Would you participate on a Q&A site that required you to make a substantive answer to a question before you could see the other user's answers?

Would you participate on a Q&A site that required you to make a substantive answer to a question before you could see the other user's answers?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

I like the basic concept, but would prefer to eliminate the whole modded-substantive-answer part. How about you just can’t see the other answers until you’ve answered. You could still have mods to enforce basic rules and writing standards, similar to ask-public.
by

Related questions

Anyone else get the private survey question for a new Q&A site?

Description : Anyone else get the private survey question for a new Q&A site?

Last Answer : Nope never got it , it could be a scam . Or it could be a special something for special people to get . If in doubt ask the builders , or throw it out

Is it OK to post a question here and on other Social Q&A sites simultaneously?

Description : Is it OK to post a question here and on other Social Q&A sites simultaneously?

Last Answer : It doesn’t seem like a breach of etiquette to me, but I wouldn’t announce that you are asking a question on multiple sites, just ask it as you normally would. It might turn some people off to the question if they know you are asking it on more than one site.

What is an easy, low tech, foolproof way for someone to link to a personal photo on a Q&A site?

Description : What is an easy, low tech, foolproof way for someone to link to a personal photo on a Q&A site?

Last Answer : answer:I upload mine to http://tinypic.com/index.php Here’s the uncut version of my avatar photo: http://oi58.tinypic.com/2hxr0w1.jpg

Do you think Facebook Questions new application is going to "kill" all other Q&A web sites?

Description : Do you think Facebook Questions new application is going to "kill" all other Q&A web sites?

Last Answer : answer:I want to say no. Since I am not crazy about Facebook. A million people giving random opinion on subject matter. We have issues trying to get it right with the motley crew we have here.

Can I answer a question that has a lot of answers and will the questioner care?

Description : Can I answer a question that has a lot of answers and will the questioner care?

Last Answer : answer:There is actually a time stamp, but it's cleverly hidden. If you hover your mouse just to the right of the flag as' thingy right below the question, you'll see a red paragraph mark. Hover over ... ! Breathing new life into old questions is kind of fun. As an asker, I wouldn't mind a bit.

Why is it that, a reasonable question will get zero, or maybe one, great question award, but the answers will get multiple great answer awards?

Description : Why is it that, a reasonable question will get zero, or maybe one, great question award, but the answers will get multiple great answer awards?

Last Answer : Fluddies. Fluther buddies hi-fiving each other.

When you read questions on Fluther, do you find yourself popping off quick sarcastic answers in your mind before really thinking the question through?

Description : When you read questions on Fluther, do you find yourself popping off quick sarcastic answers in your mind before really thinking the question through?

Last Answer : No. I don’t go into questions like that.

Can any Q&A site stand the test of time by only offering Q&A (serious answers only please)?

Description : Can any Q&A site stand the test of time by only offering Q&A (serious answers only please)?

Last Answer : answer:I think they live and die by the quality of their communities. That requires social engineering. There is a complex relationship between interface, rules, and community culture. You need to know what you ... the team that will make the site. That's what's unique and individual to every site.

How could I have asked this question without biasing the answers?

Description : How could I have asked this question without biasing the answers?

Last Answer : There are closed (yes/no) questions, open questions and leading questions. Closed and leading questions are safe because you can control and predict the reactions and outcomes. Open questions are risky ... to run that risk. Unfortunately that means you didn't get the honest reactions you wanted.

When was the e-question dot com question-answer site created ? When was the e-question dot com question-answer site created ? Who created this Q&A site ?

Description : When was the e-question dot com question-answer site created ? When was the e-question dot com question-answer site created ? Who created this Q&A site ?

Last Answer : In March 2019 ,

How does this site compare to Yahoo Answers, Amazon Askville, Answerbag, etc.?

Description : How does this site compare to Yahoo Answers, Amazon Askville, Answerbag, etc.?

Last Answer : We have a fairly active community (though not at this time of day). Since I’m the community manager here, I might sound biased, but it’s a fantastic community, too! Helpful, thoughtful, and smart.

What do you think the best question answer site is?

Description : What do you think the best question answer site is?

Last Answer : Fluther.com.

Why does anyone go to a non-religious question and answer site with religious questions?

Description : Why does anyone go to a non-religious question and answer site with religious questions?

Last Answer : Fluther is neither a religious or non-religious site.

Which users catch your eye when they ask or answer any questions?

Description : Which users catch your eye when they ask or answer any questions?

Last Answer : gailcalled, kevbo, delirium, nikipedia, johnpowell… hmm, too many to list, I’d feel bad about leaving someone out.

Would you skip a question that has too many answers?

Description : Would you skip a question that has too many answers?

Last Answer : No. I’ll often wait until everyone has had their say and then give a detailed answer often taking the string in a related, but broader area. To do this too early in a thread can either kill it or take it in a direction unintended by the OP and is considered rude.

