Why can't we blow hurricanes away? (DETAILS )

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:In the first place, you seem to have a very fundamental misconception of the so-called “butterfly effect”, which assuredly DOES NOT state that “the flap of a butterfly’s winds can change the direction of a tornado”. I suggest that you re-examine the term Butterfly Effect, as it is more about the nuance of “tipping points” and “at what point does something as minor as a butterfly influence something as vast as climate”. But that’s on you. (In any case, that misunderstanding has led to the idea that followed it, so I would definitely recommend that you correct that misconception.) Second, while meteorologists describe how “high pressure areas” tend to create barriers to entry for hurricanes and “push” them in various directions, it is actually the low pressure areas which pull them in the directions they follow. High pressure areas move masses of air in the general direction of low pressure areas (with directional / rotational momentum change provided by the Coriolis Effect). In this sense, high pressure and low pressure air masses are only high and low with respect to each other. I do not believe that humanity currently has the physical capability to create a machine – or any network of machines – which could generate an “artificial high pressure area” of the continental size necessary to move a hurricane. With this in mind, there is no combination of air moving fans that could create an artificial high pressure area to blow a hurricane away from a low pressure area that tends to direct its movement. (In addition to which, if you wanted ship-mounted fans to have an effect, they would have to be anchored – and strongly anchored at that – practically right on the shoreline. This would tend to kill massive amounts of sailors manning those ships as the storm destroyed them and moved onshore anyway, if it is wont to do so.) What is wanted, if it really is wanted, to move an actual, formed and organized hurricane, is a mid-sea low pressure area that will tend to attract it. One of the best ways to create a low pressure area, strange as it might seem, would be to heat the air, which would tend to make it less dense, and to rise… and generally to create a new storm. (Massive low pressure areas are, in fact, what we experience as “storms” and are far, far more powerful than hurricanes, but spread over continental areas, not just a few hundred square miles.) One of the best ways to heat the air to this extent, if it’s going to be done artificially, would be… a massive array of thermonuclear explosions. That might work, if you think you could sell it. The trick is, if it can be managed, to prevent the hurricane from forming and organizing “as a hurricane” in the first place. Maybe we should just kill all of the butterflies…

Related questions

Description : What could I say that would blow you away?

Last Answer : That you kissed a poisonous toad and liked it.

Description : Hurricanes spawn tornadoes. Do they get any of the other kinds of weather we (in Kansas) expect with tornado formation, like hail?

Last Answer : I just googled it and I can’t link it and don’t have time to read it but there’s lots on “why is hail rare in a hurricane?” I googled “can a hurricane have hail?”

Description : Can a house really be built to survive hurricanes?

Last Answer : Yes, buildings (houses) can withstand even Cat 5 hurricane winds. Where they run into problems, though, is often the placement that gets affected by the storm surge or flooding from the deluge ... substantial amount. That's why North Carolina is facing such a huge problem recovering from Florence.

Description : Are hurricanes good for the economy?

Last Answer : It definitely causes some spending. The local economy gets a boost in some ways, but if there is a lot of damage to the area, there is a stoppage in spending, income, and taxes for a while ... . For some people it makes them rich, but that's an individual thing. Some people lose almost everything.

Description : How does the WMO decide what to name the Hurricanes other than by the alphabetical order part?

Last Answer : They also alternate between male and female names. Prior to 1979 all hurricanes were female.

Description : How do you suppose the United States will cope with situation in which several poweful hurricanes march up our coasts annually?

Last Answer : If you're asking if certain opinions will be changed, just because of obvious/proven science and change right in their faces, no . Limbaugh has already claimed that Irma is a liberal conspiracy. Do you think ... to find out . Heads in the sand would be an upgrade, over where their heads are now

Description : Why do hurricanes in the Atlantic make a "right hook" as they approach Florida or other Eastern land areas?

Last Answer : It has to do with the direction of the wind. Hurricanes that originate near Cape Verde are pushed toward the Caribbean by east-to-west blowing trade-winds, but slightly north due to ... of Atlantic hurricanes. This map shows the wind directions that explain the movement of the hurricanes.

Description : Hurricanes (typhoon) hitting Australia? is this common?

Last Answer : Last one was in February of 2015 by checking a couple of weather sites.

Description : Wouldn't the zombies on The Walking Dead be cleaned up by hurricanes?

