Why does Waldorf's second-grade reading policy work?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:Their theory is that the brain has not developed in appropriate ways until second grade. There’s apparently some research to show this is true. If you learn other stuff (twiddling?) before you are 7, then your brain ends up being ready to learn to read at that point, and you lose no time compared to any other kid. It just drives me nuts that mothers are constantly freaking out that their children have to be ahead, so they make their kids do flash cards at age 3 or something. They want them to read before kindergarten. It’s ridiculous. The problem is, that some children can read that young, more often, those kids are girls, not boys. Boys really aren’t ready to sit down and study or whatever it takes to learn to read until that age. But people believe the rat race starts as soon as you are born, and you have to stimulate the baby… hold on, I forgot. It starts before they are born: playing Mozart so they’ll have little math brains or something. Turns out that research isn’t even true. Oh well. SO parents freak out, and there are very few who can deal with their anxiety about their kids falling behind. But those that can will send kids to more alternativy kinds of schools, like Waldorf schools. So Waldorf doesn’t waste people’s time with wasted work. They learn just fine at age 7 and no one can tell the difference in a year or so. Fuck, I was the second to last person to learn to read in my first grade class. I didn’t catch on until nearly the end of the year. I was almost 7. But I sure felt stupid not knowing if I would ever get it. I only say this because a number of people have been accusing me of being smart, and I use this as evidence to show you that I am and always have been somewhat slow. ;-)

Related questions

Description : Do you have any suggestions on improving grade school education?

Last Answer : Increase teacher pay and school funding. Ending steaming is a good thing too. There are probably tweaks that need to be made regularly to cirriculum to keep it globally competitive, ... between the cracks for various reasons. Class biases and stereotyping can strongly affect individual outcomes.

Description : What do you think of the way grade school math is taught in Singapore, as explained in this article?

Last Answer : I have lived in school districts that have adopted the Singapore math method, and I thought it was a nightmare. I was unable to help my kids, and my kids seemed so frustrated because they were quite capable of math, but couldn’t get their head around the new way of thinking of numbers.

Description : How can I prepare for the grade 12 English diploma exam (details inside)?

Last Answer : answer:No one can teach you how to do this. If it's a matter of sitting for the entire period and taking the test to completion (or completion of the time allotted, at least, whether or not ... judging you for your reasons - then perhaps college classes are not going to suit you in any case.

Description : What do you think of the idea of having computers grade student essays?

Last Answer : What a ridiculous idea! Does it write notes in the margins, too?

Description : Parents: How do you feel about grade-monitoring programs?

Last Answer : answer:I think when dealing with kids and education, the more parents know, the better. Kids can hide their grades or may not tell their parents that there is a problem until it's too late. I ... of an A+ and demand answers. But those moms usually already know their kids' grades every day anyway.

Description : In your area, what do teachers give as a grade to students who don't hand in anything at all?

Last Answer : 6

Description : Is anybody familiar with the simulation game featured in the documentary World Peace and Other 4th Grade Achievements?

Last Answer : answer:This is interesting and I'm certain it could serve as a valuable aid to teaching a whole slew of subjects. The object is for all countries to come out ahead. If that's really the ... 's ideological makeup. And leaving out such countries would seem to make world peace much easier to achieve.

Description : I got a B+ final grade from a [B+, 30%] and [A, 50%] with a remaining 20% participation. What did I get in participation for my final grade to be a B+?

Last Answer : Does the professor have anything in the syllabus about if the grade is teetering on the edge of an A-/B+, they have discretion over which way the grade goes? It could have come down to attendance ... e-mail or visiting them in their office to discuss it so your GPA can correctly reflect your effort.

Description : How would I convince a school district of the importance of fifth grade music education (see details)?

Last Answer : answer:I suspect that it is a budgetary issue. Every public school in my area has had to cut back, with great reluctance, many programs that they love. They have to make draconian decisions. Would ... go to the school board meetings when they discuss and explain the budget? It is a cautionary tale.

Description : Did you hear about the 3rd grade math problems in Georgia that include wording and subjects such as slavery and beatings?

Last Answer : Personally, I don’t think children should be exposed to slavery and beatings until they get to calculus.

Description : How much schooling have you had, and what do you call your various school years - e.g. grade school and high school? Middle school? Wherever in the world you are - please explain a bit about your schooling system.

Last Answer : I finished 7 of 11 grades in Russia where schools weren't divided into age-related portions. When I moved to the US, I went to some middle school followed by high school through grade 12. I went to ... in a PhD program that should last around 5-7 years. I never went to pre-school or kindergarten.

Description : What are some good academic lessons I can teach to a child going into the 5th grade?

