When writing history papers, should you change how groups are referred to to reflect modern sensibilities?

When writing history papers, should you change how groups are referred to to reflect modern sensibilities?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

I would use the term as it is used within the original work but you might consider putting it in quotation marks. There is a strong case to be made for considering terms in the historical context in which they were created and I would not Bowdlerize them or expect that your Professor would want it done.
by

Related questions

Why do people often not use capital letters when writing modern English?

Description : Why do people often not use capital letters when writing modern English?

Last Answer : I believe it leaked over from computing where email addresses and URLs are lower case.

Do you think we should stop teaching cursive writing?

Description : Do you think we should stop teaching cursive writing?

Last Answer : My daughter was never taught it.

Do you have any writing tips and tricks?

Description : Do you have any writing tips and tricks?

Last Answer : Here’s one tip. Catch that “t” and add it to “here” for “there ya go.”

Do you know of any good reputable sites that buy writing from...

Description : Do you know of any good reputable sites that buy writing from...

Last Answer : Amazon publishing I think they buy e-books for kindle.

When you were little and read a story, did you see the story, or the writing?

Description : When you were little and read a story, did you see the story, or the writing?

Last Answer : Images for sure. I need editors in my life when I try to write. Flither had helped a bunch though.

Do you know any website I can use to improve grammar and writing?

Description : Do you know any website I can use to improve grammar and writing?

Last Answer : This Grammar of Doom game from the list looks like fun.

In writing a backward-trending narrative, is it wise to write it in past tense?

Description : In writing a backward-trending narrative, is it wise to write it in past tense?

Last Answer : answer:What about describing events in present tense as though you're slowly watching the scene rewind. For instance, if she was stabbing him, you could describe something to the effect of her ... into existing holes, which slowly disappear as the blade slides back out. Does that make sense?

Do I use an apostrophe when writing "the marble's weight"?

Description : Do I use an apostrophe when writing "the marble's weight"?

Last Answer : You are right; Word is wrong. Word.

Do I use quotations when writing in the first person?

Description : Do I use quotations when writing in the first person?

Last Answer : Yes.

Can I use "...that is" in a professional writing piece?

Description : Can I use "...that is" in a professional writing piece?

Last Answer : Imho, ‘that is’ is not needed. It slows down the reader and keeps you from getting to the really good part of the sentence- the part where something happens.

Does writing improve ones english?

Description : Does writing improve ones english?

Last Answer : From what I’ve read, or questions that are posted here when it comes to improving english, the suggestions are to practice it constantly. Please give me a random topic to talk about. And I shall type in what I would say in english

when writing a paper, when do you use footnotes and when do you cite on the page (endnotes)?

Description : when writing a paper, when do you use footnotes and when do you cite on the page (endnotes)?

Last Answer : I don't know, but I used to use endnotes when I needed my paper to be longer, and footnotes when I needed it to fit within a page limit. Seriously! :-) I never had a professor question me on either one. So I would say take your pick.

East/West Coast Sensibilities?

Description : East/West Coast Sensibilities?

Last Answer : I think it’s pretty obvious that the east coast is the better of the two. ~

Imagine every human being since the dawn of human beings had your brain. Civilization advances only as far as your ability to figure things out, and all of society is built according to your sensibilities. What would the world be like?

Description : Imagine every human being since the dawn of human beings had your brain. Civilization advances only as far as your ability to figure things out, and all of society is built according to your sensibilities. What would the world be like?

Last Answer : It would be a miracle if we even discovered fire.

Why is it An Historic... but it's A History?

Description : Why is it An Historic... but it's A History?

Last Answer : answer:This article may help you understand more. Both a historic and an historic are correct.

Writing Summary, Research, and Theory/Comment papers?

Description : Writing Summary, Research, and Theory/Comment papers?

Last Answer : Which writing style are you using (MLA, APA)? The rules for the papers may vary a bit from one writing style to another.

Does MLA work cited offer help writing papers at the high school level?

Description : Does MLA work cited offer help writing papers at the high school level?

Last Answer : MLA work cited does not offer help writing papers. MLA work cited is a type of document format that is used for the way you should list cited information you used in your document.

The research papers writing methodology has slight variations in reference to Options: A) The standards maintained by research journals B) The interests of the researchers C) The research traditions D) All of the above statements are correct with slight variations

Description : The research papers writing methodology has slight variations in reference to Options: A) The standards maintained by research journals B) The interests of the researchers C) The research traditions D) All of the above statements are correct with slight variations

Last Answer : D) All of the above statements are correct with slight variations 

How did each division for the KKK reflect postwar adjustments and the modern age?

