Simple debate: Free will or determinism?

Simple debate: Free will or determinism?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

The only ‘right’ answer is we know absolutely nothing for sure…so, that renders my input virtually useless.
by

Related questions

Curious how many have changed their opinion regarding the free will/determinism debate?

Description : Curious how many have changed their opinion regarding the free will/determinism debate?

Last Answer : answer:I’ve studied this stuff for years and ultimately I think there is a lot of credibility in non-dualism. The Adviata Vedanta is a mind f—k, but…whew….uh..that’s all I’m sayin’. lol

Free will or determinism -- what difference would it make in how you live your life?

Description : Free will or determinism -- what difference would it make in how you live your life?

Last Answer : None in terms of my life. How could it? I come to a juncture and have to make a decision. What choice do I have but to make it. Otherwise, I can spend the rest of my life dithering by the side of the road deciding whether to cross or not.

What do you think about this video as an argument against determinism?

Description : What do you think about this video as an argument against determinism?

Last Answer : As I understand it, Determinism is the belief that all events are caused, or acted upon, by prior events. Nothing happens without cause. I think that the video posits an argument for Indeterminism; that is ... are not caused by prior events and that may, or may not, have effect on future events.

Do you believe in determinism?

Description : Do you believe in determinism?

Last Answer : If you drop a rock off a cliff, it will fall down. Physics above the quantum level is deterministic, and there is no indication that the randomness at the quantum level translates to randomness above that level. So, yes, I subscribe to determinism.

Is there a connection between determinism and moral responsibility?

Description : Is there a connection between determinism and moral responsibility?

Last Answer : Which religious belief? Which morals? Which responsibility?

What impact does determinism have on responsibility?

Description : What impact does determinism have on responsibility?

Last Answer : answer:None. Wether your action are because of free will or determinism, they're still your actions. If, say, a murderer kills someone, and we're looking at it from a free-will point of view ... is still of the single individual: wether of his personality or of his brain doesn't really matter.

Explain the concept-of ‘Determinism’ with suitable examples. -Geography

Description : Explain the concept-of ‘Determinism’ with suitable examples. -Geography

Last Answer : (i) In the beginning humans are hugely influenced by nature. (ii) They were afraid of nature’s fury. They worshipped the nature. (iii) Nature determines societies attitudes decisions and their lifestyles. Humans were passive agents and nature dictates their lives as per determinism.

Name the geographers who advocated ‘Environmental Determinism.’ -Geography

Description : Name the geographers who advocated ‘Environmental Determinism.’ -Geography

Last Answer : German expert Ratzel and his student Ellen Churchill Simple advocated ‘Environmental Determinism.’

Which view says that the origin of patriarchy do not locate in legal, political rights or economic determinism but rather in the very roots of masculine psychology, language and thought? (a) Marxist View (b) Socialist Feminist View (c) Radical View (d) Traditional View

Description : Which view says that the origin of patriarchy do not locate in legal, political rights or economic determinism but rather in the very roots of masculine psychology, language and thought? (a) Marxist View (b) Socialist Feminist View (c) Radical View (d) Traditional View

Last Answer : (b) Socialist Feminist View

How come people [here on Fluther] like to talk/debate/argue so much about things they don't understand or don't have a clue about?

Description : How come people [here on Fluther] like to talk/debate/argue so much about things they don't understand or don't have a clue about?

Last Answer : Well I think the point is to have an opinion about something and HOPEFULLY facts and sources would back up statements. Unfortunately this isn't NASA or the Pentagon or the Print Media so you know, the ... in lolly gag discussions here and there. But at least we try. This might go to META btw.

Was the Missouri compromise a good solution to the debate free states and slave states?

Description : Was the Missouri compromise a good solution to the debate free states and slave states?

Last Answer : NO,because it splits the nation in half. "later starts the civilwar."

Have you ever mistaken education for debate?

Description : Have you ever mistaken education for debate?

Last Answer : I do find other people think they’re in a debate when I’m actually trying to educate them.

Is the debate among pro abortionists ("pro-choicers'') similar/same to the one between anti and pro abortionists?

Description : Is the debate among pro abortionists ("pro-choicers'') similar/same to the one between anti and pro abortionists?

Last Answer : Name a pro abortionist.

If you forget all the things you want to say to another person because (s)he's talking for a determined amount of time and you pay attention to him/her, would you still participate in a debate?

Description : If you forget all the things you want to say to another person because (s)he's talking for a determined amount of time and you pay attention to him/her, would you still participate in a debate?

Last Answer : Why would you need to debate this person?

The Tape Debate: where do you place it?

Description : The Tape Debate: where do you place it?

Last Answer : Here's what I do: I start by placing the gift neatly in the center of a rectangle of a piece of wrapping paper. I start by pulling one side over half the gift. I pull the other side over and pull about ... is a nice mess of wrapping paper surrounding a gift. I then cry In short, I am 100-piece-er

Should men have any real say, in any kind of abortion debate?

Description : Should men have any real say, in any kind of abortion debate?

