What's wrong with the dismissive "It's just a theory." reasoning?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:@ETpro: “What’s the most effective way to help those unschooled in science understand the differences in individual hunch-style theory, scientific hypothesis, scientific theory and scientific law?” Great question. It seems, however, that people who use theory in the “hunch” sense when discussing science aren’t merely ignorant of the concept of a scientific theory. Many of these people appear to be intentially misusing the word. There are apologists that have been doing their thing for many years, and have been called out on their lack of understanding of scientific theory for just as many years. The fact that they continue to practice this deception is intentional. There’s no way around it. We recently had a thread about how amazing science education is in public schools in the U.S. (~), so I think average people with a high school diploma know the difference – or knew there was a difference at one point. Maybe they need a reminder. It’s too bad that scientists can’t just decide on a new term altogether, as “theory” appears to have been ruined. But I can’t see this as solving much other than to hand certain groups another piece of ammo in their conspiracy theories about how science is trying to pull the wool over everyone’s eyes.

Related questions

Description : Does this seem dismissive to you?

Last Answer : I think many people have no idea what to write or say in difficult, upsetting, or tragic situations. They do their best, may not fully understand the importance of certain details, but just want to be ... and say something nice . People often miss the mark, but I like to assume they mean well.

Description : Identify the incorrect statement: (A) A hypothesis is made on the basis of limited evidence as a starting point for further investigations. (B) A hypothesis is a basis for reasoning without ... is a proposed explanation for a phenomenon. (D) Scientific hypothesis is a scientific theory.

Last Answer : (D) Scientific hypothesis is a scientific theory. 

Description : The first scientist to apply scientific reasoning to cosmology was Rene Descartes. What was his theory called?

Last Answer : Answer: Vortex Theory.

Description : What type of reasoning what is used in the development of evolutionary theory?

Last Answer : It was bad reasoning.Charles Darwin saw how breeders of dogs or cattle selected forcertain good traits when they breed their animals. Darwin thoughtthis was how one species evolved into another ... speciesevolving into another even in the fossil record there is noevidence of any intermediary forms.

Description : A digital investigator pursuing a line of investigation in a case because that line of Investigation proved successful in two previous cases is an example of: a. Logical reasoning b. Common sense c. Preconceived theory d. Investigator’s intuition

Last Answer : c. Preconceived theory

Description : Aristotle’s theory of syllogism and Descartes and kant’s critic of pure reasoning made knowledge on _____. A. Logic B. Computation logic C. Cognition logic D. All of above 

Last Answer : A. Logic 

Description : What's the reasoning behind shoelace length?

Last Answer : I think it has to do with ethics aesthetics. The dress shoes would look ridiculous with a big, fat bow. Granted, it can be a little hassle tying them (the short laces in the dress shoes), but it looks slick. Why the sneakers come with 100 feet, i have not an idea. Edited: Thanks @Fyrius !

Description : People who hate thrift stores and second hand stores, whats your reasoning?

Last Answer : Cause the clothes cost as much as brand new clothes, except they've been worn for years by someone else.

Description : Assertion (A) : After Russian occupation in Poland, the Russian language was imposed on its people. Reasoning (R) : The use of Polish

Last Answer : Two statements are given below as Assertion (A) and Reasoning (R). Read the statement and choose the most ... (A) is false but Reasoning (R) is true.

Description : The following statement is an example of what kind of logical fallacy? "The university should increase funding of intramural sports because it has a responsibility to back its sports programs financially." a) ... Reasoning c) Ad Populum (Bandwagon) Argument d) False Analogy e) None of the above

Last Answer : b) Circular Reasoning

Description : The following statement is an example of what kind of logical fallacy? "The university should increase funding of intramural sports because it has a responsibility to back its sports programs financially." a) ... Reasoning c) Ad Populum (Bandwagon) Argument d) False Analogy e) None of the above

Last Answer : b) Circular Reasoning

Description : In induction, reasoning proceeds to a conclusion that is ---------- to the scope of its premises.   A) confined B) not confined C) narrow D) restricted.

Last Answer : B) not confined 

Description : To what extent do you think our moral codes are governed by our reasoning ability?

Last Answer : However which way it goes, one thing I’m certain of is that emotions have a lot to do with it.

Description : An eco-heretic’s weighty reasoning?

Last Answer : This is interesting, and if the numbers on it held up (that is, if he’s right that current environmentalist methods don’t work well enough) I’d be inclined to agree with him.

