How much blame can you assign to WWII Nazis, and where is the line drawn between personal maliciousness and cooperation in order to not be persecuted?

How much blame can you assign to WWII Nazis, and where is the line drawn between personal maliciousness and cooperation in order to not be persecuted?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

Following orders during war is one thing. Human rights violations is another. They knew that what they were doing was wrong. Their actions went agents the Geneva Conventions. One thing being a soldier following orders. Another, when you help with the architectural design.
by

Related questions

Do people in Germany and Japan feel that their countries "started" WWII?

Description : Do people in Germany and Japan feel that their countries "started" WWII?

Last Answer : The actual people of these countries were not in control, it was the governments of these countries who started WWII. In Germany an egocentric took center stage & swept the people along who were ... think the government was looking for a way to surmount trade restrictions & a sense of superiority.

What is your opinion about using medical knowledge obtained in atrocities such as the WWII Holocaust?

Description : What is your opinion about using medical knowledge obtained in atrocities such as the WWII Holocaust?

Last Answer : answer:Of course we can't condone what happened, but knowledge is knowledge, no matter how come by. How many deaths could be prevented using the information they gained, and how many lost if we ... to reinvent the wheel by waiting for someone to discover the same information by more mundane means?

Short Story of WWII Solider?

Description : Short Story of WWII Solider?

Last Answer : Average daily life for a German or Italian soldier, or daily avg. life for an Allied soldier in one of those countries?

I want to know about jazz around WWII.

Description : I want to know about jazz around WWII.

Last Answer : answer:

Would the Nazis have lost without US involvement?

Description : Would the Nazis have lost without US involvement?

Last Answer : The Germans had been broken at the battle of Kursk. US invasion only accelerated eventual German defeat.

Why did holocaust happened?

Description : Why did holocaust happened?

Last Answer : Which holocaust? There have been several.

How do these photographs make you feel?

Description : How do these photographs make you feel?

Last Answer : Sad. I hope it will never happen again, but I'm sure it will. Next time they probably won't target the Japanese, they will target another people group (there are plenty to choose from). They, meaning ... the power to do so, in the US or anywhere else. History is full of this type of behavior.

Do you think President Obama is right in saying that he will not apologize for Hiroshima bombing?

Description : Do you think President Obama is right in saying that he will not apologize for Hiroshima bombing?

Last Answer : He has nothing to apologize for. Was he even alive at that time?

What is this Oskar Gröning and Eva Kor story about?

Description : What is this Oskar Gröning and Eva Kor story about?

Last Answer : My guess, it's for them about reconciliation. The man accused made no attempt to deny the charges, though it may well be argued that his involvement was peripheral. This guy's conviction ... faced the decisions confronting him at 22 nor the decision of whoever bore responsibility for his conviction.

Have you ever known someone who is angry all the time, and also blames other people for mistakes that are obviously their own mistakes?

Description : Have you ever known someone who is angry all the time, and also blames other people for mistakes that are obviously their own mistakes?

Last Answer : I did and it turned out they were bi-polar.

To what extent should those who joined the Nazi party to avoid persecution be condemned?

Description : To what extent should those who joined the Nazi party to avoid persecution be condemned?

Last Answer : I think if someone joined becasue they were genuinely in fear for their lives or they were in fear for their families lives then I don't think they should be punished at all. I think probably ... torture people against your will to save your or your loved one's lives, should be punishment enough.

If the Confederate States seceded from the US during the 1860's and became a sovereign nation, would they have become an ally of Nazi Germany during WW2?

Description : If the Confederate States seceded from the US during the 1860's and became a sovereign nation, would they have become an ally of Nazi Germany during WW2?

Last Answer : They would’ve remained neutral, but why wouldn’t they be on their side? They were in the business of preserving our lord and saviors master race and obtaining more lebensraum for them. Lol.

Why was the US military occupation of Japan and Germany peaceful compared to Iraq and Afghanistan?

Description : Why was the US military occupation of Japan and Germany peaceful compared to Iraq and Afghanistan?

Last Answer : If you’re just going off pictures…....There are many pictures out there of soldiers having a good time with the locals of the cities they inhabited while in the Middle East. Conversely, there are also pictures of horrors from both wars.

Today we remember Pearl Harbor,the Holocaust, the beginning of World War Two, but why do some hold this generation accountable?

Description : Today we remember Pearl Harbor,the Holocaust, the beginning of World War Two, but why do some hold this generation accountable?

Last Answer : Based upon car sales I’d say that Japanese / German prejudice is a thing of the past. I just came from a Bar Mitzvah celebration this weekend in Westchester County. There were so many BMWs in the parking lot it looked like an Oktoberfest Celebration.

Can anyone recommend a good autobiography (or two) by jewish authors that survived the Holocaust?

Description : Can anyone recommend a good autobiography (or two) by jewish authors that survived the Holocaust?

Last Answer : There’s Elie Wiesel’s Night.

Can you please direct me to some resources about life in the Japanese internment camps?

Description : Can you please direct me to some resources about life in the Japanese internment camps?

