Why are some Orthodox Jews opposed to Zionism?

Why are some Orthodox Jews opposed to Zionism?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

The Jewish tradition holds that, in the end of days, the Messiah will restore Jewish sovereignty in Jerusalem and the traditional Land of Israel, restoring worship to the Temple Mount and rebuilding the Temple, Judging all the earth. Starting with the disappointment caused by a series of failed claimants to the title of Messiah 2000 years ago (Simon Bar Kochba's revolt that was crushed in the year 135 was the last straw), the rabbinic tradition downplayed the messianic elements of Judaism, but in the Hassidic world, these elements have become central. As a result, many (not all) Hassidic Jews hold that re-establishing Jewish dominion in Israel before the Messiah comes verges on being an improper usurpation of the role of the Messiah.On the other side of this are Orthodox Jews in the settle
by
selected by

Related questions

Why are some Jews against Israel and Zionism?

Description : Why are some Jews against Israel and Zionism?

Last Answer : The Jewish tradition holds that, in the end of days, the Messiah will restore Jewish sovereignty in Jerusalem and the traditional Land of Israel, restoring worship to the Temple Mount and rebuilding the Temple, ... of the role of the Messiah.On the other side of this are Orthodox Jews in the settle

Which was the most in famous film in which orthodox Jews were stereotyped and marked? -History 9th

Description : Which was the most in famous film in which orthodox Jews were stereotyped and marked? -History 9th

Last Answer : THE ETERNAL JEW WAS THE FIRST FAMOUS FILM IN WHICH ORTHODOX JEWS WERE STEREOTYPES AND MARKED!

What is the major difference in worship between orthodox and reform Jews?

Description : What is the major difference in worship between orthodox and reform Jews?

Last Answer : The most noticeable difference is that Orthodox synagogues haveseparate seating for men and women. This is so that worshipers canconcentrate on the prayers instead of on the opposite sex. Theseparate ... (Talmud, Sukkah 51b), so itis the Reform congregations that have broken away fromtradition.

Why don't Orthodox Jews accept non-Orthodox conversions?

Description : Why don't Orthodox Jews accept non-Orthodox conversions?

Last Answer : All conversions to Judaism (any branch) must be overseen by a beit din, a Jewish court composed of 3 judges. Orthodox Jews generally reject the rabbinic ordination offered by non-Orthodox seminaries, so ... Jew may not place barriers in the way of the non-Orthodox convert's performance of any

Do Orthodox Jews have non-Jewish friends?

Description : Do Orthodox Jews have non-Jewish friends?

Last Answer : Yes, frequently, unless they live in segregated communities where they rarely encounter non-Jews.

How similar are Orthodox Jews to the Amish?

Description : How similar are Orthodox Jews to the Amish?

Last Answer : Hassidic Jews (as opposed to the broader class of Orthodox Jews) tend to wear black coats and pants and white shirts, and Hassidic men usually grow full beards and wear hats at all times. ... Hassidic Jews and Amish do not generally use Birth Control (aside from extended breast feeding, which does

What do ultra orthodox Jews do for work?

Description : What do ultra orthodox Jews do for work?

Last Answer : Ultra-Orthodox is not the preferred term, but I know a Hassidic Jews who is a semiconductor engineer, another who works in a meatpacking plant, a jeweler, and a deli owner. Many Hassidic ... Jews are no less Orthodox and because the things that make Hassidic Jews distinctive are not their degree

Why do Secular Jews join Orthodox Judaism?

Description : Why do Secular Jews join Orthodox Judaism?

Last Answer : For many of the same reasons that secular people of other religions become religious. Sometimes, as you grow older, you realize the need for community, and religion offers community. Sometimes, as ... in outreach to non-religious Jews and is quite happy if they affiliate with any Orthodox community.

Why do orthodox Jews always dress in black, and wear hats?

Description : Why do orthodox Jews always dress in black, and wear hats?

Last Answer : Some of them don't dress like that. Modern Orthodox Jews tend to dress like the people around them (although with attention to modesty). However, Hasidic Jews frequently do dress in black and wear long coats ... sense. This can range from a yarmulke or kippah (a beany) to a regular straw hat or fedo

Is Orthodox Judaism a cult in the eyes of Jews?

Description : Is Orthodox Judaism a cult in the eyes of Jews?

Last Answer : No, Orthodoxy doesn't qualify as a cult. However, some of the streams of Orthodoxy may qualify. Some of the Chassidic groups certainly have aspects that seem very cult-like. On the other hand, when ... , and most of the Chassidic groups are well over 100 years old. We speak of Chassidic dynasties.

What does Zionism mean to you?

