Why is it considered to be so horrible to rub a dog's nose in it when they deliberately poop in the house? Please read details.

Why is it considered to be so horrible to rub a dog's nose in it when they deliberately poop in the house? Please read details.
by

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:It is very cruel. The dog is aware that it pooped in the house. It is not the optimum choice for the dog so one of several things happened: 1. It had not been taken out and given a chance to poop adequately beforehand. Owner’s fault. 2. It was left in the house too long and could not hold it. Owner’s fault. 3. It got sick with diarrhea. No one’s fault. These things happen. So the reasons not to do it are legion: 1. The dog knows very well it did something not usually acceptable (not to the dog either, by the way). 2. Dogs have exquisite senses of smell and rubbing its nose in excrement is far more cruel than if you were to do that to a child (and would you? do that to a child?). 3. it does not accomplish what you want it to (getting the dog not to poop in the house). So why do it? Except to be cruel? If it was separation anxiety, which it sounds like it might have been from your description, it would be much more effective to crate him while you are gone until he learns not to poop in the house.
by

Related questions

How do you train your dog to poop in one area of your yard?

Description : How do you train your dog to poop in one area of your yard?

Last Answer : answer:I would place a photo of my ex mother-in-law in the desired spot, say the word, “Here!” and the dog did the rest. He ruined the photo, BTW. September 1, 2008, 5:31 PM EDT

Did Native Americans have pet dogs that helped them when they went hunting?

Description : Did Native Americans keep dogs as pets?

Last Answer : Yes, some Native American tribes had close relationships with their dogs. Some tribes forbade the killing of dogs for food. But not all tribes placed any value on dogs. Many tribes allowed their ... their goods and if necessary, tribe members in dog travois, and stood guard over their villages.

How do I stop my dog's whining?

Description : How do I stop my dog's whining?

Last Answer : A hand held water gun works with one of my dogs to stop barking. The other one I have a Dazzer II which when the button is pressed it makes a high pitch super-sonic noise that the human ear can't ... dead in it's tracks then responded a minute later with a weird super sonic noise. It was funny :)

Can old dogs learn new tricks?

Description : I'm looking to adopt a dog from our local shelter. They have a beautiful and sweet Lab that is a bit wild. She's 7 1/2 years old. I was wondering if it is possible to train her to be a bit less rambunctious and walk nicely on a leash. Can you teach an old dog new tricks?

Last Answer : Yes, older dogs are definitely capable of learning. Training may take more time, but be consistent, use only positive methods and most of all, be patient. Check out Simple and Effective Dog Training tips to get started.

Can you stop a dog from barking like mad everytime people walk by the house?

Description : Can you stop a dog from barking like mad everytime people walk by the house?

Last Answer : You can squirt lemon juice in their mouth every time they do it. The lemon creates a sensation in their mouth or throat that is displeasing to the dog but not harmful to them. What I like about ... you must do this while they are barking because dogs memories/minds do not work the same as humans.

How do I get my dog to stop chewing things when I leave the house?

Description : How do I get my dog to stop chewing things when I leave the house?

Last Answer : Think it’s about training her to find something else to chew on, like a…well, chewing thingy? Kinda like a scratching pole that cats use?

Does anyone here have experience with a citronella no-bark collar?

Description : Does anyone here have experience with a citronella no-bark collar?

Last Answer : My neighbors got one for their dog. It was a poodle (small) and would bark incessantly over nothing. When they put it on, it didn’t take long for the dog to realize when it barked, it got sprayed. I don’t know if it was citronella or not, but it was effective. The dog settled down quite a bit.

How can I make my old dog comfortable with my new dog?

Description : How can I make my old dog comfortable with my new dog?

Last Answer : Is the pup 8 weeks or 8 months? you said both He's jealous! Are you neutering just because of the new dog issues? IMO it won't help for that, although there are many good reasons to neuter anyway. I ... say never'!:-/) You should google it; there are loads of sites with advice for this. Good luck!

How do you train a dog to not pee on himself?

Description : How do you train a dog to not pee on himself?

Last Answer : DH’s dog does this too… not quite as often as when he was younger, maybe they will outgrow it eventually? Sorry I have no advice:-)

Romantic line to use in dog trick?

Description : Romantic line to use in dog trick?

Last Answer : “Awwww shucks!”

