Do you think this study on the supposed benefits of smacking children will encourage such behavior?

Do you think this study on the supposed benefits of smacking children will encourage such behavior?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

The world is full of bad advice, and the academic world is even more full of shit studies.
by

Related questions

When a parent wants to take their kids to a psychologist due to "behavior issues," do you think that part of the therapy should include installing a nanny cam in the house for a certain amount of time?

Description : When a parent wants to take their kids to a psychologist due to "behavior issues," do you think that part of the therapy should include installing a nanny cam in the house for a certain amount of time?

Last Answer : I think you're right about the parent's role in child issues. I went as an unofficial step-parent to meetings at a child rehabilitation center, and it was clear that most of the parents were in denial/ ... isn't going to want the camera, and/or will avoid abusing on-camera if they know about it).

If your teenager was drinking regularly and doing very dangerous behavior would you stop drinking?

Description : If your teenager was drinking regularly and doing very dangerous behavior would you stop drinking?

Last Answer : “Do as I say, not as I do” never works.

To the jelly parents, care to explain this behavior?

Description : To the jelly parents, care to explain this behavior?

Last Answer : I don't know. I don't think that's how I'll react when they're old enough to ask the question. I think any of us can say no you don't have to get me anything' and I think we can tell the ... really does mean you don't have to get her anything but doesn't see the irony of what she then tells you.

What are you thoughts on my father's interesting behavior? (Details inside)

Description : What are you thoughts on my father's interesting behavior? (Details inside)

Last Answer : answer:Perhaps the telephone game is the problem here. Your dad receives an email from you that he is not expecting. He's discussing it with your sister and makes an off the cuff comment about how you must ... original comment. Just a theory :) I think it's great that you sent your dad that email.

How can I make my mother understand that I am going to be a musician and won't ever study anything "real" to get a "real job"?

Description : How can I make my mother understand that I am going to be a musician and won't ever study anything "real" to get a "real job"?

Last Answer : answer:As someone who is heavily involved in the Florida metal scene Do you like money? How about food? Places to live? I know dudes who have had incredibly successful musical careers, who ... are just straight-up homeless and living in tents and storage facilities. You need a contingency plan.

What do you think about the sacrifices parents make when they probably had their children for selfish reasons anyway?

Description : What do you think about the sacrifices parents make when they probably had their children for selfish reasons anyway?

Last Answer : answer: ...deserve some sort of special respect when they signed on for exactly that responsibility when they chose to have a child? I think this is worded kind of oddly. I don't know anyone that acts like ... it about all other things as well. Is that sort-of what you meant? If not, I'm sorry.

How many parents out there chronically think about killing their children?

Description : How many parents out there chronically think about killing their children?

Last Answer : Tragically, way too many it seems. I’m lucky, I worship my kids & would never knowingly put them in harm’s way. I don’t know what the solutions are for those who feel they can’t cope & take such drastic irreversible action, I just know it’s very, very sad.

What do you think about changing the names of adopted children?

Description : What do you think about changing the names of adopted children?

Last Answer : if they want them to choose their own names, their current names should be one of the choices

Asperger's Syndrome, benefits of a full diagnosis?

Description : Asperger's Syndrome, benefits of a full diagnosis?

Last Answer : I would think knowing would be half the battle. Once you know what you're dealing with, you can then work on ways to well deal with it. As far as confronting' your mom, go ahead and ... to protect you by keeping you in the dark. Misguided, yes, but probably with good intentions. Good luck!

A religious leader said substituting pets for children is a sin. Why?

Description : A religious leader said substituting pets for children is a sin. Why?

Last Answer : Who is that religious leader, exactly? Anyone with some status in the religious world can say stupid things like that. It doesn’t mean everyone who follows the same religion has to agree. This is just another egomaniac who thinks because he is on the high up he represents God.

People with grown-up children who moved back in with them because of the pandemic, how did that work out for you?

