa Unger you know, I could go on and on, I'm a confirmed bookoholic I'm afraid!!

Is there a television show or movie that is set in (supposedly) your region? If so, what inaccuracies take you out of the story?

Description : Is there a television show or movie that is set in (supposedly) your region? If so, what inaccuracies take you out of the story?

Last Answer : The FX show “Justified” takes place about ten minutes away from where I live. Haven’t seen the show, but I’ve heard it’s really good.

Tightly knit metal braid wire can be used with a printed circuit board when ___________. A. conductor flexibility is required B. desoldering components in the circuit C. electrically produced magnetic fluxes would cause inaccuracies in adjacent components D. reactance in the circuit must be kept to a minimum

Description : Tightly knit metal braid wire can be used with a printed circuit board when ___________. A. conductor flexibility is required B. desoldering components in the circuit C. electrically produced magnetic ... cause inaccuracies in adjacent components D. reactance in the circuit must be kept to a minimum

Last Answer : Answer: B

Who is the author of the Harry Potter series?

Description : Who is the author of the Harry Potter series?

Last Answer : Answer: J.K. Rowling

Have you read all seven of the Harry Potter books?

Description : Have you read all seven of the Harry Potter books?

Last Answer : Never read any of them, nor seen the films. Not my thing..a niece of mine a big fan though. To each their own I suppose.

Do you think the Harry Potter books turned more kids into readers?

Description : Do you think the Harry Potter books turned more kids into readers?

Last Answer : Yes. Temporarily any way. My girls and I are voracious readers. Chris never cared for it. I walked in the living room one day, and he was curled up in my reading spot, spell bound by Harry Potter!!!!!

According to you, what's the most realistic portrayal of time travel? The one of "Harry Potter 3" by J. K. Rowling, or that of the TV series "Lost"?

Description : According to you, what's the most realistic portrayal of time travel? The one of "Harry Potter 3" by J. K. Rowling, or that of the TV series "Lost"?

Last Answer : The last mission in the Iconian War story arc in the game “Star Trek Online”.

Harry Potter pop quiz question?

Description : Harry Potter pop quiz question?

Last Answer : This scene came to mind first, though the room looks way bigger in the movie scene than in your pic so I’m not sure.

Am I a Harry Potter fan?

Description : Am I a Harry Potter fan?

Last Answer : answer:Do you think about Harry Potter all day? Do your eyes sparkle when someone talk about Harry Potter? Do you collect Harry Potter related things like posters? Being a fan is different than just like . ... . When you like, you don't have that enthusiasm. You only enjoy the books and the movies.

Harry Potter fans: Where does Dumbledore apologize to Harry for forgetting what it was like to be young?

Description : Harry Potter fans: Where does Dumbledore apologize to Harry for forgetting what it was like to be young?

Last Answer : Harry, I owe you an explanation, said Dumbledore. An explanation of an old man's mistakes. For I see now that what I have done, and not done, with regard to you, bears all the hallmarks ... seem to have forgotten, lately -Albus Dumbledore, Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (Chapter 37)

Which Harry Potter character whould make a good fancy dress idea?

Description : Which Harry Potter character whould make a good fancy dress idea?

Last Answer : http://elouai.com/harrypotter/characters.php VOLDEMORT!

Do the Harry Potter books rank as great children's literature?

Description : Do the Harry Potter books rank as great children's literature?

Last Answer : Only history will tell. What will kids read in 2040? Astrid Lindgren or Joanne Rowling? Here’s my bet: Astrid Lindgren.

What did **** Voldemort say in his spell when he tried to kill Harry Potter in the last movie?

Description : What did lord Voldemort say in his spell when he tried to kill Harry Potter in the last movie?

Last Answer : Avada Kedavra is the killing curse. It is one of the three unforgivable curses.

Harry Potter fans: Did you cry during the Deathly Hallows?

Description : Harry Potter fans: Did you cry during the Deathly Hallows?

Last Answer : Nope. It was a good end but not that good.

Harry Potter fans: Is it known how and when Peter Pettigrew came into the Weasleys' lives as Scabbers?

Description : Harry Potter fans: Is it known how and when Peter Pettigrew came into the Weasleys' lives as Scabbers?

Last Answer : answer:According the this wiki article Pettigrew went into hiding when Death Eaters suspected him of being a traitor (After the fall of What's-His-Face). He chose a wizarding family so he could keep ... the Weasley family. Sounds like he imposed himself upon them (as a rat) until he was discovered,

If given the chance to create a title for a Harry Potter book, yours will be Harry Potter and-?

Description : If given the chance to create a title for a Harry Potter book, yours will be Harry Potter and-?

Last Answer : Harry Potter and the Naughty Invisibility Cloak User.

In Harry Potter, what does ********* mean to the wizards?

Description : In Harry Potter, what does Christmas mean to the wizards?

Last Answer : I don’t know what the official answer is, but I always thought that because Christmas is widely celebrated in the UK, and that’s where the story takes place, that’s why they celebrate Christmas.

