If all mental illnesses are a result of a physical ailment, shouldn't we be telling our GP everything, not bothering with shrinks at all?

If all mental illnesses are a result of a physical ailment, shouldn't we be telling our GP everything, not bothering with shrinks at all?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

How are all mental illnesses the result of a physical ailment again?
by

Related questions

Are mental illnesses only relatable thru’ direct observation, experience and anecdotal evidence?

Description : Are mental illnesses only relatable thru’ direct observation, experience and anecdotal evidence?

Last Answer : I’m not entirely sure what you’re asking. Your question is sort of hodge-podge.

Are there any mental or physical illnesses that can be cured with wining big on the lotto?

Description : Are there any mental or physical illnesses that can be cured with wining big on the lotto?

Last Answer : The short answer is no. Money doesn’t cure illnesses. The long answer is that you answered in the negative by dreaming of a diet detrimental to your health along with an avoidance of exercise.

Are there any mental or physical illnesses that can be caused or made worse with winning big on the lotto?

Description : Are there any mental or physical illnesses that can be caused or made worse with winning big on the lotto?

Last Answer : You can have these without having a lot of money as well so why not have the money instead? Spending too much money on lotto hoping that you’ll win jackpot won’t be a good idea though!!

Do mental illnesses have a physical basis?

Description : Do mental illnesses have a physical basis?

Last Answer : Yes. When I don’t take my thyroid pill, I inevitably get tragically depressed.

Have you ever performed self-hypnosis to cure some ailment?

Description : Have you ever performed self-hypnosis to cure some ailment?

Last Answer : Not self hypnosis but I have gone through hypnotherapy for stress and smoking cessation. Works amazingly well, but you have to really WANT to make changes otherwise your subconscious is going to resist. ... . It's not magic but can be a very beneficial tool for overcoming certain behavioral issues.

Got something that just drives you nuts? Let's see if it's a condition - or if the shrinks have a name for it.

Description : Got something that just drives you nuts? Let's see if it's a condition - or if the shrinks have a name for it.

Last Answer : Late-o-phobia? :-)

Shouldn't patients have the right to choose the treatment of their choice for certain illnesses/diseases?

Description : Shouldn't patients have the right to choose the treatment of their choice for certain illnesses/diseases?

Last Answer : Yes, choices should be given in most cases. The exception is highly contagious diseases threatening the lives of large communities.

Do you think labelling psychological illnesses and disorders helps or hinders healing and recovery?

Description : Do you think labelling psychological illnesses and disorders helps or hinders healing and recovery?

Last Answer : Things need labels and names. What would we call…everything? I think we could narrow this down and tackle the problem of people being misinformed about many things in general. Kate the Great asked a question similar to this about mental illness.

Under age 50: Do you know anyone that had an ailment discovered during an annual physical?

Description : Under age 50: Do you know anyone that had an ailment discovered during an annual physical?

Last Answer : (Age ~15) High blood pressure, though the only useful treatment was awareness and diet modification, though various other tests and drugs were prescribed. Whatever the tool for that is called. (Age ... not in people I know, of cancer being detected and needing treatment. Some didn't survive.

Do fish get mental illnesses?

Description : Do fish get mental illnesses?

Last Answer : Well. That’s why they call them fighting fish. They are highly territorial. It’s their instinct. That being said, many are probably inbred, in pet stores. All kinds of problems could sprout from that…

Do you think paranoia and other mental illnesses help people survive extreme circumstances?

Description : Do you think paranoia and other mental illnesses help people survive extreme circumstances?

Last Answer : answer:I would say mental illness is usually caused by traumatic events that don't get processed and healed. People definitely shut down their emotional reactions at the time of trauma in order to survive them ... that matters and goes on to form patterns around it for the rest of the person's life.

Should doctors add video game addiction to the medical encyclopedia of mental illnesses?

Description : Should doctors add video game addiction to the medical encyclopedia of mental illnesses?

Last Answer : I’d say the more likely scenario is that your addictions listed here are rather a symptom of some other underlying mental illness.

What is the general view of society about people with mental illnesses and/or disabilities?

Description : What is the general view of society about people with mental illnesses and/or disabilities?

Last Answer : I think it’s very different. It’s hard to have for example a child with mental illnesses. And I think that even if many people support this human and even if there is more acception then in earlier times it is really hard. There are still many people that do not accept people who are different.