Description : What does Zionism mean to you?

Last Answer : Why?

Is saying "Zionism is racist" a racist statement?

Description : Is saying "Zionism is racist" a racist statement?

Last Answer : As per Wikipedia: Zionism is the international Jewish political movement that originally supported the reestablishment of a homeland for the Jewish People in Palestine. The area was the Jewish Biblical homeland ... could be deemed racist by either party. It does little to rectify the dilemma though.

Why do orthodox women shave their head?

Description : Why do orthodox women shave their head?

Last Answer : They generally don't. There are some Hasidic women who do, butthe vast majority of Orthodox Jewish women do not.

Where are the majority of followers of eastern orthodox Christianity found?

Description : Where are the majority of followers of eastern orthodox Christianity found?

Last Answer : The most notable "hot pockets" are the Mediterranean, EasternEurope, North Africa, and the Middle East. However, Orthodox isthriving in central and southern Asia and in North America, and isgrowing in many parts of Sub-Saharan Africa, and in some parts ofEastern Asia and Latin America.

Why do orthodox women shave their head?

Description : Why do orthodox women shave their head?

Last Answer : They generally don't. There are some Hasidic women who do, butthe vast majority of Orthodox Jewish women do not.

Where are the majority of followers of eastern orthodox Christianity found?

Description : Where are the majority of followers of eastern orthodox Christianity found?

Last Answer : The most notable "hot pockets" are the Mediterranean, EasternEurope, North Africa, and the Middle East. However, Orthodox isthriving in central and southern Asia and in North America, and isgrowing in many parts of Sub-Saharan Africa, and in some parts ofEastern Asia and Latin America.

Can a conservative Jew or an Orthodox Jew be pro-LGBT?

Description : Can a conservative Jew or an Orthodox Jew be pro-LGBT?

Last Answer : The Conservative movement moved to allow ordination of gay, bisexual and lesbian rabbis in 2006 and to allow Conservative rabbis to officiate at same-sex marriages in 2012. They have not yet reached ... , but there has been no movement on these issues by the institutions that guide Orthodox Judaism.

Is Reform Judaism becoming more 'orthodox'?

Description : Is Reform Judaism becoming more 'orthodox'?

Last Answer : Orthodox may be the wrong term, but traditional Reform in the early 20th century abandoned a large number of practices that it has since or is now reclaiming. A century ago, there ... current Reform prayerbook has restored the preliminary services (with notes saying some congregations skip them).

Is Orthodox Judaism a religion or a cult?

Description : Is Orthodox Judaism a religion or a cult?

Last Answer : It is a religion. Note that Orthodoxy, like other branches of Judaism, is not homogeneous. Broadly speaking, Orthodox Judaism is divided into the Modern Orthodox, Jews who observe Jewish law ... Some Hassidic groups do have strong cult-like aspects, including focus on a single charismatic leader.

How much time does it take to convert to Orthodox Judaism?

Description : How much time does it take to convert to Orthodox Judaism?

Last Answer : Conversion to any stream of Judaism, Orthodox or not, is not fast. Potential converts must typically spend many hours of study under the supervision of a rabbi before they face a rabbinical ... depend on the community. Some large communities have formal classes for converts, with a fixed curri

Does a conservative Jew differ from an orthodox Jew?

Description : Does a conservative Jew differ from an orthodox Jew?

Last Answer : Conservative Judaism is considered to be a liberal branch of Judaism because the Conservative movement is egalitarian. Men and women sit together in most Conservative congregations, women are counted toward a ... or a phrase there, not the kind of wholesale changes the Reform movement has made.

What's the difference between Orthodox and Messianic Judaism?

Description : What's the difference between Orthodox and Messianic Judaism?

Last Answer : Orthodox Judaism entirely ignores the Christian New Testament and focuses on careful adherence to the 613 commandments in the Torah, as understood through the lens of the prophets, the later writings ... Jews attempt to preserve the form of Jewish worship while placing Christian beliefs at its core.

How does Orthodox Judaism differ from other types of Judaism?

Description : How does Orthodox Judaism differ from other types of Judaism?

Last Answer : Orthodox Judaism resists innovation in the interpretation of halacha, traditional Jewish law, and considers halacha to be binding on all Jews. In practice, this is most visible in the role of women. ... , ordain women as rabbis, and allow the use of electricity on the Sabbath.Some people poin

Can a converted conservative Jew convert to Orthodox Judaism?

Description : Can a converted conservative Jew convert to Orthodox Judaism?

Last Answer : I know of one woman who converted to Judaism under a Conservative rabbi, and then fell in love with an Orthodox man, so she re-converted under Orthodox auspices. So, the answer is yes, it has been done.