Description : How did each division for the KKK reflect postwar adjustments and the modern age?

Last Answer : Need answer

How does modern western law enforcement reflect its historical heritage particularly in states like California Texas and Arizona?

Description : How does modern western law enforcement reflect its historical heritage particularly in states like California Texas and Arizona?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Did past tense of 'to light' change?

Description : Did past tense of 'to light' change?

Last Answer : I still think it’s lit. “My neighbor lit her candle” sounds much better than “My neighbor lighted her candle.”

How will history textbooks reflect the Trump years? How will school curricula in Germany and France differ from school curricula in the US?

Description : How will history textbooks reflect the Trump years? How will school curricula in Germany and France differ from school curricula in the US?

Last Answer : ”...people around the world” already learn two completely different interpretations. Actualy more than two interpretations. And there isn;t even agreement on US histroy wohin the United States. And we aren’t talking just US history, but world history.

What was cincinnatus's contribution to roman history How does he reflect some of the ideas of roman civilization?

Description : What was cincinnatus's contribution to roman history How does he reflect some of the ideas of roman civilization?

Last Answer : Need answer

How did American Romanticism reflect life in America during this period celebrated the individual focused on colonial history celebrated famous political leaders identified with the Age of Reason?

Description : How did American Romanticism reflect life in America during this period celebrated the individual focused on colonial history celebrated famous political leaders identified with the Age of Reason?

Last Answer : Need answer

Can both first person and third person be used in an autobiography?

Description : Can both first person and third person be used in an autobiography?

Last Answer : It might be used effectively by a really skillful author but it sounds like your friend is a novice so I would steer her away from that idea. Generally it would not be used.

Why is it upper bound and lower bound and not higher bound and lower bound?

Description : Why is it upper bound and lower bound and not higher bound and lower bound?

Last Answer : My first search revealed this is a mathematical concept. So you should direct this question to whoever first coined the term. The definition is below. https://www.mathsisfun.com/definitions/upper-bound.html

Please may you identify and resolve the problems in my online test taking?

Description : Please may you identify and resolve the problems in my online test taking?

Last Answer : I can't offer a diagnosis, but I can readily tell you your grammar is good. You rarely make errors in your writing on here, and we look for poor English. I think taking online tests is ... would not put great importance on the result. Perhaps you could view it lightheartedly. You could try anyway.

What are some tricks to discover a bot?

Description : What are some tricks to discover a bot?

Last Answer : RedDeerGuy1, could you please restate the question? I can’t tell whether you’re talking about here on Fluther or elsewhere, and if you’re thinking of texts or email or some other medium. And I don’t quite know what you mean by tricks. I assume you’re referring to spambots, but maybe not—?

How far can I raise my test scores, from going on a low FODMAP diet for IBS (Irritable Bowel Syndrome)?

Description : How far can I raise my test scores, from going on a low FODMAP diet for IBS (Irritable Bowel Syndrome)?

Last Answer : How are we supposed to be able to answer this? Keep up the good work and let us know how you are doing. You have nothing to lose and stand to gain in health and getting into a university. Are you still planning to go to a university? How many years has it been?

Who is the instigator of the action in this combination?

Description : Who is the instigator of the action in this combination?

Last Answer : I interpret it as I don’t like the fact he’s reading books. I don’t completely understand either of your interpretations.

The use of the word "warrant"?

Description : The use of the word "warrant"?

Last Answer : They aren't incorrect. They are a bit awkward. People don't use warranted in that manner in everyday speech, especially in the second example. Warranted implies ether a sort of authorization, ... reason or justification. Those sense would not be used in a conversation about someone seeking a job.

What is the best spell checker website that doesn't require you to sign up?

Description : What is the best spell checker website that doesn't require you to sign up?

Last Answer : I don’t know that a best spell checker is required. You just need something that checks spelling. GOOGLE “spell checker” for lists of free services.

Should exclamation points and question marks be at the beginning of a sentence?

Description : Should exclamation points and question marks be at the beginning of a sentence?

Last Answer : Perhaps. They do do that in Spanish.

Famous with or among?

Description : Famous with or among?

Last Answer : You could say either, preferably among of those two, but neither is a common preposition to sue with famous . Much more common (by a ratio of 9:1) is famous in , though that requires not ... in US teenage pop culture. See https://lingohelp.me/preposition-after-adjective/famous-for-in-of-by-as/

What is the difference between these two sentences? (Have been/were)

Description : What is the difference between these two sentences? (Have been/were)

Last Answer : There are two possibilities. She might start wondering before you arrive, in which case I would say, If you are late she will be wondering where you are. Alternatively, she might start wondering at the time ... in which case I would say, If you are late, she will be wondering where you had been.