Description : Science is derived from Latin word “scientia” which means-----? A. Reasoning B. Logic C. Knowledge (Answer) D. Life

Last Answer : C. Knowledge (Answer)

Description : State the pH of distilled water and rainwater. Justify your answer with proper reasoning.

Last Answer : Answer. The pH of distilled water is 7 because it has no dissolved minerals. The pH of rainwater is slightly acidic less than 7 because it becomes a little acidic due to CO2 and SO2 molecules present in the atmosphere.

Description : If you want to get smarter, you can take classes, learn logical reasoning and critical thinking skills, and so on. But what should you do if you want to become wiser?

Last Answer : Do all the things associated with getting smarter, and combine it with life experience.

Description : Can you figure out this basic symbolic reasoning puzzle?

Last Answer : Nope

Description : Reasoning/logic question: Premises, conclusion?

Last Answer : I would lean towards C. There is not enough information to arrive at a conclusion.

Description : What is the reasoning behind this logic question?

Last Answer : if housing starts are down, merrihew lumber does not necessarily go out of business. the question only states explicitly, that ML will not have to declare bankruptcy if housing projects are up. it does ... is unknown and it can not be determined whether or not they will phase out their masonry line.

Description : Is CPS allowed to publicize their reasoning for taking children away from their guardians?

Last Answer : No. CPS issues are only accessible by another CPS worker. It's supposed to be confidential, so if I am aware of someone having an indicated report, or other issue, I am not supposed to ... person, and people have been arrested for that (for looking/accessing information they had no reason to).

Description : How does one go about "reasoning" with a kid who doesn't speak English?

Last Answer : There is no reasoning with a 13 month old child. Just move them out of reach of the thing, distract them, or whatever to keep them safe until they are mature enough they can understand such concepts on their own.

Description : Any tips/advice on getting better at logical reasoning?

Last Answer : answer:Welcome to Fluther. Write more. By that I mean “write a lot”, read what you write and look for the holes. Then rewrite to correct the flaws. Repeat as necessary.

Description : Do you find that older people are more likely to accept suffering and inconvenience in their lives, and can you explain your reasoning?

Last Answer : Not at all. Older people tend to rant and rave more about “their suffering” and play the martyr card more. Screw it, I’m going somewhere with power.

Description : What distinguishes human intelligence, reasoning, and conceptualizing from animal intelligence?

Last Answer : answer:I think they are more intelligent than we give them credit for. I have seen them problem solve. I don't know if dogs can count, but theu can tell time to the minute, I don't think they spend ... us in that they live in the present. But really I think it is a matter of degree of difference.

Description : You and a friend are victims of kidnapping. The kidnapper tells you that one of you may go free but you are to make the choice. Who goes free? What is your reasoning?

Last Answer : Depends on the friend. Does that make me selfish?

Description : What is the reasoning behind gambling being illegal on US soil?

Last Answer : The government doesn’t collect its cut from illegal gambling, but makes serious bank on lotteries and approved casinos and such.

Description : If you were in this hypothetical scenario, would you rather make out with your mum or kill a friend? What is your reasoning?

Last Answer : Both.

Description : Can you help me wrap my head around conditional reasoning?

Last Answer : Sufficient must occur for the necessary to occur. Apples and apple trees really are biconditional statements. Because in real life you need apples to make apple trees (A -> T), and apple trees to ... required for survival, but without air survival is impossible. In other words, air is necessary. --

Description : Is the U.S. following in the footsteps of Rome's collapse? Explain Your Reasoning In Detail.

Last Answer : Definately. If history teaches us nothing else it is that great nations eventually fall.

Description : What is the evolutionary reasoning behind a mosquito's buzz?

Last Answer : Ok, I'm going to have to go do some research but I'm pretty sure that only the females buzz (and only the females bite). Maybe a method for finding mates? Some trivia: http:// ... /blog/2007/07/05/why-mosquitoes-buzz-in-peoples-ears/ http://www.sciencenewsforkids.org/articles/20040811/Feature1.asp

Description : What do you all value most, Love, (Charity,) Faith , or Hope, in what order, (or not)please explain your reasoning.

Last Answer : You want us to order those according to our personal priorities? Let's see. Charity. Honesty and accountability. Hope. Love. Faith. I'm going to put honesty and accountability on the same level of importance. ... life alone, so that goes under hope. As for faith well ...let's not go there.

Description : What is rule-based reasoning?