Last Answer : answer:I have an old friend from high school. He and his family were interned in a camp in the Philippines. He described how he, aged 4, and his sister, aged 6, were forced to watch another American ... nightmares and he is now 75. Would you like me to ask him how he feels about being interviewed?

If Hitler had been assassinated, could the holocaust & world war II have been averted?

Description : If Hitler had been assassinated, could the holocaust & world war II have been averted?

Last Answer : answer:I think there is every chance that things would have been changed. His generals thought his conduct of the war was wrong. I am not at all sure there would have been the will to see the Holocaust through.

Who was "CNO" (chief of naval operations) during Cuban Missile Crisis?

Description : Who was "CNO" (chief of naval operations) during Cuban Missile Crisis?

Last Answer : George Anderson

Could Hitler have pulled off the Holocaust without Joseph Goebbels or someone of his skill?

Description : Could Hitler have pulled off the Holocaust without Joseph Goebbels or someone of his skill?

Last Answer : I feel like all world leaders, particularly those who do terrible things, need someone to be the front man for their operation. Humans (hopefully) don't want to be part of atrocities, but ... spoon-fed the pablum of an administration spokesperson or a News channel pundit is not actually helpful.

If you believe in ghosts can you tell me this?

Description : If you believe in ghosts can you tell me this?

Last Answer : I would say there are a few answers to this question. 1. First, not all spirits are here because of tragedy. It is only one possibility. Of course according to your example that would just add ... belief system wherever it comes from. But this is some information I have picked up about the topic.

Why do kamikaze's wear helmets?

Description : Why do kamikaze's wear helmets?

Last Answer : radio in the helmet, so that you can receive orders till the very end maybe?

How many P-38s, P-40s, B-17s, B-24s, and B-29s are left that fly?

Description : How many P-38s, P-40s, B-17s, B-24s, and B-29s are left that fly?

Last Answer : I don’t know but there are plenty of DC-3s still around.

Suppose your friend has just left the home on scooter along with his son, immediately you hear the news that they met a road accident. What will you do in this case? Options: A) You will mock at him because you have poor relations with him B) You will rush immediately and extend all possible help keeping in mind that this is not the time of personal enmity C) You will leave the place immediately so that nobody can blame you later on D) You will visit them next day and give an impression that you knew it just now from neighbourhood

Description : Suppose your friend has just left the home on scooter along with his son, immediately you hear the news that they met a road accident. What will you do in this case? Options: A) You will mock ... D) You will visit them next day and give an impression that you knew it just now from neighbourhood

Last Answer : B) You will rush immediately and extend all possible help keeping in mind that this is not the time of personal enmity

Why must I be so abused and persecuted?

Description : Why must I be so abused and persecuted?

Last Answer : Clearly you are being punished by the Lord for sins committed in the womb.

What do you feel you were most persecuted for by family and friends?

Description : What do you feel you were most persecuted for by family and friends?

Last Answer : I was prosecuted, not persecuted, for just causes, for the most part.

How difficult would it be, and what would the punishment for getting caught be, for successfully throwing a tomato or similar missile against the "persecuted" members of the 1%?

Description : How difficult would it be, and what would the punishment for getting caught be, for successfully throwing a tomato or similar missile against the "persecuted" members of the 1%?

Last Answer : I think attacking anyone with any kind of missile negates the concept of a “peaceful demonstration”.

Are you more likely to get persecuted if you're bisexual than gay?

Description : Are you more likely to get persecuted if you're bisexual than gay?

Last Answer : You are more likely to be assumed promiscuous or slutty if you are bisexual.

My daughter tells me she is feeling persecuted in her school?

Description : My daughter tells me she is feeling persecuted in her school?

Last Answer : private schools are tough, she should have realized that before hand. I’d call the school and simply ask what the nature of her detentions were, sometimes teenagers, especially teenage girls, exaggerate.

Why does the LGBT community feel persecuted by the religious community, when there are perfectly non-religious reasons in other countries for feeling it isn't natural?

Description : Why does the LGBT community feel persecuted by the religious community, when there are perfectly non-religious reasons in other countries for feeling it isn't natural?

Last Answer : Because this isn’t China. In the United States, discrimination against LGBT people is driven almost entirely by religious groups. Look at Proposition 8 in CA, as just one example. Close to 100% of the funding for Prop 8 came from religious groups.

What is the method of expressing sympathy towards the poor and oppressed brothers ? What is our duty to our Muslim brothers and sisters who are being persecuted in different parts of the world ?

Description : What is the method of expressing sympathy towards the poor and oppressed brothers ? What is our duty to our Muslim brothers and sisters who are being persecuted in different parts of the world ?

Last Answer : All praise is due to Allah. Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning): The believers are brothers. Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning ) : The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon ... did you take off your shoes ? Khalil said: You are walking barefoot so I sympathize with you.

Who established a colonial for Quakers after being persecuted for his Quakers beliefs in England?

Description : Who established a colonial for Quakers after being persecuted for his Quakers beliefs in England?

