Why are most of the training jobs that I see advertised for instructional designers and not for facilitators?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:To answer your question: * Instructional design takes a much longer time to produce a quality product than it does to train a facilitator to teach a class. Thus, more IDs are needed if the project is time-sensitive. * IDs can build in pre- and post-classwork, thus reducing the amount of time for facilitators and participants to be in the classroom. The last job I had was working in a training department for a large hotel organization. Over the past several decades (since computers came out), the focus for training gradually shifted from classroom instruction to CBT (Computer Based Training). The company’s goal was to provide the best and most consistent training possible as quickly as possible. CBT training worked well for learning certain skills like how to use the chain-wide computer system. It also reduced the amount of time needed to bring new managers up-to-speed on the history and culture of our company before they came to a management training class. What we learned is that CBT is not a substitute for certain skills, such as sales and customer service. This takes classroom discussion, role-playing, and then actual practice in the real world. It also required follow-up after the class. Like you, I prefer facilitation over instructional design. It is rare to find someone who enjoys both. From what I’ve witnessed you might be better off seeking out independent training companies that deliver both ID and facilitation to other companies. When we needed to outsource our training needs due to high demand, there were several companies that were hired to work with us. Their business was not limited to the hotel industry. If you would like some leads, feel free to send me a PM, and I would be glad to share the names of these companies. Another factor to keep in mind is that during recessions, training is one of the first areas to be cut. Sad, but true.

Related questions

Description : Has anyone ever been a Soccer coach for young kids?

Last Answer : Are you thinking of coaching? I haven’t coached soccer. I know a few fundamentals but not a lot of them. John Wooden was a legendary basketball coach in the US. He was all about fundamentals. Get those down and the rest is easy.

Description : What's your reaction to Jim Tressel resigning at Ohio State?

Last Answer : answer:I disagree @josie. I think it is time for the double standard to stop. The colleges and universities are making money off the backs of these young men, and they are getting nothing. That’s not right. I think it is the NCAA system that has to change.

Description : Any cheerleading savvy people out there?

Last Answer : I am. Got any photos?

Description : Are you a player or spectator?

Last Answer : I am a spectator and a player. I love watching baseball (basball junkie…watching WBC right now) and particpate in bowling. I also enjoy an occasional indoor soccer game.

Description : What are some ways of reaching people who are in career transition?

Last Answer : Try ex-brokers. I am serious (as well as having fun): see this article about JumpStart NYC

Description : What are your experiences with mindmapping?

Last Answer : I use a piece of paper and a pencil :). You can also use mindmanager which is a cool piece of software but I just prefer a big whiteboard or paper for personal mind map.

Description : What is it called when someone always starts their comments with "I know it seems silly, but..." or "This might sound stupid, but..."? What is that type of prefacing called? Is there some specific term?

Last Answer : Self-effacing would be one term.

Description : how can I best expand a new coaching business?

Last Answer : Real coaching – or the telling people what they want to hear for exorbitant amounts of cash, without one’s having studied anything prior like, say, Psychology, or heaven forbid, a real shrink.? That kind of business?

Description : Are there any suggestions out there for a new volley ball coach?

Last Answer : answer:Let me suggest that you consider aligning yourself with the American Volleyball Coaches Association They should be able to supply you with any ideas you might need. Volleyball is the national ... very excited watching a bunch of gals playing volleyball, without wearing any team uniforms.

Description : Badminton Coaching

Last Answer : A great coach is behind every great badminton player. Early on in a player's career, the coach fills the all-important role of being a mentor, the spiritual and emotional guide for the young ... High level techniques are a common sight, and so are quick exchanges propelled by powerful jump smashes.

Description : ADD Coaching

Last Answer : About six percent of the American adult population today is suffering from Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD). ADD is a behavioral condition that cannot be prevented or cured; however, different forms of ... adults. By taking advantage of ADD coaching, adults can finally take charge of their lives.

Description : What do you think would the effects on the economy and society at large be, if sales people in general treated customers like in this instructional training video?

Last Answer : It was pretty funny, I even LOL’d, but no I hope it never comes to this, yikes!

