Is there a better alternative to the peer review system in scientific research?

Is there a better alternative to the peer review system in scientific research?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

I’ve often wondered this myself. I do think there needs to be a way to anonymize the papers before peers can read and judge and I feel like I would appreciate an independent research team in place to replicate some findings ( I know that’s not feasible to put into practice but still).
by

Related questions

In response to peer review a scientific journal might choose not to publish a paper submitted by a scientist. is a reason why a paper might be rejected for publication?

Description : In response to peer review a scientific journal might choose not to publish a paper submitted by a scientist. is a reason why a paper might be rejected for publication?

Last Answer : Need answer

A process comprising an ongoing consideration and evaluation of the firm's system of quality control, including a periodic inspection of a selection of completed engagements, designed to enable the firm to obtain reasonable assurance that its system of quality control is operating effectively. a. Inspection b. Monitoring c. Peer review d. Engagement quality control review

Description : A process comprising an ongoing consideration and evaluation of the firm's system of quality control, including a periodic inspection of a selection of completed engagements, designed to enable the firm ... effectively. a. Inspection b. Monitoring c. Peer review d. Engagement quality control review

Last Answer : Monitoring

In connection with the element of professional development, a CPA firm's system of quality control should ordinarily provide that all personnel a. Possess judgment, motivation, and adequate experience. b. Seek assistance from persons having appropriate level of knowledge, judgment, and authority. c. Demonstrate compliance with peer review directives. d. Have the knowledge required to enable them to fulfill responsibilities assigned.

Description : In connection with the element of professional development, a CPA firm's system of quality control should ordinarily provide that all personnel a. Possess judgment, motivation, and adequate ... review directives. d. Have the knowledge required to enable them to fulfill responsibilities assigned.

Last Answer : Have the knowledge required to enable them to fulfill responsibilities assigned.

Why is this considered an example of unhelpful feedback provided during the peer-review process?

Description : Why is this considered an example of unhelpful feedback provided during the peer-review process?

Last Answer : It doesn’t provide any suggestions for improvement

Why is this considered an example of unhelpful feedback provided during the peer-review process?

Description : Why is this considered an example of unhelpful feedback provided during the peer-review process?

Last Answer : It doesn’t provide any suggestions for improvement

A process designed to provide an objective evaluation, before the report is issued, of the significant judgments the engagement team made and the conclusions they reached in formulating the report. a. Peer review b. Inspection c. Engagement quality control review d. Monitoring

Description : A process designed to provide an objective evaluation, before the report is issued, of the significant judgments the engagement team made and the conclusions they reached in formulating the report. a. Peer review b. Inspection c. Engagement quality control review d. Monitoring

Last Answer : Engagement quality control review

It involves a study or evaluation of the quality of audit of financial statements through a review of quality control measures established by on CPA firms and individual CPAs in public practice to ensure compliance with accounting and auditing standards and practices a. External audit b. Compliance audit c. Peer review d. Quality review

Description : It involves a study or evaluation of the quality of audit of financial statements through a review of quality control measures established by on CPA firms and individual CPAs in public practice to ... standards and practices a. External audit b. Compliance audit c. Peer review d. Quality review

Last Answer : Quality review

What will an auditor who has been proposed for an audit engagement usually do prior to accepting a new client? a. Draft the financial statements of the client as a measure of goodwilb. With the permission from the prospective client, contact the predecessor auditor to determine if there are any disagreements between the client and the audit firms. c. Obtain the potential client's permission to talk to the former auditor and review work papers. d. Perform a peer review on the potential client in accordance with professional standardsl

Description : What will an auditor who has been proposed for an audit engagement usually do prior to accepting a new client? a. Draft the financial statements of the client as a measure of goodwill b ... review work papers. d. Perform a peer review on the potential client in accordance with professional standards

Last Answer : With the permission from the prospective client, contact the predecessor auditor to determine if there are any disagreements between the client and the audit firms