Last Answer : If you remember a while back a rep/con politician stated that a woman couldn’t get pregnant from a rape because her body shuts down from the traumatic experience,really?? and it’s idiots like this that make laws that affect millions of women.

Which animals do people debate whether or not they are sentient?

Description : Which animals do people debate whether or not they are sentient?

Last Answer : I'd say most viruses and bacteria are not considered sentient but how do we know if they feel pain or discomfort? Some say fish do not feel pain but I'm pretty sure suffocating to death flopping around the ... or on the shore of a lake, rover or ocaen is not a pleasant experience for the poor fish.

What are your thoughts about Trump's "stalking" of Clinton during the debate?

Description : What are your thoughts about Trump's "stalking" of Clinton during the debate?

Last Answer : I think it was a maneuver to intimidate her, by making her walk around him to return to her seat. Yes, the visuals backfired on him.

Are you watching the presidential debate tonight?

Description : Are you watching the presidential debate tonight?

Last Answer : I have it on while I’m ask-publicing. I wasn’t going to watch it but there’s not much else on and I don’t feel like reading. I hate contention and I hate this political bullshit – it’s all spins and sound bites.

Who won the debate between VP candidates Tim Kaine and Mike Pence?

Description : Who won the debate between VP candidates Tim Kaine and Mike Pence?

Last Answer : answer:I am supporting Hillary. Pence won the debate, because Kaine was quite annoyingly interrupting every question. Pence had a smooth radio voice, and seemed in better control. Kaine, however, ... checkers are able to point out the hundreds of misrepresentations and flat out lies Pence made.

Is the job of a moderator for 2016 US presidential election debate very difficult?

Description : Is the job of a moderator for 2016 US presidential election debate very difficult?

Last Answer : I mean Is the job of a presidential election’s moderator difficult? I flagged it

Did the debate change your vote?

Description : Did the debate change your vote?

Last Answer : Nope, but I have been a Hillary supporter for a long time. The debate wasn’t going to change my mind, but then again there hasn’t been a debate in decades to get me to change my mind.

Who won the debate?

Description : Who won the debate?

Last Answer : CNN. I enjoyed it.

What snack foods will you bring to the 2016, september 26 , American presidential debate?

Description : What snack foods will you bring to the 2016, september 26 , American presidential debate?

Last Answer : I doubt I’ll be eating. I hope to be cuddling on the sofa with my husband, and fast forwarding through any BS.

Why is there such endless debate about pitbull attacks?

Description : Why is there such endless debate about pitbull attacks?

Last Answer : answer:One big reason is that there is no reliable reporting system linking dog bite incidents to breed. News reports jump all over any incident supposedly involving a pit bull (largely because it ... whereas the black and hispanic people I encounter often exclaim about what a beautiful dog he is.

When is it okay to bring up Hitler in a debate?

Description : When is it okay to bring up Hitler in a debate?

Last Answer : Well its perhaps ok to bring up Hitler when emphasising how extreme a certain act or attitude towards a minority. I sometimes bring up Hitler when debating with homophobes (particular homophobes who regard homosexuals ... as Hitler. Then ask them why they align with Hitler's morality (or lack of).

How shall the Trump-Sanders televised debate drinking game be played?

Description : How shall the Trump-Sanders televised debate drinking game be played?

Last Answer : Drink everytime one of them says “huge” or “yuuuuuuuge”. With Trump talking about his penis, you just may get drunk.

With all the debate swirling around, why can't they just make it so that anybody can go in any bathroom they want?

Description : With all the debate swirling around, why can't they just make it so that anybody can go in any bathroom they want?

Last Answer : answer:Makes sense to me. A lot of restaurants just have a bathroom. You lock the door when you go in, no one else can come in and bother you. I don’t have gender specific bathrooms at home (although my kids’ has all my daughter’s stuff out everywhere and her brother prefers to use my bathroom.)

Did you watch the Democratic Debate in Miami?

Description : Did you watch the Democratic Debate in Miami?

Last Answer : answer:I never watch the debates, because it irks me that people choose candidates like they choose football teams. HOWEVER, after the last few days excitement I want to see some Hillary/Bernie debates. ... video online this weekend. We haven't had a bona fide leftist in the spotlight for decades!

Debate topics for Gr. 6?

Description : Debate topics for Gr. 6?

Last Answer : answer:Sixth graders are 10 – 12 years old. What the heck do they know about Uber and Syria? Have them debate whether school uniforms stifle individual expression, or whether metal detectors will make school safer, or whether they should do away with homework, or if video games rot your brain.

Will the Republican debates lose all credibility if the candidates take over management of the debate process?

Description : Will the Republican debates lose all credibility if the candidates take over management of the debate process?

Last Answer : ”Will the republican debates lose all credibility”? Not in the eyes of the conservatives. To the cons, It will be a “courageous stand against the communist media”.

What is there to debate about the message from WHO re. processed meat, charred meat etc?

Description : What is there to debate about the message from WHO re. processed meat, charred meat etc?

Last Answer : answer:Most of the debate is just trying to understand what the findings actually mean for people, in terms of a single life. We're finding everything is dangerous to some extent, from sugar, to ... trying to make an informed decision if meat is still worth the risk. best summary I've found here

How do you think Donald Trump did in the debate last night?

