Do Jews follow the Talmud, or the Torah, or both?

1 Answer

Answer :

Both, but that's an oversimplification. Here's an example: The Torah says, don't work on the Sabbath. But what is work? When exactly does the Sabbath begin and end? For questions like this, the Talmud is useful. The Talmud records the different opinions of a wide variety of rabbis from the time of the Pharisees to about the year 400. When different rabbis disagreed, the Talmud doesn't always say whose opinion wins, so for that, it's useful to look at later commentaries. The arguments about some issues continue to this day: Is it work to turn on or off an electric light on the Sabbath? For that, you need to ask modern rabbis, but their answers (even the from the Reform movement) refer back to the Talmud.

Related questions

Description : Which is more sacred for the Jews, the Talmud or Tanakh?

Last Answer : The Tanakh (that is, the Hebrew Bible, composed of the Torah (law), Neviim (prophets) and Ketuvim (prophets)) is at the center. The Talmud can be thought of as the collected lecture notes of the ... 't always agree with each other. You swim in the sea of Talmud in order to better understand Torah.

Description : Who helped Jews study the Torah the nevi um and the ketuim?

Last Answer : Moses

Description : Who helped Jews study the Torah the nevi um and the ketuim?

Last Answer : Moses

Description : Which group in the Jewish community only follow the Torah?

Last Answer : There are several levels here:Most modern Jews, including Orthodox, Conservative and Reform Jews, follow the Torah as interpreted by thousands of years of commentators. We (I am one) have ... who have gone to Israel have generally adopted modern Judaism with little difficulty.The Samaritans separ

Description : What is Talmud ?

Last Answer : A complete set of Babylonian tamud. Talmud (English: Talmud, Hebrew: 6), talmūd means to teach , study , discuss from LMD ) is a holy book of the Jews , not like the Torah. This is known ... Era) , written between the 2nd and 5th centuries, gives an analysis of the original text of the mission.

Description : If you follow the logic of the Trump advisors, the US will be building internment camps for various subcultures in the US. Muslims, Asians, Jews, and Mexicans (actually anyone coming from south of the border) have been mentioned. How would they do this?

Last Answer : None of the above and no, nearly all whites would not support it.

Description : Who is the Torah revealed to ?

Last Answer : The Torah was revealed to Musa (AS).

Description : What are the books in the torah?

Last Answer : Torah refers to five books are moses which are known in Hebrew as Chameesha Choomsy Torah. These are : Bresheit ( Genesis), Shemot (Exodus), Vayicra (Leviticus), Bamidbar (Numbers) and Devarim (Deuteronomy). Hope you liked it.

Description : What is the traditional beginning of Judaism are described in the ancient text known as the Torah?

Last Answer : Torah-tradition states that Abraham (18th century BCE) founded Judaism.The Kuzari (Rabbi Judah HaLevi,1075-1141) states that Abraham was gifted with high intelligence; and, as Maimonides (1135-1204) describes, ... 49:29-32) is located in Hebron and has been known and attested to for many centuries.

Description : What shared history is recorded in what collection of writings (Old Testament especially the Torah)?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : What part of the bible is called the Torah?

Last Answer : The first five books of The Bible are referred to as the Torah...GenesisExodusLeviticusNumbersDeuteronomy

Description : What are first 5 books of the Torah?

Last Answer : Genesis Leviticus Exodus Numbers Deuteronomy

Description : Who established a school for teaching Torah at Yavneh?

Last Answer : The answer you're looking for is Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, butit (and the question) is inaccurate. The Torah-academy at Yavnehwas already in existence; and what Rabbi ben Zakkai did was togreatly swell its ranks with additional sages.

Description : Why is the Torah hand copied?

Last Answer : The Torah is available in printed form in any Bible (the books of Genesis through Deuteronomy), not to mention the copies of the Chumash typically found in synagogue sanctuaries and Jewish homes ... backed by numereous passages scattered through the Talmud and codified in later codes of Jewish law.

Description : What Two contributions that the Torah says about moses?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : What are the stories of the Torah?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : Why is the Torah hand copied?