Last Answer : Most would have been practically gone in a month or two just from decomposition.

Description : Are you safe from the hurricanes in the USA ?

Last Answer : answer:All is well on Oahu. Madeline missed this island, and Lester will dump a bunch of rain, but we'll be okay. Thank you for asking. Aloha Friday of a long weekend! Someone needs to start ... pancakes. I have haupia cream sauce and chopped macadamia nuts for them. (Haupia is made from coconuts.)

Description : Is it true hurricanes and other large storms clean the air?

Last Answer : I don't know much about hurricanes, specifically, but storms (those with lightning, in particular) ionize the air. Pollutants tend to be positively charged particles, but the increase of negative ions in ... parts of the process someone else will come along and fill in my gaps. Rough idea, though.

Description : It's the beginning of the end of the world - but not Armageddon-style with nukes and floods and hurricanes; so what subtle incident would signify the end of the world for you?

Last Answer : answer:My internet is getting flaky. Where’s my darn email? Why can’t I google anything? “And I feel fine…”.

Description : If humans find a way to stop or divert storms and hurricanes, would it have negative effects on Mother Nature?

Last Answer : Yes, weather has the effect of acting as an equalizer. The earth is constantly in a state of equilibrium, and stopping weather patterns would have disastrous effects.

Description : Why is America so prone to tornadoes and hurricanes?

Last Answer : answer:The United States extends from tropical conditions in the south along the gulf, to arctic conditions in the north. The Rockies from a barrier on the west, and the Appalachians on the ... Tornadoes do happen in other countries, but not with the same frequency. Fascinating read on tornadoes.

Description : Have two hurricanes ever joined together to form one hurricane?

Last Answer : GQ!!!!!!! I know Fabian and Isabel in 2003 were so close together that it probably seemed that they merged. But I think scientists say no, they can’t literally combine. Though that would make a badass movie if it involved a giant squid and/or Godzilla.

Description : Why live where hurricanes and tornados can wipe out your house?

Last Answer : yeaaa never got the people who live in tornado alley. Like “ohhh nooo my house was destroyed by a tornado” hmmmmmmmmm wonder why?

Description : Why are typhoons in the Pacific and hurricanes in the Atlantic? Aren't they basically the same type of storm?

Last Answer : They are the same, I do not know why they have different names due to the region. I guess it’s just like color and colour.

Description : Oil spill and hurricanes: The Atlantic hurricane season started June 1st. Which of the following scenarios do you think is most likely?

Last Answer : answer:I think both are very likely except the part where a hurricane would be oil would be pulled into the storm as an aerosol and dispersed. The hurricane center has a nice FAQ on this matter ... grossly under reported. IMO we should be preparing for a worst case scenario for many years to come.

Description : Are you concerned that global warming could increase the intensity of hurricanes?

Last Answer : No, I am not concerned.

Description : Could Hurricanes Spawn A Permanent El Niño?

Last Answer : Theres the tree rings that can tell the growth rate (and thereby whether the conditions were suitable or not) odd oceanic rocks up high etc etc

Description : Hawaiian Hurricanes?

Last Answer : The reason they hit Hawaii so infrequently in comparison to the mainland is a matter of size. Hawaii is tiny in comparison to the mainland. Often hurricanes pass by th islands. Unfortunatly Iniki hit Kauai head on therfore the distruction was immense.

Description : Tornadoes and hurricanes?

Last Answer : I experienced a few hurricanes when I lived in N. Carolina. No major damage from any, for our family, beyond the inconvenience of losing power and having people move in with us because their homes were flooded ... , we hook up to the generator and don't suffer the way some do when the power goes.

Description : thanks. (tuxedo) added: if possible, more precise data - when he worked, where, or damage, loss of life, force according to Saffir-Simpson ...

Last Answer : https://www.wmo.int/pages/prog/www/tcp/Storm-naming.html these are the names of tropical storms, always set for 6 years by the World Meteorological Organization, a tropical storm, if it ... more than 6 years removed names can be found on Wikipedia under "retired hurricane names" or something

Description : resp. since when do they name themselves? (tuxedo)

Last Answer : since 1945, one Australian at the end of the 19th century has tried to do so, but it was more out of anger because he was struck by a plan to establish an Australian National Meteorological Institute and he began naming weather disasters after politicians who voted against

Description : Where there are a lot of them.