Description : People with grown-up children who moved back in with them because of the pandemic, how did that work out for you?

Last Answer : My son was living with me when Covid hit, as he was in his first job and getting ready for law school. Then he did his first year of law school remotely from home. He is now moved into his ... that we did was eat dinner together just about every night, no media and no phones at the dinner table.

When a parent is about to be on the steet (homeless) do the children go to foster parents?

Description : When a parent is about to be on the steet (homeless) do the children go to foster parents?

Last Answer : Ideal?

Should parents who go about losing small children on a regular basis be investigated?

Description : Should parents who go about losing small children on a regular basis be investigated?

Last Answer : I wouldn’t put it to the level of losing small children on a regular basis. They have ahd one targedy, and perhaps one more in their lives. They didn’t lose the two year old, he walked on a poorly covered borehole.

Do you believe parents should take precedence over their children?

Description : Do you believe parents should take precedence over their children?

Last Answer : You don’t have kids, do you? All the logic and reason you argue really doesn’t happen much in messy, emotionally fraught, real life.

Can you help me find an article where it states clearly that Trump is taking the children hostage until he can get his wall?

Description : Can you help me find an article where it states clearly that Trump is taking the children hostage until he can get his wall?

Last Answer : Interestingly enough, while researching this I came across a video of him telling reporters that it could not be changed by executive order. As soon as this video finished another popped up showing him doing exactly ... that will bring it up. Watch the video and then the one that pops up after it.

Parents....do you expect to get a gift from your children?

Description : Parents....do you expect to get a gift from your children?

Last Answer : I don’t expect anything. I raised my children to be their own people…make their own decisions based on their own views. My kids live about 4 states away so gifts are optional in my view. It is nice to get a Christmas or Birthday card, though.

What will the children of "helicopter parents" do after their parents are gone?

Description : What will the children of "helicopter parents" do after their parents are gone?

Last Answer : Possibly all of the above will happen to some of them. Just as children of abusers end up differently from one another in adult life, children of helicopter parents will thrive or falter. But I do agree with your main point, that they are likely to be rudely awakened at some point.

In what ways should we be treating children differently from adults?

Description : In what ways should we be treating children differently from adults?

Last Answer : I find I don’t need to marinate them as long. Seriously, I treat them with more patience. They’re people without a lot of experience, so I cut them more slack.

When the time comes, do you expect your grown children to be there, or at least be with you in your final days?

Description : When the time comes, do you expect your grown children to be there, or at least be with you in your final days?

Last Answer : You can never predict how fast or slowly your death may come. I wouldn’t expect my kids to put their lives on hold for months to sit by my bedside, but I would expect them to make an effort to come to wherever I am to see me while I was dying and/or for a funeral. And I believe they would do so.

Grandparents and parents: have you ever done something to or for your grandchildren or children that at least one of the parents was against?

Description : Grandparents and parents: have you ever done something to or for your grandchildren or children that at least one of the parents was against?

Last Answer : answer:My grandmother used to give me a certain amount of money everytime I visited her. Although my father was strongly opposed to it, saying that she needed the money for her living, she still gave me ... to spend only a little, and kept the rest. We still haven't told grandma about our decision.

Parents of grown step children, how do you handle it when the kids are disrespectful to your spouse?

Description : Parents of grown step children, how do you handle it when the kids are disrespectful to your spouse?

Last Answer : answer:My adult step children and their father (my former husband) have had serious ups and downs over the years but they talk about it. If my ex has or had issues, he dealt with them. I stayed ... , primarily because they grew up and had families of their own. I'm not sure how helpful this is.

Have you ever been ashamed of your parents? Are your children ashamed of you?

Description : Have you ever been ashamed of your parents? Are your children ashamed of you?

Last Answer : answer:I felt ashamed, or perhaps embarrassed, of my parents when I was young. That typical teenage drop me off a block away so no one sees you, mom type of stuff. I'm still sometimes embarrassed ... random people, but I'm not so much ashamed of her. I've been disappointed in my parents plenty.