Why does my dog run?

Description : Why does my dog run?

Last Answer : Because he’s not getting enough exercise. He’s shut inside all day, what do you expect?

What can i do to stop the chewing?

Description : What can i do to stop the chewing?

Last Answer : There are “chew toys” that you can get for dogs like that, and any pet store can help you with that decision. So can your dog’s Vet.

How can I make my new dog get along with my other dog?

Description : How can I make my new dog get along with my other dog?

Last Answer : First, you could have a real problem here because of the size differential. Even when playing, your pit bull mix could injure a chihuahua. Second, you have a puppy. Make sure this dog is well trained ... was not home. Your dog has the right to live free from fear. Also, welcome to the collective.

How can I help my dog-aggressive dog?

Description : How can I help my dog-aggressive dog?

Last Answer : There are all manner of methods, but once when I had to mind our daughter's Rottie while she was overseas we had a problem. He didn't like our Rottie and the feeling was reciprocated. ... sniffing out the neighbourhood together, barking in unison at strange dogs etc,. , they became best buddies.

Why did my new dog attack the dog we already have.

Description : Why did my new dog attack the dog we already have.

Last Answer : Your question is cut off, so I am not sure what the ending was. Many Mals are very dog-aggressive. They also tend to be dominant, pushy dogs. Frankly, a Mal may not be a good fit for your situation, ... . It's always best to do a meeting before you adopt a dog to make sure the dogs will get along.

What's the best method for teaching a dog the trick "play dead"?

Description : What's the best method for teaching a dog the trick "play dead"?

Last Answer : answer:I was told (although never tried) that to get a dog to stay still you get him to stay and walk away from him in an increasingly large spiral. This is what I would do: -Teach him to lay ... dead' and keep walking away. This way the dog will learn to stay dead even if you're moving around

how do i get my dog to listen to me

Description : content:

Last Answer : Patience and repitition usually do the job. Choose a time each day. Teach your dog one command at a time until s/he masters it. When the dog doesn't respond, never punish, it doesn't work and ... without it, praise and give a treat. Check our articles on dog training. And remember, patience is key.

How can I train a spoiled dog not to beg at the table?

Description : We adopted a dog from a friend who was no longer able to take care of her. She is a sweet thing, but has this annoying habit of begging at the table. Is there any way to get her to stop?

Last Answer : Train her the down and stay commands, increasing the time spent with stay. Temporarily put up a gate or barrier to keep her out of your eating area. Never offer her anything at the table. You can feed ... . Or give her a puzzle toy with treats stuck in it to keep her occupied while you are eating.

How can I teach my dog to be friendly to strangers?

Description : I have a pug, and she really doesn't like new people. Is there anything that I can do to make her less nervous and barky around them?

Last Answer : Many breeds are by nature reserved with strangers. Dogs will read your body language and usually if you are welcoming, they will accept a stranger although they may never be best pals. Train your dog ... trust strangers, there are also some people you might not want your dog to be friendly towards.

How can I get my dog to stop barking at the gardener?

Description : The gardener comes aroung about once every couple of weeks. When he comes in the house, he pets our dogs and they like him. If he starts working outside, they go crazy. Is there any way to get them to ... he's working. It's really only one dog that's the problem. That dog starts the other one off.

Last Answer : answer:

When should you use a muzzle on a dog?

Description : Are there any times that a muzzle is called for?

Last Answer : A muzzle should only be used as a safety backup. In some places, it's the law to muzzle your dog when out walking. A muzzle is sometimes used at the vet's office for nervous dogs who may bite. ... dog. It can often make an aggressive dog more so. Use it only if you know circumstance will warrant it.

How can I teach my dog to fetch?

Description : My dog is pretty smart. I've taught her to heal and sit. How can I teach her to fetch?

Last Answer : Get some treats that she really likes. Throw the ball and then when she has it in her mouth call to her and when she comes give her a treat, she'll get the hang of it soon. :) But some dogs play 'mine' and won't play fetch, at all. My dog sometimes fetches but usually plays 'mine'. Hope it helps!

Can you train a deaf dog?

Description : There's a really sweet dog at the shelter that I'm considering adopting. He's young, large and he's deaf. If I adopt him, will I be able to train him? I only want to teach him basic training. Is it possible to train a deaf dog?

