If the Holocaust didn't happen, what did, exactly?

If the Holocaust didn't happen, what did, exactly?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

Let me tell you something about the Iowa Cynic. He’s a former wis.dmer that moved here. In all my discussions with him, he’s never actually denied the Holocaust. He just questions the 6 million number.
by

Related questions

Are Catholic services and Jewish services similar or vastly different?

Description : Are Catholic services and Jewish services similar or vastly different?

Last Answer : Not at all, even superficially.

I honestly have no idea what some people have against Jews! Will you enlighten me?

Description : I honestly have no idea what some people have against Jews! Will you enlighten me?

Last Answer : Antisemitism predates Christianity as well. It was around in Greek and Roman times. I might add to your support of Judaism that wherever the Jews are, there is a great influx of arts and culture. They lead the way in ... as early as 1200 C.E. So aren't they just as much a part of us' as anyone?

Jews changing planes in Arab countries? How does this work?

Description : Jews changing planes in Arab countries? How does this work?

Last Answer : answer:Pure speculation on my part: A traveling Israeli would avoid stopping in an Arab country that didn't allow Israelis. And, if they did, they would only be transiting at the airport, not passing ... message on Israeli stamps: some say it is grounds for denial, others say it does not matter.

Do you think Jews tend to be more intelligent than Christians on average?

Description : Do you think Jews tend to be more intelligent than Christians on average?

Last Answer : Not at all. I’ve known smart Jews and ignorant Jews both, but I tend to determine intelligence based on how well I know the individual, not assumptions and generalizations based on religious affilation.

For Star Wars nerds: Why would George Lucas name the desert-dwelling merchants of Tattooine "Jawa's" - isn't that a little too close to Jews to be a coincidence?

Description : For Star Wars nerds: Why would George Lucas name the desert-dwelling merchants of Tattooine "Jawa's" - isn't that a little too close to Jews to be a coincidence?

Last Answer : I’m not a Star Wars nerd, so I’ll skip this question…

How do Jewish Holy Days, traditions, etc. help the Jews connect to their past?

Description : How do Jewish Holy Days, traditions, etc. help the Jews connect to their past?

Last Answer : answer:Just celebrating them reinforces the traditions. Things are changing a little in America, not sure about other countries, but still for the most part Jewish holidays are celebrated without a lot of decoration ... t want that to happen. They feel the way to get back is to live, to continue.

Purim plans?

Description : Purim plans?

Last Answer : We usually just buy hamentashens.

How big is a yamika?

Description : How big is a yamika?

Last Answer : Here are some patterns that may help. You will also have better results if you search for “yarmulke” or “kippah.”

How do you become Jewish?

Description : How do you become Jewish?

Last Answer : Sign me up ;)

Why the animosity toward Jews?

Description : Why the animosity toward Jews?

Last Answer : answer:I have never understood this. My best guess would be that in medieval times Jews often worked in trades like money-lending and banking that were off-limits to ‘proper’ Christians. Great question by the way, I look forward to reading the responses of those more learned than myself.

Can I wish you a Happy Passover?

Description : Can I wish you a Happy Passover?

Last Answer : Happy Passover!

What does Hava Nagila mean?

Description : What does Hava Nagila mean?

Last Answer : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hava_Nagila translated: “Let us rejoice.”

Ahmendinejad. You didn't disagree with him about his Holocaust denial, how about his killing of the protesters?

Description : Ahmendinejad. You didn't disagree with him about his Holocaust denial, how about his killing of the protesters?

Last Answer : we actually had quite the discussion about this here

What exactly is the law regarding packages sent to you that you didn't order (see details)

Description : What exactly is the law regarding packages sent to you that you didn't order (see details)

Last Answer : answer:If this happened to me, and I was genuinely interested in returning the items cost-free, my first step would be to phone the merchant and explain to the manager what had happened. They will very ... a bad idea), but so he knows that this is happening. The merchant probably won't inform him.

A woman went into a bank to cash an insurance refund check. By mistake the teller gave her dollars for cents and cents for dollars. She put the money in her purse but accidentally dropped a nickel on the floor. When she got home, she found that she had exactly twice the amount of the check she had cashed. She didn't have any money in her wallet before going to the bank. What was the exact amount of that check? -Riddles

Description : A woman went into a bank to cash an insurance refund check. By mistake the teller gave her dollars for cents and cents for dollars. She put the money in her purse but accidentally dropped a nickel on ... money in her wallet before going to the bank. What was the exact amount of that check? -Riddles

Last Answer : The amount must have been $31.63. She received $63.31. After she dropped a nickel there would remain the sum of $63.26, which is twice the amount of the check.

Did you learn about the Holocaust in K-12 school?

Description : Did you learn about the Holocaust in K-12 school?

Last Answer : I learned about it from books, and television programming.

What is your explanation for this conundrum about White Supremacists, Nazis and Holocaust Deniers?

Description : What is your explanation for this conundrum about White Supremacists, Nazis and Holocaust Deniers?