Last Answer : answer:According to this: A particular type of reasoning which uses if-then-else rule statements. As mentioned above, rules are simply patterns and an inference engine searches for patterns in the ... is TRUE AND suspect lacks alibi is TRUE THEN probable cause is TRUE ELSE round up usual suspects

Description : What reasoning could be provided in the future when an ultra life-like robot kills a human, and does not wish to take any responsibility for those actions?

Last Answer : Termination

Description : If you believe in satan, ghosts or demons but don’t believe in god will you say your reasoning behind why?

Last Answer : I don't believe in Satan or demons, but do ghosts, I've had several occurrences that can't be explained otherwise, and God there's no evidence just as Satan and demons, and if there is why do ... people with their interpretations. I don't believe in something I can't see or experience, explain....

Description : If you believe in satan, ghosts or demons but don’t believe in god will you say your reasoning behind why?

Last Answer : I don't believe in Satan or demons, but do ghosts, I've had several occurrences that can't be explained otherwise, and God there's no evidence just as Satan and demons, and if there is why do ... people with their interpretations. I don't believe in something I can't see or experience, explain....

Description : A person of good understanding knowledge and reasoning power -Do You Know?

Last Answer : Intellectual is the answer

Description : Which passage is the best example of deductive reasoning?

Last Answer : (Apex) Everyone in Mr. Kim's class got an A on the test. Casey is in Mr. Kim's class, so he must have received an A on the test.

Description : what kind of reasoning can lead to stereotyping if based on too few examples?

Last Answer : Inductive reasoning. :)

Description : Based on the cases that followed, was the Bakke decision a complete win for supporters or for opponents of affirmative action Explain your reasoning, referring to at least one of the cases that followed?

Last Answer : 26% of the total cases

Description : Which passage is an example of inductive reasoning Apex?

Last Answer : Rain is fingers hurt when she plays the guitar for two hours a day she tells her mom that all Guitars feel pain when they play for a long time

Description : What is subjective reasoning ?

Last Answer : : A logical argument that has a conditional relation between purpose and predicate is called relative argument. In such an argument, acceptance or rejection of the subject matter is presented ... are two types of subjective reasoning ; Namely: a. Hypothetical Proposition b. Disjunctive Proposition

Last Answer : Usually we see that many saints and Vaishnavas around us wear sandalwood and tilak. And we think that maybe only they should wear sandalwood and tilak. This idea , how much is it based on ... applying sandalwood on the forehead keeps the brain cool , increases endurance and keeps the mind calm !!

Description : Assertion and Reasoning questions: Assertion (A): Urban poverty is more harmful than rural poverty.

Last Answer : Assertion and Reasoning questions: Assertion (A): Urban poverty is more harmful than rural poverty. ... ) is not the correct explanation of (A).

Description : Assertion (A) : Kerala has low Infant Mortality Rate. Reasoning (R) : Kerala has adequate provision of basic health and education facilities.

Last Answer : Two statements are given below as Assertion (A) and Reasoning (R). Read the statement and choose the most ... (A) is false but Reasoning (R) is true.

Description : Assertion (A) : The distrust between Sinhalese and Tamil communities turned into widespread conflict in Sri Lanka. Reasoning (R) :  1956 Act

Last Answer : Two statements are given below as Assertion (A) and Reasoning (R). Read the statement and choose the most ... (A) is false but Reasoning (R) is true.

Description : Assertion (A) : Power sharing is good. Reasoning (R) :  It helps to reduce the possibility of conflicts between social groups.

Last Answer : Two statements are given below as Assertion (A) and Reasoning (R). Read the statement and choose the most ... (A) is false but Reasoning (R) is true.

Description : Assertion (A) : Majority community is dominant in a few democratic states. Reasoning (R) :  Dominance can undermine the unity of the country.

Last Answer : Two statements are given below as Assertion (A) and Reasoning (R). Read the statement and choose the most ... (A) is false but Reasoning (R) is true.

Description : Assertion (A) : Indian farmers should diversify their cropping pattern from cereals to high value crops. Reasoning (R) :  This will increase income

Last Answer : Two statements are given below as Assertion (A) and Reasoning (R). Read the statement and choose the most ... (A) is false but Reasoning (R) is true.

Description : Assertion (A) : In Britain, the formation of the nation-state was not the result of a sudden upheaval. Reasoning (R) : Ethnic groups of Britain

Last Answer : Two statements are given below as Assertion (A) and Reasoning (R). Read the statement and choose the most ... (A) is false but Reasoning (R) is true.