Description : Which one of the following best describes users? a. Providers of both strategic and tactical direction to the project. b. Those intended to receive benefits or operate outputs. c. Facilitators of an appropriate issue resolution procedure. d. Those providing full-time commitment to the project.

Last Answer : b. Those intended to receive benefits or operate outputs.

Description : Which one of the following best describes users?  a. Providers of both strategic and tactical direction to the project.  b. Those intended to receive benefits or operate outputs.  c. ... of an appropriate issue resolution procedure.  d. Those providing full-time commitment to the project.

Last Answer : b. Those intended to receive benefits or operate outputs.

Description : Most jobs are either not advertised or are actually filled before an ad is placed

Last Answer : Need Answer

Description : Designers, Photographers, Animators: What are some of the most common interview questions you have been asked for industry-related jobs?

Last Answer : Who have you worked for is one. A second would be what is your favorite picture. Third, show me your best work.

Description : In ............. generation of operating system, operating system designers develop the concept of multiprogramming in which several jobs are in main memory at once. A) First B) Second C) Third D) Fourth

Last Answer : C) Third

Description : Where can I find more info about interior designers and their work and training?

Last Answer : HGTV employs many interior designers on their reality-styled shows. You can learn more about their work and training by watching that channel, or browsing HGTV.com instead.

Description : What great instructional class project can I present in 7-10 minutes?

Last Answer : answer:Well, to take cooking and beauty products and smash them together, why not bring your blender and/or food processor, and demonstrate to the class how to make all-natural cleansers and beauty ... wash off five minutes later), strawberry-and-milk puree facial, and almond and honey face scrub.

Description : Does anyone know a good belly dancing instructional DVD or video?

Last Answer : I rented some belly-dancing DVDs from Netflix. The ones I got were taught by identical twins - I think their names were Reena and Veena or Neena or something. Anyway, I did it in the living room every evening and had a lot of fun. I'd recommend them.

Description : What are the best masters programs for Instructional design or Educational Technology?

Last Answer : As always, start with U.S. News & World Report. You should be able to look up schools by program and the converse.

Description : What is instructional economy or socialist economy ?

Last Answer : An economy in which most of the resources and means of production of the society are owned by the state or government is called instructional economy. This economy is also called socialist economy. ... . Because in this economy all economic decisions come from a central planning authority ( CPA) .

Description : What are the disadvantages of using instructional materials in teaching?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : What is instructional leader traits and behaviors?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : What is Instructional leader traits and behavior?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : What is Instructional leader?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : A teacher will become an effective communicator if: (a) He use instructional aids (b) He helps students to get meaning of what is being taught (c) He asks questions between teaching (d) He helps students get correct answers on the topic

Last Answer : (b) He helps students to get meaning of what is being taught

Description : Visualization in the instructional process cannot increase (a) Interest and motivation (b) Retention and adaptation (c) Stress and boredom (d) Curiosity and concentration

Last Answer : (c) Stress and boredom

Description : Additional requirements other than the usual human skills of the teacher in the models of teaching is the (a) Support system (b) Social system (c) Nurturant effects (d) Instructional effects

Last Answer : (a) Support system

Description : The five domain taxonomy of instructional objective was proposed by (a) Anderson & Krathwohl (b) Mc Cormack and Yager (c) Jerome S. Bruner (d) Benjamin S. Bloom

Last Answer : (b) Mc Cormack and Yager

Description : The Test On The Basis Of Which A Teacher Takes Decision About The Students Is Known As Options: A) Performance Test B) Institutional Test C) Revision Test D) Instructional Test

Last Answer : A) Performance Test

Description : The most important function of a teacher is to Options: A) facilitate learning B) manage instructional resources C) coordinate curricular activities D) provide information

Last Answer : A) facilitate learning 

Description : Instructional objectives are useful to Options: A) Teachers B) Students C) Question paper setters D) All of the above

Last Answer : D) All of the above

Description : Which of the following is not instructional material? Options: A) Over Head Projector B) Audio Cassette C) Printed Material D) Transparency

Last Answer : D) Transparency

Description : Instructional aides are used by the teacher to (A) Glorify the class (B) Attract the students (C) Clarify the concepts (D) Ensure discipline 