An engagement in which a CPA firm arranges for a critical review of its practices by another CPA firm. a. Attestation engagement b. Peer review engagement c. Quality control engagement d. Quality assurance engagemen

Description : An engagement in which a CPA firm arranges for a critical review of its practices by another CPA firm. a. Attestation engagement b. Peer review engagement c. Quality control engagement d. Quality assurance engagemen

Last Answer : Peer review engagement

In which of the following circumstances would a CPA be bound by ethics to refrain from disclosing any confidential information obtained during the course of a professional engagement? a. The CPA is issue a summons enforceable by a court order which orders the CPA to present confidential information. b. A major stockholder of a client company seeks accounting information from the CPA after management declined to disclose the requested information. c. Confidential client information is made available as part of a quality review of the CPA's practice by a peer review team authorized by the PICPA. d. An inquiry by a disciplinary body of PICPA requests confidential client information

Description : In which of the following circumstances would a CPA be bound by ethics to refrain from disclosing any confidential information obtained during the course of a professional engagement? a. The CPA is ... the PICPA. d. An inquiry by a disciplinary body of PICPA requests confidential client information

Last Answer : A major stockholder of a client company seeks accounting information from the CPA after management declined to disclose the requested information

The confidential relationship will be violated if, without client's permission, the CPA provides working papers about client to a. A court of law which subpoenas them. b. Another CPA firm as part of a peer review. c. Another CPA firm which has just purchased the CPA's entire practice. d. An investigative or disciplinary body which is conducting a review of the CPA's practice.

Description : The confidential relationship will be violated if, without client's permission, the CPA provides working papers about client to a. A court of law which subpoenas them. b. Another CPA firm as part ... . d. An investigative or disciplinary body which is conducting a review of the CPA's practice.

Last Answer : Another CPA firm which has just purchased the CPA's entire practice.

A CPA in public practice shall not disclose any confidential client information without the specific consent of the client. The confidentiality rule is violated if CPA disclosed information without client's consent as a result of a a. Subpoena or summons. b. Peer review. c. Request by client's largest stockholder. d. Complaint filed with the trial board of the Board of Accountancy

Description : A CPA in public practice shall not disclose any confidential client information without the specific consent of the client. The confidentiality rule is violated if CPA disclosed information without client' ... s largest stockholder. d. Complaint filed with the trial board of the Board of Accountancy

Last Answer : Request by client's largest stockholder.

What are the relevance of literature review in a scientific research?

Description : What are the relevance of literature review in a scientific research?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Are there any peer-reviewed scientific studies that show gender roles are artificial & that being gay is natural?

Description : Are there any peer-reviewed scientific studies that show gender roles are artificial & that being gay is natural?

Last Answer : You want to look in an academic journals database that allows you to search for peer-reviewed journals and tyr keywords such as “homosexuality” and “normal” or “biology” and “sexual orientation.” Don’t confuse gender roles with sexual orientation but do do your own research.

What are some good, readily accessible peer-reviewed journals on obscure issues (particularly scientific and environmental ones)?

Description : What are some good, readily accessible peer-reviewed journals on obscure issues (particularly scientific and environmental ones)?

Last Answer : Use Lexus Nexus to search your topic several peer reviewed articles will come up. Look for the common publishers of those articles. Talk to a librarian (preferable one on a university campus) to assist you with ... They can do all this work for you in about one tenth of the time it will take you.

The official peer-reviewed Journal of the EWRS (European Weed Research Society) is a). Journal of Crop and Weed b). Weed Research c). Weed Science

Description : The official peer-reviewed Journal of the EWRS (European Weed Research Society) is a). Journal of Crop and Weed b). Weed Research c). Weed Science

Last Answer : b). Weed Research

A research paper (A) is a compilation of information on a topic. (B) contains original research as deemed by the author. (C) contains peer-reviewed original research or evaluation of research conducted by others. (D) can be published in more than one journal.

Description : A research paper (A) is a compilation of information on a topic.  (B) contains original research as deemed by the author. (C) contains peer-reviewed original research or evaluation of research conducted by others. (D) can be published in more than one journal.