Last Answer : answer:Make it as fun and interesting as you can and don't over do it! Kids who struggle will get frustrated even more if it becomes a chore. Reading with her is the biggest thing you can ... . Take her to kids museums as there are always engaging exhibits that kids really can learn things at.

Description : If someone gave you a surprise exam on your favorite science fiction movie, what grade would you get?

Last Answer : answer:I would get an A on The Matrix. @takidavaki306 Indiana Jones is not science fiction, save maybe the 4th one.

Description : Should we make 12th grade optional?

Last Answer : Yes absolutely. Senior year is a joke. But then again, our entire public education system is a joke.

Description : How does a computer grade the written section of the GMAT?

Last Answer : An actual person grades those. They hire english teachers to do it and they give them a rubric to try and keep the scores as consistent as possible. They also have multiple people grade each one.

Description : Grading system A+ through F , but no "grade E"?

Last Answer : I’m pretty sure when the letter grade system was first introduced it ran from A through E. Later they switched the E for F, probably since it is the first letter in fail. Now tell me, where are all the B batteries?

Description : Can schools grade students based upon attendance?

Last Answer : Most school i know do this, unless u have a doctors notes\ records showing you where out for medical reasons. Its unfair, but it looks like they are allowed to do this

Description : What were your favorite books in sixth grade?

Last Answer : I loved alot of books like… Diary of a Wimpy kid,Swindle,Skeleton Creek,the Twilight series,Harry Potter series,loves me loves me not,wayside school books,hole,and more! I still remember what every one of them were about ;)

Description : What are some art project ideas for a 6th grade class studying Ancient Egypt?

Last Answer : It’s not exactly an art project, but I always thought drawing my name in heiroglyphics was fun… =)

Description : What color combination is best for reading on a sheet of paper?

Last Answer : Whenever I write a note in my Google Keep app I don't think I've ever found a pleasant color combination (the paper' is colored, the text is in black. In Instagram Stories, where you can choose from ... think hey, that's easy on the eyes . Black and white is not common for nothing, I think.

Description : Best way to retain info when reading a textbook?

Last Answer : Use it some how. Or teach it to someone.

Description : How do I help a child with severe reading and writing problems?

Last Answer : My son was defiant in not wanting to learn to read. We now know he is bipolar and was just a square peg in a round hole. The key for him was to find something that was easy to read and was ... . I just wish there were goose bump math books. He never really got that although he IS a natural musician.

Description : What can teachers do to improve reading conditions when their classrooms have only fluorescent lights or no windows?

Last Answer : I found this, @717richboy. I hope it gives you some ideas.

Description : Have any flutherites had great success improving their reading skills by way of some special technique or program?

Last Answer : It's my understanding that those sorts of classes, speed-reading and such gimmicks, are rubbish. The only way to improve reading skills is with practice. If you're having issues with absorbtion or ... well. Writing out my thoughts, even in just a few words, helps clarify things for me.

Description : How good are your sons/daughters at at reading? What is their lexile score, if you know?

Last Answer : answer:My 3 year old knows his alphabet and their individual sounds (no compounds yet, like “ph” or “gr”) and can sight-read certain words like “stop” “go” “cat” “dog” “Mama” “Daddy” and “Ian” My Lexile scores came back “post college” from about seventh grade on.

Description : In the visual age, will reading become less important?

Last Answer : answer:I am an audio visual person, and don't particularly like reading books. It drives my father crazy that I am like this. However, I do see great value in books and the written word. I don't ... about a topic, I think the best way still is reading about the topic. I can't see that changing.

Description : Have you ever taken a speed reading course?

Last Answer : answer:I never have, but in 7th grade literature, I still remember my teacher telling us how you're supposed to look at a hunk of three words at once, and read the sentences in 3 word groupings. I enjoy ... a week, so speed reading kinda depresses me. :] (It sure is great for textbooks, though. :P)

Description : Do you believe average reading comprehension and writing skills have decreased in the general adult population? If so, what factors do you think exacerbate and proliferate the trend?

Last Answer : First, do you have any statistics or studies that show that reading comprehension and the ability to communicate have decreased? There is no diminution of demand for the skills. In fact, it is more vital than ever to be able to read and comprehend what is read. Reading is part of most jobs today.

Description : Is 13.8 flesch-kincaid reading grade level a good grade?

Last Answer : Is this a score on something that you have written?

Description : What is a good Gamecube game for somebody reading at a 1st grade level?

Last Answer : Have you thought of looking up George W. Bush’s favorite video games.

Description : I love teaching fifth grade, but have been asked to teach eighth grade English at the same school. I'd focus on reading and writing, my passions, but wonder if I'd connect to eighth graders the way I do to fifth graders. Any ideas?

