Is it ethical for medical doctors to strike, withholding even emergency care from patients?

Is it ethical for medical doctors to strike, withholding even emergency care from patients?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

It’s a direct violation of the vaunted Hippocratic oath for a doctor to withhold services for any reason other than harming the patient. Do physicians still swear the oath?
by

Related questions

When doctors make patients come in to get test results, is it ever good news?

Description : When doctors make patients come in to get test results, is it ever good news?

Last Answer : answer:It's always good news for the doctor's billing system. I get a PSA test regularly and am informed enough to know what the results mean. My doctor's office now posts results online at ... an office that is. Things will not change until you, the customer, start demanding it. Good luck.

Do you think doctors should be held responsible for their patients overdosing?

Description : Do you think doctors should be held responsible for their patients overdosing?

Last Answer : A great big, very loud NO.

Where can I find a Medical Doctor's (M.D.'s) who has a Ph.D's as well in Medical Science?

Description : Where can I find a Medical Doctor's (M.D.'s) who has a Ph.D's as well in Medical Science?

Last Answer : I think medical researchers are usually MD PhD’s. I’m not 100% sure though.

What other major medical institutions, besides Johns Hopkins, salary their doctors rather than pay on a fee for service basis?

Description : What other major medical institutions, besides Johns Hopkins, salary their doctors rather than pay on a fee for service basis?

Last Answer : Mayo is also salary-based. There is an argument (and a strong one) that salary-ing doctors is a good, good idea, because if you pay them by patients seen or by tests/etc proscribed, they ... large salaries to its doctors because it saves a lot of money by not running millions of needless tests.

How would you feel if a medical device (or medication) you relied on was recalled for harming patients?

Description : How would you feel if a medical device (or medication) you relied on was recalled for harming patients?

Last Answer : answer:I can tell you exactly how I'd feel, because I've been there! I've had issues with two different drugs in the past. One was a painkiller I had taken twice daily for quite some ... . I hope he learned to pay closer attention to people's medications when they're having an unexplained problem.

Should doctors be allowed to refuse non-emergency treatments to patients unless they lose weight or stop smoking?

Description : Should doctors be allowed to refuse non-emergency treatments to patients unless they lose weight or stop smoking?

Last Answer : Doctors should not be allowed to refuse treatment to anyone.

Even if you're not from there, what do you think about the Jersey senate passing the medical marijuana bill?

Description : Even if you're not from there, what do you think about the Jersey senate passing the medical marijuana bill?

Last Answer : I am from New Jersey – didn’t know about that. Ooh, ooh starting to feel a little sick. :-)

Do you think the actors who play doctors or nurses in hospital series know ANYTHING about the medical terms they flaunt, or the emergency/surgical procedures they carry out?

Description : Do you think the actors who play doctors or nurses in hospital series know ANYTHING about the medical terms they flaunt, or the emergency/surgical procedures they carry out?

Last Answer : answer:Generally speaking, no. I've heard several of them on talk shows (this is a common question they're asked) and they are quick to state honestly that no one should ever assume that they know anything ... several month season. That's a lot. I'm amazed they get as much accomplished as they do.

Is there a way to find out who the best doctors in a given field really are?

Description : Is there a way to find out who the best doctors in a given field really are?

Last Answer : Ask other doctors and nurses. Doctors are often considered good if they have good bedside manner. That is practically irrelevant. I want someone who is a good scientist and is willing to dig and who ... friends or kids' doctors etc who they would go for. It is the private reputations you seek.

If you had clean urine and added a crushed hydro into it would it show on a drug test at a doctors office?

Description : If you had clean urine and added a crushed hydro into it would it show on a drug test at a doctors office?

Last Answer : It would show up but the concentration would be way off what should show up since it hasn’t been through any filtering in your body. Why would you need to test positive for it?

To what extent can doctors treat themselves?

Description : To what extent can doctors treat themselves?

Last Answer : answer: For, even if the rule is justified and codes of ethics are explicit in this regard, the rule doesn't hold up in everyday life, as most physicians have already broken the rule at one time ... self-treatment occurs much more frequently than we think and much more often than we admit. Pub Med

What's with doctors just (for the most part) treating symptoms instead of finding the root causes of the issue?