Should people with personality disorders be given the same consideration as those with mental illnesses?

Description : Should people with personality disorders be given the same consideration as those with mental illnesses?

Last Answer : Personality disorders are a sub-category of mental illness. So I don’t quite understand; this is like saying “Should oranges be treated the same as fruit?”

Should people with mental illnesses be given the same (or situationally comparable) consideration as the physically-handicapped?

Description : Should people with mental illnesses be given the same (or situationally comparable) consideration as the physically-handicapped?

Last Answer : answer:I think that society gives sufficient empathy for those impacted with severe mental illness who absolutely cannot garner a better standard of life through treatments available the same way ... become more exaggerated. Of course that is my personal opinion derived from personal experiences.

What strengths do people with depression or other mental illnesses often have?

Description : What strengths do people with depression or other mental illnesses often have?

Last Answer : It taught me how to rely on myself.

Are you diagnosed with multiple mental illnesses?

Description : Are you diagnosed with multiple mental illnesses?

Last Answer : Yes I do. I'm not comfortable listing them all out, honestly. They do make a difference in treatment because certain methods work better for some than others. Some can be treated through talk therapy, some ... poorly, other ones grew to take their place. It's not a perfect tree- but it's mine.

If you suffered from any form of abuse as a child (physical, mental/emotional, sexual), how did that affect you as an adult?

Description : If you suffered from any form of abuse as a child (physical, mental/emotional, sexual), how did that affect you as an adult?

Last Answer : answer:Of course. Most of us have. The only person you need to trust is yourself! I trust myself, meaning, I trust that my own intuition and observations will not fail me in my interactions with ... that I will take right action, for myself. The only trust you really need, is trust in yourself!

Which hurts more - physical pain or mental pain?

Description : Which hurts more - physical pain or mental pain?

Last Answer : Mental pain is WAY worse then physical. With physical pain you can take two vicoden and get a doctors note and call it a day. Mental pain stays with you for the rest of your life depending on how ... try to get through it with yourself intact as much as possible and remember to never just give up.

Imagine if you had infinite mental and physical energy, everything was free, and every activity, building, and city was open to you right now; Where would you go, and what would you do, who would you visit, what would you eat, what would you be wearing?

Description : Imagine if you had infinite mental and physical energy, everything was free, and every activity, building, and city was open to you right now; Where would you go, and what would you do, who would you visit, what would you eat, what would you be wearing?

Last Answer : The library. Those bastards open at 9 and close at 6. How's anyone supposed to read anything?

What illnesses or injuries could result in chest pain?

Description : What illnesses or injuries could result in chest pain?

Last Answer : Chest pain could be a symptom of Heart Attack, Heartburns, Infections, and more. It's best to consult your doctor if you are having this problem.

When you watch a movie/tv show, or travel to a new city/place, do you notice your "instincts" telling you which way is North?

Description : When you watch a movie/tv show, or travel to a new city/place, do you notice your "instincts" telling you which way is North?

Last Answer : My husband has a built in GPS. I get backwards and upside down ALL THE TIME!

Final miserable question: Why do we bother to get treatment for terminal illnesses when our final destination is death anyway?

Description : Final miserable question: Why do we bother to get treatment for terminal illnesses when our final destination is death anyway?

Last Answer : answer:Most terminal illnesses involve a lot of pain. Most of the treatments are to abate the pain. Would you prefer that we simply let someone who has a terminal illness and is gasping to breathe just ... misery so I'm going to take your word for it. Have you considered treatment for depression?

The _______of an office must daily examine the condition of the locks of the main doors leading into the office and at least once a _____that of the locks of the boxes, etc., in the office and note the result of the examination in the ______as the case may be a) Gp D, Month, Order book or in the error book b) Officer in charge, Month, Order book or in the error book c) Officer in charge, Daily, Order book or in the error book d) None of these

Description : The _______of an office must daily examine the condition of the locks of the main doors leading into the office and at least once a _____that of the locks of the boxes, etc., in the office and note the ... the error book c) Officer in charge, Daily, Order book or in the error book d) None of these

Last Answer : b) Officer in charge, Month, Order book or in the error book

Do we live in the physical world or the one we create in our minds?

Description : Do we live in the physical world or the one we create in our minds?

