What is your understanding of the New York Reproductive Health Act?

1 Answer

Answer :

I went to the source to review it I found there were two bills originally considered, state bill S2796 and S240. Only S240 was signed by the governor. But I am listing them both here just for reference…they are pretty much the same. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2017/S2796 https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2019/s240 I read this bill and find nothing that says you can have an abortion up to 40 weeks. In fact it says that unless it is in an effort to preserve the life of the mother or the child is no longer viable, an abortion performed past 24 weeks is considered murder. Now something I did see that has me bothered is that you don’t have to be a doctor to perform an abortion, nor to determine how far along a woman’s pregnancy has progressed. It specifically states: § 2599-BB. ABORTION. 1. A HEALTH CARE PRACTITIONER LICENSED, CERTI- FIED, OR AUTHORIZED UNDER TITLE EIGHT OF THE EDUCATION LAW, ACTING WITH-IN HIS OR HER LAWFUL SCOPE OF PRACTICE, MAY PERFORM AN ABORTION WHEN,ACCORDING TO THE PRACTITIONER’S REASONABLE AND GOOD FAITH PROFESSIONAL JUDGMENT BASED ON THE FACTS OF THE PATIENT’S CASE: THE PATIENT IS WITHIN TWENTY-FOUR WEEKS FROM THE COMMENCEMENT OF PREGNANCY, OR THERE IS AN ABSENCE OF FETAL VIABILITY, OR THE ABORTION IS NECESSARY TO PROTECT THE PATIENT’S LIFE OR HEALTH. If you go to title 8 of the education law you find it covers everything from soup to nuts, but does have a section for medicine which specifically addresses licensed physicians. But the actual health care reform act only says it needs to be a health care practitioner. Health care practitioners range from PAs to acupuncturists to podiatrist to chiropractics and everything in between. I couldn’t find a specific license for abortionist, though I didn’t read each and every entry…just the ones I thought applied. My feeling is that if they specifically wanted a doctor, they would have stated licensed physician instead of health care practitioner. It does say Within his or her lawful scope of practice but when you are vague about the actual needed training, you are opening up a can of worms. To further explain this point, I went to a federal definition for Licensed Health Care Practitioner: https://definitions.uslegal.com/l/licensed-health-care-practitioner/ This definition specifically excludes physicians. It also seems to state that all that is required is for a person to say they are a licensed health care practitioner and all is good.

Related questions

Description : Can you help me fully understand the abortion issue swirling around New York?

Last Answer : I think the new law says you can legally abort a baby at 8 or 9 months if you’ve changed your mind. Tell me I’m wrong. I’ve read somewhere the nice doctors break their necks to kill them. Tell me I never read that. It created a huge mob of cheering women. So glad it made their day.

Description : Do you believe this person's assertation that she knew a woman, decades ago, who was forced to carry her stillborn baby because it would have been considered an abortion to do otherwise?

Last Answer : I was surprised to learn this: “If your doctor determines your baby has died, you’ll need to discuss your options. If you do nothing, labor will likely start on its own within a few weeks” Link: https://www.healthline.com/health/pregnancy/stillbirth#what-happens-next

Description : Do the priests have to live with the anguish of having committed a mortal sin, or is it only the nuns who have to live with this upon their souls?

Last Answer : Only the priests know what is in their hearts and only they have to answer to God for their sins.

Description : Why do anti-abortion people keep insisting that an unwanted embryo or fetus or however an unborn is called be born?

Last Answer : Put yourself in their shoes and imagine you believed that terminating a pregnancy was morally equivalent to killing an adult person. Would I don't want it around be a good enough reason ... that would insist on pregnancies being carried to term in most circumstances (maybe even all circumstances).

Description : What are the best reasons for being pro-choice?

Last Answer : For me the argument boils down to whether or not the state should be allowed to compel a woman to bear a child.

Description : What do you think of pro-life supporters who use pictures of aborted embryos to make a point?

Last Answer : Cheap move. Below the belt. Debate with words, wits and good arguments, not shock images. It shows their intentions were not to convince or prove their statement, but to simply shock and nauseate the supposed ... was someone's child, or at the very best, it was a living being. Have some respect.

Description : What does Roe Versus Wade say in the fewest, simplest words?

Last Answer : Abortions are between a women, her doctor and God. Is the one that I heard the most often.

Description : Do you still question whether late term abortion should be legal?

Last Answer : Nope. Never have, never will.

Description : Is there any point to railing against abortion when the surest signpost to poverty is a single woman with children?

Last Answer : Pro-lifers don’t care if you’re poor. They don’t care if the child is starving. They don’t care if there are no social programs and resources to support the child. They care only about the life that is in need of being saved.

Description : Should medical abortion medication be available over the counter?

Last Answer : Rarebear, I would defer to YOU for the answer. Is it safe? That should be the standard for the answer to your question.