Description : What's with doctors just (for the most part) treating symptoms instead of finding the root causes of the issue?

Last Answer : It really depends on if it's a short term issue or a long term issue (from my experience). With your headache example, if it's the first time having the problem (and it's just a headache with no other ... it more. It's far more likely that it's just a short term thing than a long term/serious issue.

What's the point of making a doctor's appointment if they never see you at that specific time?

Description : What's the point of making a doctor's appointment if they never see you at that specific time?

Last Answer : According to doctors. they are often dealing with emergencies, etc. I get that, but I still feel like our time as patients is less valued than theirs.

If you are an organ donor, do ER doctors not try as hard to save you?

Description : If you are an organ donor, do ER doctors not try as hard to save you?

Last Answer : Don’t they work on a bonus scheme , the more parts they harvest the bigger the pay ?

From a med student's point of view, which doctors are the lightweights?

Description : From a med student's point of view, which doctors are the lightweights?

Last Answer : Chiropractors? Or so I’ve heard… What kind of school do they go to? Is this even a med profession? I don’t know. Note: I am not a med student, but felt like answering anyway.

Why is there a serpant on the doctors symbol?

Description : Why is there a serpant on the doctors symbol?

Last Answer : That would be the Rod of Asclepius... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rod_of_Asclepius

What role should the patient's opinion play in treatment?

Description : What role should the patient's opinion play in treatment?

Last Answer : I guess it would depend on the flexibility of the doctor and her judgment of the patient’s suggestion. I don’t have a hard and fast answer except to believe that a patient has the right to refuse treatment.

Why do patients lie to their physician(s)

Description : Why do patients lie to their physician(s)

Last Answer : If it’s an addiction of some type it may be just from embarrassment that they can’t overcome it. They’d rather take the risk than admit a weakness.

Does medicine ever change the rules to gain patients?

Description : Does medicine ever change the rules to gain patients?

Last Answer : More studies have come out showing that blood sugars in the 120–140 range, which we consider “glucose intolerance” can: 1) cause complications if present for a long time and 2) lead to frank diabetes if not corrected. That’s why the thresholds were adjusted downward.

How many patients does a doctor typically have?

Description : How many patients does a doctor typically have?

Last Answer : If they’re just on clinic duty, chances are they probably won’t, but if it’s more specialized, let’s so an oncologist, they’re probably going to remember the patient because they will see them more often. As for how many exactly, I can’t say.

Do patients think that surgeons are generally less congenial as compared to other physicians?

Description : Do patients think that surgeons are generally less congenial as compared to other physicians?

Last Answer : I haven’t had a surgeon I’ve met so far who hasn’t been a wonderful person to me. My general physician on the other hand is kind of a tepid personality but I know it’s his work demeanor because when he’s socialized with my family then he’s been very warm.

Do you think that someone's ability to access healthcare (including emergency situations such as accidents) should be based upon their ability to pay, for example if they have no health insurance?

Description : Do you think that someone's ability to access healthcare (including emergency situations such as accidents) should be based upon their ability to pay, for example if they have no health insurance?

Last Answer : Nah, base it on race. White's only hospitals, black only hospitals, yellow only hospitals, etc. I'm in rare form today. My apologies. Didn't the guy that figured out blood transfusions die outside of a ... back some other way. @jca I'm waiting for someone to hand me my head for that answer. :)

At an Emergency Room, will they spot THC (main psychoactive substance of marijuana) in standard blood and urine tests? If so, what are the consequences?

Description : At an Emergency Room, will they spot THC (main psychoactive substance of marijuana) in standard blood and urine tests? If so, what are the consequences?

Last Answer : Pretty sure there gonna be on to him. Probably didn’t even need the test to know. Luckly having THC in you system isen’t a crime.

None Emergency The pill Good Will ?

Description : I Emergency Pill To eat Would like But To understand I can't Which one? Good Will be And Price How much? Wear.

Last Answer : You Ipil To eat Can. That No At the pharmacy Found Goes. Price Wear 100 Money

Should doctors in South Africa go on strike?