Last Answer : Since I did not imagine that tree limb that bashed me in the forehead when I wasn’t looking where I was going…I’m going to say we live in the physical world.

After a black out the emergency generator comes on; On restoring the main supply we are closing the circuit breaker of the main generator without bothering about synchronizing. How is this possible?

Description : After a black out the emergency generator comes on; On restoring the main supply we are closing the circuit breaker of the main generator without bothering about synchronizing. How is this possible?

Last Answer : There is a power link connection breaker between the main generator and the emergency generator. During black out, this breaker trips. The emergency generator starts and its breaker closes and feeds only ... , there is no paralleling between main and emergency generator. Ask E/O for more details.

Do you mind telling me everything you know about Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma? If you or anyone you know has had it, please share your stories.

Description : Do you mind telling me everything you know about Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma? If you or anyone you know has had it, please share your stories.

Last Answer : A niece was treated for it when she was in her 20s. Don’t know much about it but she is now in her 40s. She had a treatment that could possibly have rendered her infertile but went on to have three healthy children.

If a person with a mental illness such as anxiety can be disqualified from the military, then shouldn't people that have gender dysphoria be disqualified as well?

Description : If a person with a mental illness such as anxiety can be disqualified from the military, then shouldn't people that have gender dysphoria be disqualified as well?

Last Answer : I dunno. Would gender dysphoria interfere with the ultimate mission? Would it interfere with efficiently killing other people?

What questions should I ask our doctor concerning our daughter's repeated illnesses?

Description : What questions should I ask our doctor concerning our daughter's repeated illnesses?

Last Answer : answer:Looking for a new doctor sounds like an excellent starting point. I wish I knew the questions you should ask. A high fever every month is definitely something that should be investigated. I wish you all the best of luck in getting to the bottom of this mystery.

An old ailment? What causes stuttering and have you known anyone who was cured? How?

Description : An old ailment? What causes stuttering and have you known anyone who was cured? How?

Last Answer : The most impressive example of a cure, that I know, is by Gareth Gates

Advice needed: How do you stop yourself from scratching at night when you have eczema (or any other similar extremely itchy skin ailment)

Description : Advice needed: How do you stop yourself from scratching at night when you have eczema (or any other similar extremely itchy skin ailment)

Last Answer : Wow that must be really difficult to deal with and you have my sympathies. Up until I read the last part of your post gloves were the first thing which popped into my mind. However, this may ... layers of tape would be enough to wake you up sufficiently to prevent further damage. Just a thought.

What ailment was Nintendo sued (and lost) for, resulting in payouts? -Gaming

Description : What ailment was Nintendo sued (and lost) for, resulting in payouts? -Gaming

Last Answer : The complaint alleges that Nintendo's Joy-Con controllers move in-game ... A boy and his mother today filed a class action lawsuit against Nintendo for not doing ... I sincerely hope these shameless money-grabbers lose and have to pay for ...

Atherosclerosis refers to the ailment of

Description : Atherosclerosis refers to the ailment of

Last Answer : Atherosclerosis refers to the ailment of A. Lungs B. Heart C. Kidney D. Liver

ECG is done to diagnose an ailment connected with? (1) Kidney (2) Heart (3) Brain (4) Blood

Description : ECG is done to diagnose an ailment connected with? (1) Kidney (2) Heart (3) Brain (4) Blood

Last Answer : (2) Heart Explanation: ECG stands for electrocardiogram and it is commonly used to detect abnormal heart rhythms and to investigate the cause of chest pains.

What ailment is caused by the blockage of blood vessel by a blood clot?

Description : What ailment is caused by the blockage of blood vessel by a blood clot?

Last Answer : Thrombosis

Do you have a mental condition that your doctor won't touch with a ten foot pole?

Description : Do you have a mental condition that your doctor won't touch with a ten foot pole?

Last Answer : answer:I haven’t seen a doctor about my mental health. I went as far as to get a referral from my GP, but never had the guts to make an appointment. My brother did get dumped by his psychiatrist. Bipolar pathological liar… I guess the fees weren’t worth the waste of time.

How can I learn the basics for being a mental health therapist?

Description : How can I learn the basics for being a mental health therapist?

Last Answer : I don’t know what APA formatting is. However, you need to get a college degree to practice any kind of therapy.