Description : For those of you that are anti-choice: Why should there be exceptions for rape and incest?

Last Answer : answer:Well, we don’t have any of those here soo…. no they are not worth any less

Description : Why do some pro-life people seem to think that babies created by rape or incest have less value than a baby created accidentally by two consenting adults?

Last Answer : answer:I find that when discussing anything, the exceptions are things that really shed light on the rule. When we think about hunting, many of us will say that trophy hunting is wrong but killing for ... in the US. While legal, there are constant legal challenges to it in the most creative ways.

Description : How likely is this to be true? These articles are claiming that Planned Parenthood sells fetus body parts for cash.

Last Answer : That slimy little piece is just crawling with oily clues regarding its credibility, starting at the top with the 2 outfits Center for Medical Progress and Live Action News. The thing that puzzles me most about ... readers are fools, and in this assumption, well- some of the people all of the time

Description : Do pro life societies offer any financial help for pregnant women?

Last Answer : answer:I'd like to say that it's not preaching for many pro-lifers, although that's what you hear from liberals all the time. It's a cause they hold close to their ... of emergency services to women facing crisis pregnancies. http://missourilifenews.wordpress.com/category/abortion-alternatives/

Description : What is your stance on abortion?

Last Answer : Abortion saves lives. In fact, it could have saved the lives of 6 million jews.

Description : Where do you think the question of the legal status of abortion should be resolved—in courts or legislatures?

Last Answer : Court. Federal. It was decided that way in America and they keep trying to chip away at it at the local level. I think the law of the land is constantly being broken on local levels regarding abortion.

Description : What is your opinion on abortion?

Last Answer : answer:Let the mother choose. Give the child a voice. Her choice. But I will not deny there be a child forming from day one. Within hours of conception, recombination of DNA assembles a new ... a person to prison for life. Personhood is established. Yet, the choice should always be the mothers.

Description : Abortion: what's with all the controversy?

Last Answer : answer:Some people believe that abortion ends a tiny possible life and that possibility should be treated as a person. Some believe people should be in control of their own bodies and decisions ... people involved. Both positions make sense and are exclusive of the other, so there's controversy.

Description : Chemical abortion?

Last Answer : there should be a medical or nurse hotline you can call locally in your town/city. If not, it’s probably worth the long distance to call one in the next largest town over. Call right away and all the best to you.

Description : Do pro-choicers think that pro-lifers have in general, anti-women sentiments?

Last Answer : I don't think that those who are pro-choice believe that all or most who are anti-choice have explicit or consciously misogynistic views. Some do, of course, and quite blatantly so. But that doesn ... that being anti-choice is itself a misogynistic view, even if it is not easily recognized as such.

Description : Do you throw a woman in jail for getting an abortion at 6 weeks and 1 day in North Dakota?

Last Answer : Can you post a link, @Rarebear, please?

Description : If a human fertilized egg/fetus had the same legal rights as a person, should employing a pregnant woman be illegal?

Last Answer : answer:I think the people who would grant an embryo legal status would probably agree with you. They don't like women, much less pregnant women, working. You can also say the embryo is entitled ... the people that would propose this. This is what happens when poor thinking tries to impose itself.

Description : What labels do you use to communicate your stance(s) on abortion?

Last Answer : answer:Other things Americans think: About a decade ago, 20 percent of Americans still believed that the sun revolves around the earth. About half of Americans realize that Judaism is the oldest of the three ... Americans between the ages of 18 and 24 can find the state of New York on a map.

Description : Why do the media and many in the West want to call abortion in India infanticide?

Last Answer : Links? It’d help us know who exactly is “they” for this question.

Description : Conceived in Rape--What do you think?

Last Answer : I have a somewhat extreme view on abortion rights. I think the woman should be free to do whatever she wants with what’s growing inside of her, at any time, without restrictions. Period.

Description : During the process of abortion, can the baby feel it?

Last Answer : I think that depends on your stance as to when life begins. If you're of the mind that it's just a mass of undeveloped cells, then no, it can't feel anything. Others who feel differently about ... abortion is performed early enough (within the first 16 weeks, or whatever the standard is), then no.

Description : Did Obama really make 9 month abortion legal?

Last Answer : No.

Description : Will a woman be psychologically traumatized by what is seen during the aspiration?

Last Answer : Every woman is different as is every situation involving abortion. There is no telling whether or not she will be traumatized but I'm thinking her anxiety about it won't make the situation better. As ... painful but that's like any medical procedure where rest is needed for a couple of days after.

Description : Is there a such thing as a natural abortion?

Last Answer : I appreciate honestly but not immaturity in 2010!!!

Description : What are your veiws on abortion?

Last Answer : It should be a last resort. It’s not something anyone enjoys or wants. There are a million steps that can and should be available to fertile human beings before this question ever arises.

Description : Would you support abortion under these circumstances?