Last Answer : Dogs can be born deaf or lose their hearing through illness, injury or old age. But deaf dogs can be trained, you just have to adjust your methods and be kind and patient. There are vibrating ... training. Never scold or punish. The dog only learns to fear you and will not respond to training.

How can I stop my dog from barking when we put him in a crate?

Description : We're trying to crate train our dog before we take him on holiday. As soon as he goes in the crate, he starts barking and won't stop. How can we get him to calm down so we can enjoy our summer vacation with him?

Last Answer : The best way to calm your dog is to make the crate a pleasant place for him. Begin training well before you go on vacation. Place a couple of favorite toys and a treat in the crate to entice ... he's quiet good things happen. Gradually lengthen the time in the crate and your distance away from it.

What can I do to stop my dog from begging at the table?

Description : We adopted a 4-year-old dog and she came with this annoying habit of begging at the table. I never give my dog scraps from the table and I don't let anyone else give her any either. What I do to get her to stop begging when we sit down for a meal?

Last Answer : Teach your dog the down/stay commands, gradually lenthening the stay until you finish your meal. You can also temporarily put up a barrier - a gate - to keep your dog away from your eating area. Never ... a toy or puzzle that you can put treats in to keep her occupied until you finish your meal.

How can I get my dog to use his new bed?

Description : Our dog likes to sleep curled up on the carpet, We got him a bed because we thought it would make him more comfortable, but he doesn't use it. How can we get him to sleep in his bed instead of on the floor?

Last Answer : Dogs like to sleep in a place that's warm and secure. First be sure your dog's bed is in a clean area away from drafts. Place an article of clothing or a towel that has your scent on the bed. Or ... ). When your dog gets in the bed even for only a moment, praise him lavishly. He'll get the message/

Do you think someone made this penis-nose deliberately, as a joke?

Description : Do you think someone made this penis-nose deliberately, as a joke?

Last Answer : I think it is the power of suggestion, I guess it kinda looks like a penis but not anything I would have picked up on right off the bat, no. I like the green eyes too, just leave it alone and see if anyone else sees the penis nose. haha

How to rub a nose?

Description : I have a good cold and I've been blowing my nose into gray toilet paper all day. I have a frayed nose, nostrils, skin under my nose and around. Please advise some cream or anything that can alleviate skin irritation Thanks

Last Answer : I have Hema gel for abrasions

How can two dogs from the same litter, trained by the same person, be so different? (please read details)?

Description : How can two dogs from the same litter, trained by the same person, be so different? (please read details)?

Last Answer : For the same reason that two children raised by the same parents are different! Like humans, dogs are individuals.

Why do dogs shake their legs when you rub their belly?

Description : Why do dogs shake their legs when you rub their belly?

Last Answer : From Googling: Tickle a dog's tummy, and you could get a knee-jerk reaction. There is a certain area on a dog's body that is referred to as the saddle region. It vaguely consists of ... reflex as a diagnostic tool, much like when doctors tap humans just below the kneecap to test nerve reactions.

Why does it put babies and dogs to sleep to lightly rub their foreheads and in between their eyes?

Description : Why does it put babies and dogs to sleep to lightly rub their foreheads and in between their eyes?

Last Answer : I fall asleep when someone does that to me. I think it relaxes them and they know you care for them. But I’m no dog so I wouldn’t know…

How do you rub dogs' paws?

Description : I mean in winter as protection against salt, or from a long run on rough terrain.

Last Answer : I tried to lubricate the dogs' paws with Indulon when I was young. Not only did they lick the cream, even though I was watching it, but worse, the horny skin on my paws softened. And the salt was ... into spring and combing is a pain for us. For both. And today our neighbor took a picture of us.

Why do dogs eat poop?

Description : Why do dogs eat poop?

Last Answer : I will ask the Dog. As you can see, she is studying the sidewalk intently. She is watching bugs—and then she will eat them.

Why are my dogs eating their own poop!

Description : Why are my dogs eating their own poop!

Last Answer : Because they’re dogs?

How do you guys teach your dogs to poop in the right places?

Description : How do you guys teach your dogs to poop in the right places?

Last Answer : I poop there first and stick his nose in it so he knows where to go

Why do mama dogs eat their puppies poop?