Last Answer : The Torah is available in printed form in any Bible (the books of Genesis through Deuteronomy), not to mention the copies of the Chumash typically found in synagogue sanctuaries and Jewish homes ... backed by numereous passages scattered through the Talmud and codified in later codes of Jewish law.

Description : Is the Torah the same thing as the Holy Bible?

Last Answer : No. The Torah is the first 5 books of The Bible, Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy. That is the first part of the Hebrew Bible, which is the Bible of Judaism, also called the Old Testament when it is incorporated into the Christian Bible.

Description : Can Orthodox Jewish women study the Torah?

Last Answer : Of course they can

Description : What is the role of the Torah in Jewish life?

Last Answer : The Torah is the foundation on which observant Jews live their lives. The Torah is to Judaism, much like the U.S. Constitution is to life in the United States. It is the foundation on ... permitted, but Jewish law, as worked out through centuries of rabbinic argument, concludes that they are.

Description : Do both Jews and Arabs belong to the Semitic race?

Last Answer : If I were writing in 1900, I would say no, because back then, Jews, Arabs, Turks, Italians, and Egyptians were generally classified as their own races. Today, people who believe that race matters ... the same alphabet (but Hebrew print is a square block print and Arabic is always presented in cu

Description : What are Jews views on the after life and how does it affect the way they live?

Last Answer : My understanding is that Jews don’t believe in the afterlife. I hope I am wrong.

Description : Should Catholics or Jews be banned from taking in foster children?

Last Answer : I think anyone who is religious should be banned. Why stop at just Catholics and Jews? Why not Mormons too, at least?

Description : I honestly have no idea what some people have against Jews! Will you enlighten me?

Last Answer : Antisemitism predates Christianity as well. It was around in Greek and Roman times. I might add to your support of Judaism that wherever the Jews are, there is a great influx of arts and culture. They lead the way in ... as early as 1200 C.E. So aren't they just as much a part of us' as anyone?

Description : What do you think about the hotel in Switzerland posting a sign for Jews to shower before entering the pool?

Last Answer : It's standard practise here for swimmers to shower before bathing and the rule applies to everyone. To say only Jews should shower makes no sense and is offensive but it is hardly an anti-Semitic ... situation is that it is part of a petty squabble between the hotel owner and some Jewish guests.

Description : How long will it be until countries in the Middle East will start closing their borders to all Americans? How long will it be until Germany (as an example) closes its border to Jews?

Last Answer : Like any Jew would go to Germany…

Description : Do the Falasha (Ethiopian) Jews identify with the Mizrahi or the Sephardi?

Last Answer : The word “Falasha” is considered a derogatory term.

Description : Does how you feel about the Israeli Palestinian conflict have anything to do with how you feel about Jews, Israelis, Palestinians or Muslims in your country?

Last Answer : If you're asking if the Israeli/Palestinian issue influences my views on Jewish or Palestinian residents of the United States, the answer is: Yes. Of course I make assumptions, the ... Palestinians pro Palestine. Interacting with Jews or Palestinians here, the topic rarely comes up. Interesting

Description : If the Jews left Israel what would happen in the middle east?

Last Answer : answer:Thomas Edward Lawrence (Lawrence of Arabia) was quite antisemitic; however, he was one of a group of Brits who were to decide on a National home for Jewish people. In 1917 Great Britain ... day, many Arabs try to migrate into Israel with various deceptions to become a citizen of Israel.

Description : Jews changing planes in Arab countries? How does this work?

Last Answer : answer:Pure speculation on my part: A traveling Israeli would avoid stopping in an Arab country that didn't allow Israelis. And, if they did, they would only be transiting at the airport, not passing ... message on Israeli stamps: some say it is grounds for denial, others say it does not matter.

Description : Do you think Jews tend to be more intelligent than Christians on average?

Last Answer : Not at all. I’ve known smart Jews and ignorant Jews both, but I tend to determine intelligence based on how well I know the individual, not assumptions and generalizations based on religious affilation.

Description : What happened to American Jews in the United States during World War 2?

Last Answer : Nothing that I know of.

Description : For Star Wars nerds: Why would George Lucas name the desert-dwelling merchants of Tattooine "Jawa's" - isn't that a little too close to Jews to be a coincidence?