So should we maybe stop punishments for children, full stop?

Description : So should we maybe stop punishments for children, full stop?

Last Answer : I think it’s unrealistic for parents never to yell, simply because they get frustrated. I would not call that punishment. As for swearing at your children, no that is not necessary…and yes, I do think punishing children is superfluous and counterproductive.

What do you do that you don't want your children to do?

Description : What do you do that you don't want your children to do?

Last Answer : I hang around being invisible. I would not want them to do that, because then they might see me doing the things I don’t want them to do, only I wouldn’t know it. That would be very bad.

Do children tend to follow in the footsteps of a parent(s) on welfare?

Description : Do children tend to follow in the footsteps of a parent(s) on welfare?

Last Answer : Sometimes. It really depends on how they feel about public assistance. Some see it as their right, some see it as an embarrasment and do what they can to get away from it. Some may grow up ... . And others failed to see it possible to become something. They labeled themselves as losers and gave in.

What is the most treasured gift you've received from your children?

Description : What is the most treasured gift you've received from your children?

Last Answer : Their love and respect. If you’re thinking material things, it was their handmade birthday cards to me. I’m a mother

Do children have to be forced to forgive?

Description : Do children have to be forced to forgive?

Last Answer : answer:Of course one cannot change what is in someone's heart, but the lesson is important for children to learn about appropriate behavior and getting along in a civilized society. So did your niece learn ... why she hates the other girl? What would you have done if this happened in front of you?

Parents: when your children misbehave do you get angry at them?

Description : Parents: when your children misbehave do you get angry at them?

Last Answer : No, It’s a teaching moment, not a screeching moment.

Should parents speak to their children in their native language?

Description : Should parents speak to their children in their native language?

Last Answer : answer:A fun way to teach your child two languages at one time is to have one parent speak the foreign language, and the other speak the country's language. Have the parents pretend like they cannot speak ... is ready. The child would then go to mom and speak to her in German that dinner is ready.

Parents: How does it feel when one of your children graduates?

Description : Parents: How does it feel when one of your children graduates?

Last Answer : answer:I miss mine a lot. I try not to be a pest because I know they have their own lives. Sometimes I wonder if I give them too much room; my youngest complains of being lonely, but managing that is ... kiss and tell you they ove you more than anything Leaving left a hole in my heart and my life.

Who else has seen parents raising their children to fit stereotypes?

Description : Who else has seen parents raising their children to fit stereotypes?

Last Answer : Designer labels on kids, period.

How much have you helped your grown children financially? Grown children, how much have your parents helped you?

Description : How much have you helped your grown children financially? Grown children, how much have your parents helped you?

Last Answer : answer:My mom helped me a lot after my ex-husband walked out and left me with a 10-month-old. She helped with watching my son so I could work and buying things I needed for him if I couldn't afford ... other money. We both know that we would help the other if we needed it and could afford to do it.

Do children have the right to know their biological parents?

Description : Do children have the right to know their biological parents?

Last Answer : I think they should know who there biological parents are. If I didn’t know who mine were, I would want to know.

If a custodial parent is living by his/herself with the children, would you consider that person a single parent if the other parent is very active and looks after the children on a regular basis?

Description : If a custodial parent is living by his/herself with the children, would you consider that person a single parent if the other parent is very active and looks after the children on a regular basis?

Last Answer : I believe the single in single parent is more of a signifier that the parent is not with partner rather than they’re raising the child by themselves but I see your point.

I know parents should love their children, should they like them ?

Description : I know parents should love their children, should they like them ?

Last Answer : It helps :\. My parents certainly seem to like me and my sister, and they seem to have done a pretty good job.

Someone please explain why pregnant women or those with small children deserve special parking spaces?

Description : Someone please explain why pregnant women or those with small children deserve special parking spaces?