Last Answer : well, I guess there is only one way to find out whether you'd connect or not. I personally feel I would connect better with students at an 8th grade level than a 5th grade. Not sure why, maybe ... the position, worst case scenario, you hate it and you end up going back to teaching 5th grade again.

Description : How to memorize a reading once read and remember 100% guarantee till the test ? I am in eighth grade

Last Answer : I don't remember reading or I forget everything I read. This problem is present in almost all the students. Many people do not read the correct rules, but after a few days they forget it. Again many ... going to bed tomorrow. Then revise it after a week and it will be remembered for a long time.

Description : How can I help to improve my child's 4th grade reading comprehension?

Last Answer : Finding out what hobbies or interests your child has, and finding books on those subjects is one way to increase your child's reading level. Asking your child to read news articles from the paper out loud at the table before meals will help with pronunciation and confidence.

Description : Which of the following includes examples of quantitative variables? a. Age, Temperature, Income, Height b. Grade Point Average, Anxiety Level, Reading Performance c. Gender, Religion, Ethnic Group d. Both a and b

Last Answer : d. Both a and b

Description : Jurors typically average just over ____ years of education and an eighth-grade reading level. a. 9 c. 11 b. 10 d. 12

Last Answer : d. 12

Description : Jurors typically average just over year of education and eight-grade reading level (a) 11 (b) 9 (c) 10 (d) 12

Last Answer : (d) 12

Description : During a visit to a second-grade classroom, a student teacher observed a child spending the time allotted for a worksheet either looking out the window or doodling on his paper. When the student ... finish work before the whole class is finished must not interrupt the students who are still working

Last Answer : B) A routine for rewarding students who finish work promptly is not in place.

Description : Would a university study any and every ridiculous notion out there like "the five second rule"?

Last Answer : I have thought about the issue of weird university studies a few times. I believe the purpose is to give students experience at conducting in depth studies, without the access to findings of others who have ... . So, it is not about the results or topic, but the methods used to reach conclusions.

Description : What are the best MBA programs to learn a second language before you graduate?

Last Answer : This site can answer your questions about how different factors lead to different school choices.

Description : Why are second languages taught differently from first languages?

Last Answer : answer:For one thing, first languages are taught to children who have generally already been speaking in the language at least colloquially for several years. All they need to learn are the formal rules ... in terms of comparison: the rules you already know vs. the rules of the new language.

Description : With a low undergrad GPA, is it worth it to do a second BS?

Last Answer : answer:Your verbal is a bit low, especially considering your writing score. It's so hard to get a decent writing score on the GRE. If you are an international student or going into a ... school. You MUST get an internship to get practical experience (unless your pursuits are academic in nature).

Description : Name for English as a Second Language Teaching Institute?

Last Answer : English Class – easy to remember, straight to the point

Description : What is a good topic or skill that is apt to be in the zone proximal development for most students in second grade.

Last Answer : My daughter was in a blended K-3 class for K-1, and they did a daily “incredible equation” where the answer had to be equal to the date. The number of operations varied over time, and by skill level. The first week or two, the parental involvement was heavy, but got less as time went on.

Description : Where can I download second grade worksheets?

Last Answer : http://www.tlsbooks.com/secondgradeworksheets.htm This website offers a plethora of free second grade worksheets for a myriad of different subjects. Subjects include math, language arts, science, social studies, and more.

Description : What kind of communion dress should I buy for my second grade daughter?

Last Answer : An appropriate communion dress for a second grader needs to modest and not too revealing. It should be white and knee length. Lace communion dresses are a pretty popular trend currently.

Description : Mr. Thorn says that Lonnie, a new black student in an all-white school, must have cheated on the test because Lonnie made the second-highest grade in the class. At what point does this claim become institutional racism?

Last Answer : When the principal says nothing should be done to stop Mr. Thorn

Description : Second grade toilet soap should have a TFM of?

Last Answer : 70%

Description : Give an account of acts of Aggression and Policy of Appeasement on which the Second World War broke out. -SST 10th

Last Answer : Acts of Aggression and Policy of Appeasement: When the acts of aggression began, the aggressed countries, the Soviet Union and many leaders in different countries of the world demanded collective action to defeat ... as long as it did and would not have been able to unleash the Second World War.

Description : What was the effect of Japan’s Policy of Expansion on the Second World War? -SST 10th

Last Answer : Japan's Policy of Expansion: After the First World War, Japan increased her resources of army because of industrialization and modern technology. She captured Manchuria in 1931 and invaded China in ... territories. In brief, Japan's policy of expansion also created war like situation in 1930s.