Last Answer : I’m not a Star Wars nerd, so I’ll skip this question…

Description : Mel Gibson vs Jews, is there no room for reconciliation?

Last Answer : Jews have bigger problems than one worthless bigot lol.

Description : How do Jewish Holy Days, traditions, etc. help the Jews connect to their past?

Last Answer : answer:Just celebrating them reinforces the traditions. Things are changing a little in America, not sure about other countries, but still for the most part Jewish holidays are celebrated without a lot of decoration ... t want that to happen. They feel the way to get back is to live, to continue.

Description : How is it that so many Jews ended up in the forests of central Europe?

Last Answer : answer:I am not sure how the Jews wound up in Europe, I think probably we travelled to where the work was or where we were not being killed or enslaved, but that is a guess, my history ... 1900's, Many considered themselves Zionists. I don't find your question antisemitic or offensive by the way.

Description : Do the Jews get any preference when it comes to issues of racism?

Last Answer : answer:Anti-Israeli govt. =/= Antisemetism (i.e. Anti-Jew ) All the Jews/Israelis I've ever met disagreed with a lot of the internationally contentious behaviours of the Israeli Govt. And, ... says, he's a natural power-monger. Sounds like he's buddies with the expansionist Israeli politicians.

Description : Why the animosity toward Jews?

Last Answer : answer:I have never understood this. My best guess would be that in medieval times Jews often worked in trades like money-lending and banking that were off-limits to ‘proper’ Christians. Great question by the way, I look forward to reading the responses of those more learned than myself.

Description : Jews: Whatcha doin for Pesach? Non-Jews: Want to learn about Passover?

Last Answer : This year I may throw caution to the winds, and hide the Apfikomen.

Description : Why were the Jews given Palestine?

Last Answer : For the record, the British Mandate and subsequent UN partition did not give Palestine to the Jews. It was split into two states initially, that were subsequently unified during the war of 1948 (when ... Kingdom (it could easily have been incorporated as part of the plan back then, but wasn't).

Description : Fellow Christians have you ever been to your elder brothers Messianic Jews worship places?

Last Answer : Messianic Jew is an oxymoron.

Description : Why some Jews are for West Bank & Gaza (Settlements) and others are not?

Last Answer : Why are some people for any issue and some not. There are differences of opinions. I don’t know of any population of humans that thinks in lock step on any issue. We are not a hive mind, after all.

Description : What Persian queen preserved the Jews? -Riddles

Last Answer : Hadaosoh—Esther viii. 7.

Description : Why did Adolf Hitler preach extreme hatred against the German Jews? -SST 10th

Last Answer : Adolf Hitler preached extreme hatred against the German Jews because they were blamed not only for the defeat of Germany in the First World War but for all the ills of Germany.

Description : Describe Hitler’s policy towards the Jews. -History 9th

Last Answer : The Nazis originally sought to rid the German state of Jews and Romani by means of deportation (and later extermination), while blacks were to be segregated and eventually eliminated through compulsory sterilization.

Description : Describe Hitler’s policy towards the Jews. -History 9th

Last Answer : The racial policy of Nazi Germany was a set of policies and laws implemented in Nazi Germany (1933–45) based on a specific racist doctrine asserting the superiority of the Aryan race, which claimed ... the Herrenvolk ("master race") of the Volksgemeinschaft ("people's community") at the top.

Description : Which letters denote Jesus Nazareth King of the Jews?

Last Answer : INRI

Description : Explain why Nazi propaganda was effective in creating a hatred for Jews? -History 9th

Last Answer : Nazi propaganda was effective in creating hatred for the Jews for the following reason: (i) The Jews were stereotyped as killers of Christ. They had been barred since medieval times from ownership of ... theories fanned this hatred. He wanted all Jews to be eliminated from Germany. hope this helps u

Description : How were 'Jews' referred in films? -History 9th

Last Answer : Jews were referred as Vermin, rats and pests and their movements were compared to those of rodents.

Description : Which was the most in famous film in which orthodox Jews were stereotyped and marked? -History 9th

Last Answer : THE ETERNAL JEW WAS THE FIRST FAMOUS FILM IN WHICH ORTHODOX JEWS WERE STEREOTYPES AND MARKED!