Last Answer : banana

How did Christianity spread throughout the roman empire even though they were persecuted by the Romans?

Description : How did Christianity spread throughout the roman empire even though they were persecuted by the Romans?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Who did the Russian leader who persecuted the Jews?

Description : Who did the Russian leader who persecuted the Jews?

Last Answer : Need answer

Which religion is most persecuted?

Description : Which religion is most persecuted?

Last Answer : In recent years, the Yazidis have probably been subject to the most intense persecution -- The so-called "Islamic State" certainly attempted genocide. The Uyghur in China and the Rohinngya in ... the colonial era on islands like Hispaniola. Total extermination of all of the believers in a religi

Which Security forces were created by Nazis to control order in society? -History 9th

Description : Which Security forces were created by Nazis to control order in society? -History 9th

Last Answer : answer:

How does Hofstede view Masculinity in a given society? A. As a representation of achievement, assertiveness and material reward for success. B. As a preference for cooperation, modesty, and quality of life. C. As a representation of individualism and personal free will. D. As a preference for virtue and moral standard.

Description : How does Hofstede view Masculinity in a given society? A. As a representation of achievement, assertiveness and material reward for success. B. As a preference for cooperation, modesty, and quality ... of individualism and personal free will. D. As a preference for virtue and moral standard.

Last Answer : As a representation of achievement, assertiveness and material reward for success

Did the "baby boom" after WWII make up for all the deaths?

Description : Did the "baby boom" after WWII make up for all the deaths?

Last Answer : Now here is an interesting thing. My dad was a pow of ww2. My mother was a war bride. She told me, ( she was a very different sort of thinker always) that, according to Edgar Cayce: They returned so ... was a little girl, because I dreamt of war until I was a young adult. Make of it what you will.

Do you think there will be another war on the scale of WWI or WWII in the next 50 years?

Description : Do you think there will be another war on the scale of WWI or WWII in the next 50 years?

Last Answer : answer:Nah. Maybe in outer space.

What would have happened if the US did not drop the atomic bombs on Japanese Cities in WWII?

Description : What would have happened if the US did not drop the atomic bombs on Japanese Cities in WWII?

Last Answer : answer:No man can say. The Japanese were probably as terrified of a Russian invasion from the west as they were from the American invasion or even nuclear weapons. By 1945 it seemed ... the careless or even deliberate targeting of Axis civilians in bombing raids that occurred throughout the war.

Are sharks as abundant as they were in WWII?

Description : Are sharks as abundant as they were in WWII?

Last Answer : answer: Around the world, sharks and rays are taken in fisheries ranging from small subsistence fisheries in inshore waters, to large industrialised fisheries in the open ocean. Since the 1950s, ... every year. Around the world many shark fisheries have declined or collapsed from fishing. Sources

Would the war hawks still be as supportive if the death rate was that of WWII?

Description : Would the war hawks still be as supportive if the death rate was that of WWII?

Last Answer : I'm curious as to why you picked those battles with those numbers but my answer is yes, the hawks will still be supportive. That's only my opinion, unless the numbers reach or exceed the ... might be some shift in their positions but doubtful if that will be enough to end all engagements there.

Best tank during WWII?

Description : Best tank during WWII?

Last Answer : answer:Sherman on the US side Panzer on the German side

I'm looking for good sites about WWII. Anyone know of some?

Description : I'm looking for good sites about WWII. Anyone know of some?

Last Answer : The History channel site would be a good place to start.

Care for WWII leather pistol holster and belt.

Description : Care for WWII leather pistol holster and belt.

Last Answer : Most conservators advise against attempting to apply any treatment to antique leather, but there are a couple of things you can use that will have little or no long term detrimental effect: One is a ... lanolin Neatsfoot oil, saddle soap, mink oil, etc. will actually shorten the life of the leather.

Is War on Terror categorized as WWIII or WWII & a half or what?

Description : Is War on Terror categorized as WWIII or WWII & a half or what?

Last Answer : Asking a question like that shows a ridiculous level of ignorance about the size and scope of the actual World Wars.

German WWII radio broadcasts translated?

Description : German WWII radio broadcasts translated?

Last Answer : You may enjoy this site.

Can you tell me the name of this movie about WWII?

Description : Can you tell me the name of this movie about WWII?

Last Answer : Can’t help you out with just that. Any idea who was acting in it?

Similarities and differences between the causes of wwi and wwii?

Description : Similarities and differences between the causes of wwi and wwii?

Last Answer : Homework question?

What is Bovarro? It came in a jar, back during WWII.

Description : What is Bovarro? It came in a jar, back during WWII.

Last Answer : I wonder if it wouldn’t have been understood to be Bovril, a popular British condiment. Changing the name could have been a way of skirting trademark laws.

How close did the Germans come to winnning WWII?

Description : How close did the Germans come to winnning WWII?

Last Answer : The Germans may have won the war but the following reasons blocked them from winning. Hitler had no luck in enticing England to join them in the war against USSR.He had to opt for less powerful ... for the mistakes highlighted above and some other ones which I have not included in this write up.