Description : content:

Last Answer : Mama dogs eat their pups' poop to keep the area they live in clean. The smell can also attract predators which is another reason mama cleans up. She also licks her pups' bottoms to help stimulate them to defecate and urinate. This is normal behavior. It stops once the puppies are weaned.

Why is a hate crime considered worse than the same crime with no "hateful" overtones? (PLEASE READ DETAILS).

Description : Why is a hate crime considered worse than the same crime with no "hateful" overtones? (PLEASE READ DETAILS).

Last Answer : I understand exactly what you mean, @KatawaGrey. I’ve wondered this myself. It is just politics.

I think we would all agree that the video I posted in the details is horrible...but would you agree that this kind of behavior is glorified in so many ways in our society today?

Description : I think we would all agree that the video I posted in the details is horrible...but would you agree that this kind of behavior is glorified in so many ways in our society today?

Last Answer : answer:I agree that most of the reactions are rather counterproductive. It reminds me of Sophie Lancaster, a goth girl who was killed by some dudes who beat the crap out of her for being a goth, and ... important part is that kids look up to us as exemplary models on how to deal with these things.

I have such horrible FATIGUE, can you please give me ALL of the tips you can think of to help fight it?

Description : I have such horrible FATIGUE, can you please give me ALL of the tips you can think of to help fight it?

Last Answer : answer:Mushrooms… eat all the mushrooms you can. It’s like eating sunshine. And if you set them in the sunlight for a minute or so they will increase their already high vitamin D content by 10,000X or more. If you can’t eat the mushrooms, then get a regular dose of sunlight on your body. Mushrooms!

Horrible Constipation!! Please help!

Description : Horrible Constipation!! Please help!

Last Answer : Did you try an enema? Also if you eat, eat some raisins or prunes. Also, drink some caffeine.

Hey, do you like pony poop? (see details)

Description : Hey, do you like pony poop? (see details)

Last Answer : Hahaha, strange thing is, I know exactly what you are talking about. I absolutely love that smell. I used to ride horses and I’d always look forward to that smell.

Hypothetical question: If you witnessed a horrible accident...(rest in details)

Description : Hypothetical question: If you witnessed a horrible accident...(rest in details)

Last Answer : Come forward, of course. It’s just a phone call.

Which footwear is ideal for tracking in dog poop and spit, etc., into the house?

Description : Which footwear is ideal for tracking in dog poop and spit, etc., into the house?

Last Answer : Wooden shoes, also known as clogs.

I found pigeon feathers & poop in my house.. No open windows what does this mean?

Description : I found pigeon feathers & poop in my house.. No open windows what does this mean?

Last Answer : I think it was a prank.

Which is more effective, spaying female dogs and cats or neutering the males? (Please see details.)

Description : Which is more effective, spaying female dogs and cats or neutering the males? (Please see details.)

Last Answer : Well neutering the males is cheaper and far less risky and invasive. On the hand, personally, the racket a female cat in heat makes me want to murder things.

I would like to have a dog's nose for a day. What animal sense would you like to experience?

Description : I would like to have a dog's nose for a day. What animal sense would you like to experience?

Last Answer : answer:The eyes of a mantis shrimp “some species are capable of seeing light that is invisible to us, distinguishing more shades of visible light than us, and detecting properties of light impossible for humans to comprehend.”

Why is a dog's nose sometimes wet and sometimes dry?

Description : Why is a dog's nose sometimes wet and sometimes dry?

Last Answer : Snot. And your dog’s tongue. Disgusting little beasties.

Should a healthy dogs nose be warm or cold, wet or dry?

Description : Should a healthy dogs nose be warm or cold, wet or dry? Should a healthy dogs nose be warm or cold, wet or dry?

Last Answer : It's an old wives tale if you can tell how your dog is feeling by feeling his nose. Dogs' noses feel differently depending on activity, weather, etc. You can read more about dogs and their noses here in The Pet wiki article: Dogs and Cold, Wet Noses

Why is it so important to get pot legalized? (Please read details).

Description : Why is it so important to get pot legalized? (Please read details).

Last Answer : Why do you assume that there is such a large legalization of pot movement? I am not sure that is so.

Do you think that Procter & Gamble is wrong to make a poisonous product that they deliberately design to look like candy?

Description : Do you think that Procter & Gamble is wrong to make a poisonous product that they deliberately design to look like candy?

Last Answer : Yes.