Last Answer : Untreated mental illness. I think this explains a lot of things including conspiracy theorists, flat earthers, and more. Locking people in institutions and experimenting on and abusing them clearly wasn't ... it too. We simply do not have successful enough tools to help certain mentally ill people.

Do you think 9/11 needs to be remembered like the Holocaust?

Description : Do you think 9/11 needs to be remembered like the Holocaust?

Last Answer : I associate “never forget” with the holocaust, but I don’t see 911 as just as important as the holocaust. For each event I remember all the things you mentioned. Remember 911? Absolutely. But applying “never forget” to 911? No.

What were your children taught about the Holocaust in school, and do you believe 6 million Jewish people were killed?

Description : What were your children taught about the Holocaust in school, and do you believe 6 million Jewish people were killed?

Last Answer : But yeah, those non-believers are also very present in the following numbers: __Almost half (45 percent) of Americans were unable to name a single concentration camp, and the number was even worse for ... ). Two-thirds (66 percent) of millennials were unable to explain what Auschwitz was.__ ...

Were you satisfied with Trump’s statement for Holocaust Rememberence Day?

Description : Were you satisfied with Trump’s statement for Holocaust Rememberence Day?

Last Answer : I am glad that he mentioned the Jews this time.

Let's say a young adult today, early 40's, has never heard of the Holocaust: What do you think their reaction would be to movies like Schindler's List?

Description : Let's say a young adult today, early 40's, has never heard of the Holocaust: What do you think their reaction would be to movies like Schindler's List?

Last Answer : I think trying to educate people is wonderful, but if I thought the person was going to be a closed-minded ignoramus about it, I wouldn't bother. That's just my opinion. Others may feel it's worth while ... She must really live in a bubble if she's in her 40's and has never heard of the Holocaust.

Why did holocaust happened?

Description : Why did holocaust happened?

Last Answer : Which holocaust? There have been several.

When you hear "never forget" regarding the Holocaust, what does that mean to you?

Description : When you hear "never forget" regarding the Holocaust, what does that mean to you?

Last Answer : For me it is fairly redundant. I am married to a Jewish lady and the holocaust is raw front and center in her family having lost loved ones so long ago. Sadly there are a vast majority of ... need to honor these anniversaries to remind us that we shall do everything and anything to avoid a repeat.

Should Nuclear Terrorism denial be a crime, just like Holocaust denial?

Description : Should Nuclear Terrorism denial be a crime, just like Holocaust denial?

Last Answer : answer:Holocaust denial is not a crime here in the U.S., and it should most definitely not be. Same goes for the nuclear terrorism stuff. But of course I’ll join you in contemplation of the horror of the annihiliation of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

Is it possible to 'honour' the 3rd Reich without glorifying the Holocaust?

Description : Is it possible to 'honour' the 3rd Reich without glorifying the Holocaust?

Last Answer : Well, they had a really great wardrobe department. The uniforms were so avant-garde.

What did people do in the Ghettos during the holocaust?

Description : What did people do in the Ghettos during the holocaust?

Last Answer : answer:The classic ghetto was the Warsaw ghetto . Type that in your search engine; There are hundreds of documents for you to read. Start by finding an accurate definition of ghetto. ... camps together. They were two separate social structures with two different purposes, at least superficially.

Have you visited the Holocaust Museum in Washington DC?

Description : Have you visited the Holocaust Museum in Washington DC?

Last Answer : I think it’s to help you get emotionally invested. Why do you think it’s insensitive? To whom?

Where can I find information on Holocaust conspiracy theory?

Description : Where can I find information on Holocaust conspiracy theory?

Last Answer : If you look up “Holocaust Denial” on a search engine you will be inundated with links.

Do you believe the holocaust happened?

Description : Do you believe the holocaust happened?

Last Answer : I’ve seen the tattoos on some of my Jewish clients and looked into their eyes when they noticed I saw it.

Joan Rivers Holocaust Joke: All in good fun or crossing the line?

Description : Joan Rivers Holocaust Joke: All in good fun or crossing the line?

Last Answer : Geez, it’s not anti semitic, who is upset? Germans?

Was it Nietzsche's fault that the Holocaust happened?

Description : Was it Nietzsche's fault that the Holocaust happened?

Last Answer : answer:I don’t think so. Was it the Beatle’s fault the Manson Family killed Sharon Tate and the LaBianca family?

Which was worse? Holocaust, US Slavery, or Native American policies?

Description : Which was worse? Holocaust, US Slavery, or Native American policies?

Last Answer : answer:Yes. It’s not worthwhile to compare atrocities and rank them. Study them, understand them, keep further ones from happening, sure. But “Oppression Olympics” aren’t useful.

Holocaust Denial: Rhetoric or Actual Belief?

Description : Holocaust Denial: Rhetoric or Actual Belief?

Last Answer : I don't understand any of the conspiracy therorists. Like, Elvis is still alive, we didn't really go to the moon, the government had President Kenndy shot, we blew up the trade center ... psychiatrists say is true - people just want to believe that they know something that no one else knows.