Description : How do you think Donald Trump did in the debate last night?

Last Answer : As good as his hair!

Would you love to see a Trump/Hilary debate?

Description : Would you love to see a Trump/Hilary debate?

Last Answer : No, it would be appalling if he were nominated.

Aside from the US, is there even a debate regarding evolutionary theory in the rest of the world?

Description : Aside from the US, is there even a debate regarding evolutionary theory in the rest of the world?

Last Answer : Not here, no.

Screwed over by debate team?

Description : Screwed over by debate team?

Last Answer : Just tell your professor you worked with bums and want extra credit to compensate for their inadequacies. That’s what I’d do.

What are the top 10 controversial topics about which people (you feel close to) frequently debate about?

Description : What are the top 10 controversial topics about which people (you feel close to) frequently debate about?

Last Answer : answer:“What are your personal most controversial topics?”

Do you answer questions or debate why the question was asked?

Description : Do you answer questions or debate why the question was asked?

Last Answer : answer:It depends on what is appropriate. If someone asks a question that is based on a false presupposition, then it is both legitimate and logical to point out that the question is flawed. ... when so many of them rest on assumptions that are themselves questionable-or even just plain false.

When people post very opinionated, negative things on FB, do you jump into the debate or leave it alone?

Description : When people post very opinionated, negative things on FB, do you jump into the debate or leave it alone?

Last Answer : I leave it alone. Facebook has my name attatched to it and some day an ultra conservative future employer may be reading my profile when I’m applying for a job. Always remember: if you’re not paying for a service you’re the product, not the customer.

Einstein debate was he on the autism spectrum ?

Description : Einstein debate was he on the autism spectrum ?

Last Answer : answer:I would have taken Einstein to Vegas with me for sure. your link is broken

Do people debate about littering?

Description : Do people debate about littering?

Last Answer : The only debate about littering is to decide how best to kick someone’s ass who does.

Calling all jellies: Can you help me mount a debate against anorexia in the fashion industry?

Description : Calling all jellies: Can you help me mount a debate against anorexia in the fashion industry?

Last Answer : The only argument, aside from the unrealistic body models is the simple, indisputable fact, that extremely low body weight is unhealthy and can lead to death from cardiac arrest as the heart muscle is ... is a dis-ease of the mind and psyche and starvation is the manifestation of the unwell mind.

Is it difficult for you, in a debate, to get over the blasphemy of someones point of view, and at least applaud their efforts.

Description : Is it difficult for you, in a debate, to get over the blasphemy of someones point of view, and at least applaud their efforts.

Last Answer : If I see a good answer (in my humble opinion). Regardless of whether it concurs with my own, that person gets a GA. Even if I find that particular jelly has behaved (what I consider) in a ... GA is a GA. I do however notice stinginess with GA selection with some jellies, so treat same for same

Did you have the opportunity to experience open debate in college?

Description : Did you have the opportunity to experience open debate in college?

Last Answer : I was very lucky. I attended a college in which small, seminar classes were the norm and discussion and questions were encouraged. I enjoy a good back and forth although it seems to me that on ... engaging hotly in debates, I now tend to shy away from them in favor of more productive pursuits.

What is the geekiest debate you have been drawn into having?

Description : What is the geekiest debate you have been drawn into having?

Last Answer : I know a ridiculous amount about Marvel Comics history and continuity. Many times in the past I’ve overheard discussions about Marvel characters that were full of misinformation. I often can’t resist wading into the discussion to make corrections. Then I leave, feeling like a goober.

How to be a good adjudicator in debate?

Description : How to be a good adjudicator in debate?

Last Answer : answer:Are you talking about a formal debate, or something more relaxed? In formal debates, you look at a variety of things. Here is the list from the American Parliamentary Debate Association. It suggests ... In political debates, the public is the judge, and they get to judge however they want to.

If you are in a debate, how to force yourself to be open-minded?

Description : If you are in a debate, how to force yourself to be open-minded?

Last Answer : answer:Being open minded is the ability to consider other options, not necessarily accepting them. I have ideas I am convinced of, but I will still listen and consider other sides or ... are some I have changed position on due to someone presenting convincing evidence. Welcome to fluther.

Want to dialog about the debate as it happens? pt 4?

Description : Want to dialog about the debate as it happens? pt 4?

Last Answer : I don’t like that Obama keeps focusing on his own perception of Romney and his “policies.” I’m glad that Romney called him on that. I want to hear what Obama has to say about his own beliefs and policy. I wish he’d stop play such terrible defense.

Want to dialog about the debate as it happens? pt 3?

Description : Want to dialog about the debate as it happens? pt 3?

Last Answer : Obama seems a lot more confident tonight than he was last debate.

Did President Obama respond to his training for tonight's "debate"?

Description : Did President Obama respond to his training for tonight's "debate"?

Last Answer : I thought so. But I think both of them did especially when AWB / FAF was brought up. They both, but mainly Obama ran from that one like they were on fire.