Last Answer : (C) contains peer-reviewed original research or evaluation of research conducted by others.

I'd like to check out if "peer help" is better than medical and psychological support for addiction?

Description : I'd like to check out if "peer help" is better than medical and psychological support for addiction?

Last Answer : There is no method found to be better than one addict talking to another. An addict in recovery can tell his or her story to an active user and carry the message that recovery is ... are an important part of recovery, and many suggest augmenting professional help with meeting with other addicts.

What is the most likely course of action that will be taken by an auditor in assessing management integrity? a. Tour the client premises. b. Research the prospective client’s related parties. c. Research the background and histories of officers d. Review the minutes of the board of directors

Description : What is the most likely course of action that will be taken by an auditor in assessing management integrity? a. Tour the client premises. b. Research the prospective client’s related parties. c. Research the background and histories of officers d. Review the minutes of the board of directors

Last Answer : Research the background and histories of officers

Which among the following is the first step of Research Process? a) Review of Literature b) Collection of Data c) Editing and Coding d) Selection of a problem

Description : Which among the following is the first step of Research Process? a) Review of Literature b) Collection of Data c) Editing and Coding d) Selection of a problem

Last Answer : d) Selection of a problem

A research plan _____. a. Should be detailed b. Should be given to others for review and comments c. Sets out the rationale for a research study d. All of the above

Description : A research plan _____. a. Should be detailed b. Should be given to others for review and comments c. Sets out the rationale for a research study d. All of the above

Last Answer : d. All of the above

Research hypotheses are ______. a. Formulated prior to a review of the literature b. Statements of predicted relationships between variables c. Stated such that they can be confirmed or refuted d. b and c

Description : Research hypotheses are ______. a. Formulated prior to a review of the literature b. Statements of predicted relationships between variables c. Stated such that they can be confirmed or refuted d. b and c

Last Answer : d. b and c

A formal statement of the research question or “purpose of research study” generally; a. Is made prior to the literature review b. Is made after the literature review c. Will help guide the research process d. b and c

Description : A formal statement of the research question or “purpose of research study” generally; a. Is made prior to the literature review b. Is made after the literature review c. Will help guide the research process d. b and c

Last Answer : d. b and c

A review of the literature prior to formulating research questions allows the researcher to do which of the following? a. To become familiar with prior research on the phenomenon of interest b. To identify potential methodological problems in the research area c. To develop a list of pertinent problems relative to the phenomenon of interest d. All of the above

Description : A review of the literature prior to formulating research questions allows the researcher to do which of the following? a. To become familiar with prior research on the phenomenon of interest b. To ... develop a list of pertinent problems relative to the phenomenon of interest d. All of the above

Last Answer : d. All of the above

One step that is not included in planning a research study is: a. Identifying a researchable problem b. A review of current research c. Statement of the research question d. Conducting a meta-analysis of the research e. Developing a research plan

Description : One step that is not included in planning a research study is: a. Identifying a researchable problem b. A review of current research c. Statement of the research question d. Conducting a meta-analysis of the research e. Developing a research plan

Last Answer : d. Conducting a meta-analysis of the research

PERT stand for: a. Performance Evaluation Review Technique b. Programme Evaluation Review Technique c. Programme Evaluation Research Technique

Description : PERT stand for: a. Performance Evaluation Review Technique b. Programme Evaluation Review Technique c. Programme Evaluation Research Technique

Last Answer : b. Programme Evaluation Review Technique

PERT stands for __________. A. Programme Evaluation and Research Techniques. B. Project Evaluation and Review Techniques. C. Programme Evaluation and Review Techniques. D. Project Evaluation and Research Techniques.

Description : PERT stands for __________. A. Programme Evaluation and Research Techniques. B. Project Evaluation and Review Techniques. C. Programme Evaluation and Review Techniques. D. Project Evaluation and Research Techniques.

Last Answer : C. Programme Evaluation and Review Techniques.