Last Answer : (C) Clarify the concepts

Description : Arrange the following teaching process in order : (i) Relate the present knowledge with previous one (ii) Evaluation (iii) Reteaching (iv) Formulating instructional objectives (v) Presentation of instructional materials (A) (i), (ii), ( ... ), (iii), (i), (ii) (D) (iv), (i), (v), (ii), (iii)

Last Answer : (D) (iv), (i), (v), (ii), (iii)

Description : Which of the following is not instructional material ? (A) Over Head Projector (B) Audio Casset (C) Printed Material (D) Transparency

Last Answer : Answer: A  "Instructional material" means content that conveys the essential knowledge and skills of a subject in the public school curriculum through a medium or a combination ... otherwise contributing to the learning process through electronic means, including open-source instructional material.

Description : 'SITE' stands for: (A) System for International technology and Engineering (B) Satellite Instructional Television Experiment (C) South Indian Trade Estate (D) State Institute of Technology and Engineering

Last Answer : Answer: B  SITE : Satellite Instructional Television Experiment ( Indian Space Research Organisation). The SITE was an experimental satellite communications project launched in India in 1975, designed ... states and territories. (Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Orissa, Rajasthan)

Description : If you are a vegetarian, what would you think of a vegetarian restaurant that advertised serving turkey, fish and beef?

Last Answer : If I went to a restaurant that advertised itself as being a vegetarian restaurant, but then I found out that they also served meat, and fish, and fowl, I would consider that to be fraudulent advertising ... when people who can't choose to eat any vegetarian or vegan items, understand why we need to.

Description : Do you know a back pain patient who has done this as advertised?

Last Answer : My daughter has severe back pain. She’s disabled. And yes. That’s a thing, but it couldn’t be tried in her case. :(

Description : Would you ever buy anything advertised as being made from animal fur?

Last Answer : answer:One of my cats absolutely refuses to play with anything made of synthetic fur, but loves playing with cat toys made from actual rabbit fur. That said, I prefer to get such cat toys from local ... and ground beef that I make burgers from. Somehow, I doubt my cat has any such ethical concerns.

Description : Is it so wrong to want my technology to work as advertised?

Last Answer : THAT my friend is why a smart person does not buy an ipod, but a generic mp3 player. As long as mp3 exists and usb exists, an mp3 player, no matter from when, will work.

Description : Blank DVD media are advertised as "printable"; what does this mean?

Last Answer : Yes you need a special printer but its not that uncommon a feature on home inkjets to be honest once you get in to the mid-range models.

Description : Have you cold-called/approached an owner of a house you wanted to rent without it being advertised?

Last Answer : answer:Somewhat. A woman that I used to know (I haven’t seen her in about 30 years), asked if she could rent the spare bedroom in my house. I said she could, so she moved in. She paid me $100/month. That was a good deal for both of us, because my mortgage payment was only about $200/month.

Description : Have you been to a concert at the Houston Rodeo? Did it start when it was advertised to?

Last Answer : answer:I have. It didn’t. They never will. I don’t know wny this is, but every Texas rodeo I’ve been too, or that my father-in-law has been to, has been about an hour late getting started.

Description : What is the name of that DIY (do-it-yourself) furniture refinisher that is advertised in infomercials? UK/USA?

Last Answer : Trade Secret?

Description : What are different ways that goods or events are advertised?

Last Answer : Radio, Newspapers.

Description : What is the name of that easy computer backup lollipop device that's advertised on TV?

Last Answer : i dont know about no lollipops, but was it perhaps mozy ?

Description : Does a Spongetech sponge work as advertised?

Last Answer : The website says the car sponge [for instance] is good for up to 8 washes. That counts in the fact that when you squeeze the sponge, soap washes out. You would be better off with a normal sponge and a ... of soap should last you about 6 months of car washing [if you wash your car 4 times a month].

Description : Does Target beat prices of advertised prices?

Last Answer : do you mean - do they price match? because i'm pretty sure they don't as a general rule, but that the team leads might have the power/ability to do so. I'd say it's worth asking.. but ask in ... and avoid asking "do you price match?" directly.. try to make them FEEL the competition. :-) good luck!