Has anybody been to the Harry Potter theme park in Orlando? If so, what did you think of it?

Description : Has anybody been to the Harry Potter theme park in Orlando? If so, what did you think of it?

Last Answer : I’m sorry, I haven’t been, but this reviewer seems to hate it.

Harry Potter fans: if you could have any one item other than a wand from the world of Harry Potter in your real life, what would it be?

Description : Harry Potter fans: if you could have any one item other than a wand from the world of Harry Potter in your real life, what would it be?

Last Answer : An owl. Specifically, Harry’s owl. I love that owl.

I heard that J.K. Rowling was sued $400 million for stealing the Harry Potter figures from a Canadian author…what happened to the case?

Description : I heard that J.K. Rowling was sued $400 million for stealing the Harry Potter figures from a Canadian author…what happened to the case?

Last Answer : dismissed due to lack of evidence.

What mythology has JK Rowling borrowed from other sources to construct the saga of Harry Potter?

Description : What mythology has JK Rowling borrowed from other sources to construct the saga of Harry Potter?

Last Answer : Well, for one, Nicholas Flamel was a real person. For another, the Philosopher's Stone ( Sorcerer's Stone in the American edition, presumably because we aren't expected to know our cultural heritage) is ... ), with its potions, charms, spells, incantations, etc., etc., is about as old as humanity.

Do you enjoy suspending your disbelief in order to watch a good Harry Potter or Captain Kangaroo flick?

Description : Do you enjoy suspending your disbelief in order to watch a good Harry Potter or Captain Kangaroo flick?

Last Answer : YES, I like a lot of fantasy books and shows. George R R Martin’s Song of Ice and Fire has me hooked. If they make an of it into a movie I’ll be there. Deathly Hallows was the best HP book imho.

Harry Potter question: Why couldn't Harry see the thestrals until Order of the Phoenix?

Description : Harry Potter question: Why couldn't Harry see the thestrals until Order of the Phoenix?

Last Answer : how much does a one year old remember? this is what i thought when this came up.

What books should I read if I love Harry Potter?

Description : What books should I read if I love Harry Potter?

Last Answer : Try His Dark Materials, a trilogy by Philip Pullman. The Golden Compass is volume 1. My husband and I did the entire HP series as a read-aloud in weekly installments that spanned many months. We did ... series the same way and enjoyed it very much, even though I would have liked to fix the ending.

What are the dragons in Harry Potter called?

Description : What are the dragons in Harry Potter called?

Last Answer : Oh, I think you're talking about hippogriffs perhaps? Those are seen in one of the earlier books (maybe the third, the one with Sirius getting out of prison), Hagrid takes care of it. The exact one is ... . There aren't really other dragons in HP as far as I can remember, but I could be wrong.

What happens in the new Harry Potter book?

Description : What happens in the new Harry Potter book?

Last Answer : Check out the Muggle book on the newest release which is the last book in the series. Hence it's popularity. There are many predictions in it. You can expect to lose a major character I hear in the final series.

Continuity question for Harry Potter 7 readers.

Description : Continuity question for Harry Potter 7 readers.

Last Answer : Remember how in the Chamber of Secrets with the basilisk, Harry pulled the sword out of the Sorting Hat too and used it to kill the snake? Then later he learned that "only a true Gryffindor" could have ... . (Interesting that both times the sword came out of the hat it was used to kill a snake!)

Which Harry Potter did you like the best?

Description : Which Harry Potter did you like the best?

Last Answer : goblet of fire

Who is the writer of Harry Potter -Do You Know?

Description : Who is the writer of Harry Potter -Do You Know?

Last Answer : J.K.ROWLING British creator, maker of the well known and widely praised Harry Potter series

4. What is the name of the fourth book in the Harry Potter series? -Music and Art

Description : 4. What is the name of the fourth book in the Harry Potter series? -Music and Art

Last Answer : 4. Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire

Harry Potter or Hunger Games?

Description : Harry Potter or Hunger Games?

Last Answer : Harry Potter

Is Harry Potter appropriate for kids 7?

Description : Is Harry Potter appropriate for kids 7?

Last Answer : Depends. How old are the kids? How mature are theirpersonalities? What would you feel comfortable with themseeing?

is magic actually real or is the wonderful world of harry potter just a kids fantasy?

Description : is magic actually real or is the wonderful world of harry potter just a kids fantasy?

Last Answer : Magic is just a child's fantasy.

Do you think Madam Hooch in Harry Potter could be a lesbian?

Description : Do you think Madam Hooch in Harry Potter could be a lesbian?

Last Answer : I want to explain myself a bit... I forgot it in the context.I would like her to be, I have always had a big crush on her, so I demand honest opinions from other people.Physically speaking, she ... and interesting and we hardly ever see them and we don't know anything about them ! Life is unfair !

What is Harry Potter ?

Last Answer : Harry Potter is a "children's book".