The core elements of dissertation are (A) Introduction; Data Collection; Data Analysis; Conclusions and Recommendations (B) Executive Summary; Literature review; Data gathered; Conclusions; Bibliography (C) Research Plan; Research Data; Analysis; References (D) Introduction; Literature Review; Research Methodology; Results; Discussion and Conclusion

Description : The core elements of dissertation are (A) Introduction; Data Collection; Data Analysis; Conclusions and Recommendations (B) Executive Summary; Literature review; Data gathered; Conclusions; ... ; References (D) Introduction; Literature Review; Research Methodology; Results; Discussion and Conclusion

Last Answer : A

Which is the main objective of research ? (A) To review the literature (B) To summarize what is already known (C) To get an academic degree (D) To discover new facts or to make fresh interpretation of known facts

Description : Which is the main objective of research ? (A) To review the literature (B) To summarize what is already known (C) To get an academic degree (D) To discover new facts or to make fresh interpretation of known facts

Last Answer : (D) To discover new facts or to make fresh interpretation of known facts

Identify the correct sequence of research steps : (A) Selection of topic, review of literature, data collection, interpretation of findings (B) Review of literature, selection of topic, data collection, interpretation of findings (C) Selection of topic, data collection, review of literature, interpretation of findings (D) Selection of topic, review of literature, interpretation of findings, data collection

Description : Identify the correct sequence of research steps : (A) Selection of topic, review of literature, data collection, interpretation of findings (B) Review of literature, selection of topic, data ... of findings (D) Selection of topic, review of literature, interpretation of findings, data collection 

Last Answer : (A) Selection of topic, review of literature, data collection, interpretation of findings

Which one of the following belongs to the category of good 'research ethics’? (A) Publishing the same paper in two research journals without telling the editors. (B) Conducting a review of the literature that acknowledges the contributions of other people in the relevant field or relevant prior work. (C) Trimming outliers from a data set without discussing your reasons, in a research paper. (D) Including a colleague as an author on a research paper in return for a favour even though the colleague did not make a serious contribution to the pa per.

Description : Which one of the following belongs to the category of good 'research ethics'? (A) Publishing the same paper in two research journals without telling the editors. (B) Conducting a review of the literature ... for a favour even though the colleague did not make a serious contribution to the pa per. 

Last Answer : (B) Conducting a review of the literature that acknowledges the contributions of other people in the relevant field or relevant prior work.

What is the best free scientific search engine (besides GoogleScholar) alternative for Scirus?

Description : What is the best free scientific search engine (besides GoogleScholar) alternative for Scirus?

Last Answer : Doesn’t seem like there are a lot of choices….this article gives you the low-down on the most popular and this article lists search engines by science search engines, portals, and directories by specialty.

What is the goal of the Department of Energy's research regarding alternative fuel sources?

Description : What is the goal of the Department of Energy's research regarding alternative fuel sources?

Last Answer : Answers is the place to go to get the answers you need and to ask the questions you want

Brainstorming is used by the management for 1. Work allocation of the shop floor 2. Generating alternative for problem solving 3. The promotion of research and development 4. Training employees 5. None of these

Description : Brainstorming is used by the management for 1. Work allocation of the shop floor 2. Generating alternative for problem solving 3. The promotion of research and development 4. Training employees 5. None of these

Last Answer : Generating alternative for problem solving

A layer of the OSI model on one system communicates with the layer of its peer system. a. above b. same c. below d. None

Description : A layer of the OSI model on one system communicates with the layer of its peer system. a. above b. same c. below d. None

Last Answer : b. same

A… ................is an implementation of the same protocol in the equivalent layer on aremote system. a. Physical layer b. peer c. protocol stack d. layer

Description : A… ................is an implementation of the same protocol in the equivalent layer on aremote system. a. Physical layer b. peer c. protocol stack d. layer

Last Answer : b. peer

Consider the following statements regarding Peer -to -Peer computing environment : 1. In this system,...

Description : Consider the following statements regarding Peer -to -Peer computing environment :  1. In this system, clients and servers are not distinguished from one another.  2. All nodes distributed throughout the ... just a replica of the file -server system.  Which of the above statements are correct ?

