Why doesn't the sex offender registry violate the US Constitutional ban on Ex Post Facto?

1 Answer

Answer :

Ex Post Facto refers to punishing someone for an act that was legal at the time they committed the act.For example:There was a time when an 18 year old could legally possess and consume alcohol; however, as we know now, the government would end up raising the age to 21.If the the age increased to 21 on March 1st, an 18 year old cannot be arrested for drinking in February. This is because, at the time he was drinking, it was legal for 18 year olds to drink - He was not breaking any laws at the time he was drinking.However, in the instance you've mentioned, the Ex Post Facto defense does not apply. If the defendant is being placed on a sex offender registry, they committed an illegal sex offense. The act was illegal at the time the defendant committed it, thus the defendant can be legally punished.Now, could there be a Constitutional question regarding offender registries? Absolutely, however, Ex Post Factois not the appropriate argument. One could certainly argue that being placed on to a public list after already serving a sentence is "Cruel and Unusual Punishment"; however, courts have looked at this issue before, and consistently put the safety of society over the rights of the offender.

Related questions

Description : Why do you think the constitution forbids congress from passing ex post facto laws?

Last Answer : The constitution prohibits making a law ex post facto because itwould retroactively change the rules of evidence in a criminalcase, retroactively after the definition of a crime, increasepunishment retroactively or punish conduct that was legal whencommitted.

Description : Which of the following attempts to understand relationships among phenomena as they naturally occur, without any intervention? a. Ex post facto research b. Experimental research c. Prospective design d. Retrospective design

Last Answer : a. Ex post facto research

Description : In order to carried out a study on Juvenile delinquents, the best method is Options: A) Ex-Post Facto method B) Case-Study method C) Experimental method D) Genetic method

Last Answer : A) Ex-Post Facto method

Description : Generally the external and internal validity is present in the inference, we get from Options: A) Experimental method B) Survey method C) Ex Post Facto method D) None of the above

Last Answer : C) Ex Post Facto method 

Description : In correlation design of Ex Post Facto Research, we study Options: A) The variable which has been measured in advance and will be work as an causative factor for second variable B) The ... causative factor for first and second variable D) All the above three situations and occurrence of variables

Last Answer : D) All the above three situations and occurrence of variables

Description : A research intends to explore the effect of possible factors for the organization of effective mid-day meal interventions. Which research method will be most appropriate for this study? (A) Historical method (B) Descriptive survey method (C) Experimental method (D) Ex-post-facto method

Last Answer : (D) Ex-post-facto method 

Description : Ex Post Facto research means (A) The research is carried out after the incident (B) The research is carried out prior to the incident (C) The research is carried out along with the happening of an incident. (D) The research is carried out keeping in mind the possibilities of an incident. 

Last Answer : (A) The research is carried out after the incident 

Description : The study in which the investigators attempt to trace an effect is known as: (A) Survey Research (B) ‘Ex-post Facto’ Research (C) Historical Research (D) Summative Research

Last Answer : (B) ‘Ex-post Facto’ Research

Description : Can a sex offender get a dealer licence in California?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : Can you lose your pension in NYSE if convicted of felony while employed as a sex offender?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : where can i find halfway housing for a sex offender?

Last Answer : You should be able to get a list from your parole officer. If there is no place near you then ask for permission to go to the closest city near you. It shows initiative on your part and may get you some brownie points.

Description : As a convicted sex offender, do I qualify for low income housing for me and my family?

Last Answer : Yes, it's possible, there are companies that purchase these types of annuities. How much you'd get for it depends on the amount of the annuity, but also the credit rating of the issuer. noooooooooooooooooooo

Description : i want to change my daughters last name. her father has nothing to do with her refuses to pay support and is a level 3 sex offender. i dont want my daughter to carry his last name.?

Last Answer : well it is on your daughter as well,but if she's too young then it's understandable, what you do is go online or local sights, or just go to your main court house and explain that,you have ... responsibility if he: * Was married to the mother when the child was born; * For births registered f

Description : If the Syrian rebels are aided by Al Qaeda, doesn’t that make anyone aiding the rebels de facto Al Qaeda supporters?

Last Answer : The enemy of my enemy is my enemy too. I agree; it is a sorry mess.

Description : 8. Amniocentesis for sex determination is banned? in our country. Is this ban necessary? Comment -Science

Last Answer : Since Amniocentesis is misused to find out the sex of the foetus leading to female foeticides, it is necessary. It is the prenatal diagnostic technique, that helps to find out chromosomal ( ... laws, such as banning sex determination ultrasounds but raising the social & economic status of women,

Description : What proposal aimed ot ban sex discrimination but did not become a law?