Last Answer : To encourage them to shop at the store providing them. Realistically, one reason could be similar to the wider bays offered for wheelchair parking- to allow more room for them to remove and replace some of those monstrous prams without destroying the paintwork on adjacent vehicles.

Adult children: How often do you call/talk to your parents?

Description : Adult children: How often do you call/talk to your parents?

Last Answer : Weekly or biweekly.

Do parents give their children middle names so that the kids will know when they're in big trouble?

Description : Do parents give their children middle names so that the kids will know when they're in big trouble?

Last Answer : Hmmm. I don’t have a middle name, and my parents have never had a problem letting me know when I am in trouble.

What is your view on parents and kissing their children on the lips?

Description : What is your view on parents and kissing their children on the lips?

Last Answer : Gro-ho-ho-ossss

How do you divide up belongings that will be inherited amonst the children?

Description : How do you divide up belongings that will be inherited amonst the children?

Last Answer : I think I’m going to go start tagging my art for the kids. I never want to put them in this position. I guess I better make a list for my jewelry too. I’m so sorry you have to go through this. There are really no good answers.

Tattooed parents: How do you feel about your children getting tattoos?

Description : Tattooed parents: How do you feel about your children getting tattoos?

Last Answer : I won’t care at all. I’ll probably really like it if he enjoys getting tattoos, like I enjoy getting them.

How do adult children of alcoholics learn what's socially expected?

Description : How do adult children of alcoholics learn what's socially expected?

Last Answer : We learn from Family Ties and Charles in Charge. That’s how I learned about normal family life when I was a kid.

What is your opinion on "medical neglect" of children by their parents?

Description : What is your opinion on "medical neglect" of children by their parents?

Last Answer : Religious beliefs are wrong when a human life is at stake. No faith should require you to sit back and watch your child die.

Should people have to pass a test before having children?

Description : Should people have to pass a test before having children?

Last Answer : Though I often feel this way, it’s not really ethical. I mean, what if they have test anxiety?

does parents debt pass on to the children

Description : does parents debt pass on to the children

Last Answer : Debt generally gets reconciled with the estate, so that when your grandmother dies all her remaining assets will be used to pay off the debt and then the other creditors will just go away ... answer for financial planning purposes, you or your parents should really talk to a lawyer or accountant.

When starting a new job, how long do you think you have to be there before you can ask a coworker to stop smacking her gum?

Description : When starting a new job, how long do you think you have to be there before you can ask a coworker to stop smacking her gum?

Last Answer : I’d first be SURE it distracted me. Maybe it’s the training that’s difficult (or the trainer) and you’re just taking it out on the chewing – and you may not even realize this. Or maybe it’s the woman herself.

Does smacking your child help?

Description : Does smacking your child help?

Last Answer : Getting smacked teaches kids not to do certain behaviors in front of their parents. Understanding why a behavior is wrong, means the person will not do the behavior even when they could get away with the ... give you a smack for not sitting still. Give me a break. How does anyone justify it?

Is smacking your dog effective in the disciplinary department?

Description : Is smacking your dog effective in the disciplinary department?

Last Answer : What? No. It’s not effective with anyone or any living being unless you want them to dislike you or be scared of you.

Rewrite : What thirst quenching,lip smacking,delicious non alcoholic drinks would you recommend for a party of teetotalers?

Description : Rewrite : What thirst quenching,lip smacking,delicious non alcoholic drinks would you recommend for a party of teetotalers?

Last Answer : Coke Zero. Tastes great, and there’s no guilt involved.

Does driving encourage narcissistic and sociopathic behavior? Is this a problem of negligence or lack of empathy? What can be done?

Description : Does driving encourage narcissistic and sociopathic behavior? Is this a problem of negligence or lack of empathy? What can be done?

Last Answer : answer:Possibly more car-free lifestyles would encourage improvement. Sadly, we don’t demand formal driver’s training. If everyone had to take that, driving would be better.