Boring question #30: what question is there to ask that will get tons of non-answers only debates?

Description : Boring question #30: what question is there to ask that will get tons of non-answers only debates?

Last Answer : self-explanatory

What question(s) have you asked here that generated or resulted in the best answers and comments, or discussion in your opinion?

Description : What question(s) have you asked here that generated or resulted in the best answers and comments, or discussion in your opinion?

Last Answer : answer:I asked this I rather liked the discussion it generated. I hope I’ll be able to come up with more like that.

Do you get amused when you see lots of old answers of yours get GAs?

Description : Do you get amused when you see lots of old answers of yours get GAs?

Last Answer : Wow, @incendiary_dan , I was just wondering about that yesterday or was it Thursday? when I saw a bunch of old answers of mine getting GAs! I was rather flattered, then it occurred to me ... going through old threads and GAing everybody! Still, fun, though, and I enjoy revisiting those threads.

If you could get an answer for a question in the form of: "What's the deal with ______," then how would you fill in the blank?

Description : If you could get an answer for a question in the form of: "What's the deal with ______," then how would you fill in the blank?

Last Answer : “What’s the deal with politics, I don’t get it, am I right people?” – Cosmo Kramer

How to get more upvotes for my answers in a q&a website?

Description : How to get more upvotes for my answers in a q&a website?

Last Answer : If you are looking for a way to get noticed then you need to give people a reason to notice you. Your answer and how you address the question is so important on Q & A sites. Here are a few tips to help ... answer for the person and in the end, you can give them the link if they'd like to read more.

Here is the unanswered page , and what if there was a Q&A page ? What would it be like then ? Can the question and answer page be given ?

Description : Here is the unanswered page , and what if there was a Q&A page ? What would it be like then ? Can the question and answer page be given ?

Last Answer : Now the page has been added.

Does it bother you when a question you ask here shows up on other answer sites the next day?

Description : Does it bother you when a question you ask here shows up on other answer sites the next day?

Last Answer : No it doesn’t, they’re only questions after all.

What best idea could you think up to stop point gaming on a Q&A site?

Description : What best idea could you think up to stop point gaming on a Q&A site?

Last Answer : I think I’d be willing to let people game the system. Any site that uses points to “win prizes or cash” is inviting people to game it, and it likely deserves to be gamed. Let the sad people have their way with it.

Are people who make flippant answers point mining, and if so what for?

Description : Are people who make flippant answers point mining, and if so what for?

Last Answer : My sense is that A) some people don't really care to help, they want to use the site for their own personal (and other peoples') entertainment B) don't know a legitimate answer, so simply ... yes, I typically think that unless a legitimate answer (or 10 have been given), jokes are disrespectful.

In the planning stage of an audit engagement, the auditor is required to perform audit procedures to obtain an understanding of the entity and its environment, including its internal control. These procedures are called a. Substantive tests b. Tests of controls c. Risk assessment procedures d. Dual-purpose tests

Description : In the planning stage of an audit engagement, the auditor is required to perform audit procedures to obtain an understanding of the entity and its environment, including its internal control. These ... a. Substantive tests b. Tests of controls c. Risk assessment procedures d. Dual-purpose tests

Last Answer : Risk assessment procedures

Are one-time users’ questions worth elaborating on?

Description : Are one-time users’ questions worth elaborating on?

Last Answer : If the question is interesting, and you feel like answering in detail, then sure, go ahead.

Why do some users give opinions in the general section when the OP is asking for facts?

Description : Why do some users give opinions in the general section when the OP is asking for facts?

Last Answer : answer:My feeling about your question would be different if you had linked to a question of another user. But you linked to your question so I have my reason to suspect that this question has ... don't you at least appreciate that they cared enough to take their time to answer your questions?

Have you ever looked back on your questions and answers and thought, I can’t believe I wrote that?

Description : Have you ever looked back on your questions and answers and thought, I can’t believe I wrote that?

Last Answer : Sometimes!

Why do people think they are going to get answers to personal issues from any social media?

Description : Why do people think they are going to get answers to personal issues from any social media?

Last Answer : They might have experienced the same problem, and want to share what worked for them.

Should we post follow-up answers to questions we asked in the past?

Description : Should we post follow-up answers to questions we asked in the past?

Last Answer : Yeah, I wonder if that kid ever showed up, the one apparently lost in the frizzer!!

What three questions do you wish you knew the answers to?

Description : What three questions do you wish you knew the answers to?

Last Answer : What happens when you die? Is uranus really that big? What will santa bring me this xmas?

How much planning do you put into questions and answers here?

Description : How much planning do you put into questions and answers here?

Last Answer : answer:I surf Fluther like I surf through life; If we had a plan, we'd be screwed! . The way I see it, doing anything other than stream of consciousness is dishonest, and I am too honest to abide ... you read is what I think, fucks, shits,, and all. The only real planning I do is spell-checking.

Do you know of any questions with no real answers?