Last Answer : East Coast of Asia and America ...

Description : How come California the west side dont have Hurricanes and Tornadoes?

Last Answer : The West Coast (California) doesn't have the right ocean temperature nor weather patterns to produce hurricanes and tornadoes. First, the Pacific Ocean (on the West Coast) is too cold to support ... country. Also, cold fronts often come down from Canada, which creates instability in the atmosphere.

Description : When a hurricane's eye landsa dome of water about 65 to 80 km wide called?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : Are they tornadoes or hurricanes in Madagascar?

Last Answer : There have been tornadoes in Madagascar that have caused seriousdamage. A tropical storm that originates over the Indian ocean andwinds get to 74 miles per hour are called cyclones. Hurricanes formover the Atlantic Ocean. Typhoons form over the Pacific Ocean.

Description : What do hurricanes sound like?

Last Answer : it sounds like something is exploding or people are droppingbombs

Description : What US states do hurricanes usually strike?

Last Answer : The US states that have the most problems with hurricanes areTexas, Louisiana, Alabama, Mississippi, Florida, Georgia, NorthCarolina, and South Carolina.

Description : In the southern hemisphere hurricanes rotate?

Last Answer : counterclock wise

Description : Do hurricanes always end in catastrophe?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : What are the rotation of hurricanes related to?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : Where does hurricanes energy come from?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : What hurricanes destroyed new Orleans?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : Do hurricanes spin slower then tornado?

Last Answer : no

Description : Do hurricanes and tornadoes are both spinning storms that starts over water?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : Are hurricanes are the most common in the middle of the continent?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : Which weather technology is used to gather pressure wind speed and other first-hand observations of hurricanes that are out at sea?

Last Answer : reconnaissance aircraft

Description : Which weather technology is used to gather pressure wind speed and other first hand observations of hurricanes that are out at sea?

Last Answer : reconnaissance aircraft

Description : Are hurricanes are the most common in the middle continent?

Last Answer : No. Hurricanes cannot occur in the middle of a continent. Ahurricane can only form over warm ocean water and will rapidly losestrength if it hits a major landmass.

Description : Where are hurricanes least likely to happen?

Last Answer : Hurricanes, Cyclones and Typhoons (they are all the same thing)dissiape enormous amounts of energy. On Earth this energy comesfrom the Sun and the Sun;s energy stored in Sun warmed waters ... regiones.Thus the poles and the centre of continents are areas wherehurricanes are least likely to happen.

Description : What are the positive effects of hurricanes?

Last Answer : Human's coming together and genuinely helping each other.

Description : Who makes shutters for southern Hurricanes in my area?

Last Answer : BAD question: I don't know whose area they are refering to.

Description : What is the mean number of hurricanes affecting the US per decade?

Last Answer : Number of hurricanes by Saffir-Simpson Category to strike the mainland U.S. each decade. ... U.S. Hurricane Strikes by Decade. Decade Average Per Decade Saffir-Simpson Category1 4 1.2 5 0.2 All 1,2,3,4,5 17.7 Major 3,4,5 6.0

Description : What is the Miami hurricanes mascot?

Last Answer : The University of Miami's mascot is Sebastian the Ibis. They chose this mascot because the Ibis is the last animal to take cover during a hurricane and the first animal to come out after a hurricane.

Description : What city in Florida never gets hit with hurricanes?

Last Answer : Tampa Bay was hit with a hurricane in 1921 Key West was hit with a hurricane in 1919

Description : What city in Florida never gets hit with hurricanes?

Last Answer : Tampa Bay was hit with a hurricane in 1921 Key West was hit with a hurricane in 1919

Description : The tropical cyclones of the Bay of Bengal are usually called (a) Typhoons (b) Hurricanes (c) Depressions (d) Tornadoes

Last Answer : Ans: (b)

Description : Which of the following is least likely to be an effect of global warming? (1 ) Increased frequency of hurricanes (2) Loss of fertile delta region as for agriculture (3) Decreased rate of photosynthesis in vegetation (4) Shrinking of the polar ice regions

Last Answer : (3) Decreased rate of photosynthesis in vegetation Explanation: Global warming is the current increase in temperature of the Earth's surface (both land and water) as well as it's atmosphere. ... . However, the gradual heating of Earth's surface, oceans and atmosphere will not affect photosynthesis.