Last Answer : this is a tough call. However, self-preservation should prevail in all cases. The pregnant woman is already a developed person and have been heavily invested on this earth. The fetus, well is still a ... would be acceptable if and only if it endangers the life or physical well-being of the mother.

Description : Are you anti-abortion and if so are there any situations where you would find abortion acceptable?

Last Answer : I think people fall on a wide spectrum on this question, and identify with one side or the other. I consider myself to be pro-choice, but not in all circumstances.

Description : If you are to have an abortion is it better to the take the abortion pill or do it surgically?

Last Answer : Abortion pill?

Description : Can any physician perform an abortion?

Last Answer : No, not just any doctors. There are doctors that specialize in it. Hence why there are abortion clinics, there are doctors that specialize in that specific field. However, there are doctors that don't ... got one when I was seventeen, with no parental consent needed (in the state of New Jersey).

Description : How far along in a pregnancy can a person have an abortion?

Last Answer : Generally speaking, through the second trimester or about 24 weeks. It varies though. Here is a breakdown of different state laws.

Description : Assume abortion has always been legal with no moral stigmatism: do you believe your birth mother would have still kept you under the circumstances of the time?

Last Answer : My parents were married already and have a 2 year old daughter when they had me. I’m pretty sure they were in full-parent mode at that point.

Description : What are your views on abortion?

Last Answer : You might be interested in this thread. Your question was previously asked.

Description : 4. Do you think that reproductive health in our country has improved in the past 50 years? If yes, mention some such areas of improvement -Science

Last Answer : Yes, in the last 50 years, reproductive health in our country has improved. Some such areas of improvement are (i) massive child immunization (ii) maternity and child health (iii) ... and illiteracy and poor overall health remains a major challenge for governments and non government organizations.

Description : Suggest the aspects of reproductive health which need to be given special attention in the present scenario. -Science

Last Answer : The aspects of reproductive health which need to be given special attention are : Introduction of sex education in schools to give right information to the young minds about reproductive organs, accessory ... and sex-related crimes, use of drugs, tobacco and alcohol etc.) among young people.

Description : 1. What do you think is the significance of reproductive health in a society? -Science

Last Answer : Reproductive health in a society is significant because the people are aware of (i) birth control methods and advantages of small family, (ii) sexually transmitted diseases and methods to avoid them, ( ... care of the mother and baby and (iv) equal opportunities for the male and female children.

Description : What do we mean by reproductive health ?

Last Answer : The human reproductive system is a very important system. Through this human reproduction takes place. Reproductive health is about maintaining the hygiene of the reproductive organs , being free from infection, and ... law of the country, the age of marriage for boys should be at least 21 years.

Description : How being aware of your reproductive health will help prepare you for adulthood?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : Understanding Diet and Health Recommendations?

Last Answer : The Dietary Guidelines for Americans, first published in 1980, are updated and issued every 5 years by the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the Department of Health and Human Services ( ... For most, reducing calorie intake can be accomplished simply by choosing smaller portions of high-calo

Description : Why is it necessary that health workers have a basic understanding of the fundamental principles of maintaining a healthy body (50—75 words)?

Last Answer : Why is it necessary that health workers have a basic understanding of the fundamental principles of maintaining a healthy body (50—75 words)?

Description : Understanding How the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act Protects Consumers?

Last Answer : The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) was first enacted in 1977 to protect consumers against certain debt collection tactics. This goal of the FDCPA is to keep debt collectors from deceiving, ... will not void the consumer's debt, it should help the consumer repay the delinquent amount.

Description : The members of a group act, feel and think together, in a way which is different from the normal acting, feeling and thinking of individual, who come together to for the group. It is known as Options: A) memsis B) Co-operation C) Understanding D) Group working

Last Answer : A) memsis

Description : I am unemployed and my COBRA just ran out last month. Any suggestions for cheap health insurance? I am from New York.

Last Answer : I recommend you start with your state's health services programs: http://www.nysegov.com/citGuide.cfm?superCat=106&cat=110&content=main http://www.nyhealth.gov/nysdoh/fhplus/index.htm http://www. ... jobs, Vocational Rehabilitation services might also help: http://www.vesid.nysed.gov/do/home.html

Description : Important quality of bioagents a). Attack only host plant b). Free from predators/parasites and quick adoption to new environment c). Able to kill reproductive parts of weed d). All of these

Last Answer : d). All of these

Description : What can you tell me about your experience with assisted reproductive technology?

Last Answer : answer:My cousin was conceived through In-Vitro. She's in college now, so I'm certain things have come a long way since then. My aunt contracted breast cancer a couple of years afterward; they said it ... a natural reconstruction and has been fine ever since (with the tits of a teenager, no less).

Description : What does "Reproductive Rights" actually mean?

Last Answer : In what cases do American taxpayers pay the tab now?