Description : Do you know of any questions with no real answers?

Last Answer : answer:I’ll start… Do stairs go up or down? How come you never hear father-in-law jokes? If you try to fail, and succeed, which have you done?

Are answers enough?

Description : Are answers enough?

Last Answer : Sweet holy moly, sometimes the answer has to come from you yourself. If you ask if you should pursue a certain career choice, people can tell you the pros and cons as they see it but in the end you ... are the one who can at least make the choice even if the answers you seek is not there precisely.

Can questions/answers not be edited after a certain point?

Description : Can questions/answers not be edited after a certain point?

Last Answer : I think you have about ten minutes to edit a question or answer. You can change a question once it has been answered, and you can edit an answer when you’ve been given a ‘great answer’.

"NF" Suffix on answers to "General" questions?

Description : "NF" Suffix on answers to "General" questions?

Last Answer : I think it is unnecessary. If you are not following a question or not makes no difference to me. If I want a response and don’t get one, I’ll PM you.

Are you annoyed with people who have smartass first-answers to questions?

Description : Are you annoyed with people who have smartass first-answers to questions?

Last Answer : As tempting as it was to make a smart-ass first answer, there is a general rule that you save smart-ass answers or jokes until after the question has been answered for real =)

Do the responses to your questions and/or your answers ever upset you?

Description : Do the responses to your questions and/or your answers ever upset you?

Last Answer : answer:Somebody made a reference to me yesterday and I cried all day long. But, other than that, I try and get something out of everything that’s said. It doesn’t hurt to see something from a different view point.

What do you really think about the new Yahoo! Answers home page design?

Description : What do you really think about the new Yahoo! Answers home page design?

Last Answer : it does not answer the burning question of How babby formed?.

How long should questions, details, (Oxford comma) and answers be?

Description : How long should questions, details, (Oxford comma) and answers be?

Last Answer : I don’t mind if a question or answer is long as long as it’s readable. Breaks and paragraphs are nice and readable. When someone just writes on and on in one big block then I give up.

Are you annoyed when answers given in a topic seems like no one read the details?

Description : Are you annoyed when answers given in a topic seems like no one read the details?

Last Answer : AY Laddie! And no.

How do you feel about jellies who ask numerous amounts of questions, but never once acknowledge anybody who answers them or give you a GA?

Description : How do you feel about jellies who ask numerous amounts of questions, but never once acknowledge anybody who answers them or give you a GA?

Last Answer : People have heard this before, so it bears repeating When someone annoys me it takes 42 muscles in my face to frown, BUT, it only takes 4 muscles to extend my arm and bitch-slap that that thoughtless AH ... really bother me, my family and pets lurve me all the time. That's all the lurve I need!

If you were guaranteed honest answers to three specific questions, of whom would you ask them and which three questions would you ask?

Description : If you were guaranteed honest answers to three specific questions, of whom would you ask them and which three questions would you ask?

Last Answer : Always be careful of asking questions which require a truthful answer. The kindly ones are notorious for answering (truly) with answers that cause more harm than good. Heck, the Scottish Play was at least ⅔ trouble caused by the Erinyes’s answers.

How much revenue does Yahoo Answers generate for Yahoo?

Description : How much revenue does Yahoo Answers generate for Yahoo?

Last Answer : It seems like this is a question better asked of Yahoo, no?

Do you think that USA's secrets agencies really hide answers to humanity's secrets?

Description : Do you think that USA's secrets agencies really hide answers to humanity's secrets?

Last Answer : Most of them seem to be immature in attitude, irresponsible and thoughtless and as such they are probably run by teenagers, and so what they hide best is more than likely the usual teenage cover-up requirements, acne, skin blemishes, and in this day and age, paunches.

Does it bother you when people profit from your questions and answers?

Description : Does it bother you when people profit from your questions and answers?

Last Answer : Yes, bendrew wrote a blog about some of the issues they’ve been dealing with.

Can you think of questions that call for creative answers?

Description : Can you think of questions that call for creative answers?

Last Answer : I used to work for chacha.com I gave factual answers and would be a smartass with smartass questions.

What kind of impact do the ask-public answers have on people?

Description : What kind of impact do the ask-public answers have on people?

Last Answer : Depends on the person asking I suppose. If they are gullible and malleable enough to do whatever is told to them then it could have a negative impact. The asker needs to have the wisdom to ... take everything with a grain of salt from their shaker knowing that only they know the whole story.

What are your answers to James Lipton's famous questions?

Description : What are your answers to James Lipton's famous questions?

Last Answer : 1. What is your favorite word? cacophony 2. What is your least favorite word? cunt 3. What turns you on? librarians 4. What turns you off? frat boys 5. What's your favorite curse word? fuck 6. ... would you like to hear God say when you arrive at the Pearly Gates? The keg is next to the hookers.

Have you ever used Microsoft Answers?

Description : Have you ever used Microsoft Answers?

Last Answer : MSA Shill?