Description : Should doctors in South Africa go on strike?

Last Answer : Doctors should never go on strike

Been Super Anxious, Having Migraines and Been Paranoid/Having Panic Attacks After Quitting Medical Pot?

Description : Been Super Anxious, Having Migraines and Been Paranoid/Having Panic Attacks After Quitting Medical Pot?

Last Answer : THC does not store in your fat. LSD has been known to store and come back, but THC does not. Nor is it hallucinogenic. Paranoia happens sometimes while using it, but the effects are gone by the time ... doctor, it will be such a huge relief. Hang on, love. The answers are out there, somewhere.

What's your greatest medical surprise?

Description : What's your greatest medical surprise?

Last Answer : Just a few months ago, I finally had my first, and long overdue, colonoscopy. My results were so spectacularly excellent, I don’t need to repeat for 10 years. Why was this such an amazing surprise? My father died from colon cancer, when he was just 3 years older than my current age.

This is a medical question. Would it make sense to make appointments between appointments to see your doctor,when you have Lupus?

Description : This is a medical question. Would it make sense to make appointments between appointments to see your doctor,when you have Lupus?

Last Answer : answer:Can you call the office and discuss your concerns with the nurse? What do you mean by want to know what to do ? Do you means the basics like diet, meds, exercise, etc? Did not ... your concerns and anxieties, which must be (understandably) considerable. Here's one Here's another And one more

Do you have any stories of extreme medical incompetence?

Description : Do you have any stories of extreme medical incompetence?

Last Answer : Wow. She is a lawsuit waiting to happen… My sister had to have a kindey stone removed. After a couple years of pain, they discovered that a staple was left inside her bladder. Idiots!

Processing medical marijuana: how long does it take to use a bubble bag etc?

Description : Processing medical marijuana: how long does it take to use a bubble bag etc?

Last Answer : answer:I am surprised and a bit dismayed to learn that concentrate is no longer available at the dispensary for patients. I know here in CO, there are a variety of concentrated items available ... reducing cannabis into a concentrated butter or oil (cannibutter) on the stovetop for use in edibles.

What cartoon characters have medical conditions?

Description : What cartoon characters have medical conditions?

Last Answer : Elmer Fudd had post nasal drip.

Radiologists and Medical Radiation Technologists; what's the difference?

Description : Radiologists and Medical Radiation Technologists; what's the difference?

Last Answer : Radiologists are physicians who specialize in radiology, meaning all that extra schooling for being a physician. The techs are the ones who perform the actual x-ray, and don’t require nearly as much schooling.

Medical jellies, my cousin is in the ICU and they have inserted a trach. He has Spina Bifida and according to a family member, he is on death's door. Why would he need a trach?

Description : Medical jellies, my cousin is in the ICU and they have inserted a trach. He has Spina Bifida and according to a family member, he is on death's door. Why would he need a trach?

Last Answer : Certain issues with the windpipe can make a trach the only way to ensure an unobstructed airway.

How does one convert Marijuana (Medical- read description please) to hash oil?

Description : How does one convert Marijuana (Medical- read description please) to hash oil?

Last Answer : I really wish I had the right answer to this one, @Dog, I really wish I did. No one should ever be mindlessly denied relief from their suffering because of outdated or misguided views regarding marijuana. ... . I hope someone here has something else, Good luck, friend, you are doing the right thing.

What should I do about my medical situation?

Description : What should I do about my medical situation?

Last Answer : answer:Medication can help in the short term. But the key is getting to the bottom of why you're having the attacks. What are you thinking about when you first start feeling the panicky feeling? I' ... . Therapy has helped me deal with what was causing the anxiety and I no longer suffer from them.

How would you answer this question on a medical form?

Description : How would you answer this question on a medical form?

Last Answer : answer:Those are all vague terms. Unless the suicide attempt was successful, in which case we would not be having this conversation. Just say no.

Medical people- what's my husband got? (He's resisting going to the doctor to find out)

Description : Medical people- what's my husband got? (He's resisting going to the doctor to find out)

Last Answer : Where did he travel, what countries and areas?

Any home remedies for alleviating swollen feet, from a medical condition?