Last Answer : wgusdifsdgsdgsdgsgsdgsdgsgsfgfgfsfgfsfgsfgdfgdfgdfgsfgsfsfgf

Description : Is John Q citizen a de facto cause of outsourcing in the US?

Last Answer : Tariffs are the right way to fix that. Counting on JQP to insist on “made in the USA” will only be partly successful. Too many JQP are looking for the label “guaranteed lowest price”.

Description : Can a repeat dui offender just move to another state?

Last Answer : I like the last two tags you gave this question. He has a serious problem if he’d rather move states than stop drinking and driving! OMG.

Description : Find a person on probation violent offender in kitsap county WA?

Last Answer : Clarify, please.

Last Answer : If an offender gives a confessional statement in court involving himself and others, the court may use this confession against another person. Usually if there is more than one accused in a case then ... co-accused is evidence of weak nature, the other accused cannot be punished on this basis alone.

Description : What terms refers to a sentence where the offender serves a term of imprisonment followed by a term of probation?

Last Answer : There may be a number of terms to describe it; however, it sounds like you're referring to "Shock Probation".In Shock Probation, a defendant is sentenced to do a short period of time in jail/ ... Probation is generally used on young offenders who have not have not served any prison time in the past.

Description :  If an offender is sentenced to imprisonment for a term exceeding one year, the  term of solitary confinement shall not exceed (a) Shall not exceed three month (b) Shall not exceed one month (c) Shall not exceed two months (d) Shall not exceed forty-five days.

Last Answer : (a) Shall not exceed three month

Description : If an offender is sentenced to imprisonment for a term exceeding six months but  not exceeding one year, the term of solitary confinement (a) Shall not exceed 15 days (b) Shall not exceed one month (c) Shall not exceed two months (d) Shall not exceed forty-five days

Last Answer : (c) Shall not exceed two months

Description : In all cases in which judgment is given that a person is guilty of one of several  offences specified in the judgment, but that it is doubtful of which of these offences he is  guilty, the offender ... subject to the discretion of the court as to the quantum of  reduction d) None of the above

Last Answer : a) For which the lowest punishment is provided if the same punishment is not provided for all

Description : Punishment of offence made up of several offence is a) Offender shall be punished with a more severe punishment. b) Offender shall be punished with any one of such offences c) Offender shall be punished with all offence one by one d) None of these

Last Answer : b) Offender shall be punished with any one of such offences

Description : In case of an offence punished with fine only, an offender who is sentenced to pay a  fine exceeding Rs. 100, the imprisonment in default of payment of fine shall not exceed (a) Two months (b) Three months (c) Four months (d) Six months

Last Answer : (d) Six months.

Description : In case of an offence punished with fine only, an offender who is sentenced to pay a  fine of not exceeding Rs. 100 but exceeding Rs. 50, the imprisonment in default of  payment of fine shall not exceed (a) Two months (b) Three months (c) Four months (d) Six months.

Last Answer : (c) Four months

Description : In case of an offence punished with fine only, an offender who is sentenced to pay a  fine of not exceeding Rs. 50, the imprisonment in default of payment of fine shall not  exceed (a) Two months (b) Three months (c) Four months (d) Six months.

Last Answer : (a) Two months

Description : In every case of offence offender punished a) With imprisonment only b) With fine only c) With imprisonment or fine or both d) None of these

Last Answer : c) With imprisonment or fine or both

Description : Sentence of imprisonment for non-payment of fine under section 64 of IPC (a) Shall be in excess of any other imprisonment to which an offender has been  sentenced (b) Shall be concurrent of any other imprisonment (c) Shall not be in excess of any other imprisonment (d) Both (b) & (c).

Last Answer : (a) Shall be in excess of any other imprisonment to which an offender has been  sentenced

Description : The amount of fine which offender is liable is a) Rs 25000/- b) Unlimited c) Unlimited but shall no be expensive d) None of these

Last Answer : c) Unlimited but shall no be expensive

Description : In every case in which sentence of imprisonment for life shall have been passed,  the appropriate Government may, without the consent of the offender, commute the  punishment for imprisonment of either description for a term not exceeding a) 20 years b) 12 years c) 14 years d) 18 years

Last Answer : c) 14 years

Description : When a proclamation issued against absconded person fails to appear at the  specified place and time  a) The court may, after making such inquiry as it thinks fit. b) The court pronounce him a proclaimed offender and make a declaration to that effect. c) Both the A & B d) None of these

Last Answer : c) Both the A & B

Description : Any police officer may arrest without warrant any person (a) Who has been concerned in any cognizable offence (b) Who has been proclaimed as an offender (c) Who is reasonably suspected of being a deserter from any armed forces (d) All the above

Last Answer : (d) All the above

Description : Should we have blue ribbon juries and judges for trying cases that relate to really tough issues such as scientific or genetic questions, or issues like GMOs, or does that violate the trial by your peers idea?