Last Answer : Consider the following statements regarding Peer -to -Peer computing environment :  1. In this system, clients and servers are not distinguished from one another.  2. All nodes distributed throughout the system ( ... .  Which of the above statements are correct ? 1, 2 and 3 only

How much merit do you place in the concept of ideas/articles/claims being "Peer Reviewed"?

Description : How much merit do you place in the concept of ideas/articles/claims being "Peer Reviewed"?

Last Answer : NONE, just because they showed it to their peers, means nothing.

Will we , or are we, running out of ideas for scientific research and development ?

Description : Will we , or are we, running out of ideas for scientific research and development ?

Last Answer : We are nowhere close to running out of ideas. The real bottleneck for scientific research is not ideas, but money. We lack the funds to study everything that currently appears to be worth studying. As for ... long list, and no one could possibly know what the cutting edge of each one is right now.

How do I arrange it so that my body is donated to scientific research after my death?

Description : How do I arrange it so that my body is donated to scientific research after my death?

Last Answer : Put it in your will and make sure it is common knowledge in your family.

Can you explain the difference between scientific and non-scientific research?

Description : Can you explain the difference between scientific and non-scientific research?

Last Answer : Research implies spanning among as many sources as needed to gain a bigger confidence in your position or to learn a lot more about the positions and information available. If Ben did his research, he’d end up in religious studies, and then mythology, and history. He didn’t do his research.

ISRO is abbreviation for (1) Indian Scientific Research Organisation (2) International Space Research Organisation (3) International Sales Research Organisation (4) Indian Space Research Organisation

Description : ISRO is abbreviation for (1) Indian Scientific Research Organisation (2) International Space Research Organisation (3) International Sales Research Organisation (4) Indian Space Research Organisation

Last Answer : Indian Space Research Organisation

What is a peer-reviewed journal?

Description : What is a peer-reviewed journal?

Last Answer : A: A peer-reviewed journal is a scholarly publication that requires all articles to be reviewed and evaluated by experts in the field before they are accepted for publication.

What are some positive forms of peer pressure?

Description : What are some positive forms of peer pressure?

Last Answer : The opposite of the ones that got you smoking and drinking and hanging around with the wrong girls when you were a kid.

Is peer pressure, to some extent, facilitated by parents?

Description : Is peer pressure, to some extent, facilitated by parents?

Last Answer : answer:Yes, we get our keep up with the Joneses attitude from our early age and from our parents. Children are told that they need to try harder because the other children are doing better than ... the teaching to an extent, so that the child doesn't learn to base everything they do on others.

How do I know an article or journal is scholarly and peer-reviewed?

Description : How do I know an article or journal is scholarly and peer-reviewed?

Last Answer : There’s usually citations and a bibliography.

Where can a High School graduate go on the internet to read, learn and practice writing articles on Peer Reviewing?

Description : Where can a High School graduate go on the internet to read, learn and practice writing articles on Peer Reviewing?

Last Answer : answer:@talljasperman, do you want to know how to peer review articles OR to write them? Those who peer review articles would generally have a strong research and publication history in that area or with that ... is less of a specialist to read it for meaning. Good luck. Hope this helps a little.

What percent of young people would you guess stand up against peer pressure?

Description : What percent of young people would you guess stand up against peer pressure?

Last Answer : I, for one, can say I do not go along with most of my peers. Most of the stuff they say and do just doesn't go with what I like or think appropriate. I'm still a teen, and close to ... own morals, without having to do silly stuff just to get more friends, or gain popularity, or to fit in .

I need an outside viewpoint, my current peer group is lacking, but I don’t feel high functioning enough to “get out there”?

Description : I need an outside viewpoint, my current peer group is lacking, but I don’t feel high functioning enough to “get out there”?

Last Answer : I wonder if you could be a little more specific. You seem to be engaged in an important struggle, and looking seriously for help, but if you said in plain words what you are feeling I might know better how to respond.