Description : Any home remedies for alleviating swollen feet, from a medical condition?

Last Answer : If there’s any chance it is a blood clot, do NOT massage it.

Medical jellies, what is this pain in my chest?

Description : Medical jellies, what is this pain in my chest?

Last Answer : Probably muscular, but it is possible to crack a rib coughing. Best see your doctor; he/she may want to do an x-ray.

What is the most disgusting medical treatment you've ever heard of?

Description : What is the most disgusting medical treatment you've ever heard of?

Last Answer : Second to the treatment you have stated in the details, I would have to say that the use of leeches for medical treatment is quite horrifying. I don’t know if it happens here in America, but in the country I am from does it to treat many things. It scares me!

In archaic medical terms what would alcohol induced cardiomyopathy have been called?

Description : In archaic medical terms what would alcohol induced cardiomyopathy have been called?

Last Answer : answer:How archaic? I think the knowledge of cardiomyopathy even existing is new enough that there really isn’t an old term for it.

Why are you skeptical of the medical community?

Description : Why are you skeptical of the medical community?

Last Answer : answer:As long as health care is a business, it should never be fully trusted. or if healthcare is free but they are cutting corners to save money or doing certain things like hiering temporary doctors ... the school of thought that vaccines work, and that for the most part doctors want to do good.

What kind of medical solution or remedy can I give to my mother to stop her from snorting and spitting out mucus?

Description : What kind of medical solution or remedy can I give to my mother to stop her from snorting and spitting out mucus?

Last Answer : answer:Sounds like allergies or a mild infection. Some people say a neti pot helps. Is the mucous grreen? That wold be an indication of infection. Augmentin or Levoquin might do the trick, but those ... fight off crap like this, but since it started when she moved, I think that is very significant.

What is "the job" of a physician in delivering medical bad news, poor prognosis?

Description : What is "the job" of a physician in delivering medical bad news, poor prognosis?

Last Answer : In my opinion, a physician must be able to deliver any medical news in a professional, simple and sensitive manner because they, in our society, are entrusted with much and are responsible for a ... more should be comfortable with saying I advise you to see another physician for a second opinion'.

Have you ever suffered from a medical illness (of some sort) that made you feel depressed?

Description : Have you ever suffered from a medical illness (of some sort) that made you feel depressed?

Last Answer : Yeah. Hypothyroidism can mask as depression, as can hypogonadotropic hypoganadism, and other illnesses as well. It is always a good idea to rule out medical causes before treating for depression.

Do you respect the medical profession?

Description : Do you respect the medical profession?

Last Answer : I respect people; I’m not so awed by positions. But with that said, I’ve had remarkably good doctors for the most part. My favorite was a crusty old guy in Michigan about 20 years ago. My second favorite was a female doctor I had in Connecticut who has since moved; I need to find another now.

How do you feel about a medical organization having a "partnership" with a soda beverage company?

Description : How do you feel about a medical organization having a "partnership" with a soda beverage company?

Last Answer : The AMA did this a number of years ago. They partnered with Sunbeam, and started hawking their medical supplies (scales, etc.). I dropped my membership at that point, and have never ... reputation of physicians and giving the public more ammunition to prove that doctors are money-grubbers.

What is the sequence of medical "conditions"?

Description : What is the sequence of medical "conditions"?

Last Answer : Medical conditions are used to describe a patient's conditions in a hospital. These terms are most commonly used by the news media and are rarely used by doctors in their daily business, preferring ... simply by being moved from one place to another, with no change in actual physical state.

Do you know anyone who runs medical imaging equipment like MRI, CT Scan, laproscopic support equipment?

Description : Do you know anyone who runs medical imaging equipment like MRI, CT Scan, laproscopic support equipment?

Last Answer : Yes, I know radiology technicians. It is a very rewarding job. It takes several years of school/training to learn how to run the complex machines like MRIs and CT scanners. Basic imaging (x-ray, ultrasound, etc.) takes less time to learn.

Is A physical focusing on the general medical care of hospitalized patients is known as?

Description : Is A physical focusing on the general medical care of hospitalized patients is known as?

Last Answer : Need answer