Last Answer : Fun fact: nothing in the US Constitution guarantees you a trial by your peers. The idea is a holdover from British common law and originally protected lords from being tried by commoners ... they are experts. What matters is only their ability to meet the constitutional requirement of impartiality.

Description : Would my business violate Florida's auto dealer statutes?

Last Answer : answer:I reread the statutes and it defines a “person” as a corporation, firm, partership, or business. What if I formed corporation 1, sold my three vehicles, formed corporation 2, sold it’s three vehicles, ..... Since they are different corporations would this be a viable option?

Description : What law, if any, did this man violate by knocking on an armored car window?

Last Answer : I don’t know what specific law, but it seems reasonable there should be rules about approaching armored cars carrying who-knows-how-much money. Don’t mess with them! It’s always deemed suspicious, at least, I would think.

Description : If you do not use any names can you violate someone’s privacy?

Last Answer : answer:In the case that you cite there could be friends who know the people in question but have no idea about the private event. The billboard would inform them of this private event. That's where the privacy ... that this was not privacy violation. But I'd have to look at the facts, case by case.

Description : If I'm under 15 and want to fly from Japan to America alone, would I violate any rules against minors flying by themselves?

Last Answer : answer:You may be considered Unaccompanied minor status , in which case you'll have to pay an additional fee ($75 is the most common reference that I see). 16 seems to be the cut-off age. (I started ... then.) Your best bet will be to find out what airline you'll be using and give them a call.

Description : What conversion/ripping tools should I avoid to ensure that I don't inadvertently violate YouTube copyrights/anti-piracy measures?

Last Answer : Try http://www.flv2mp3.com/ – it was working for me as of a few days ago.

Description : How not to violate software copyright policy?

Last Answer : If you're modifying existing code, what you are creating is most likely a derivative work, which requires the copyright holder's permission. Basically, you have to rewrite the whole thing from scratch without ... And if you take on this job, you need to consult with a good copyright lawyer too.

Description : Does a constant function violate the extreme value theorem? Why/why not?

Last Answer : answer:I feel like I'd be doing your homework for you if I answered this. The extreme value thm says that a continuous function on [a,b] will have a max and min in that range. Think about the definition ... then you'll have one answer; if you say they have to be unique, you'll have the other answer.

Description : How did president Santa Anna violate the constitution of 1824?

Last Answer : Santa anna murdered a donkey

Description : Are there any circumstances under which a sociologist might violate a research subjects confidentiality?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : How advertisement violate human autonomy?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : When we inflated a balloon the volume and pressure increases . does it violate the Boyle's law . explain?

Last Answer : No, this doesn't because P1V1 is a constant, which I think meansit needs to have the same quantity of gas, which blowing a balloonisn't. Boyle's law is only used when a fixed amount of gas is beingcompressed or uncompressed, changing only its volume andpressure.

Description : When we inflated a balloon the volume and pressure increases . does it violate the boyles law . explain?

Last Answer : No, this doesn't because P1V1 is a constant, which I think meansit needs to have the same quantity of gas, which blowing a balloonisn't. Boyle's law is only used when a fixed amount of gas is beingcompressed or uncompressed, changing only its volume andpressure.

Description : Will chipper trucks violate the noise ordinance of Burbank, CA?

Last Answer : Most local noise ordinances designate certain "quiet hours" -- for example, from 10 p.m. to 7 a.m. on weekdays and until 8 or 9 a.m. on weekends. So running a power mower may be ... common issues in relation to noise control in the City of Burbank. http://www.burbankca.org/license/noise.htm

Description : can a probation officer violate the probation due to inability to pay?

Last Answer : If you mean inability to pay a fine then yes because just getting a fine would be a crime so a violation.

Description : what happens if you violate probation in Palm Beach County ?

Last Answer : It depends on what you were on probation for, but if you do it any amount at all you are going to jail just about anywhere in Florida.