Can Orthodox Jewish women study the Torah?

Description : Can Orthodox Jewish women study the Torah?

Last Answer : Of course they can

How much does it cost to quickly convert to Orthodox Judaism?

Description : How much does it cost to quickly convert to Orthodox Judaism?

Last Answer : Conversion to any branch of Judaism requires an extended period of study under rabinnic supervision. Sometimes this study involves taking classes, sometimes it is one-on-one with a rabbi. Some conversion classes do ... in which case, the conversion is a sham and so is the court that accepted the b

Can a Reform Jew marry into Orthodox Judaism?

Description : Can a Reform Jew marry into Orthodox Judaism?

Last Answer : It is not so much as marrying into Orthodoxy as it is a matter of being Jewish according to Orthodox standards and agreeing to live as Orthodox Jews. If a Jewish couple goes to an Orthodox ... Orthodox backgrounds. If the bride or groom came from non Orthodox backgrounds, the rabbi might ask them t

How does Liberal Judaism differ from Orthodox Judaism?

Description : How does Liberal Judaism differ from Orthodox Judaism?

Last Answer : The most obvious difference to an outside observer is in the role of women. Orthodoxy generally does not recognize women serving as rabbis or permit women to lead prayers in a mixed ... the rabbinate. The liberal movements generally allow more personal autonomy in an individual's interpretation o

How to convert from Orthodox Judaism to Reform Judaism?

Description : How to convert from Orthodox Judaism to Reform Judaism?

Last Answer : Technically, there is no conversion required for the vast majority of Orthodox Jews who might want to be accepted into a Reform congregation. If an Orthodox Jew shows up in a Reform congregation and takes ... a non-Jewish father who grew up in a non-religious household would be welcome as a Jew

What distinguishes a Reform Jew from an Orthodox Jew?

Description : What distinguishes a Reform Jew from an Orthodox Jew?

Last Answer : Orthodox Jews consider themselves bound by the 613 commandments in the Torah as understood by the unbroken chain of rabbinic tradition stretching from biblical times to the present. Reform ... generally accept traditions about separation of sex roles, while Reform Jews generally reject sexual seg

What is the difference between orthodox and Hasidic Judaism?

Description : What is the difference between orthodox and Hasidic Judaism?

Last Answer : Orthodox Jews are those who accept the authority of Orthodox rabbis in the interpretation of Jewish law, based on the 613 commandments in the Torah. Observing Jewish law to Orthodox standards does not ... centuries. Each Hassidic sect revolves around its rebbi, that is, chief rabbi. In some sects

What is the significance of December 25th to an Orthodox Jew?

Description : What is the significance of December 25th to an Orthodox Jew?

Last Answer : Nothing. Christmas has no significance to Jews, Orthodox or not. There is a modern secular Jewish tradition to eat (kosher) Chinese food on Christmas and to go to movies. There is an older ... practices (and even more problematic beliefs) that many of these prohibitions apply, at least in part.

What are the origins of the Eastern Orthodox Church?

Description : What are the origins of the Eastern Orthodox Church?

Last Answer : The Christians of the Byzantine Empire did not want to recognize the pope in Rome as their leader, so in 1054 they agreed to divide from the Catholic Church and form their own branch of Christianity. This divide was called the great schism.

Why did the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church split?

Description : Why did the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church split?

Last Answer : Historical backgroundDuring the period of persecution, the Early Christian Church developed differently according to the part of the Roman Empire; the Church in the East developed differently from the West ... Diocletian formally divided the Empire into 2 sections in early part of the 4th century)T

Can a Catholic marry an Orthodox Jewish woman?

Description : Can a Catholic marry an Orthodox Jewish woman?

Last Answer : A Catholic priest would ask that the Jewish woman first convert to the Catholic church. A rabbi would suggest that the Catholic man first convert to Judaism. The clerk in the marriage bureau in ... study, possibly involving conversion classes, but in a small community, possibly one-on-one study.