Can anyone define "checks' or "checking" as it pertains to mental illness?

Description : Can anyone define "checks' or "checking" as it pertains to mental illness?

Last Answer : I have to do certain checks. I can’t rest unless I do them, and if something has moved it drives me crazy and I search absolutely everywhere until it is found. I have even been known to search the bins.

Some adults are said to have a mind of a child, but what about the rest of the population? What milestones should the rest of the age groups have to belong to a certain mental age?

Description : Some adults are said to have a mind of a child, but what about the rest of the population? What milestones should the rest of the age groups have to belong to a certain mental age?

Last Answer : answer:Good question Well it really is simplified into personality trait, one with the mind of a child is mentally immature whereas a mature individual or normal person is more settled in ... is more conditioned to respond to the responsibilities and events involved at that certain stage in life

Do you believe that in controlled situations under the guidance of a trained professional, LSD could be useful in mental therapy?

Description : Do you believe that in controlled situations under the guidance of a trained professional, LSD could be useful in mental therapy?

Last Answer : In the very least, it would be really cool to try it.

Where would you place yourself on the meds--therapy spectrum for treatment of mental illness?

Description : Where would you place yourself on the meds--therapy spectrum for treatment of mental illness?

Last Answer : Right now I’m all meds, no therapy. Would love to flip it. And if I could do cardio on a regular basis, I probably could lay down the meds altogether, right?

What are your conceptions of those with mental illness?

Description : What are your conceptions of those with mental illness?

Last Answer : All of the above.

Is it possible to codify the mental steps necessary to achieve genius?

Description : Is it possible to codify the mental steps necessary to achieve genius?

Last Answer : I read a wide variety of books from D&D to physics and watch intelligent TV…I used to play “Mike Tyson’s Super Punch Out” for self confidence…some genius is just recognizing patterns and using tricks.

What are the best ways to overcome mental roadblocks?

Description : What are the best ways to overcome mental roadblocks?

Last Answer : It is one thing telling ourselves “I can do it”, but it is making our heads think otherwise is the problem.

Grieving process. When is it too long and maybe a mental issue?

Description : Grieving process. When is it too long and maybe a mental issue?

Last Answer : We beat ourselves up with too many shoulds. Your feelings are your feelings; six months doesn't seem that long to me to be still grieving for something that meant a lot to you. It's funny how you can ... them but we all do. Be kind to yourself, don't beat yourself up and you will come through it.

What are reasons for hallucinating if your are not physically ill, and don't really think you have serious mental illness and stuff?

Description : What are reasons for hallucinating if your are not physically ill, and don't really think you have serious mental illness and stuff?

Last Answer : Dehydration

What is a mental cue ?

Description : What is a mental cue ?

Last Answer : Memory of past instinctive reactions - the impulsive stimulus that comes from impressions or weights is called mental cue or mental queue.

Can you open your back or front door, step outside, and fire a shotgun without bothering your neighbors?

Description : Can you open your back or front door, step outside, and fire a shotgun without bothering your neighbors?

Last Answer : answer:Are you crazy? I'd shoot out my neighbor in back's windows. The police would show up, and I would be hauled in for vandalism and recklessness and probably for having a gun I am not ... the US in a nice, but densely packed neighborhood. Anyone shooting a shotgun off around here must be crazy.

Have you ever had a thought which kept sticking in your mind and bothering you, and you found it difficult to let go? How did you deal with it, and did the annoying thought finally go away?

Description : Have you ever had a thought which kept sticking in your mind and bothering you, and you found it difficult to let go? How did you deal with it, and did the annoying thought finally go away?

Last Answer : There is a memory or two that I try to push back. I used to dwell on it everyday. Months would pass & the thought would drift in & out of consciousness. It's been 4 years now & the thought almost ... a question that digs up painful memories. :) I'm teasing. Really, it's just a matter of time.

I'm sort of a heavy smoker. But with this new job (8 hrs per day,) I made the decision not to smoke except during my one break (30 minutes for lunch.) It isn't really bothering me at all. Anyone have any idea why?

Description : I'm sort of a heavy smoker. But with this new job (8 hrs per day,) I made the decision not to smoke except during my one break (30 minutes for lunch.) It isn't really bothering me at all. Anyone have any idea why?

Last Answer : Maybe you’re just over it. In any case, congratulations!