Today we remember Pearl Harbor,the Holocaust, the beginning of World War Two, but why do some hold this generation accountable?

Description : Today we remember Pearl Harbor,the Holocaust, the beginning of World War Two, but why do some hold this generation accountable?

Last Answer : Based upon car sales I’d say that Japanese / German prejudice is a thing of the past. I just came from a Bar Mitzvah celebration this weekend in Westchester County. There were so many BMWs in the parking lot it looked like an Oktoberfest Celebration.

Can anyone recommend a good autobiography (or two) by jewish authors that survived the Holocaust?

Description : Can anyone recommend a good autobiography (or two) by jewish authors that survived the Holocaust?

Last Answer : There’s Elie Wiesel’s Night.

If you could go back in time and kill Hitler before he started the Holocaust, would you?

Description : If you could go back in time and kill Hitler before he started the Holocaust, would you?

Last Answer : I’d like to believe I would.

How can robots help prevent a nuclear holocaust in Japan?

Description : How can robots help prevent a nuclear holocaust in Japan?

Last Answer : answer:Robots are still not that smart or dexterous compared to humans. Even tele-robotic (human-controlled) devices are limited in mobility. Not that those tracked robotic vehicles described in the ... , while motors, wiring, and structural elements should function fine unless they melt from heat.

If Hitler had been assassinated, could the holocaust & world war II have been averted?

Description : If Hitler had been assassinated, could the holocaust & world war II have been averted?

Last Answer : answer:I think there is every chance that things would have been changed. His generals thought his conduct of the war was wrong. I am not at all sure there would have been the will to see the Holocaust through.

What is your opinion about using medical knowledge obtained in atrocities such as the WWII Holocaust?

Description : What is your opinion about using medical knowledge obtained in atrocities such as the WWII Holocaust?

Last Answer : answer:Of course we can't condone what happened, but knowledge is knowledge, no matter how come by. How many deaths could be prevented using the information they gained, and how many lost if we ... to reinvent the wheel by waiting for someone to discover the same information by more mundane means?

Should Holocaust Denial be decriminalised across the 14 countries where it still remains illegal?

Description : Should Holocaust Denial be decriminalised across the 14 countries where it still remains illegal?

Last Answer : This would be like making it illegal to believe in creationism, so even though those people just look like huge idiots, it’s still wrong to make it illegal for them.

Could Hitler have pulled off the Holocaust without Joseph Goebbels or someone of his skill?

Description : Could Hitler have pulled off the Holocaust without Joseph Goebbels or someone of his skill?

Last Answer : I feel like all world leaders, particularly those who do terrible things, need someone to be the front man for their operation. Humans (hopefully) don't want to be part of atrocities, but ... spoon-fed the pablum of an administration spokesperson or a News channel pundit is not actually helpful.

Is the Holocaust a hoax?

Description : Is the Holocaust a hoax?

Last Answer : I would ask them why the Nazis left concentration camps all over central Europe if the Holocaust was a hoax. Seems like a waste to me.

Im trying to limit my topic of the holocaust, which would you most like to hear about in a essay?

Description : Im trying to limit my topic of the holocaust, which would you most like to hear about in a essay?

Last Answer : Perhaps you could list the specific areas which you are considering.

How do you feel about anti-Holocaust Denial laws?

Description : How do you feel about anti-Holocaust Denial laws?

Last Answer : If it’s against the law, how will we identify the deniers?

It is the International Holocaust Memorial day. What does it mean to you?

Description : It is the International Holocaust Memorial day. What does it mean to you?

Last Answer : Nie wieder.

In Europe and Canada, people are thrown in jail for questioning details of the Holocaust. Do you support this and why?

Description : In Europe and Canada, people are thrown in jail for questioning details of the Holocaust. Do you support this and why?

Last Answer : No, I don’t think there should be similar laws. Free speech, and all that. People who deny the Holocaust are saying more about themselves than the Holocaust.

What is the name of the book that answers allegations by Holocaust deniers, and what is the author's name?

Description : What is the name of the book that answers allegations by Holocaust deniers, and what is the author's name?

Last Answer : You might want to check out this Wikipedia article, it’s probably on there :)

How is a good way to explain to someone the importance of learnig about the Holocaust?

Description : How is a good way to explain to someone the importance of learnig about the Holocaust?

Last Answer : Well, I'd say it'd be even more disrespectful if this would ever happen again, which might very well happen if we don't work to keep realizing the horrors of it all. Even reproductions ... claiming to be offended by someone watching and feeling for what they or their relatives had been through.

I'm writing an essay on the holocaust and don't know what i should put for my thesis statement any suggestions?

Description : I'm writing an essay on the holocaust and don't know what i should put for my thesis statement any suggestions?

Last Answer : What is the focus of your paper. A general overview? The thesis statement would be different if you were focusing on his art. Some details would be helpful.

Holocaust help?

Description : Holocaust help?

Last Answer : answer:Ok, let’s get started. First thing you need is a thesis statement. What is yours?