In 1985, the famous chess player David Levy beat a world champion chess program in four straight games by using orthodox moves that confused the program. What was the name of the chess program? a) Kaissa b) CRAY BLITZ c) Golf d) DIGDUG

Description : In 1985, the famous chess player David Levy beat a world champion chess program in four straight games by using orthodox moves that confused the program. What was the name of the chess program? a) Kaissa b) CRAY BLITZ c) Golf d) DIGDUG

Last Answer : b) CRAY BLITZ

Orthodox seeds after dissemination may be a. None dormant b. Dormant c. Quiescent g. All of above

Description : Orthodox seeds after dissemination may be a. None dormant b. Dormant c. Quiescent g. All of above

Last Answer : All of above

Seed which do not remain viable for long time at low temperature is called – a. Orthodox seed b. Recalcitrant seed c. Dry seed d. None of these

Description : Seed which do not remain viable for long time at low temperature is called – a. Orthodox seed b. Recalcitrant seed c. Dry seed d. None of these

Last Answer : b. Recalcitrant seed

Which of these is/are the feature of an underdeveloped economy? (a) Greater inequalities ; (b) High incidence of unemployment ; (c) Orthodox means of production ; (d) All the three

Description : Which of these is/are the feature of an underdeveloped economy? (a) Greater inequalities ; (b) High incidence of unemployment ; (c) Orthodox means of production ; (d) All the three

Last Answer :  (d) All the three 

What is SEZ? The setting of SEZ has been opposed by some people in India. Why? Explain. -SST 10th

Description : What is SEZ? The setting of SEZ has been opposed by some people in India. Why? Explain. -SST 10th

Last Answer : In recent years, central and state governments in India are taking special steps to attract foreign companies to invest in India. So Special Industrial Zones are being set up. They are also called Special ... any source of livelihood. (ii) Labour does not get the protections of labour law in SEZs.

Why were some Americans opposed to the war with Mexico?

Description : Why were some Americans opposed to the war with Mexico?

Last Answer : Need answer

What are some of the benefits of swimming pools in ground as opposed to the other swimming pools?

Description : What are some of the benefits of swimming pools in ground as opposed to the other swimming pools?

Last Answer : In ground Swimming Pools are usually bigger than above ground pools. Although rather more expensive, in ground pools will last longer than above ground pools.

What are some advantages of having phone and internet through my cable company, as opposed to other options such as satellite or DSL?

Description : What are some advantages of having phone and internet through my cable company, as opposed to other options such as satellite or DSL?

Last Answer : Your cable company will provide a discoutn for bundling your services. You can also receive a similar discount thru your phone company.

Is there a strategic advantage to Russia attacking Ukraine in mid-winter, as opposed summer or fall?

Description : Is there a strategic advantage to Russia attacking Ukraine in mid-winter, as opposed summer or fall?

Last Answer : Ras Putin is drawing on his own nations history as a cautionary measure. If his plan backfires and he starts a major war, and the NATO alliance gets any ideas about chasing his armies back to ... drops, but he has surface to air missile installations to rely on I'm sure. Just speculating here.

In your opinion, what are the factors that lead one to judge a profession, that you know very little about, as either "too easy" and "not a real job", as opposed to "that is way too complicated for me"?

Description : In your opinion, what are the factors that lead one to judge a profession, that you know very little about, as either "too easy" and "not a real job", as opposed to "that is way too complicated for me"?

Last Answer : People are too quick to judge. They have no experience in the job and they think they know all the pressures and requirements that come with it, and often they are clueless. Moreover, I think some people ... looking down on someone very high on the ladder or lower on the ladder, it doesn't matter.

In a game where a random success rate is offered (as opposed to a game that is 100% winable) what should you expect as a success rate?

Description : In a game where a random success rate is offered (as opposed to a game that is 100% winable) what should you expect as a success rate?

Last Answer : LOL! Interesting question. But you missed a spot on the floors. Well, you have to factor in that it’s not just random success. There is some strategy involved too.

How much is aesthetics intentionally incorporated into industrial/military design, as opposed to purely being the result of function?

Description : How much is aesthetics intentionally incorporated into industrial/military design, as opposed to purely being the result of function?

Last Answer : We made and sold parts to an automotive company. They had a specific design requirement that there be no flat surfaces visible when looking at the engine with the hood open. That meant all parts had a ... the parts a tiny bit more resistant to impact damage. I will PM you with the company name.

What are the things one can't do on a tablet as opposed to desktop and maybe laptop?

Description : What are the things one can't do on a tablet as opposed to desktop and maybe laptop?

Last Answer : I’m guessing that you meant to type, ”...desktop and maybe laptop?” If yes, you might want to edit and clarify.

What is dried kidney beans as opposed to just kidney beans?

Description : What is dried kidney beans as opposed to just kidney beans?

Last Answer : The difference is the “kidney beans” are in a can.

Does your face look strange to you when you see an actual image of yourself as opposed to your reverse mirror image?

Description : Does your face look strange to you when you see an actual image of yourself as opposed to your reverse mirror image?

Last Answer : answer:Mostly no. But I do have a bit of a hump in my nose. I try to make it look less obvious in photographs. You’d only really notice it if I took a side profile picture. Don’t beat yourself up over it.