Is the use of "have eaten" correct in this sentence?

Description : Is the use of "have eaten" correct in this sentence?

Last Answer : have not

What is the difference between these two sentences?

Description : What is the difference between these two sentences?

Last Answer : Was is in the past.

The use of articles?

Description : The use of articles?

Last Answer : No 1 is correct. No native English speaker would use 2 or 3.

What periods of time are implied?

Description : What periods of time are implied?

Last Answer : Can you illustrate when studying takes place in each of them. When? In all three sentences, the studying took place before the exam. How long before the actual exam? It is unclear. We can only ... exam. It suggests that the person put more effort rather than more time in studying for the exam.

The combination of tenses?

Description : The combination of tenses?

Last Answer : I don’t know if “were” should be interpreted as past tense. It might be a subjunctive. When you say “We have thought”, it creates a hypothetical.

What is the difference among "have been", "having been", and "have been doing"? What is the difference between "have been doing" and "have been here"?

Description : What is the difference among "have been", "having been", and "have been doing"? What is the difference between "have been doing" and "have been here"?

Last Answer : I am drafting a response to your questions, but also want to know why you are being so analytical of this sort of thing: 1. To be able to explain this to your mom? 2. To strengthen ... the differences of the verb forms you are wanting to understand without having some basic knowledge of the above.

What is the difference between "being" and "having been"?

Description : What is the difference between "being" and "having been"?

Last Answer : This is why literacy is important. Being able to read the words helps to understand grammar and pronunciation. In fact, we can observe that dialects partly evolve from illiteracy, although to be clear ... it wrong again. There are exceptions in English since the spelling of so many words is unusual.

Can "que" ever translate to "it" or does "que" only translate to "that"?

Description : Can "que" ever translate to "it" or does "que" only translate to "that"?

Last Answer : Que can translate to that, than, who , whom , which , what , or and in English. I don't see a way to make que mean it . See https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary ... com/questions/38119/what-is-the-meaning-of-que-fu%C3%B1enga Sounds like it is sort of like how crappy or something.

Is it "Latinos para (Trump/Biden)" or "Latinos por (Trump/Biden)"?

Description : Is it "Latinos para (Trump/Biden)" or "Latinos por (Trump/Biden)"?

Last Answer : Por Latinos por Biden.

Why is it Tengo un libro para ti instead of Tengo un libro por ti? Isn't por used for exchanges? The sentence Tengo un libro por ti indicates that I will give you something and giving is exchanging, right? Please help.

Description : Why is it Tengo un libro para ti instead of Tengo un libro por ti? Isn't por used for exchanges? The sentence Tengo un libro por ti indicates that I will give you something and giving is exchanging, right? Please help.

Last Answer : Exchange means trade or swap: you give them something and they give you something back for it. It's not a gift, its one thing traded for another: I give you the book and you give me a scarf. So maybe ... a gift. I don't know the Spanish rules at all, but I can see that you're misusing exchange.

What is this type of person called?

Description : What is this type of person called?

Last Answer : You could say they are recalcitrant.

Grammar question: where is the line between the passive voice and (to be) as a linking verb?

Description : Grammar question: where is the line between the passive voice and (to be) as a linking verb?

Last Answer : Here is how I see it. For a word to be an adjective, it must be describing some object. If you say, The pot was watched , watched is not a property of the pot. There is an irony in ... would ordinarily be on the current state of the pot rather than acts of tarnishing that had been made on it.

What's the difference in the meaning of the following sentences?

Description : What's the difference in the meaning of the following sentences?

Last Answer : He was handsome, tall and a musician. The words after was describe he, the subject of the sentence. He was a handsome, tall musician. Handsome and tall describe musician, which is ... then sentence. Ultimately, the sentences are talking about the same thing using different ways of getting there.

In the game show Wheel of Fortune has anyone ever bought an y?

Description : In the game show Wheel of Fortune has anyone ever bought an y?

Last Answer : No, you only have to pay for A, E, I, O and U. Y is always treated as a consonant

Isn't the phrase "I'm sorry for your loss" grammatically incorrect?

Description : Isn't the phrase "I'm sorry for your loss" grammatically incorrect?

Last Answer : I think it could mean: “I feel sorry for you, that you lost your brother”. It’s not not so much an apologetic sentence as it is an empathic one.